- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes choosing where to insert a fixed-basis adapter in an equivariant MLIP (MACE-OFF23/MACE-MP-0) by a held-out linear reachability score. For each candidate placement, a orthonormal slice of the first-order-active adapter factor is taken. The energy-force Jacobian on a fit split is used to solve a ridge-regulararized, trust-region-constrained least squares for the required correction. The same coefficients are applied through the validation-split Jacobian and the normalized residual is the score. Prop.1 specifically notes this score is invariant under an invertible coordinate change if the coefficient metric is co-transformed.
Critical strengths
1.Framing placement as a problem about which output-space corrections a module can express, with forces as mixed coordinate-parameter derivatives, is a reasonable and clearly stated viewpoint for MLIPs.
-
The experimental bookkeeping is unusually careful: prospective vs. post-hoc analyses are labelled, untouched test frames are kept untouched, Jacobians are verified by finite differences checks, and the locality remainder is reported separately from rank agreement.
-
This paper is honest about limitations, even though slice-coverage imbalance, non-local regime, and the LoRA reversal would undercut the main claim.
Critical weaknesses
-
The proposed selector does not outperforms trivial alternatives. On the six-molecule cohort the paper reports that fit-only residual, gradient norm, and Gauss-Newton trace also select the readout in 18/18 cases (Sec 4.4) and Table 16 showcases fit-only ties the held-out score on every other task. However, an "always choose readout" rule reproduces every molecular selection. Therefore, the specific contribution that the authors champion, the held-out transfer construction, is therefore never shown to add anything over a fit-only residual or a gradient norm.
-
The readout preference might be a slice-coverage evidence. The 32-dimensional slice covers 50% of the readout's 64 coordinates but 12.5%/1.6%/0.6%/3%/6% of the other five spaces (Table 2). A random half of a small space naturally reaches more of that space's corrections than a random 0.6% of a large one. This paper though acknowledges this shortly ("unequal fractional coverage may contribute") but never runs the obvious control: full native spaces or matched fractional coverage.
-
Prop. 1 is a change of variables () and does not warrant the framing as a "reparameterization principle". The question, for instance, which metric to use, is left to the user ("the native metric is meaningful when it matches the deployed parameterization"), and the paper shows that the answer would change the conclusion.
Questions for authors
See above weaknesses.