1. The paper does not convincingly show that its proposed association method is more effective than appropriately adapted existing trackers, leaving its contribution to the broader MOT community unclear. In surveying satellite-video MOT work, I found substantially different evaluation protocols even for VISO: its original paper specifies a MOT training/validation/test split, while HRTracker randomly selects 20 videos for training and five for testing. LocaLock also documents differences in matching criteria by reporting results under both near-zero and 0.4 IoU thresholds. These differences make published scores difficult to compare directly. I recognize this as a field-wide difficulty and do not expect the authors to reproduce every previous tracker. A new evaluation split can nevertheless support a fair comparison if representative baselines are appropriately adapted and evaluated under a common protocol.
The paper claims to establish such a comparison in Table 1 by using identical detector outputs, but the information provided is insufficient to assess whether the baselines were appropriately adapted. It does not explain whether and how CO-MOT, developed for generic MOT, was retrained for satellite-video MOT or how its end-to-end detection pipeline was adapted to the shared detections. MP²Net is already a satellite-video method, but its learned joint detection-and-tracking pipeline also requires explanation under this comparison. For generic detection-based trackers such as ByteTrack and OC-SORT, it is unclear whether thresholds and track-management parameters originally selected for ordinary MOT were adequately tuned for tiny satellite targets. These choices can materially affect the ranking, leaving uncertainty about whether the reported advantage reflects a stronger association method or differences in baseline adaptation.
I think that, as an ICLR submission, the paper should establish a methodological or conceptual contribution relevant to the broader MOT community, not only to researchers working on satellite-video MOT. In this paper, comparisons with existing trackers are a central part of the evidence for the proposed association representation's value. The internal ablations deserve credit for showing that ADATrack's components help within its own system, but they cannot by themselves establish what the approach adds relative to existing MOT methods. Without a sufficiently credible comparative basis, I remain unconvinced that the reported results establish a method or insight that the broader MOT community can reliably build on.
2. The paper does not establish how its recurrent spatial field resolves ambiguity between nearby targets more effectively than a simpler recurrent model of motion uncertainty. The motivation concerns identity preservation under weak appearance cues and uncertain localization. However, the detector objectness map in Eq. (4) is shared across tracks and indicates possible object locations without identifying which track an object belongs to. Distinguishing targets therefore depends on their historical states and the resulting field shapes. Spreading support along motion can tolerate longitudinal localization errors, but can also increase responses to nearby competing detections along the same axis. Whether the retained field resolves this tradeoff is not examined directly.
The component ablations provide meaningful evidence: removing the recurrent field reduces VISO HOTA from 67.1 to 61.6, while learned isotropic diffusion achieves 65.0 compared with 67.1 for the full model. These results support the usefulness of field retention and motion direction within ADATrack. However, the source-only control removes field memory, and the propagation controls vary the update within the same spatial representation. They do not establish the added value of retaining a full spatial field over a compact state that also preserves temporal information and directional uncertainty. A recurrent motion-aligned Gaussian response, using the same anchor predictions, detector evidence, gating, and track-management rules, would provide a more targeted comparison.
An analysis of association decisions should show where the full field improves over such a control and where it fails, for example under localization errors aligned with motion versus closely spaced targets competing along that axis. Changes in the score separation between the correct detection and competing detections, together with actual assignment errors or identity switches, would help connect the representation to the problem it is intended to solve. The current aggregate tables and selected TP/FP/FN visualizations do not establish this connection. Consequently, the distinct association capability provided by the recurrent field, and the conditions under which it is preferable to a simpler alternative, remain insufficiently understood.