- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 1
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
The paper investigates whether internal-state interventions in Qwen3.5-122B-A10B can separately control an editing rule and source-code features. It patches instruction-token states to transfer the rule and old-code-token states to transfer source structure, and reports that combining both interventions produces the intended composite edit. Additional experiments study downstream restoration and the influence of Plan-state interventions on action selection.
Critical strengths
1.Controlled causal design. The paper keeps visible prompts fixed and includes self-replacement, repeat, and donor-background controls; 2.Behavioral evaluation. The strongest experiments evaluate complete and applicable code edits, rather than relying only on probes or next-token statistics.
Critical weaknesses
1.Insufficient and narrowly scoped evidence. The main claims rely on one model and a few hand-constructed factorial cases, often only four outcomes per condition, without statistical uncertainty. Several Plan experiments are also inconclusive: the specificity criterion is not met, one repository cohort fails its verifier criterion, and only 4/96 unforced outputs are semantically valid. The main text lacks a unified method diagram and complete per-condition results, making the approach and evidence difficult to assess. 2.Unclear novelty. The method is largely standard activation/interchange patching, closely related to prior request/context composition. The main novelty appears to be its application to structured code editing, while the composition, restoration, and Plan experiments do not form a sufficiently clear or unified methodological advance.
Questions for authors
1.What is the precise methodological contribution beyond prior interchange-intervention and request/context composition work? 2.How were layers B17/B18 and the intervention spans selected, and were these choices fixed before evaluating the reported tasks? 3.Assessment-changing evidence: Do the composition results replicate across additional models, independently selected programs, and non-aligned token spans?