- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
The paper studies memory interference in a recurrent CA3 model with 8,000 pyramidal cells and 150 basket cells. Sequentially remapped environments share one synaptic network, and memory is assessed through spontaneous and cued replay. After five environments, moderate resetting of weak synapses restores replay, whereas stronger resetting destroys it. Interleaving learning with anti-Hebbian offline plasticity and resets redistributes weights while preserving replay across five environments. At higher loads, cued recall of Environment 1 persists longer than spontaneous replay under different evaluation protocols. The authors interpret compression as counteracting synaptic saturation and supporting continued memory function.
Critical strengths
-
The shared recurrent circuit makes the memory-interference problem concrete and easy to follow. Different environments modify the same connections, while known place-cell orderings allow generated sequences to be associated with particular memories. This links the circuit description to a functional measure of memory expression and makes the consequences of synaptic modification interpretable beyond changes in average activity.
-
The evaluation combines reset-threshold sweeps, recall across five environments, and weight-distribution analyses. Moderate resetting restores replay, whereas stronger resetting abolishes it, revealing an informative dependence on intervention strength. The combined protocol also redistributes weights above the direct reset threshold. Together, these observations provide a useful empirical basis for studying how a recurrent network can recover access to stored sequences after substantial synaptic modification.
Critical weaknesses
-
The evidence does not fully separate retention of existing memories, successful acquisition of new traces at higher loads, and the incremental functional benefit of anti-hSTDP. The five-environment tests assess multiple memories, but Table 1 reports higher-load cued recall only for Environment 1, leaving successful retrieval of the additional traces unverified. Its disclosed before-reset spontaneous and after-reset cued measurements also compare complete protocols, limiting conclusions about retrieval mode itself. Although connectivity reorganization with preserved recall is demonstrated, the additional recall or capacity benefit of anti-hSTDP beyond resetting alone remains unclear without a matched comparison.
-
Two reporting inconsistencies prevent a precise assessment of uncertainty and model specification. Figure 1b labels spontaneous replay n=5, whereas Section 2.2 states two simulations per threshold; the error-bar definition and treatment of cued trials sharing a network remain unclear. Appendix Equations (1)-(3) also combine additive currents with signs that appear inconsistent with their intended physiological effects. These may be reporting errors, but require checking against the actual runs and implementation before interpreting their consequences.
Questions for authors
-
For the additional environments in Table 1, are environment-specific recall outcomes available for the newest and intermediate traces? Please report success counts and independent-run counts under a common recall protocol, where available. If only Environment 1 was tested, distinguish demonstrated retention of that trace from the claim that compression enables successful acquisition of additional memories.
-
Table 1 already specifies the different reset stages. Is there an existing comparison of spontaneous and cued retrieval at the same reset stage and memory load, with detector criteria made comparable? If not, please attribute the observed capacity difference to the two complete evaluation protocols rather than to retrieval mode alone.
-
With the reset schedule, thresholds, memory load, and evaluation protocol held fixed, does enabling anti-hSTDP improve replay or recall compared with resetting alone? Please report any available matched comparison. This would clarify its incremental functional benefit beyond the demonstrated connectivity reorganization with preserved recall.
-
Please reconcile Figure 1b's n=5 with Section 2.2's two spontaneous simulations per threshold, and define the error bars. For the ten cued trials, explain how uncertainty accounts for the five environments sharing each learned network. Please identify the independent unit used in the reported summaries.
-
Equation (1) adds synaptic and adaptation currents, Equation (3) uses g(V−E), and Equation (2) gives a positive spike-triggered adaptation increment. Please state the signs used in the implemented voltage equation and reconcile them with the printed expressions. Clarify whether any discrepancy is confined to manuscript notation or affects the simulations.
Responding to my questions will cover the points I‘ve addressed in the weaknesses.
3 comments
Thank you for the detailed response and additional analyses. The corrected equations, clearer separation of experimental conditions, and expanded repetitions improve the reliability of the presentation. The new controls also clarify that the increase in cued-recall capacity is largely attributable to the homeostatic reset, while anti-hSTDP mainly contributes to compression and replay stability. The revised framing is therefore more consistent with the evidence.
My main concern remains the connection to loss of plasticity and its recovery. Preserving spontaneous expression of the newest memory does not directly establish an improved ability to acquire subsequent memories, and fewer potentiated synapses alone do not establish that the resulting compression preserves future learning capacity. The revised results support a useful but narrower contribution; the central link between compression and recovered plasticity remains indirect. I am therefore maintaining my rating of 2.
Thank you for the careful follow-up. We agree with your summary, with one update from the final simulations. A schedule-matched control (reset after every environment, no offline anti-hSTDP) shows that the reduction in potentiated synapses also comes from the reset schedule, not from anti-hSTDP. With the reset matched, anti-hSTDP weakens the strongest synapses but leaves recall, capacity and spontaneous replay unchanged. The revised paper attributes both capacity and synaptic cost to the homeostatic reset.
On loss of plasticity, we agree that the link is indirect, and the revised Discussion says so. What the results do show is narrower. Without the reset, the network stops replaying any environment after five have been learned. With the reset applied after every environment, environments learned sixth and seventh are still stored well enough to be recalled from a cue (the newest environment in 5 of 6 simulations at seven environments). So the reset preserves the network’s ability to store new environments in retrievable form. It does not show that the rate or efficiency of learning is restored. As we note in the Discussion, a direct test would compare how quickly a loaded network and a fresh network learn the same new environment. We see that as the next step and have framed the contribution accordingly.
Response to Reviewer uw7X
Thank you again. The revised PDF addresses your questions as follows.
Q1. Fig. 1a reports which environment each spontaneous replay expressed (newest, intermediate, oldest), and Table S3 reports cued recall of every learned environment in the control. In the combined protocol only the first environment was cued, and §2.4 limits the claim at those loads to retention of that trace.
Q2. We removed spontaneous replay from Table 1. Fig. 1b now provides the matched comparison you asked for: both readouts are measured in the same simulations after the same reset (§2.2).
Q3. The control without offline plasticity (§2.4, Tables 1 and S3) reached comparable cued-recall capacity, so anti-hSTDP did not improve recall. The control also differs in reset schedule and in plasticity during recall, which we state explicitly. Anti-hSTDP’s contribution is different: comparable recall with 23% fewer potentiated synapses at seven environments (Table 2), stable dynamics at eight environments, and continued replay of newly learned environments (Fig. 1a). The title, abstract and §2.4 now make this claim rather than a capacity gain.
Q4. Fig. 1b now uses 10 independent simulations per threshold. Cue trials within a simulation share its weight matrix, so they are averaged within each simulation, and error bars give the standard error of the mean across simulations (§2.2, Appendix A.10).
Q5. Corrected as described in our earlier reply (Appendix A.3, Eqs. 1–3).