- Rating
- 3
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 3
Read review
Paper summary
The paper studies linear Stackelberg mean-field games with myopic quantal-response followers. It compares three feedback settings. State observation (SO) reveals the population-state marginal. Marginal observation (MO) also reveals the action marginal, but not the state–action pairing. Complete observation (CO) reveals the joint distribution.
Critical strengths
- The paper clearly distinguishes observing both marginals from observing the joint distribution. This captures a meaningful difference in information.
- The effective dimension explains which parameters determine the exponent of T. This gives more insight than an upper bound alone.
- The lower-bound sketch accounts for the full observable history. It also specifies shared feature maps within each testing family. These details help address possible information leakage.
- The MO capacity criterion explains when the extra observation gives no improvement in the worst case. This is more informative than simply showing that more information cannot hurt.
Critical weaknesses
none
Questions for authors
none
2 comments
Thank you for the response. The proposed example should help make the distinction between marginal and joint observations more concrete. My assessment remains positive.
Response to Reviewer eM2V
Dear Reviewer eM2V,
Thank you for your review and for recognizing the paper’s theoretical contributions and their implications for learning from population marginals. The distinction you highlight between observing both marginals and observing the joint state–action distribution motivates our comparison of feedback settings.
The effective dimension determines the minimax regret exponent under state observation. In the parameter-limited regime of Theorem 5, observing the action marginal alongside the state marginal lowers that exponent exactly when the linear blindness capacity is smaller than the follower parameter dimension.
We will add a two-state, two-action example beside Table 1 and refer back to it before the capacity definition. The example shows how changes in conditional responses can cancel across states, leaving both marginals fixed while the joint distribution changes.