- Rating
- 3(+1)
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper investigates long-horizon planning in Offline Goal-Conditioned Reinforcement Learning. It addresses a specific challenge where agents know how to execute individual local actions but struggle to compose them into long and complex tasks. To tackle this, the authors propose ATQ, or Algebraic Task Quotient, which adds a task-level planning layer on top of existing reinforcement learning policies. Under the offline goal-conditioned setup, the agent learns entirely from pre-collected interaction trajectories and receives both the current state and target goal to output control actions.
ATQ operates through a four-step framework. First, it identifies key task-relevant information to retain from offline trajectories. Second, it learns transition rules describing how state changes occur when specific events happen. Third, it generates an event-level plan at the task layer. Fourth, it executes a step, observes the result, and replans dynamically.
The primary evaluation is conducted on a robotic button-pressing Puzzle task, where pressing a button toggles multiple board lights to reach a specified target pattern. Experiments demonstrate substantial performance gains when comparing GCIQL combined with ATQ against both standard GCIQL and GCIQL augmented with Test-Time Graph Search.
Critical strengths
The primary value of this paper lies in extracting repeatable task transitions from offline interaction trajectories into explicit event rules and combining them with existing goal-conditioned policies via a high-level planner, thereby enhancing performance on long-horizon, complex tasks. By decoupling task-level decision-making from low-level action execution, this architecture offers an effective solution to the challenge where agents possess local skills but struggle with long-horizon tasks. Remarkably, without modifying the underlying policy, the proposed method increases the success rate on Puzzle 4×6-play from 12.5% to 99.4%, demonstrating that well-designed task representations and planning mechanisms can substantially improve existing policies.
The paper also presents compelling validation regarding compositional generalization and methodological effectiveness. The authors evaluate state-event combinations unobserved during compiler fitting and demonstrate that these unseen pairs still sustain high task success rates. This indicates that, under stable event dynamics and suitable model candidates, the system can leverage rules identified from limited data to infer novel operational sequences without relying on complete trajectory coverage. Furthermore, ablation experiments—including event effect shuffling, greedy planning, and feedback interventions—verify the respective importance of correct event semantics, multi-step planning, and closed-loop error correction, providing a thoroughly grounded explanation for the source of performance gains.
Critical weaknesses
The proposed method relies heavily on hand-crafted structural priors, and its capacity for automatic discovery as well as its generalizability require clearer definition. Candidate variables, operator types, and execution interfaces across different environments are all manually pre-designed, while the primary benchmark task, Puzzle, inherently features an XOR structure particularly suited for algebraic solving. Consequently, the current evaluation does not fully isolate the individual contributions of automated task-structure extraction, event-model selection, algebraic solving, and feedback replanning. The authors should consider adding a simplified baseline that directly learns XOR masks for planning under the same front-end and execution mechanisms to clarify the incremental value of the full ATQ framework. Additionally, the theoretical section mostly provides abstract conditions and a unified formalization; as the authors acknowledge that the quotient construction inherits classic residual-language abstraction ideas, its explicit contribution to actual algorithm design and performance warrants further elaboration.
Two points in the experimental design require further clarification. First, TTGS employs a default open-loop setting without replanning, whereas ATQ dynamically replans based on execution feedback. As a result, the performance gap in the main experiments conflates the effects of representation modeling with those of feedback mechanisms, meaning it cannot be attributed solely to the event-rule model itself. Second, the identification of "unseen combinations" is restricted to the dataset used for compiler fitting, whereas the underlying policy utilizes a more complete offline dataset; hence, the current evidence primarily supports compositional generalization at the compiler level. Incorporating a comparison where both methods are allowed to replan, along with a test setup where specific combinations are held out from both the compiler and the low-level policy, would significantly strengthen the attribution of contributions and the credibility of system-level generalization claims.
Regarding applicability, while the paper reports strong results on Puzzle, performance gains on other tasks are inconsistent, with visible degradation observed in certain HumanoidMaze benchmarks. This indicates that the effectiveness of the high-level event model critically depends on whether the abstraction preserves essential information and whether the low-level policy can reliably execute the subgoals generated by the planner. Currently, the explanation for these failures lacks thorough diagnostic analysis. It is recommended to further disentangle the root causes—such as event-model errors, executability misjudgments, improper subgoal construction, or low-level control failures—and evaluate the method on tasks featuring context dependencies, irreversible operations, or sequential constraints. These additions will help clarify whether ATQ's advantages can generalize beyond clean, highly structured puzzle tasks to broader long-horizon decision-making problems.
Questions for authors
See Critical Weaknesses
6 comments
Part 1: Supplied Structure, Direct-XOR Baseline, and Role of Theory
We sincerely appreciate your constructive comments on supplied structure, the direct XOR baseline, and how our theoretical results inform the algorithm.
1. Supplied registers and the direct-XOR baseline
A task representation through registers specifies which aspects of task state are recorded, such as whether a light is on (Section 2.1), but does not specify which lights each switch changes or which switches solve a new goal. As in a digital circuit, simple stored values and elementary logic operations support complex computations through composition over time. Likewise, simple register variables support long-horizon behavior when their changes are learned and composed to reach a goal.
ATQ supplies a family-specific language for variables and updates, using replay to determine concrete event rules and execution targets (Section 2.2; Appendix B.1, Tables 3–4). These structural assumptions beyond receiving a goal observation are central to the method.
Following your suggestion, we fitted a direct XOR baseline using the same register extractor, event identities, execution prototypes, and planning interface. Across all eight Puzzle datasets, it recovered the original executable model used in the submitted policy evaluations. Removing the explicitly named XOR candidate (fitting general Boolean updates) and supplying physical Lights-Out masks also recovered the same model:
| Operator construction | Result across the eight Puzzle datasets |
|---|---|
| ATQ candidate selection | Selects XOR on 8/8 datasets |
| Direct XOR fitting from replay | Recovers the same executable model on 8/8 |
| Explicit XOR candidate removed | General Boolean fitting recovers equivalent COPY/NOT updates on 8/8 |
| Physical Lights-Out masks | Matches the learned executable model on 8/8 |
The XOR-removed fits achieve 100% held-out whole-register successor accuracy on the four play datasets and 99.51–99.94% on the noisy datasets; all four constructions have identical accuracy under this evaluation. These accuracies use the held-out 20% of training replay, with events identified from pre-event effector positions. Appendix C.1 reports a separate structural-compiler audit on official validation replay with different event grounding. Executable-model equivalence is checked against the original policy-evaluation banks, verifying equality of all model fields used by the executor rather than treating identical models as independent rollouts.
This clarifies the contribution: on Puzzle, candidate-family selection does not improve performance over directly fitting the correct family. The benefit lies in recovering reusable event laws and composing them with the frozen policy.
2. How the theory informs the method
Theorems 1 and 2 provide a theoretical basis for the compositional view behind the circuit analogy (Section 2.1; Appendices A.1–A.2):
- One-step consistency (Theorem 1): An exact deterministic task-event circuit factoring source transitions through the register extractor exists if and only if states assigned the same register values (for a fixed goal) agree on one-step goal completion, event applicability, and next register values (Eq. 2). When these local conditions hold, outcome preservation extends by induction to executable event sequences. This motivates fitting and validating operators on one-step transitions, though finite-replay validation does not by itself guarantee that Eq. (2) holds globally.
- Predictions at unseen configurations (Proposition 2): Section 2.3 explains when observed transitions determine predictions at new configurations within an operator family (Appendix A.4, Proposition 2). When the true effect class is identified and the global XOR structure holds, one exact transition fixes that event's mask (). Alongside event-type coverage (Appendix C.5), this helps explain the empirical recovery of the full operator bank from eight replay episodes (Figures 2 and 3).
- Continuation quotient and Puzzle planning (Theorem 2 & Corollary 1): Theorem 2 uses the classical continuation-language construction to characterize the coarsest merging of task configurations preserving which future event sequences reach the goal. Under Puzzle's XOR structure, Corollary 1 (Section 2.4) shows that the goal-relative state is the residual , planning reduces to subject to over (Eq. 16), and the valid configuration space forms equivalence classes—one per reachable residual in and, when , one merged class for all unreachable residuals (Eq. 17; Table 7).
Part 2: Replanning in Both ATQ and TTGS, and Shared-Exclusion Controls
Thank you for asking us to separate feedback effects and test generalization beyond both learners' training data.
1. Replanning in both ATQ and TTGS
The submitted event-substitution test assesses ATQ's recovery (Section 3.2, Figure 2; Appendix C.7). We now compare TTGS without replanning, with its released drift-triggered replanning, and with replanning every 50 environment steps. ATQ either replans from observed registers or keeps its initial event set fixed. The latter retains local event detection and retries, removing global plan revision rather than all feedback.
| Puzzle dataset | TTGS no replanning | TTGS native replanning | TTGS every 50 steps | ATQ fixed event set | ATQ with replanning |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 3×3 play | 98.25 ± 0.59 | 98.20 ± 0.61 | 98.05 ± 0.52 | 100.00 ± 0.00 | 100.00 ± 0.00 |
| 3×3 noisy | 98.05 ± 0.50 | 98.05 ± 0.50 | 98.15 ± 0.52 | 100.00 ± 0.00 | 100.00 ± 0.00 |
| 4×4 play | 25.65 ± 1.61 | 25.90 ± 1.57 | 16.85 ± 0.35 | 78.85 ± 1.91 | 98.45 ± 0.50 |
| 4×4 noisy | 44.15 ± 1.75 | 44.15 ± 1.75 | 48.25 ± 1.60 | 94.55 ± 1.61 | 95.20 ± 1.47 |
| 4×5 play | 1.80 ± 0.58 | 1.95 ± 0.61 | 0.65 ± 0.18 | 78.55 ± 1.84 | 100.00 ± 0.00 |
| 4×5 noisy | 2.30 ± 0.53 | 2.30 ± 0.53 | 2.55 ± 0.43 | 88.05 ± 3.20 | 97.85 ± 0.57 |
| 4×6 play | 0.60 ± 0.25 | 0.70 ± 0.15 | 0.15 ± 0.11 | 80.00 ± 3.14 | 99.60 ± 0.15 |
| 4×6 noisy | 0.25 ± 0.15 | 0.20 ± 0.15 | 0.20 ± 0.15 | 85.00 ± 1.37 | 98.85 ± 0.51 |
All entries are new success percentages (mean ± SEM over eight frozen GCIQL policy seeds, five official tasks, 50 episodes per task). Checkpoints and reset seeds are shared; TTGS variants use the same 4,000-node graphs.
Native replanning triggers in 36.6% and 67.6% of episodes on 4×5-play and 4×6-play, and never on the noisy datasets. The periodic control replans in at least 99.8% of episodes on each 4×5 and 4×6 dataset. It improves TTGS on 4×4-noisy, but TTGS remains below 3% on 4×5 and 4×6 under both settings. Fixed-set ATQ substantially exceeds both replanning TTGS variants, and ATQ's own replanning adds 9.80–21.45 percentage points on these datasets. Thus, feedback contributes, but the tested replanning mechanisms alone do not close the gap.
2. Combinations excluded from both policy and compiler training
The submitted experiment measures compiler-level novelty (Section 3.2; Appendix C.3, Table 11). We removed every training transition whose source or successor had the top-left and bottom-right lights both on, and excluded this pattern from all relabeled training goals. We refitted the compiler, including its register extractor, event rules, and execution prototypes, and trained eight new GCIQL policies per dataset on the retained replay. The compiler recovered the 20-bit and 24-bit registers within the supplied binary candidate family. TTGS used the same filtered replay with native replanning.
The following table reports the three official tasks per board whose goals contain the excluded pattern, selected by goal content rather than outcomes. Their initial states do not contain the pattern.
| Puzzle dataset | GCIQL | TTGS with replanning | ATQ (refitted extractor & rules) |
|---|---|---|---|
| 4×5 play | 0.08 ± 0.08 | 0.17 ± 0.17 | 98.00 ± 1.08 |
| 4×5 noisy | 0.00 ± 0.00 | 0.42 ± 0.25 | 95.08 ± 1.11 |
| 4×6 play | 0.00 ± 0.00 | 0.00 ± 0.00 | 100.00 ± 0.00 |
| 4×6 noisy | 0.00 ± 0.00 | 0.00 ± 0.00 | 97.00 ± 1.30 |
For the same trained models, the averages over all five official tasks, including the two whose goals do not contain the pattern, are:
| Puzzle dataset | GCIQL | TTGS with replanning | ATQ (refitted extractor & rules) |
|---|---|---|---|
| 4×5 play | 12.95 ± 0.79 | 1.90 ± 0.33 | 98.65 ± 0.63 |
| 4×5 noisy | 14.00 ± 1.94 | 1.90 ± 0.40 | 96.75 ± 0.71 |
| 4×6 play | 12.85 ± 0.87 | 1.30 ± 0.44 | 100.00 ± 0.00 |
| 4×6 noisy | 15.05 ± 1.35 | 0.40 ± 0.19 | 98.00 ± 0.77 |
3. Equal replay access without pattern exclusion
All methods use the original 60% compiler-fit episodes, without pattern exclusion, and are evaluated on all five official tasks. TTGS uses native replanning.
| Puzzle dataset | GCIQL | TTGS with replanning | ATQ |
|---|---|---|---|
| 4×5 play | 10.80 ± 0.90 | 2.30 ± 1.08 | 98.00 ± 0.83 |
| 4×5 noisy | 18.85 ± 0.23 | 2.85 ± 0.56 | 98.55 ± 0.45 |
| 4×6 play | 10.90 ± 0.94 | 0.85 ± 0.21 | 99.20 ± 0.23 |
| 4×6 noisy | 17.10 ± 0.69 | 0.55 ± 0.44 | 97.45 ± 0.69 |
The two data controls use separate cohorts of eight newly trained GCIQL policies per dataset. Their tables report success percentages (mean ± SEM across policy seeds, 50 episodes per task). Shared exclusion tests a two-register combination absent from both policy and compiler training, complementing the full register–event pair audit in Table 11.
Response to Reviewer YCce
We are deeply grateful for the time and expertise you devoted to such a thorough and constructive evaluation of our manuscript. Your insightful comments guided us in designing a comprehensive set of new experiments that directly address each of your concerns, all of which we will incorporate into the revised manuscript.
ATQ needs a task representation through registers that can distinguish the states relevant to the task, but supplying registers does not supply event effects, execution conditions, or a solution.
Supplied structure, direct-XOR baseline, and theory. The submitted Theorem 1 gives one-step consistency conditions under which registers preserve event applicability, transitions, and goal completion along executable sequences. Theorem 2 characterizes the coarsest task memory preserving successful event sequences (Section 2.1), yielding Corollary 1's goal-relative residual formulation for Puzzle (Section 2.4). Proposition 2 explains when replay determines predictions at unseen configurations within an operator family (Section 2.3; Appendix A.4). These results justify composition when their conditions hold, rather than guaranteeing arbitrary unseen combinations. New direct-XOR, Boolean-without-named-XOR, and physical-mask controls all recover the original policy-evaluation model on 8/8 Puzzle datasets. Thus, the Puzzle gain comes from learning and composing concrete event rules, not an advantage over direct fitting of the correct operator family.
Feedback and generalization. First, in addition to TTGS's native drift-triggered replanning, we forced TTGS to replan every 50 environment steps; it actually replans in at least 99.8% of episodes on each 4×5 and 4×6 dataset, yet the large performance gap remains (0.15–2.55% for TTGS versus 78.55–88.05% for fixed-set ATQ and 97.85–100.00% for replanning ATQ on 4×5 and 4×6). Second, we excluded a two-register combination from both policy and compiler training, including relabeled goals, and retrained both from scratch. ATQ achieves 95.08–100.00% on official goals requiring that combination, compared with 0.00–0.08% for GCIQL and 0.00–0.42% for replanning TTGS.
Failure mechanisms and learning beyond supplied registers. First, new HumanoidMaze giant controls separately test policy connection, waypoint distance, target selection, graph support, and intervention timing. Preserving both LAVL policy stages and delaying intervention recovers 24.45 and 29.55 percentage points relative to the submitted method (84.75% and 85.30%), restoring LAVL-level performance without policy retraining. Second, in a new Scene intervention (robot-arm tasks involving buttons, a lockable drawer, a sliding window, and a cube with sequential preconditions), using learned cross-register event conditions improves success by 8.60 and 6.75 percentage points while keeping registers, event effects, and policies fixed.
The three follow-ups (Parts 1–3) provide the matched tables, protocols, and case analyses.