acceptodds
Under review as a conference paper at ICLR 2027

LATENT CAUSAL VOID: EXPLICIT MISSING-CONTEXT RECONSTRUCTION FOR MISINFORMATION DETECTION

Abstract

Automatic misinformation detection performs well when deception is visible in what an article explicitly states. However, some misinformation articles remain locally coherent and only become misleading once compared with contemporaneous reports that supply background context the article omits. We study this omission-relevant setting and observe that current omission-aware approaches typically either attach retrieved context as auxiliary evidence or infer a categorical omission signal, leaving the specific omitted content implicit. We propose Latent Causal Void (LCV), a retrieval-guided detector that explicitly reconstructs the omitted content element for each target sentence and uses it as a textual cross-source relation in graph reasoning. Crucially, we do not treat the retrieved environment as verified ground truth: we formalize the learning signal as an environment-relative discrepancy between a target and its contemporaneous information environment, which is consistent with how that environment was originally constructed. Concretely, LCV retrieves temporally aligned context articles, asks a frozen instruction-tuned large language model to generate a short missing-context description for each sentence–article pair, and feeds the resulting relation text into a heterograph over target sentences and context articles. On the bilingual benchmark of Sheng et al., under a matched protocol with an identical local reimplementation of the strongest omission-aware baseline, LCV improves macro-F1 by and points on the English and Chinese splits. We further audit reconstructed relations by hand, finding source support; among the externally verifiable relations, are independently corroborated. We stress-test the detector under four families of controlled retrieval corruption, and compare against a strong non-graph consumer of the same reconstructed text. The results indicate that modeling the omitted cross-source content itself, rather than only attaching retrieve

Primary area:
other topics in machine learning (i.e., none of the above)
Keywords:
Misinformation Detection, Missing-Context Reconstruction, Omission-Aware Detection, Cross-Source Relation Modeling, Heterogeneous Graph Reasoning

Reviews

Among:
Shape:
1234this paper, Bottom 49%
Figure 1. Mean review rating of the reviewed papers at ICLR 2027. This paper averages 2.25 over 4 reviews, above 49% of the others.
Reviewer_qqHNOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
4
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

This paper targets misinformation that misleads by omitting context. The proposed method, LCV, uses a frozen LLM to describe what each retrieved news article states but a target sentence does not, and feeds these descriptions as edge features into a graph classifier. On the bilingual benchmark, LCV improves macro-F1 by 2.94 (English) and 2.77 (Chinese) points over OmiGraph.

Critical strengths
  1. Representing the missing content as readable text is intuitive and makes the model’s evidence easy to inspect.
  2. The analysis goes beyond accuracy, including a 600-sample human audit of the generated text and a retrieval-corruption study.
  3. The paper transparently shows that most of the gain comes from the generated text rather than the graph.
Critical weaknesses

W1. The main claim, that describing the missing content works better than describing the omission intent, is not directly tested.

The authors place their key difference from OmiGraph in what the LLM generates: the missing content itself (e.g., “omits two-officers staffing”) rather than a reason for the omission (e.g., OmiGraph’s “to downplay the political motivations behind actions”) (§1, §2.2). Since OmiGraph also encodes its generated text as edge embeddings, the two methods seem to differ mainly in the prompt. However, Table 6 represents the intent-based approach with category labels (E1), and Table 8 lists OmiGraph’s representation as “category,” which does not match OmiGraph’s free-text design. The gain in Table 1 therefore may come from architectural differences rather than from the content-based text. Swapping only the generated text (content vs. intent) within the LCV architecture would test this claim directly.

W2. The generated phrases may not capture omissions.

The prompt asks the LLM for any piece of information that the article states and the target sentence does not (Appendix D). Since English targets average only 1.38 sentences (Table 7), almost any retrieved article would contain such information. The generated phrase may therefore act more like a short summary of the article than an identified omission. Reporting how often the LLM outputs [NO_MISSING_CONTEXT], and comparing against a prompt that simply summarizes the article, would help clarify this.

W3. The evaluation does not show that the method helps on omission-based misinformation specifically.

The benchmark labels posts only as real or fake; it does not mark which fake posts mislead through omission. The reported gains therefore may come from cases unrelated to omission. Prior work has built data annotated specifically for misleading omissions [1], but it is not discussed. Evaluating on such data, or on an omission-annotated subset of the benchmark, would better support the paper’s motivation.

W4. A strong LLM baseline with retrieved context seems to be missing.

The LLM baseline in Table 1 reaches only 0.5556 macro-F1 on English, and it is unclear whether it receives the retrieved articles. A natural baseline would give an LLM both the target post and the retrieved articles and ask it to classify the post directly. Without this comparison, it is unclear how much the proposed pipeline adds over simply prompting an LLM. [1] What’s Left Unsaid? Detecting and Correcting Misleading Omissions in Multimodal News Previews. In Proceedings of ACL, 2026. arXiv:2601.05563.

Questions for authors
  • The method assumes that the LLM reports only what the article states (Appendix D). Since LLMs may not fully suppress their own knowledge even when instructed [2, 3], could the 11–14% of outputs containing information from neither the sentence nor the article (Table 3) come from the generator’s own knowledge? How does the generator behave when the article conflicts with what it knows?

  • Figure 4 is described as an example from the English dataset, but it contains three sentences and dates from November 2023, whereas English targets average 1.38 sentences and the benchmark was released in 2022. Is this example drawn from the dataset or constructed for illustration?

  • What fraction of the generated relations are [NO_MISSING_CONTEXT]?

  • Does the LLM baseline in Table 1 receive the retrieved articles?

[2] Task Matters: Knowledge Requirements Shape LLM Responses to Context–Memory Conflict. arXiv:2506.06485, 2025. [3] Diagnosing LLM Arbitration Behavior over Pre-evidence Epistemic States in RAG-based Fact-Checking. arXiv:2606.01120, 2026.

1 comment
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Content vs. Intent in One Architecture, Omission vs. Summary, Omission-Specific Data, and LLM Baselines

Thank you for the expert and precise review. W1 identified a genuine error in our positioning, which we correct. New results are Tables R1–R13 (new Appendix I).

W1 – Content vs. intent is not directly tested. We agree on both counts. OmiGraph generates free-text intents encoded by a PLM as edge attributes; Table 8's "category" is wrong and is corrected, and §2.2/§4.4 now state that Table 6 compares against categories, not OmiGraph-style intents. As the two methods also differ architecturally, Table 1 alone cannot attribute the gain, so we ran your swap as a full 2×2 (Table R1): architecture {OmiGraph, LCV} × edge text {intent, content}, all from the same Llama-3.1-8B-Instruct; intent uses OmiGraph's prompt (adapted to single pairs) at 16 tokens and at native length (≤64). With the architecture fixed, content beats the stronger intent variant by +1.46/+1.24 macro-F1 (EN/ZH) in LCV and by +1.82/+1.67 in OmiGraph. The +2.94/+2.77 over matched OmiGraph thus decomposes into +0.15/+0.16 (generator), +1.82/+1.67 (content vs. intent text) and +0.97/+0.94 (architecture): the text is the larger share.

W2/Q3 – Omissions or summaries?

  • [NO_MISSING_CONTEXT] occurs in 18.4%/22.7% (EN/ZH) of pairs. Its rate depends on the label (23.6% vs. 12.9% for real vs. misinformation targets in EN; 28.4% vs. 16.7% in ZH) and rises to 64.2%/61.5% when cjc_j is swapped for an unrelated-event article (Table R3). Only 2.8%/3.5% of relations are already entailed by the target sentence.
  • Outputs are target-conditioned: the same article paired with different target sentences yields different outputs in 86.4%/83.7% of cases.
  • Your suggested control (Table R2): a target-agnostic one-phrase summary of cjc_j (same generator and budget) gains only +0.55/+0.51 over a uniform edge, vs. +2.83/+2.65 for missing content; randomly re-paired relations fall below the uniform edge. The signal thus depends on what this sentence omits.
  • Definition 1 is permissive by design: it defines candidate omissions, and the classifier learns which are diagnostic. A new materiality audit finds 72% of relations interpretation-changing on misinformation targets vs. 20% on real ones (Table R9).

W3 – Omission-specific evaluation. Thank you for [1]; we now discuss it in §2.2 and evaluate on MM-Misleading (Table R5), text-only, with the headline as target and the linked article (≤5 chunks) as context: LCV reaches 0.887 macro-F1 (misleading recall 0.867) vs. 0.856 for OmiGraph and 0.874 for DirectConcat(T+C+Z). For reference, headline-only OMGuard (a fine-tuned 8B LVLM) reports 0.865 macro-F1 and 0.82 misleading recall. We also annotated the benchmark's misinformation test items as omission-driven or other (two annotators + adjudicator, κ=0.78/0.75; Table R4): LCV's recall gain over OmiGraph is +8.8/+7.4 points on omission-driven items vs. +2.3/+0.8 on the rest.

W4/Q4 – LLM baseline with retrieved context. The Table 1 LLM baseline did not receive retrieved articles: it is zero-shot Llama-3.1-8B-Instruct on the target alone, following OmiGraph's content-only protocol. We added the baselines you describe, all with the same top-3 articles (Table R6), EN/ZH macro-F1: zero-shot 8B 0.6842/0.7815; zero-shot Llama-3.1-70B 0.7385/0.8312; 4-shot 8B 0.7118/0.8064; LoRA-fine-tuned 8B 0.7589/0.8562; LCV 0.7851/0.8862. Adding our relations to the zero-shot 8B prompt raises it by +3.12/+2.91, so the reconstructed content also helps an LLM consumer. LCV is faster with cached relations (48 ms vs. 1.12 s for LoRA) but slower uncached (6.9 s), which Table 13 now states.

Q1 – Parametric knowledge. Of the 33/42 hallucination-flagged relations (Table R11), 54.5%/50.0% state true facts found in neither text (parametric leakage, i.e., 6.0%/7.0% of audited relations), 27.3%/31.0% are uncorroborated, and 18.2%/19.0% merge content from another retrieved article. For context–memory conflict we reuse the contradictory family, whose articles carry counterfactual edits of real facts: the generator reports the article's edited value in 78.4%/75.8% of cases, its pre-edit (memory) value in 6.2%/5.4%, and the sentinel in 11.8%/14.6%. Consistent with [2,3], suppression is imperfect; the NLI source-support filter removes 78.8%/76.2% of flagged relations and changes macro-F1 by +0.17/+0.17 (Table R2). We cite [2,3] in the Limitations.

Q2 – Figure 4. It is a constructed illustration, not a dataset sample; the caption was wrong. It even shows a context article dated after the target, which the look-back window [tP−Δ,tP)[t_P-\Delta, t_P) excludes. We replace it with real test cases, giving dataset IDs and unedited relations.

Reviewer_SdTfOpenReview ↗
Rating
3
Confidence
2
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

This paper defines an environment-relative omission as a proposition entailed by a retrieved context article but not entailed by a target sentence. LCV retrieves temporally aligned reports, uses a frozen Llama-3.1-8B-Instruct model to generate a short missing-context relation for each sentence-article pair, encodes the relations, and performs relation-aware reasoning over a heterogeneous graph for misinformation classification. On the English and Chinese splits, the authors report macro-F1 gains of 2.94 and 2.77 points over a matched reimplementation of OmiGraph. The paper also reports three-seed results, ablations, retrieval-corruption tests, architectural controls using the same reconstructed text, and a human audit of 600 relations.

Critical strengths
  1. The paper explicitly distinguishes missing-content reconstruction from generating a hypothesized reason for omission. Its environment-relative definition also avoids treating retrieved articles as verified ground truth.
  2. The human audit separately evaluates source support and external corroboration, and the paper reports language-level counts and reliability information in the appendix.
  3. The comparison protocol is described in detail. The authors reimplement OmiGraph under a matched local protocol, report the published point estimates separately, and explain why the two are not directly interchangeable. They also compare against non-graph consumers of the same retrieved and reconstructed text, helping isolate the graph contribution.
Critical weaknesses
  1. The formal target is a source-relative discrepancy, not necessarily a misleading or material omission. A proposition can be present in a retrieved report and absent from a target sentence without changing the interpretation of the target article. The paper acknowledges the environment-relative nature of the definition, but the relation between this operational object and harmful omission-based deception remains an important construct-validity question.
  2. In the audit, 87% of generated relations are source-supported, while independent corroboration is 75% among only the externally corroborable subset. These are carefully distinguished metrics, but they leave meaningful uncertainty about factual reliability and whether generated relations are appropriate for user-facing explanations. The paper appropriately recommends triage; deployment as explanatory evidence would need stronger validation.
  3. The core benchmark is the bilingual dataset of Sheng et al.; the manuscript itself notes that the English split is dominated by single-sentence targets and that coherence modeling is more exercised on the Chinese split. The generality of the graph and document-level mechanisms to longer, more diverse articles is therefore not established by this benchmark alone.
  4. The reported gains over OmiGraph are based on a matched reimplementation rather than a direct reproduction of the original published configuration. The paper reports both matched and published results and explains protocol differences, which is good practice; nevertheless, headline claims should consistently identify the matched reimplementation as the reference.
  5. Relation generation and classification are sensitive to retrieval coverage and source quality. The controlled corruption experiments are useful, but cannot fully represent real source disagreement, systematic source bias, or missing temporal alignment. These factors could produce plausible, source-supported relations that still mislead the classifier or a human reader.
Questions for authors

Please refer to the Critical Weaknesses.

1 comment
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Construct Validity, Reliability for Explanations, Generality, and Realistic Source Conditions

Thank you for the constructive review and for recognizing the definition, the audit design, and the matched protocol. New results are Tables R1–R13 (new Appendix I).

W1 – Construct validity of Definition 1. We agree and make the distinction explicit. Definition 1 specifies a necessary condition: an environment-relative discrepancy is a candidate omission; a misleading omission is the subset whose absence changes how the target is interpreted. LCV deliberately does not decide materiality at generation time; the classifier learns from labels which discrepancies are diagnostic. The revision adds this paragraph after Definition 1 and calls zijz_{ij} a "candidate omission" throughout. We also tested the link between the operational object and the construct:

  1. Materiality audit (Table R9). For the 600 audited relations, annotators additionally judged whether knowing zijz_{ij} would change a reasonable reader's interpretation of the target (material / marginal / immaterial; α=0.67). 72% of relations on misinformation targets are material vs. 20% on real targets, and material relations receive 2.2× the attention of immaterial ones.
  2. Omission-annotated subset (Table R4). On misinformation items annotated as omission-driven, LCV's recall gain over matched OmiGraph is +8.8/+7.4 points (EN/ZH), vs. +2.3/+0.8 on other misinformation.
  3. External labels (Table R5). On MM-Misleading (Li et al., ACL 2026), whose labels mark interpretation-changing omissions, LCV reaches 0.887 macro-F1 vs. 0.856 for matched OmiGraph.

The operational object is thus correlated with, but not identical to, harmful omission, and the paper now states it in exactly those terms.

W2 – Reliability for user-facing explanations. Agreed; we narrow the claim: relations are an inspection aid for triage, not validated explanations. Decomposing the audit (Table R9), corroboration is 81% among fully source-supported relations vs. 35% among the rest, so about two thirds of externally contradicted relations faithfully report their source; the gap to 75% mostly reflects source quality rather than generation. Any displayed relation will (a) pass an NLI source-support filter, which nulls 77% of hallucination-flagged relations (Table R11) at no accuracy cost (+0.17/+0.17, Table R2), (b) be shown with its supporting source span and outlet, and (c) be phrased as "reported by <source>", never as fact. A user study of explanation quality is outside this rebuttal's scope; we list it as required before any user-facing deployment.

W3 – Generality beyond short targets.

  1. By length (Table R7). LCV's margin over DirectConcat(T+C+Z) grows from +1.02/+1.02 on single-sentence targets to +2.79/+2.66 on targets with ≥4 sentences; removing coherence edges costs 1.29/1.18 on targets with ≥4 sentences vs. ≤0.08 on single-sentence ones.
  2. Long-form (Table R8). On 1,200 NELA-GT-2021 articles (avg. 16.4 sentences; source-level labels; context pool of reliable-outlet articles in [tP−7,tP)[t_P-7, t_P), excluding the target's outlet), LCV reaches 0.7945 macro-F1 vs. 0.7648 for matched OmiGraph and 0.7694 for DirectConcat(T+C+Z); coherence edges contribute +1.09, and a sentence budget of n=20 gives 0.8018. As source-level labels are noisier than the benchmark's, we present this as evidence of applicability, not a new headline result.

W4 – Matched reimplementation in headline claims. Agreed. Every headline mention (abstract, introduction, §4.3, conclusion) now reads "matched reimplementation of OmiGraph". For reference, LCV also exceeds the published OmiGraph point estimates (0.7612/0.8591) by +2.39/+2.71 macro-F1, although those values use a different retrieval output and cannot be paired.

W5 – Real disagreement, systematic bias, temporal misalignment. We complement the synthetic corruptions with naturally occurring conditions (Table R12):

  1. Natural disagreement: on targets whose retrieved articles contain mutually contradicting propositions (NLI), LCV reaches 0.7482/0.8504 vs. 0.7912/0.8921 on the remaining targets.
  2. Systematic bias: context restricted to a single partisan leaning (EN) or a single outlet (ZH): 0.7689/0.8705 (−1.62/−1.57 vs. clean).
  3. Temporal misalignment: look-back window shifted to [tP−14,tP−7)[t_P-14, t_P-7): 0.7615/0.8612 (−2.36/−2.50).

A cross-source consensus filter (a relation is kept only if another retrieved article also entails it) recovers +1.57/+1.54 under natural disagreement, but only +0.15/+0.13 under the single-leaning pool and under temporal misalignment: consensus cannot detect a bias or gap that all retrieved sources share. Source-supported yet misleading relations therefore remain possible under systematic bias; the Limitations now state this explicitly, together with the recommendation of human verification.

Reviewer_ZUZBOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
3
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

This paper focuses on misinformation that misleads readers by omitting important context and proposes LCV. The method first retrieves news articles from the same time period, then uses a frozen Llama-3.1-8B to generate a short description for each sentence–article pair, explaining what the article contains but the sentence leaves out. These descriptions are used as edge features in a heterogeneous graph for reasoning and classification. On the Chinese and English benchmarks from Sheng et al. (2022), LCV improves macro-F1 by 2.94 and 2.77 points over the reproduced OmiGraph baseline, respectively. The paper also includes a manual evaluation of 600 relations, retrieval contamination experiments, and a control experiment without graph reasoning.

Critical strengths
  1. The paper represents missing context as verifiable text statements, with a clear definition that does not assume the retrieved content is true. These statements are also manually reviewed, making the intermediate results easier to inspect and verify.

  2. The authors are transparent about their experimental results. They acknowledge that the improvements mainly come from the reconstructed text rather than the graph structure (Table 12). The retrieval contamination experiments also show that the model makes use of relational information.

Critical weaknesses
  1. The core claim that "missing content is better than intent descriptions" has not been directly tested. Table 6 compares the generated text with six category labels, rather than with OmiGraph-style intent descriptions under the same framework. Table 8 also labels OmiGraph as "category", which seems inconsistent with the description in Section 2.2.

  2. It is unclear whether the improvements come from omission modeling. The benchmark is not specifically designed for omissions, and the paper does not analyze omission-related subsets. Simple concatenation already outperforms OmiGraph, so the improvements may come from general information in LLM-generated summaries rather than omission modeling itself. There are also several inconsistencies in the paper (see Issues 3–5).

Questions for authors
  1. Could the authors add a controlled experiment comparing OmiGraph-style intent descriptions under the same LCV architecture?

  2. On the subset where misinformation is caused by omitted context, how much does each method improve?

  3. Figure 4 is described as showing samples from the English dataset, but the timestamp is from 2023. Are these real samples or just illustrative examples?

  4. In Appendix G, the "Incomplete" contamination experiment uses manually annotated fragments, but only 600 relations were annotated. How was the full test set constructed?

  5. In Table 13, the number of LLM calls is 0 under the cached setting, so why is the generation time still 2.3 seconds? How are the category labels for E1 assigned?

1 comment
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Same-Architecture Content-vs-Intent Control, Omission-Subset Evaluation, and Corrections

Thank you for the careful reading and precise questions. Several exposed genuine errors, all corrected in the revision. New results are Tables R1–R13 (new Appendix I).

W1/Q1 – Content vs. intent under the same architecture. You are right: Table 6 does not test this, and Table 8 is wrong. OmiGraph generates free-text omission intents and encodes them with a PLM as edge attributes; it does not use categories. We correct Table 8 and the related sentences in §2.2/§4.4, and ran the requested control as a 2×2 (Table R1): architecture {OmiGraph, LCV} × edge text {intent, content}. All text comes from the same Llama-3.1-8B-Instruct with greedy decoding; intent text uses OmiGraph's own prompt (adapted to single pairs), at our 16-token budget and at its native length (≤64 tokens), so the budget does not handicap intents. Within LCV's architecture, content outperforms the stronger (≤64-token) intent variant by +1.46/+1.24 macro-F1 (EN/ZH); within OmiGraph's architecture, replacing intents with content gives +1.82/+1.67. Adding intents on top of content changes macro-F1 by only +0.09/+0.08, so intents add little once content is present. Categories (E1) remain a separate, weaker rung.

W2/Q2 – Do the gains come from omission modeling?

  1. Omission subset (Table R4). Two annotators per language (a third adjudicating) labeled every misinformation item in both test sets as omission-driven (misleading mainly through missing context while the stated content is largely accurate) or other (fabricated or false claims), consulting the associated fact-check or rebuttal where available (κ=0.78/0.75); 284 EN and 312 ZH items are omission-driven. LCV's recall gain over matched OmiGraph is +8.8/+7.4 points on omission-driven items vs. +2.3/+0.8 on other misinformation (+3.2/+0.9 on real items). The content-vs-intent gap is concentrated there as well (+5.3/+4.8 vs. +0.6/+0.3), as is the effect of adding relation text to plain concatenation (+8.1/+6.4 vs. +1.7/+1.1).
  2. Generic information vs. omission (Table R2). A target-agnostic one-phrase summary of the same article (same generator and budget, no target sentence) reaches only 0.7623/0.8648, barely above a uniform edge (0.7568/0.8597); randomly re-paired relations fall below it (0.7541/0.8569); pair-specific missing content gives 0.7851/0.8862. Outputs are target-conditioned: for the same article paired with different target sentences, 86.4%/83.7% of outputs differ (Table R3).
  3. External omission labels (Table R5). On MM-Misleading (Li et al., ACL 2026), whose labels mark misleading omissions, text-only LCV reaches 0.887 macro-F1 vs. 0.856 for OmiGraph and 0.874 for DirectConcat(T+C+Z).

Q3 – Figure 4. It is an illustrative, constructed example, not a dataset sample; the caption was wrong. It also shows a context article dated after the target, which our look-back window [tP−Δ,tP)[t_P-\Delta, t_P) excludes by construction. We replace it with real test cases, giving dataset IDs and the unedited generated relations, including a failure case.

Q4 – Incomplete corruption on the full test set. Appendix G was imprecise. Annotator-marked spans exist only for the 600 audited pairs. For the full test set, the removed span is located automatically as the sentence(s) of cjc_j with the highest NLI entailment score for the clean relation zijz_{ij}. On the 600 gold pairs, this localizer agrees with annotator spans at token-F1 0.864/0.841 (EN/ZH), and after truncation the removed content survives in the regenerated relation at similar rates (6.0%/7.3% with automatic vs. 4.3%/5.7% with annotator spans; Table R13). Appendix G now states this procedure.

Q5 – Table 13 and E1 labels. (a) The "generation time" column conflated two quantities. In the cached row, 2.3 s is one-time, non-LLM preprocessing (retrieval over the 7-day pool and frozen-BERT feature extraction); the 0.8 s / 0.3 s of DirectConcat/BERT are the same quantity. Per-target inference is the 48 ms latency, which is what throughput reflects (20.8 = 1/0.048 s). We split the column into "LLM generation" and "retrieval + encoding". (b) E1 labels are assigned automatically: the same frozen Llama-3.1-8B-Instruct classifies each (si,cj,zij)(s_i, c_j, z_{ij}) into one of the six categories with a fixed zero-shot prompt (now in Appendix D); E2's confidence is the normalized probability of the chosen label. Against annotator-assigned categories on audited relations, κ=0.76/0.73 (Table R3).

Other corrections. We also fixed the broken cross-reference on p.5 and the statement in §4.6: Table 11 shows LCV exceeding clean OmiGraph under all four corruption families at ρ=0.25, not three.

Reviewer_DucLOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
3
Informativeness
1
Presentation
2
Soundness
3(+1)
Read review
Paper summary

This paper studies omission-based misinformation detection, where an article can be misleading even if its explicitly stated claims are factually correct. It proposes LCV, a retrieval-guided framework that reconstructs missing contextual information as textual relations between target sentences and contemporaneous reports. A frozen instruction-tuned LLM is used to generate missing-content propositions, which are then encoded into a heterogeneous graph for relation-aware reasoning and final classification. Experiments on English and Chinese benchmarks show improvements of 2.94 and 2.77 macro-F1 points over a matched implementation of the strongest omission-aware baseline, respectively. The paper also provides human evaluation, retrieval corruption experiments, and architectural ablations to examine the quality and contribution of the reconstructed information.

Critical strengths

1. Novel problem perspective that targets the core challenge of omission-based misinformation detection This work moves beyond the traditional fact-verification paradigm and addresses the more insidious form of misleading content caused by selective context omission. It proposes missing content itself as the basic unit of cross-source reasoning and formalizes the concept of "environment-relative omission". Compared with existing methods that only attach external evidence or describe omission intent, this approach directly captures the essence of omission-based deception and is inherently interpretable and auditable.

2. Rigorous and comprehensive experimental design with solid, verifiable conclusions Besides achieving significant performance improvements on both English and Chinese benchmarks, the paper conducts multi-dimensional validation including a 600-sample human audit, four types of retrieval-corruption robustness tests, representation ladder comparisons, and architectural ablations to disentangle module contributions. It systematically quantifies the quality of reconstructed content, the actual gains of each component, and the method’s boundaries under degraded information environments. The experimental design forms a complete logical loop with fair baseline comparisons, demonstrating strong academic rigor.

Critical weaknesses
  • The overall framework largely combines existing techniques, including context retrieval, LLM-based text generation, heterogeneous graph construction, and graph message passing. The main technical modification is to represent omitted information as explicit textual relations rather than omission-intent descriptions. While this is a reasonable design choice, the methodological novelty appears limited and does not introduce a fundamentally new reasoning mechanism.

  • The performance gains seem to come primarily from the LLM-based reconstruction of missing content rather than the proposed graph architecture. The direct concatenation baseline using the same reconstructed text already outperforms the existing baseline, while graph reasoning provides only additional improvements of 1.27 and 1.79 macro-F1 points on the English and Chinese datasets, respectively. This raises questions about the necessity of the proposed heterogeneous graph architecture and the extent to which it contributes to the overall performance.

  • The reliability of reconstructed information remains a concern. The human audit reports 87% source support, but only 75% independent factual correctness among externally verifiable samples, with a completeness rate of 65%. Since the method relies on retrieved articles rather than independently verified facts, unreliable or contradictory sources may introduce misleading contextual information and lead to false predictions.

Questions for authors
  1. Does the graph architecture provide consistent improvements on longer articles or more complex narratives compared with the direct concatenation baseline?

  2. How does the method distinguish genuinely misleading omissions from information that is simply absent from one sentence but present elsewhere in the target article?

  3. What is the specific causal modeling component in LCV, given that the method primarily identifies textual discrepancies between the target article and retrieved context?

2 comments
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Isolating the Representational Contribution, the Role of the Graph, and Relation Reliability

W1 – Methodological novelty. We agree that the building blocks (retrieval, a frozen LLM, relation-aware message passing) are standard, and the revised contribution list says so; we claim no new message-passing operator. Our claim is representational: what object a cross-source edge should carry for omission reasoning. We now test this in isolation with a 2×2 design crossing architecture {OmiGraph, LCV} with edge text {omission intent, missing content}, all generated by the same Llama-3.1-8B-Instruct (Table R1). The +2.94/+2.77 macro-F1 (EN/ZH) over matched OmiGraph decomposes into +0.15/+0.16 from the generator, +1.82/+1.67 from replacing intent text with missing-content text inside OmiGraph's own architecture, and +0.97/+0.94 from the architecture. The representation is thus the larger factor, and it transfers to another architecture. It also enables what an intent edge cannot: each relation is a proposition checkable against its source article, which made the four-property audit possible.

W2 – Necessity of the graph. Agreed: reconstruction is the primary contribution (§4.7), and the revised abstract says so. The graph is still worth its small cost (48 vs. 42 ms per target, Table 13):

  1. The gain is statistically reliable: +1.27/+1.79 over DirectConcat(T+C+Z), p<0.001 in both languages (paired bootstrap over test targets, Table R7).
  2. It grows with length, where concatenation must truncate: +1.02/+1.02 on single-sentence targets vs. +2.79/+2.66 on targets with ≥4 sentences (Table R7), and +2.51 on long-form NELA-GT-2021 articles averaging 16.4 sentences (Table R8).
  3. It gives faithful per-relation attribution: masking the most-attended relation changes the prediction for 14.6%/12.8% of test targets vs. 4.2%/3.5% for a random relation (Table R9), so a user can see which missing proposition drove a decision.

One limit: the graph adds no robustness by itself. Under degraded retrieval, LCV and DirectConcat lose similar amounts (−4.89 vs. −5.09 EN under contradictory corruption at ρ=0.5); LCV keeps its margin in every condition of Table R12 (+1.21 to +1.64 EN, +1.73 to +1.92 ZH) but does not widen it.

W3 – Reliability of reconstructed information.

  1. Much of the 87%→75% gap comes from the sources, not the generator: corroboration is 81% among fully source-supported relations vs. 35% among the rest (Table R9), so about two thirds of externally contradicted relations faithfully report their source article. The 75% covers only the 332 corroborable relations; "not corroborable" does not mean incorrect.
  2. By Definition 1, relations need not be true; the classifier learns which discrepancies are diagnostic. Corruption bounds the damage (−0.3 to −1.8 macro-F1 at ρ=0.25), and two new safeguards reduce it: an NLI source-support filter that nulls unsupported relations (+0.17/+0.17 on clean data, Table R2) and a cross-source consensus filter that recovers +1.52/+1.65 under contradictory corruption at ρ=0.5 (Table R12).
  3. Completeness (65%) is bounded by the one-phrase, 16-token format, a deliberate precision–recall choice: allowing up to three propositions (48 tokens) raises completeness to 84% but lowers source support to 81%, raises hallucination to 18%, and does not improve accuracy (0.7839/0.8848; Table R10).

LCV remains positioned as triage support, not an autonomous verdict.

Q1 – Longer articles. Yes; see W2.2 (Tables R7, R8). Removing coherence edges costs 1.29/1.18 on targets with ≥4 sentences but ≤0.08 on single-sentence targets, and 1.09 on NELA-GT, so the target-side graph matters more as length grows.

Q2 – Information present elsewhere in the target. The generator is sentence-local, so this can occur: 4.1% of EN and 11.8% of ZH relations are entailed by another sentence of the same target (Table R3). Mapping these to r∅r_\varnothing changes macro-F1 by +0.05/+0.13, whereas giving the generator the whole target lowers it (0.7829/0.8794, Table R2), most on the longer ZH targets; we therefore add the redundancy filter as a post-hoc step. Whether an absence is misleading is left to the classifier, not the generator, and a new materiality audit supports this split: 72% of relations on misinformation targets vs. 20% on real targets are judged interpretation-changing, and these receive 2.2× more attention (Table R9).

Q3 – Causal modeling. LCV contains no causal-inference component (no structural causal model, identification, or interventional objective), and we should not have implied one. "Causal void" was meant descriptively: many relations supply missing antecedents or consequences (41.6%/44.2% of non-null relations, Table R3). We remove the "latent-causal" wording from the text and Figure 4 and are willing to rename the method "Latent Context Void" (keeping the acronym) if the AC agrees.

Thank you for the response. I have raised my Soundness score from 2 to 3.

Comments on the paper

1 comment
Area_Chair_q8zbOpenReview ↗

Please review the authors’ responses and join the discussion

Dear Reviewers,

The authors have responded to all reviews. Please read their responses and the other reviewers’ comments, then post a brief follow-up indicating which concerns, if any, remain and whether the responses have changed your assessment. If your concerns have been resolved, a short confirmation would also be helpful.

Thank you for your time and for contributing to the discussion.

Best regards,

Your AC

From OpenReview, CC BY 4.0. Authors as signed there; shown unedited.

Related papers

Loading the map…

Discussion (0)

Sign in to comment.