- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes TEMPO, a learned temporal metric for goal-conditioned planning with latent world models. The method trains a small projection network using temporal gaps between states from recorded trajectories, then combines the resulting embedding distance with the planner's original latent-distance cost. The goal is to improve long-horizon planning without retraining the world model. The evaluation covers navigation and manipulation tasks, with comparisons using matched world-model checkpoints and planning budgets. The results show substantial navigation improvements, particularly on TwoRoom, and the ablations support combining temporal and latent distances.
Critical strengths
The paper investigates an interesting mismatch between prediction and control. A representation that supports accurate short-term prediction may not provide a useful distance for evaluating progress toward a distant goal. And the proposed method's performance on navigation environments is strong. The ablation study is also informative.
Critical weaknesses
Overall, I see the practical contribution as a lightweight modification to the terminal cost of an existing frozen-model planner. The results demonstrate useful improvements in the tested settings. The scientific contribution would be clearer, however, if the paper better established what is gained from this particular temporal embedding and blending design, when it helps, and where its limitations lie. Although the evaluation covers several application families, its applicability beyond the closely related model and planning implementations remains less clear.
Evidence for the design choices. The ablation study supports combining the original latent distance with the learned temporal distance, and Appendices I–J provide useful diagnostics of the representation and candidate rankings. However, it remains unclear which benefits are specific to the proposed embedding geometry, rather than to adding a learned progress estimate more generally. Could the authors clarify the advantages and tradeoffs of their design relative to alternative learned costs? For example, would a scalar predictor taking a pair of state representations, trained on the same temporal-gap labels and used in the same blended planning cost, provide similar improvements?
Interpretation of temporal distance. Equation (4) uses the observed number of steps between two states as supervision. These gaps may reflect waiting or detours, rather than the minimum time needed to travel between the states. Could the authors clarify how the behavior that generated the trajectories affects the learned metric and planning performance? In particular, under what conditions should the observed time gap provide a reliable measure of progress toward the goal?
Presentation of the method. The method section would benefit from separating the general formulation from the experimental configuration. The roles of temporal normalization, the supervision cutoff, the blending weight, and the required model interface should be explained before introducing their chosen values, network dimensions, and training schedule.
Questions for authors
Please see weaknesses.