- Rating
- 3
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes TopoMath, a mathematical concept graph-based framework for LLM mathematical reasoning. The method first constructs a graph of mathematical concept relationships using Wikidata, then extracts relevant concepts and their relationships for each problem to form a scaffold that guides reasoning. It also combines SymPy-based execution verification with concept-membership checks to revise potentially problematic reasoning results. The authors conduct experiments on six mathematical reasoning benchmarks and three backbone models. The results show that the method consistently improves final-answer accuracy and achieves some improvements in structural metrics for reasoning processes.
Critical strengths
The research idea demonstrates a certain degree of novelty. The authors construct a graph based on relationships among mathematical concepts to assist LLM reasoning. Relevant mathematical concept information is provided before reasoning generation, and concept checks and symbolic execution verification are used for targeted revision afterward, forming a relatively comprehensive reasoning and feedback mechanism. Compared with traditional chain-of-thought and reasoning search methods, this work offers a useful perspective from the organization of mathematical knowledge.
The experiments are relatively comprehensive and involve a considerable amount of work. The method is evaluated on six benchmarks and three backbone models, compared with several mainstream inference-time baselines, and further examined through ablation studies and reasoning-process analyses. The results are reasonably convincing.
Critical weaknesses
The contribution of the core innovation could be further validated. Although the ablation study in Table 3 shows that the scaffold brings some performance improvements, it also introduces additional mathematical concepts. In my view, the current ablation study does not clearly distinguish whether the improvements come from the additional mathematical concepts or the topological relationships among them. A comparison that retains the same concept information without providing topological relationships would be helpful.
The ablation study of the dual-verification mechanism could be further improved. The authors design two verification mechanisms: execution-based verification and topology-based concept-membership verification. The existing ablation study does demonstrate a positive effect of the combined mechanism, but the individual effects of the two verification methods are not separately analyzed. Separate ablation studies would help clarify their respective contributions.
Questions for authors
If the model is provided with mathematical concepts but without the topological relationships among them, could it achieve similar experimental results? Such a comparison would help further clarify the contribution of the topological structure itself.
Could the authors provide separate ablation results for SymPy-based execution verification and topology-based concept-membership verification to clarify the respective contributions of the two mechanisms?
3 comments
Thanks for the detailed response. After reading the rebuttal and other reviews, I believe my current score is reasonable.
Thank You for Your Feedback
Thank you for taking the time to review our rebuttal and additional results. We appreciate your feedback and evaluation of our work.
Contributions of Topological Relations and Dual Verification
Thanks for the two suggestions. We agree that the original experiments did not sufficiently distinguish the contributions of concept information from that of topological relations, nor did they separately examine the effects of the two types of verification feedback. We thus conducted additional comparisons on Omni-500, as reported below.
Since commercial model API services may be updated over time and outputs may vary across runs, we re-evaluated the TopoMath pipeline and all ablation variants, using the complete pipeline from this evaluation batch as the common reference. Consequently, the absolute scores slightly differ from those in the original paper. All ablation differences are re-calculated within this new batch, without mixing original and re-evaluated results. Delta denotes the absolute change in Pass@1 relative to the TopoMath pipeline in this batch.
(1) Distinguishing Concept Information from Topological Relations
To address this question, we added the w/o Topological Relations variant. It retains the same concepts and their available definitions as the complete TopoMath pipeline but replaces the structured scaffold with an unordered concept list. Concept paths, hierarchies, and connections are no longer explicitly presented, while both verifiers are retained. This setting differs from w/o Scaffold, which provides no scaffold guidance in the reasoning prompt.
The complete TopoMath pipeline achieves a Pass@1 of 0.610, compared with 0.588 for the concept-list control, a difference of 2.2 percentage points. Thus, the structured scaffold achieves higher accuracy even when the supplied concept information is held constant. This provides evidence for the incremental value of explicit topological relations within the current pipeline.
(2) Separately Examining Execution Verification and Concept-Membership Verification
We also added two individual ablations. w/o Topology Verification retains the scaffold and SymPy execution verification, removing only concept-membership checks. Its Pass@1 decreases to 0.582, a reduction of 2.8 percentage points relative to the complete pipeline. w/o Execution Verification retains the scaffold and concept-membership checks, removing only SymPy verification. Its Pass@1 is 0.596, a reduction of 1.4 percentage points. Removing both verifiers also yields a Pass@1 of 0.596.
The complete configuration achieves higher accuracy than each ablation variant, supporting the retention of both types of verification feedback. However, the reductions are not simply additive, and performance does not increase monotonically with the number of verifiers. These results reflect the contribution of each module within the current pipeline, rather than independent, linearly additive gains. We also distinguish the scope of the two verifiers: SymPy checks executable computational claims, whereas concept-membership verification checks whether the concepts used in the reasoning belong to the problem-relevant concept set.