acceptodds
Withdrawn from ICLR 2027

SwiftLight: One-Step Low-Light Image Enhancement via Trajectory-Aware Distillation and Global-Local Consistency

Withdrawn from ICLR 2027, so left out of the paper lists and the map.

Abstract

Diffusion models have shown promising performance in low-light image enhancement. However, iterative sampling incurs substantial computation, especially for high-resolution images. Aggressive acceleration can degrade restoration quality, while independent patch processing may produce inconsistent illumination. To address these challenges, we propose SwiftLight, a trajectory-aware distillation framework for one-step low-light image enhancement. Specifically, we introduce a three-stage training strategy. In the first stage, we distill a multi-step teacher into a few-step model through segment-wise consistency learning. In the second stage, the few-step model supervises a one-step student that starts from the low-light input. Teacher trajectory cues and input darkness guide spatial supervision in both stages to retain important restoration corrections. In the third stage, adversarial refinement is incorporated into one-step training to improve texture realism. Furthermore, we design a lightweight consistency head to calibrate independently enhanced patches using a full-image prediction. Adaptive low-frequency correction and center-weighted fusion align illumination and color while retaining local details. Experiments demonstrate strong perceptual quality with one-step patch inference. Code will be made publicly available.

Primary area:
applications to computer vision, audio, language, and other modalities
Keywords:
Low-Light Enhancement

Reviews

Among:
Shape:
1234this paper, Bottom 27%
Figure 1. Mean review rating of the reviewed papers at ICLR 2027. This paper averages 2.00 over 3 reviews, above 27% of the others.
Reviewer_QDFnOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
3
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
1
Read review
Paper summary

This paper presents SwiftLight, a one-step low-light enhancement framework combining staged diffusion distillation, trajectory-aware supervision, adversarial refinement, and global–local patch correction. Experiments on three LOL benchmarks demonstrate improved perceptual quality and reduced inference time.

Critical strengths

1.The method achieves the best LPIPS and DISTS among the compared methods on all three benchmarks. 2.The global–local correction addresses illumination inconsistency during patch-based inference, and the manuscript is generally clear.

Critical weaknesses

1.Limited methodological novelty. Segment-wise consistency distillation, teacher–student training, and adversarial refinement are established techniques. The additional contribution of trajectory-aware weighting is insufficiently isolated. 2. Limited fidelity advantage. The method achieves neither the best PSNR nor the best SSIM on any evaluated dataset. On LOL-v2-real, its PSNR is approximately 3.21 dB below HVI-CIDNet, indicating a substantial fidelity trade-off despite improved perceptual metrics. 3.Incomplete ablation controls. Table 3 uses different training schedules across variants and does not separately evaluate trajectory weighting and darkness weighting, making their individual benefits difficult to assess.

Questions for authors
  1. What distinguishes the proposed distillation strategy from existing consistency distillation beyond spatial loss reweighting?
  2. What explains the PSNR gap on LOL-v2-real, and how much of it results from adversarial refinement?
  3. Can the authors clarify the contributions of trajectory weighting and darkness weighting under matched training budgets? 4.Were runtime comparisons conducted using identical hardware, precision, and comparable patch settings? The exceptionally large MDMS runtime warrants clarification.
Reviewer_rENXOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
3
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
3
Read review
Paper summary

This work presents SwiftLight, a one‑step diffusion‑based low‑light image enhancement method using three‑stage trajectory‑aware distillation. It progressively compresses a self‑trained multi‑step diffusion teacher into a one‑step student with spatial weighting and interleaved adversarial refinement. A global‑local consistency head suppresses patch‑related illumination artifacts for high‑resolution inputs. It obtains strong perceptual performance and fast inference on LOL benchmarks.

Critical strengths
  1. Targets a practical gap: diffusion‑based low‑light enhancement incurs high inference cost, and high‑performing one‑step diffusion LLIE solutions are scarce.
  2. Proposes a tailored staged distillation pipeline. The student initializes from raw low‑light inputs (not noise).
  3. The global‑local consistency head alleviates patch‑caused illumination artifacts for high‑resolution inputs.
  4. Achieves SOTA LPIPS / DISTS and superior inference speed over iterative diffusion baselines on three LOL benchmarks.
Critical weaknesses
  1. Innovations are mainly task‑specific engineering adaptations rather than fundamental methodological advances. Progressively reducing the number of steps in diffusion in training is not new. Many individual components have existing precedents -- Consistency learning, adversarial training etc.
  2. Performance gains are partially confounded by adversarial refinement. It is well known that adversarial training can improve the results. From Table 3, the final model works even better than the initial teacher in several metrics. This needs further clarification -- is it possible the performance gain is from adversarial refinement instead of the proposed step-reduction distillation?
  3. Evaluations are limited to LOL‑series paired datasets; generalization on diverse in‑the‑wild/out‑of‑distribution low‑light samples is not sufficiently validated.
  4. The related‑work section lacks sufficient depth. One‑step diffusion techniques are widely studied across many computer‑vision tasks, yet the paper neither discusses these existing works nor clarifies whether the proposed method draws inspiration from them.
Questions for authors

Please refer to the weaknesses outlined above. In particular, an ablation study should be provided to clarify the actual contribution of adversarial refinement. Moreover, the source of performance gains relative to the original multi‑step teacher needs to be identified.

Reviewer_ob3VOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
4
Informativeness
2
Presentation
3
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

SwiftLight compresses a 25-step conditional diffusion enhancer into one evaluation on patches. Stage 1 reweights segment-wise consistency distillation by a teacher-improvement map MLM_L and a Max-RGB darkness map D(y)D(y). Stage 2 trains a student that starts from the low-light image at t=333t=333 and matches a frozen four-step teacher. Stage 3 adds an adversarial update that uses DINOv3 features and HYPIR heads.

Critical strengths

Sec. 1 asks a real residual question: one evaluation has to keep corrections that a long teacher still makes, and separate patches can disagree in illumination. [Lan et al., 2025] leaves single-step LLIE short of its 2-step model, so the target of SwiftLight is the right one. Appendix A.1 specifies the weight in full, with wmin⁡=0.5w_{\min}=0.5, wmax⁡=2w_{\max}=2, warm-up R=5000R=5000, γL=γS=1\gamma_L=\gamma_S=1, and a detached unit-mean map (Eq. (19) to Eq. (22)). Appendix A.2 specifies the 2×22\times 2 group of 192×192192\times 192 patches, the anchor YfixY_{\mathrm{fix}}, and the head loss (Eq. (23) to Eq. (25)). Table 3 keeps the stage effects visible. GT-only one-step training reaches 23.195623.1956 dB, S1+S2 is 22.817822.8178 dB, and the schedule that adds Stage 3 moves CLIP-IQA from 0.51390.5139 to 0.62390.6239. Table 2 is informative next to CWNet at 8.6368.636 s: SwiftLight takes 5.8955.895 s, and the stride-8 MDMS entry of 70761.8870761.88 s is an extreme schedule.

Critical weaknesses
  1. Pre-25Steps matches the LOL-v1 MDMS row of Table 1 at 22.746422.7464 dB, SSIM 0.90600.9060, LPIPS 0.08350.0835, and CLIP-IQA 0.51350.5135, while Sec. 3.2 cites the teacher jointly as [Jiang et al., 2023; Yi et al., 2023; Shang et al., 2024] (Table 3). ReDDiT [Lan et al., 2025] distills an LLIE trajectory after reflectance-aware refinement. Eq. (7) and Eq. (9) reweight the loss, and the text never states how this differs from that refinement. The citation is absent from Sec. 2.2, Sec. 3, and Table 1. Stage 3 moves CLIP-IQA from 0.51390.5139 to 0.62390.6239 with uncited DINOv3 features [Simeoni et al., DINOv3, 2025, attribution survey] and HYPIR heads [Lin et al., HYPIR, 2025, attribution survey]. MLM_L, MSM_S, and D(y)D(y) are not removed (Table 3).

  2. The LPIPS order needs a declared alignment. Table 1 gives HVI-CIDNet 23.808323.8083 dB and LPIPS 0.08560.0856 on LOL-v1. [Yan et al., 2025] gives 28.20128.201 dB and LPIPS 0.0790.079 with GT-mean on 15 pairs. LLFlow is 21.149121.1491 dB here and 24.99824.998 dB or 25.13225.132 dB in [Yan et al., 2025; Lan et al., 2025]. ReDDiT LPIPS 0.0620.062 is missing. Retinexformer [Cai et al., 2023] and SNR-Net [Xu et al., 2022] are cited and omitted. GPP-LLIE is blank on LOL-v2-real. Table 4 moves LPIPS by 0.00090.0009. Table 2 times 1920×10801920\times 1080 and reports no image quality there.

  3. The equations leave the sampler underdetermined. cc in Eq. (1) to Eq. (4) is never instantiated. Eq. (8) writes L~(x)=ymax⁡(x)\tilde{L}(x)=y_{\max}(x) and L(y)=Gauss(L~)L(y)=\mathrm{Gauss}(\tilde{L}), mixing xx, yy, and L~\tilde{L}. τi=−1\tau_i=-1 in Sec. 3.2 lies outside 0=τ0<⋯<τK=T0=\tau_0<\cdots<\tau_K=T (Sec. 3.1). Eq. (13) uses λT\lambda_T where Appendix A.3 uses λteacher=1\lambda_{\mathrm{teacher}}=1, and Eq. (14) uses label rr where that appendix uses 0.80.8. t=333t=333 is not derived from β1=10−4\beta_1=10^{-4} and βT=0.02\beta_T=0.02, and x^0S\hat{x}^{S}_{0} in Eq. (10) is not tied to Eq. (6).

Questions for authors
  1. Is the 25-step teacher the MDMS checkpoint [Shang et al., 2024]? Please add ReDDiT [Lan et al., 2025] at steps 2, 4, and 8 to Table 1 under one declared GT-mean choice, applied to every row. Which LPIPS order remains? This answer would change the rating.

  2. Please state whether every LOL-v1 number in Table 1 uses GT-mean. Please report HVI-CIDNet and LLFlow both as in Table 1 and at 28.20128.201 dB and LPIPS 0.0790.079 [Yan et al., 2025], with LLFlow also at 24.99824.998 dB or 25.13225.132 dB [Yan et al., 2025; Lan et al., 2025]. Please add Retinexformer [Cai et al., 2023] and SNR-Net [Xu et al., 2022] under that setting, and explain the blank GPP-LLIE cells on LOL-v2-real.

  3. Please ablate MLM_L, MSM_S, and D(y)D(y) one at a time on LOL-v1 with matched iterations, and report the iteration count behind GT-1step at 23.195623.1956 dB. S1+S2 is 22.817822.8178 dB after 6060K iterations, while S1-only uses 120120K. Please add bibliography entries for the HYPIR heads [Lin et al., HYPIR, 2025, attribution survey] and the DINOv3 weights [Simeoni et al., DINOv3, 2025, attribution survey] used in Eq. (14).

  4. Please define cc, repair Eq. (8), and derive t=333t=333 from the linear schedule. Please report image quality together with the 1920×10801920\times 1080 timing, plus NIQE or an equivalent on DICM, LIME, MEF, NPE, and VV. Questions 1 to 3 would change the rating. A faster fusion kernel would leave it unchanged.

From OpenReview, CC BY 4.0. Authors as signed there; shown unedited.

Related papers

Discussion (0)

Sign in to comment.