- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes KoopSDE, a two-stage framework for learning drift and diffusion functions of high-dimensional stochastic differential equations. It combines stochastic Koopman eigenfunction learning with Hutchinson trace estimation to reduce computational complexity. Experiments on synthetic systems and real-world traffic data demonstrate scalability up to 100,000 dimensions with reasonable estimation accuracy.
Critical strengths
The proposed framework effectively combines Koopman-based learning with efficient trace estimation, enabling SDE coefficient learning at dimensions that are computationally prohibitive for the evaluated baselines. The experiments demonstrate substantial memory savings while maintaining reasonable estimation accuracy.
Critical weaknesses
Although KoopSDE learns drift and diffusion in the original high-dimensional space, it relies on a limited number of Koopman eigenfunctions and a low-rank-plus-diagonal diffusion parameterization. It remains unclear whether these representations sufficiently capture complex high-dimensional dynamics, or what practical advantages they offer over directly learning lower-dimensional latent SDE dynamics. The current experiments do not adequately establish this distinction.
Questions for authors
Could the authors further clarify the advantages of recovering drift and diffusion in the original high-dimensional space over using latent SDE models? A comparison on a common forecasting task, together with experiments involving more complex high-dimensional dynamics, would help establish the practical benefits and limitations of the proposed approach.