- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes a dynamic fidelity evaluation protocol for human motion denoising and post-processing. The authors believe that traditional MPJPE and acceleration errors are insufficient to fully reflect motion quality, especially when it is difficult to distinguish between real motion details and noise that are simultaneously suppressed.
Critical strengths
I think the starting point of the entire paper is a good one. The exploration of movement quality assessment is of practical significance. The author not only evaluates whether the algorithm can repair noisy human movements, but also evaluates whether the algorithm destroys the original correct movements through Identity testing.
Critical weaknesses
- Why is there no visualization in the entire article? This work specializes in human motion evaluation and can fully demonstrate the comparison between original estimation, different post-processing methods, and Ground Truth. The author can fully display the three-dimensional human skeleton motion, joint trajectories, key time periods, and the corresponding MPJPE, LSD, and JRD at the same time. Moreover, I have not seen any supplementary materials for the "Appendix A/B, Appendix B.9, B.10" mentioned in the paper. The paper was clearly not ready for publication.
- As far as I know, LSD, jerk, and spectral analysis all have a long history of research. The main contribution of this paper is to combine these existing tools with clean input identity testing into a new evaluation protocol. However, I am not convinced by the fact that the paper has not fully demonstrated that this protocol can reflect the true quality of human movement better than existing evaluation metrics.
Questions for authors
When the MPJPE of two post-processing results are almost the same, can your LSD/JRD stably determine which human action is more visually natural and kinematically reasonable? Please demonstrate with actual human motion sequences or independent perceptual evaluation.