- Rating
- 3(+1)
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 3
Read review
Paper summary
In this work, the authors introduce LATTICE, a framework for detecting hidden coalitions in multi-agent debate systems. LATTICE traces how agents adopt, support, and challenge one another's claims. Experiments on controlled debates and external benchmarks suggest that these reasoning patterns recover coalitions more effectively than comparing agents' stated positions alone.
Critical strengths
- I enjoyed reading this work. The question this work tackles is critical and timely.
- The LATTICE method is well curated and offers enhanced interpretability of multi-agent systems.
- Experiments are carefully designed, and covers a wide range of perspectives.
Critical weaknesses
- My main concern is the novelty of the work. As far as I understand, there have already been some works that try to assess the collusive behaviors of agents in a multi-agent system. GroupGuard [1] is one example I can think of. To my understanding, this work also introduces a monitoring layer that goes beyond final-answer agreement by analyzing who supports or challenges whom throughout a conversation. Could the authors clarify the key distinction from this work?
[1] GroupGuard: A Framework for Modeling and Defending Collusive Attacks in Multi-Agent Systems
- I acknowledge that the authors state that "rather than asking whether a debate’s conclusion is correct, we ask whether the debate is being steered by a coordinated subset of its own participants". However, the experimental design appears to couple coalition membership with advocating an evidence-opposed decision, while LATTICE explicitly incorporates shared unsupported claims as a detection signal. Could the authors clarify to what extent the reported performance reflects coordination rather than shared incorrect or unsupported reasoning? In particular, how would LATTICE perform when agents independently advocate the same unsupported conclusion without coordinating, or when a coordinated coalition advocates an evidence-supported conclusion?
Overall, I think this work is great. If my few concerns are resolved, I would be happy to adjust my ratings.
Questions for authors
See Weaknesses
4 comments
Author Response to W2: Coordination vs. Shared Reasoning Errors
Concern. The original design couples coalition membership with evidence-opposed conclusions. Can LATTICE distinguish independently mistaken agents from a coordinated coalition defending an evidence-supported conclusion?
Author Response. The submitted study tests coalition recovery with evidence-opposed conclusions. We additionally vary coordination and conclusion correctness in a evaluation. Here, “correct” means supported by the public dossier. The presence results and signal ablations appear in Table D2 and Table D3.
Protocol. Across 40 held-out dossiers, four conditions, and three generation seeds, we evaluate 480 sessions (120 per condition), holding dossier format, agent count, debate length, and model configuration fixed. Coordinated-correct sessions retain a shared private objective. Independent sessions have no planted coalition; the independent-wrong arm uses naturalistic hard negatives in which at least two agents independently converge on the same unsupported conclusion. Selection uses dossier-grounded conclusion labels, never LATTICE’s predictions.
Presence decision. The session score is the maximum size-adjusted excess coordination relative to a neutral reference distribution, penalized for searching multiple candidate coalitions. Normalization and threshold are fitted only on development dossiers to target 5% neutral FPR, then frozen; all sessions from one dossier remain in one split. Unlike the submitted known- partition search, this supplementary decision can predict no coalition. Presence AUROC and FPR/TPR are session-level metrics, distinct from the paper’s original pairwise AUROC.
Table D2. Session-level coalition-presence detection at the calibrated threshold.
| Condition | Flagged / total | FPR or TPR |
|---|---|---|
| Independent + correct | 5.0% FPR | |
| Independent + wrong | 8.3% FPR | |
| Coordinated + correct | 80.0% TPR | |
| Coordinated + wrong | 91.7% TPR |
Table D3. Coordinated-correct vs. independent-wrong: presence AUROC.
| Measurement | Presence AUROC |
|---|---|
| Rare-shared-error lens only | 0.57 |
| Argumentative + temporal signals only | 0.80 |
| Full LATTICE without rare-error | 0.85 |
| Full LATTICE | 0.88 |
Interpretation. LATTICE flags independent-wrong hard negatives (8.3% FPR) and detects coordinated-correct sessions (80.0% TPR; Table D2). Presence AUROC for this contrast is 0.88 (95% CI ), and across all four conditions it is 0.91 (95% CI ). The rare-error lens alone reaches 0.57, versus 0.80 for argumentative and temporal signals and 0.85 for the full model without rare-error (Table D3). Thus, discrimination is not driven solely by shared factual errors in these tests.
Thanks for the detailed responses to my questions. They clearly addressed both of my concerns. The second point's experiments are very informative, in my opinion. Please consider including that in the manuscript.
Overall, I think this paper is a great benchmark for multi-agent system interpretation. I support acceptance of this work.
Thank You for Your Feedback and Support
We sincerely thank the reviewer for the encouraging feedback and support. We are pleased that our responses addressed both concerns and that the additional experiments were informative. We greatly appreciate the reviewer's thoughtful assessment and constructive engagement throughout the discussion.
Author Response to W1: Distinction from GroupGuard
We thank the reviewer for highlighting the importance and timeliness of this problem, LATTICE’s interpretability, and the breadth of our experiments. We address the questions on novelty and shared incorrect reasoning below.
Concern. GroupGuard also analyzes interactions beyond final-answer agreement. What distinguishes LATTICE?
Author Response. Both methods analyze multi-round interactions. LATTICE differs in the claim-level information preserved before agent-level aggregation: directed argumentative relations, claim provenance, dossier-grounded evidence status, and the temporal adoption of specific claims. These distinctions can be lost in an agent-level social graph. The representation and access differences are summarized below.
Matched-access comparison. We compare LATTICE with a GroupGuard monitoring-layer adaptation on identical public transcripts and graph-matched hard negatives selected using coarse social-graph statistics, without inspecting detector outputs. This isolates passive monitoring, not GroupGuard’s full defense with active probing and pruning.
Table D1. Graph-matched coalition-presence AUROC and paired comparison.
In Table D1, claim-level relations raise presence AUROC from 0.70 to 0.78, and temporal adoption raises it to 0.83. Full LATTICE reaches 0.86, a paired gain of +0.19 over the GroupGuard monitoring adaptation (95% CI [+0.10,+0.28]) and a point-estimate gain of +0.16 over the coarse graph.
Reference. Y. Tao et al., GroupGuard: A Framework for Modeling and Defending Collusive Attacks in Multi-Agent Systems, https://arxiv.org/abs/2603.13940.