- Rating
- 3
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 3
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes Cognition-Conditioned Deep Inverse Planning (CCDIP), a framework for inferring individual cognitive profiles from behavior in complex planning tasks. The key idea is to pretrain a hierarchical reinforcement learning policy conditioned on cognitive parameters, including outcome preferences, attentional costs, and goal-selection biases, thereby amortizing the computational cost of solving planning problems for different parameter settings. The pretrained policy is then used for likelihood-based parameter inference from observed behavior. Using a 2D driving task, the authors demonstrate parameter recovery on synthetic data and evaluate the model on human behavioral data. Their results show that incorporating attentional costs and heuristics improves model fit, while several inferred parameters exhibit stable individual differences across trials.
Critical strengths
-
Well-motivated problem. The paper addresses an important computational bottleneck in cognitive modeling: fitting planning-based models becomes computationally expensive in complex environments, particularly when optimal policies must be recomputed for different cognitive parameters.
-
A promising and scalable methodological framework. By pretraining a cognition-conditioned hierarchical policy, CCDIP amortizes the cost of planning across different parameter settings. Although the underlying techniques are not entirely new, their integration offers a practical approach to fitting resource-rational cognitive models in complex tasks.
-
Meaningful empirical validation. The authors evaluate the framework using both synthetic and human behavioral data. The parameter recovery experiments demonstrate that several cognitive parameters can be reasonably recovered, while the ablation studies show that attentional costs and heuristics contribute to explaining human behavior.
-
Potential for broader applications. The framework provides a flexible approach to cognitive model fitting that could potentially be extended to other planning tasks and cognitive model specifications. This makes it a potentially useful methodological contribution beyond the particular driving task investigated in the paper.
Critical weaknesses
-
Insufficient comparison with existing methods. The main limitation is the lack of direct comparisons with established approaches to cognitive model fitting, such as simulation-based likelihood estimation (e.g., inverse binomial sampling) or traditional inverse planning methods. While the proposed framework is promising, it remains unclear how much methodological advancement CCDIP provides over existing approaches. In particular, comparisons in computational efficiency, parameter recovery accuracy, and fitting stability would help establish its practical advantages. The current experiments primarily focus on internal model ablations rather than comparisons with alternative inference methods.
-
Limited evaluation of data efficiency. Although the authors report parameter recovery on synthetic data, the recovery accuracy varies substantially across parameters. It would be useful to examine how parameter recovery changes with the amount of available behavioral data. This would help clarify how much data is required for reliable cognitive parameter inference, particularly in complex planning tasks where different parameters may produce similar behavioral patterns.
Questions for authors
-
Scope and limitations of the methodological contribution. Could the authors further clarify the specific bottleneck addressed by CCDIP and its broader implications? My understanding is that CCDIP primarily addresses the computational tractability of fitting predefined planning-based cognitive models, while challenges related to parameter identifiability and hypothesis-space constraints remain. Importantly, collecting more behavioral data and incorporating qualitatively different process-level evidence may address different aspects of these challenges. For example, eye-tracking data have been used to reveal human planning strategies (Callaway et al., 2024), while think-aloud data have been shown to reshape the structures of automatically discovered cognitive models (Xie et al., 2026). These studies provide examples of how additional process-level evidence can help constrain cognitive model inference beyond behavioral choices alone. It would be interesting to discuss such complementary directions and how they might extend the proposed framework toward broader cognitive model identification.
-
Inconsistency between the main text and Appendix. Section 4.2 describes four cognition-conditioning parameters (collision cost, cognitive cost, goal proximity cost, and goal-flag distance cost), whereas Appendix A.2.1 (Eq. 8 and Tables 1–2) specifies only two (collision cost and cognitive cost). Could the authors clarify which parameterization was used in the actual training and experiments, and how the remaining parameters were incorporated?
References
Callaway, F., Yu, M., & Mattar, M. G. (2024). Revealing human planning strategies with eye-tracking. Proceedings of the 46th Annual Conference of the Cognitive Science Society, 4343–4349. https://escholarship.org/uc/item/8sm0k8z2
Xie, H., Jagadish, A. K., Pan, L., & Wilson, R. C. (2026). Think-Aloud Reshapes Automated Cognitive Model Discovery Beyond Behavior. arXiv preprint, arXiv:2605.05091. https://arxiv.org/abs/2605.05091
3 comments
Comment: Insufficient comparison with existing methods. The main limitation is the lack of direct comparisons with established approaches to cognitive model fitting, such as simulation-based likelihood estimation (e.g., inverse binomial sampling) or traditional inverse planning methods. While the proposed framework is promising, it remains unclear how much methodological advancement CCDIP provides over existing approaches. In particular, comparisons in computational efficiency, parameter recovery accuracy, and fitting stability would help establish its practical advantages. The current experiments primarily focus on internal model ablations rather than comparisons with alternative inference methods.
We thank the reviewer for making the connection to other advanced cognitive modeling methods. Simulation-based likelihood estimation approaches such as inverse binomial sampling (IBS) require the ability to simulate behavior under candidate parameter settings. In our task this is itself the bottleneck, and CCDIP allows us to amortize the cost of computing the choice model. Thus, the two are complementary since IBS could be run with our trained model. However it would provide a noisy estimate of the likelihood that our model gives directly and can be differentiated through, so we use the exact likelihood.
Traditional inverse planning requires a solution to the planning problem under different candidate profiles, and we are not aware of an alternative method that provides this for our task. Exact approaches (e.g., Baker et al., 2009; 2017) rely on dynamic programming over an enumerable state space, which is not available in a continuous, high-dimensional task. Approaches based on online search (e.g., Zhi-Xuan et al., 2020) have been developed for discrete, symbolic domains, where inference is over a finite set of goals with the agent’s bounded-rationality parameters held fixed; they do not directly apply to a continuous, stochastic task in which those parameters are the target of inference. The remaining alternative is to use deep RL to find solutions, but it would be impractical to do this without a cognition-conditioned policy: based on our experience training policies on this task, we conservatively estimate that training a subtask-selection policy for a single fixed cognitive profile would take at least 5 GPU-hours, so even an efficient search procedure that evaluated 100 cognitive profiles would take 500 GPU-hours. In contrast, in our implementation of CCDIP, the subtask-selection policy took 22 GPU-hours to train, works for a range of cognitive parameters, and is differentiable.
Comment: Limited evaluation of data efficiency. Although the authors report parameter recovery on synthetic data, the recovery accuracy varies substantially across parameters. It would be useful to examine how parameter recovery changes with the amount of available behavioral data. This would help clarify how much data is required for reliable cognitive parameter inference, particularly in complex planning tasks where different parameters may produce similar behavioral patterns.
We agree that this is a valuable analysis, and the reviewer’s point that different parameters may produce similar behavior is well taken. The current manuscript reports recovery at a single amount of data (six episodes per profile) and does not characterize how recovery depends on the amount of data. One advantage of CCDIP is that the trained model can cheaply simulate behavior under any cognitive profile in the trained range. This makes it possible to run simulation-based power analyses that inform experimental design, by estimating in advance whether a given design allows parameters to be recovered precisely and distinguished from one another. We now note this in the discussion as a direction for future work.
Thanks for the authors' rebuttal and clarification. I don't have any remaining concerns, and since it's already a positive score, I would keep the current score. Good luck!
We thank the reviewer for their interest in our work and their helpful comments. The reviewer raises some important questions about the novelty and contribution of our work. We address the author’s concerns and provide clarifications below.
The reviewer brings up a fascinating connection to work that uses process-level evidence in cognitive modeling. While we primarily see CCDIP as a general scalable technique for modeling choice behavior at a computational level of analysis (in the sense of Marr), it is conceptually straightforward to also have the forward model generate process outputs, such as gaze and even verbal reports, under varying cognitive constraints. We could then perform inference over both kinds of data, while leveraging process-level evidence in the model development phase, which could help with the identifiability issues the reviewer raises. This is an important point that we believe underscores the generality and extensibility of our approach, which we now note in the discussion on future work (section pasted below).
“Third, inferring latent profiles from behavioral choices presents challenges with parameter identifiability and hypothesis-space constraints. To address this, the forward model used in CCDIP could be extended to generate secondary behavioral measures, such as reaction times, eye movements, or even verbal reports, that vary with cognitive profiles but are not optimized. This extended model could then be inverted and used to better infer cognitive parameters by conditioning on the joint pattern of choices and process measures such as reaction-time (Bogacz et al., 2006), eye-tracking (Callaway et al., 2024), or think-aloud (Xie et al., 2026) data. Relatedly, because the trained model can cheaply simulate behavior under any profile in its training range, it could support simulation-based power analyses for experimental design.”
This is an important comment that echoes the concerns expressed by Reviewer 2. We thank the reviewer for bringing this oversight to our attention. We have revised the appendix, which now correctly mentions the four context parameters the model was conditioned on during training in Appendix A.2.1. We also added an additional section C in the Appendix detailing how the heuristic parameters were incorporated in our model, separate from training.