acceptodds
Under review as a conference paper at ICLR 2027

Hint-Guided Diversified Policy Optimization for LLM Reasoning

Abstract

Recent developments in Large Language Models (LLMs) have showcased impressive reasoning capabilities and a promising enhancement strategy is Reinforcement Learning with Verifiable Rewards (RLVR). However, existing reward mechanisms are constrained to the outcome-level correctness and lack explicit signals to guide the model to consider diverse solutions. In contrast, human problem-solving usually involves considering several potential solutions and choosing the most reliable one, a cognitive process that current RLVR frameworks do not explicitly incentivize. Inspired by this cognitive process, we propose Hint-Guided Diversified Policy Optimization (HDPO), allowing the model to first list all potential candidate solution outlines as hints and then select the most reliable one for further reasoning. HDPO comprises two stages of **Cold Start for Structured Reasoning** and **Hint-Guided Diversified Reinforcement Learning** to incentivize the model to generate diverse and reliable solutions following the “propose-select-think” trajectory. Experimental results show that HDPO effectively boosts LLM reasoning and enhances the diversity of candidate solutions as well as the LLM's ability to identify reliable solutions across mathematical and knowledge-intensive tasks.

Primary area:
foundation or frontier models, including LLMs
Keywords:
Large Language Model, Reinforcement Learning, Policy Optimization, Reasoning Agent

Reviews

Among:
Shape:
1234this paper, Bottom 27%
Figure 1. Mean review rating of the reviewed papers at ICLR 2027. This paper averages 2.00 over 3 reviews, above 27% of the others.
Reviewer_mXvuOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
4
Informativeness
2
Presentation
3
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

The paper proposes Hint-Guided Diversified Policy Optimization (HDPO), which trains an LLM to propose several candidate solution outlines, select one, and then develop a detailed solution. Training consists of a cold-start SFT stage using strong-teacher trajectories filtered for answer correctness and candidate-selection reliability, followed by GRPO with additional diversity and reliability rewards. Diversity is measured through embedding similarity, while reliability is approximated by the entropy ranking of candidate outlines. The evaluation covers three backbones and nine reasoning benchmarks. The paper reports substantial pass@3 improvements over corresponding GRPO baselines, alongside component ablations, candidate-selection analyses, and experiments with alternative optimization algorithms.

Critical strengths

Substantial and consistent reported improvements. HDPO improves the nine-benchmark average over the corresponding GRPO baseline by 7.27, 8.26, and 7.50 percentage points across the three backbones. Improvements extend beyond mathematics to knowledge-intensive benchmarks, making the empirical results worth investigating.

Critical weaknesses
  1. The main comparisons do not clearly isolate the proposed contribution. HDPO receives SFT on 83,279 correctness- and reliability-filtered trajectories generated by a strong teacher before reinforcement learning. It is unclear whether the GRPO baselines receive the same data and initialization. Consequently, the main gains may reflect teacher knowledge, data filtering, additional SFT, or the structured reasoning format, rather than primarily the proposed rewards. The separate reward ablations are useful, but do not replace a control that starts from the same SFT checkpoint and uses only correctness and format rewards under a comparable training budget.

  2. The reward design admits shortcuts that are not sufficiently examined. A single candidate is permitted, automatically receives the highest reliability rank, and can receive a group-derived diversity reference. This creates a possible way to obtain auxiliary rewards without meaningful exploration or selection. Moreover, a correct final answer does not establish that the unselected outlines are valid: the model could include unrelated or ineffective outlines to increase embedding diversity while solving through one useful route. Low token entropy also measures confidence rather than correctness and may depend on familiar wording or candidate order. The correlation and selection experiments provide encouraging evidence, but do not resolve these specific concerns.

  3. Important baselines and resource controls are missing. Beyond the matched-SFT GRPO control, DRA-GRPO is directly relevant because it incorporates embedding-based semantic diversity into GRPO rewards. Comparing against such a method would help establish the value of rewarding diversity within candidate outlines. The Self-Consistency comparison also needs a clearer evaluation protocol, since majority-vote accuracy and pass@3 assess different outcomes. Finally, the teacher-generation, repeated filtering, SFT, and auxiliary-model costs are not sufficiently quantified to establish an advantage under comparable total resources.

There are also two concrete issues with the supporting analysis. Figure 12 attributes failure to the absence of a complex-number approach, although candidate [3] explicitly proposes complex exponentials and roots of unity. This appears to be a selection or execution failure rather than the stated coverage failure. The inference-latency claims also lack sufficient measurement details: a single generated trajectory still requires sequential decoding, and the reported overhead is substantial in relative terms on some tasks.

Questions for authors
  1. Do the GRPO baselines use the same 83,279 filtered trajectories and the same SFT initialization as HDPO? What happens when both methods start from an identical SFT checkpoint, with the baseline retaining only correctness and format rewards?

  2. How frequently does HDPO generate only one candidate? Are single-candidate cases included in the reported selection accuracy? Can the authors show that the reward scheme encourages genuine multi-candidate exploration and that the additional outlines are valid, useful alternatives?

  3. How sensitive is entropy-based candidate ranking to candidate order and wording? Would rankings remain consistent if the same outlines were evaluated independently under a common context?

  4. How does HDPO compare with a diversity-aware baseline such as DRA-GRPO under matched initialization and resources? Please also clarify the evaluation protocol for Self-Consistency and report the full data-construction and training costs.

  5. Could the authors provide stronger comparisons with directly related diversity-aware and multi-path reasoning methods, particularly DRA-GRPO and ToTRL, under comparable initialization, training data, and computational budgets? How much of the reported improvement remains over a baseline that uses the same structured SFT checkpoint and propose-select-think format but only correctness and format rewards?

Reviewer_2H7sOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
4
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
1
Read review
Paper summary

This paper proposes Hint-Guided Diversified Policy Optimization (HDPO) to improve LLM reasoning through a "propose-select-think" process. It first uses teacher-generated trajectories for structured SFT, then applies RL with diversity and reliability rewards to encourage the generation and selection of promising solution strategies. Experiments across multiple models and reasoning benchmarks show improvements over GRPO and other RLVR methods.

Critical strengths
  1. Encouraging models to consider multiple solution strategies before detailed reasoning is a reasonable idea. The proposed "propose-select-think" framework is straightforward and easy to understand.

  2. The paper evaluates HDPO across three backbones and nine benchmarks, with generally positive results. It also includes component ablations and additional analyses of diversity and reliability.

Critical weaknesses
  1. Insufficiently fair comparisons and unclear attribution of improvements

    HDPO uses an additional structured SFT stage with 83K examples generated by a powerful teacher model and filtered using an auxiliary model. However, the baselines do not receive comparable teacher supervision. Two important comparisons are missing: (a) standard GRPO starting from exactly the same structured SFT checkpoint, to isolate the contribution of the proposed rewards; and (b) representative teacher-guided methods or conventional teacher-CoT distillation followed by RL, using comparable teacher resources and training budgets. The existing ablations do not fully address these concerns, making it difficult to determine how much of the improvement comes from HDPO's specific design.

  2. Potential reward hacking and insufficient validation of the intended reasoning behavior

    The diversity reward measures embedding dissimilarity without checking whether the proposed candidates are valid or useful solution strategies. Meanwhile, the reliability reward favors low-entropy candidates rather than directly evaluating their likelihood of success. The model could therefore generate one effective candidate alongside several unrelated candidates to obtain a high diversity reward, while consistently selecting the first, low-entropy candidate. This would satisfy the reward objectives without meaningful multi-strategy exploration or selection. Although the paper reports improved diversity and candidate selection accuracy, it does not directly examine candidate validity, selection-position biases, or whether such shortcuts emerge during training.

Questions for authors
  1. How does HDPO compare with (a) standard GRPO initialized from the same structured SFT checkpoint and (b) teacher-guided baselines using comparable teacher supervision and computational budgets?

  2. Can the authors provide evidence that the generated candidates remain valid and meaningfully distinct after RL training? In particular, how do the candidate-count and selection-position distributions change during training, and can the authors rule out the shortcut described above?

Reviewer_uUEDOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
3
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

HDPO trains LLMs to propose several solution outlines, select one, and then perform detailed reasoning. It combines structured SFT with diversity and entropy-based reliability rewards, reporting consistent improvements across three backbones and nine reasoning benchmarks.

Critical strengths
  • HDPO improves average pass@3 over GRPO by 7.27–8.26 percentage points across three backbones, showing substantial and consistent gains.

  • The component ablations, confidence–reliability analysis, and experiments with alternative optimization algorithms provide useful evidence for the method’s effectiveness.

Critical weaknesses
  • The contribution of the proposed rewards is not fully isolated. It is unclear whether GRPO shares HDPO’s SFT initialization and training budget, making it difficult to separate improvements from additional supervision, structured reasoning, and reward design.

  • Entropy is an imperfect proxy for solution reliability. The reported correlations are encouraging, but do not establish robustness when confident yet incorrect approaches compete with less familiar correct ones.

  • The diversity analysis does not establish candidate validity. Greater embedding distance need not imply more distinct, viable solution strategies, and rewarding a correct final answer does not ensure that the unselected candidates are useful.

  • The methodological novelty is incremental. HDPO combines structured proposal–selection with reward shaping; its additional contribution over prior learned multi-path reasoning, including ToTRL, requires clearer experimental isolation.

  • The practical efficiency gains remain insufficiently established. The main comparison uses pass@3, while the latency analysis lacks sufficient measurement details. Broader pass@1 results and comparisons under matched inference budgets would strengthen the efficiency claims.

Questions for authors
  • Does the diversity reward increase the number of distinct, viable approaches per question? Can this be evaluated by independently executing the candidate outlines, including those not selected?
  • Given the sensitivity to the diversity weight μ shown in Appendix C, how were the key hyperparameters selected, and what was the computational cost of tuning? Do the selected settings transfer across tasks and backbones without retuning, and how robust are the reported gains to variations in these settings?

From OpenReview, CC BY 4.0. Authors as signed there; shown unedited.

Related papers

Loading the map…

Discussion (0)

Sign in to comment.