- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 3
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper introduces a large-scale, ticker-aligned dataset connecting traditional equity markets with public blockchain activity. The dataset covers 890 tokenized equities across four blockchains, including approximately 249.5 million transfers and 31.3 million decentralized-exchange swaps, together with corresponding minute-level exchange prices, news, and company fundamentals. The paper uses this cross-market alignment to investigate on-chain activity during exchange closures, the information contained in on-chain prices, and account-level behavior across tokenized assets. The authors report four main empirical findings. First, tokenized equities remain active while U.S. equity markets are closed, and the divergence between on-chain prices and the latest exchange prices increases as the latter become stale. Second, when on-chain trading is sufficiently active and quotes are sufficiently recent, token returns during exchange closures are informative about the direction of the next exchange opening. Third, a small number of liquid tokenized index or sector assets may provide market- or sector-level signals for a broader set of equities. Fourth, account-level co-holding patterns are more strongly associated with shared news attention than with return correlations. Based on these findings, the paper formulates two learning tasks. The first is dark-window equity forecasting, which uses on-chain signals observed during exchange closures to augment existing equity forecasting models and predict the next opening gap. The second is open-world next-asset prediction, which uses an account’s historical holdings and interactions to predict the next tokenized equity it will acquire. The experiments suggest that incorporating on-chain information can improve cross-sectional RankIC for several equity forecasting models, while the next-asset prediction task highlights the cold-start and distribution-shift challenges caused by newly listed tokenized assets.
Critical strengths
- A novel and valuable dataset The paper aligns on-chain activity for tokenized equities with traditional equity prices, news, and fundamentals, connecting two research areas that have largely been studied separately. The resulting dataset provides a new basis for studying price discovery during exchange closures and account-level investment behavior.
- Strong connection between empirical findings and learning tasks The paper identifies dark-window signals, cross-asset proxy relationships, and co-holding patterns, and uses these findings to formulate dark-window equity forecasting and open-world next-asset prediction. These tasks are practically relevant and introduce useful research settings for financial forecasting and temporal recommendation.
Critical weaknesses
- The central forecasting claim requires stronger validation. The reported directional accuracy above 80% is obtained only under restrictive conditions involving high trading activity and fresh quotes. However, the corresponding sample size, asset coverage, and threshold-selection process are not clearly reported, making the generalizability of this result uncertain.
- The event definition in the account-level task requires further validation. Blockchain addresses and token transfers provide only an approximate representation of investor asset choices, since some events may result from airdrops, custody movements, or market-making activity. The paper should describe its filtering procedure more clearly and verify whether the main results remain valid when only confirmed purchase events are retained.
Questions for authors
1.For the reported directional accuracy above 80% under the conditions of at least 300 trades and a quote age of no more than one hour, how many windows, dates, and equities are included? Were these thresholds selected only on the discovery split and then fixed for evaluation on the confirmation split? 2.Do on-chain prices retain significant incremental predictive value after accounting for other publicly available off-hours signals, such as equity-index futures, overseas markets, premarket trading, or relevant news? 3.In the next-asset prediction task, how do the authors distinguish active purchases from ordinary transfers, airdrops, minting, custody movements, or market-making activity? Do the results remain valid when only verifiable purchase events are retained? 4.Does the association between news co-mentions and account-level co-holding remain significant after controlling for asset popularity, news coverage, trading activity, and token listing age?
5 comments
Q3 (continued).
(3) Results on verified purchases only. We define a verified purchase in two ways. Strict keeps an event only if its own transaction is a recorded DEX swap in which the account buys the token. Layered also keeps events delivered by an aggregator trade, an issuer mint, or an exchange withdrawal, where the channel indicates a purchase but no swap is recorded. Both exclude airdrops, distributions, and unlabelled events. We evaluate the same models, with the same folds and candidate sets, on the verified subset of the test set.
Table R8b. Events retained under each definition, and MRR on all test events → on the strict subset.
| Solana | Binance | Ondo | Ethereum | RH-chain | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| All acquisition events | 98,991 | 84,303 | 48,917 | 12,912 | 22,323 |
| Strict coverage | 39.0% | 1.9% | 0.7% | 6.7% | 12.0% |
| Layered coverage | 55.7% | 48.4% | 57.1% | 83.8% | 38.2% |
| EASE | 0.311 → 0.315 | 0.068 → 0.065 | 0.269 → 0.309 | 0.184 → 0.261 | 0.229 → 0.255 |
| SASRec | 0.311 → 0.320 | 0.066 → 0.042 | 0.307 → 0.216 | 0.234 → 0.346 | 0.288 → 0.318 |
| FDSA | 0.317 → 0.314 | 0.073 → 0.051 | 0.319 → 0.259 | 0.237 → 0.354 | 0.295 → 0.339 |
| UniSRec | 0.314 → 0.315 | 0.091 → 0.138 | 0.339 → 0.292 | 0.218 → 0.339 | 0.297 → 0.357 |
| DyGFormer | 0.233 → 0.237 | 0.379 → 0.291 | 0.286 → 0.289 | 0.071 → 0.082 | 0.139 → 0.175 |
| CAWN | 0.293 → 0.301 | 0.234 → 0.274 | 0.273 → 0.288 | 0.191 → 0.298 | 0.178 → 0.158 |
Table R8c. MRR on all test events → on the layered subset.
| Solana | Binance | Ondo | Ethereum | RH-chain | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| EASE | 0.311 → 0.308 | 0.068 → 0.051 | 0.269 → 0.175 | 0.184 → 0.183 | 0.229 → 0.254 |
| SASRec | 0.311 → 0.303 | 0.066 → 0.049 | 0.307 → 0.181 | 0.234 → 0.227 | 0.288 → 0.292 |
| FDSA | 0.317 → 0.304 | 0.073 → 0.057 | 0.319 → 0.181 | 0.237 → 0.232 | 0.295 → 0.305 |
| UniSRec | 0.314 → 0.309 | 0.091 → 0.061 | 0.339 → 0.183 | 0.218 → 0.210 | 0.297 → 0.312 |
| DyGFormer | 0.233 → 0.235 | 0.379 → 0.434 | 0.286 → 0.161 | 0.071 → 0.067 | 0.139 → 0.164 |
| CAWN | 0.293 → 0.296 | 0.234 → 0.242 | 0.273 → 0.177 | 0.191 → 0.189 | 0.178 → 0.146 |
We summarize the main findings as follows. (1) On Solana, Ethereum, and RH-chain, the results hold. On Solana, every method changes by less than 3% on the strict subset. On Ethereum and RH-chain, strictly verified purchases are easier to predict for almost every method, and the layered results stay within about 0.03 of the original. (2) On Ondo and Binance, the layered definition is the informative one. Trades there go mostly through aggregators, the issuer, or the exchange and leave no swap record, so the strict subset keeps under 2% of events. On Ondo, all methods fall from 0.27–0.34 to 0.16–0.18 under the layered definition: the removed airdrops and distributions concentrate on a few assets and were the easiest events to predict. On Binance, the sequential models stay below 0.1 under the layered definition and DyGFormer remains the strongest. (3) Training on verified purchases gives the same result. On Solana, we retrain on strict events only and keep the test set unchanged: SASRec 0.311 → 0.320, UniSRec 0.314 → 0.325. Overall, the conclusions hold when only verified purchases are retained. On Ondo, airdrops and issuer distributions raise the absolute accuracy. We have added this analysis to Section 6.2 and the full results to Appendix B.
Q2: Do on-chain prices retain significant incremental...
A3: Thank you for this question. On-chain token prices and other off-hours signals react to the same overnight information, so some overlap is expected. On weekday nights (Tuesday–Friday), equity-index futures trade continuously and dominate overnight market-wide price discovery, so the market-wide part of token prices largely follows futures. Tokens can add information in two cases. During futures closures (weekends and holidays), they are the only instrument still trading. At the level of individual equities, futures and overseas indices price the market rather than single stocks, and news is text rather than a traded price. In the revision, we add this discussion to Section 5.2 and the full details to Appendix F.
Setup. We regress the opening gap y (open over previous close, minus one) on the on-chain signal s together with the off-hours controls X that are available before the 04:00 ET decision time: y = θ′X + γ·s + ε. The controls are the returns of ES and NQ index futures from the close to 04:00 ET (Yahoo Finance, hourly bars, each scaled by the equity's beta), the Nikkei 225 (daily close), overnight news sentiment and article counts, and the equity's own after-hours return. Premarket trading starts at 04:00 ET and is therefore not available. We run three tests:
- Market level: s is the dark-window state. Weights are fitted on the discovery period and evaluated on the confirmation period (106 trading days, 52,300 instances).
- Stock level: s is the return of the equity's own token, with a day fixed effect and standard errors clustered by day (959 instances over 200 nights and 28 equities since on-chain data became available).
- Futures closures: y is the gap at which ES futures reopen and s is the return of the SPY token over the same closure (48 weekend closures since July 2025).
Findings. On weekday nights, futures dominate market-wide price discovery, and the market-wide part of token prices follows them. Adding the dark-window state to futures does not raise RankIC (0.219 to 0.226, t = 0.49). On-chain prices add information in two cases, where the other signals are silent:
- When futures are closed. Over weekends, tokens are the only instrument still trading. The return of the SPY token predicts the gap at which futures reopen (r = 0.42, permutation p = 0.003).
- At the level of individual equities. Futures and overseas indices price the market, not single stocks, and news is text, not a traded price. After removing everything common to all equities on a given day and adding all controls, the return of an equity's own token remains significant (γ = 0.46, t = 6.95). The result holds separately in the discovery and confirmation periods (t = 3.89 and t = 5.48). Coverage is currently about five equities per night.
Q4: Does the association between news co-mentions...
A4: Yes, the association remains positive and significant after controlling for all four factors.
We run a pair-level regression of co-holding on news co-mention, with asset popularity, news coverage, on-chain trading activity, token listing age, and return correlation as controls. Because pairs that share a ticker are not independent, we use standard errors clustered on both tickers and a QAP permutation test (2,000 permutations).
Table R9. Coefficient of news co-mention.
| Co-holding definition | Without controls | With controls | 95% CI (dyadic-robust) | QAP p |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Ever co-held (count) | 0.496 | 0.235 | [0.184, 0.286] | < 0.001 |
| Concurrently co-held (count) | 0.485 | 0.227 | [0.172, 0.282] | < 0.001 |
| Ever co-held (ratio) | 0.0355 | 0.0222 | [0.017, 0.027] | < 0.001 |
| Concurrently co-held (ratio) | 0.0267 | 0.0173 | [0.013, 0.021] | < 0.001 |
As can be seen, the association remains significant under all four definitions of co-holding. Every confidence interval excludes zero, and none of the 2,000 permutations reaches the observed coefficient. The controls do absorb part of it, about half on the count outcomes and a third on the ratio outcomes, with popularity the strongest among them on the count outcomes. The remaining effect is therefore not a proxy for popularity or coverage. We have added this analysis to Section 5.3 and Appendix E.
We thank the reviewer for recognizing the novelty of the dataset and the connection between our findings and the learning tasks, and for the helpful questions. We respond to each point below and have revised the paper accordingly, with changes to the text marked in blue.
W1: The central forecasting claim requires stronger validation...
Q1: For the reported directional accuracy...
A1: We thank the reviewer for raising this concern. We have revised Figure 4(b) to annotate each cell's sample size and to hatch cells too thin to support an estimate, and we have added the sample size and coverage of this region to Section 5.2.
1. Sample size. The above-80% region (more than 300 trades, quote no older than one hour) contains 1,917 windows over 270 dates and 32 equities. Its directional accuracy is 85.5% (95% CI [83.5%, 87.3%]), against 58.7% for always predicting an up move.
2. Coverage. The result does not depend on a few liquid names: accuracy is 84.6% without the top five tickers and 84.9% without the top ten. Only 34 of the 890 tickers ever exceed 300 trades in a window, but they account for 99.8% of swap volume.
3. Threshold selection. The cut-offs are the bin edges of a descriptive stratification and were set on the pooled sample, not on the discovery split alone. With the cut-offs held fixed, accuracy is above 80% on both splits: 82.3% on discovery and 87.9% on confirmation. The result is therefore not produced by selecting thresholds on the evaluation period.
W2: The event definition in the account-level task requires further validation...
Q3: In the next-asset prediction task..
A2: Thanks. We have described the filtering procedure more clearly in Section 6.2 and Appendix B, and we conducted an additional experiment that retains only verified purchases. Specifically,
(1) Current filtering. Filtering is applied to accounts, in two steps. We first exclude contract addresses, exchange wallets, issuers, and market makers, and then remove addresses flagged by six behavioural rules, such as mint/redeem addresses, same-block arbitrage, and one-to-many distributors (Appendix B). These rules remove 0.7% to 16.5% of wallets per chain. An acquisition is the first time a remaining account receives a token it does not hold. This removes the addresses that carry out minting, custody, and market-making.
(2) Additional experiment: verified purchases only. We further classify every acquisition event by the counterparty that delivers the token.
Method. For each event, we identify the counterparty that delivers the token in the same transaction and assign it to one of four channels. The labels combine three sources: address labels in the dataset and public exchange address lists; verified contract names for DEX pools, aggregators, and issuers; and the sender's behaviour over its full transfer history, where one-way batch senders are treated as airdrops or distributions and two-way high-degree hubs as custodial addresses. An event is left unlabelled when the evidence is insufficient. All thresholds were fixed before any model result was inspected.
Ondo and Binance are the two issuers on BSC. Event shares and counts split the BSC events by the issuer of the acquired token; MRR follows the folds of Table 5.
Table R8a. Share of acquisition events by sender.
As shown in Table R8a, airdrops and distributions account for 24% to 41% of acquisition events on Solana, Binance, Ondo, and RH-chain, and under 1% on Ethereum, so a substantial share of events on these four chains are not active purchases. Where our swap data cover the trading venues, the classification can be checked: on Solana and RH-chain, 93% and 96% of the events delivered by a DEX pool are confirmed by an independent swap record.