- Rating
- 3(+1)
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
In this paper, the authors propose Prompteina, an all-atom protein design model conditioned on natural-language descriptions. The model incorporates global and token-level textual conditioning, together with residue-level text-alignment fine-tuning, to enable more accessible and controllable generation of all-atom protein structures from natural-language specifications. The authors also construct Prompteina-Data, a large-scale dataset containing approximately 1.8 million protein structure entries paired with 52.4 million textual descriptions. The experimental evaluation covers structural attribute control, computational binder design, an LLM-driven iterative design pipeline, and a preliminary experimental study of GM2A-targeting candidates. The results suggest that the proposed approach is promising for natural-language-guided protein design.
Critical strengths
- The paper tackles an interesting and challenging task in text-conditioned protein design. By using natural language as a unified interface, Prompteina aims to support the specification of both global structural properties and local structural constraints.
- The proposed combination of global and token-level textual conditioning with residue-level text-alignment fine-tuning is well motivated and provides a promising mechanism for enabling fine-grained structural control.
- The authors construct Prompteina-Data, pairing approximately 1.8 million protein structures with 52.4 million textual descriptions. In particular, the residue-level alignment annotations provide a valuable foundation for enabling localized control over generated protein structures.
- The paper presents a broad range of experiments, including text-guided protein structure generation, text-guided binder design, agent-driven iterative optimization, and a proof-of-concept experimental study targeting GM2A. This extensive evaluation provides useful insights into the capabilities and potential practical applications of the proposed approach.
Critical weaknesses
- How much does the natural-language interface contribute to the model's performance beyond the underlying structural prior? In Table 8, pooled natural-language conditioning performs similarly to conditioning on dedicated CATH labels. It would be helpful to investigate whether natural-language conditioning outperforms structured labels or explicit numerical constraints when the training data and computational budgets are matched. Furthermore, the authors should provide a more systematic analysis of semantic sensitivity (whether changing a meaningful phrase produces the intended structural change) and semantic invariance (whether paraphrasing or stylistic variations preserve the intended outcome). The model's ability to generalize to unseen descriptions also warrants further investigation. These analyses would help establish the advantages of natural language as an expressive and effective interface for protein design in realistic settings.
- The claim that Prompteina is the first all-atom protein design model conditioned on natural-language descriptions appears overly broad. For example, Proteo-R1: Reasoning Foundation Models for De Novo Protein Design (ICML 2026) and Co-Generative De Novo Functional Protein Design (ICML 2026) appear relevant to the paper's claims concerning language-conditioned protein generation and joint sequence–structure design. The authors should discuss more on text-conditioned protein co-design models.
- Proteo-R1: Reasoning Foundation Models for De Novo Protein Design, ICML 2026
- Co-Generative De Novo Functional Protein Design, ICML 2026
- The evaluation of iterative binder design in an agentic setting is valuable for assessing the practical utility of the proposed approach. The authors use a shared agent and matched generation budgets, which helps ensure a fair comparison. However, the conditioning interfaces of the compared methods differ in expressiveness, potentially confounding the effects of the underlying generation models with those of their input interfaces. It would therefore be valuable to include comparisons with methods that support natural-language-based protein design, like Proteo-R1. Such comparisons would help clarify whether the observed improvements arise primarily from Prompteina's generation capabilities, its more expressive conditioning interface, or their combination.
Questions for authors
Please refer to the weaknesses.
4 comments
[W1] Generalization to unseen descriptions. We interpret "unseen descriptions" in two ways: 1) paraphrases of known properties, and 2) new phrases or terms unseen in training.
-
Paraphrases. As shown above (Table Xha9.3), Prompteina generalizes to paraphrases of known properties in different formats, and when the prompt is written by a different language model than the one used for generating its training data.
-
Terms absent from training captions. We adopt prompt expansion to support generation from unseen descriptions, as in text-to-image settings [1]: a rewriting step converts the unseen term into an in-distribution description, and Prompteina generates from that. We demonstrate this with one example, the design goal "single-chain transmembrane nanopore", which appears in 0 of the 23.4M captions in our monomer training split. We rewrite the design goal into in-distribution properties represented in our training data, and generate 960 designs per prompt, on the original prompt with the unseen term and on the expanded prompt, matched on length. Designs are scored with three measurements: a constriction diameter of at least 1.0 nm, a lumen that stays open for at least 25 Å across the membrane slab [2], and an inside-out index of at least +0.15 [3]. The unseen term generated no designs that satisfied all three criteria, while the prompt-expanded caption produced 41 (p = 2.9 × 10^-13).
Together, these suggest Prompteina supports both paraphrased and previously unseen descriptions.
[W2] Novelty and comparison to Proteo-R1 and CodeFP. The core difference between Prompteina and these two methods is whether the generative process is conditioned directly on text. In Prompteina, the text embeddings of a free-text caption condition the denoising process itself. In Proteo-R1, a reasoning model reads the text and selects key residues in a given antibody-antigen complex, and the generator conditions on those residues. Similarly, CodeFP maps the text to a term from a closed 375-term Gene Ontology vocabulary, retrieves a structural motif for that term, and conditions on the motif (Table Xha9.4). In our paper, we have now made the wording of the claim precise: "the first all-atom protein structure generation model conditioned directly on natural language, supporting diverse design objectives through a single interface". We now cite both works in Related Work and in the conditioning survey in App. A, and we describe what we could and could not run of each in W3.
Table Xha9.4. Comparison of Proteo-R1, CodeFP, and Prompteina.
| Method | Input | Output | Generator conditioned on | Conditioning in natural language |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Proteo-R1 | antigen structure, antibody framework with CDR positions masked | CDR sequences, complex coordinates | hidden states at key residue anchors | No |
| CodeFP | GO terms, from a closed 375-term vocabulary | sequence, with structure tokens decoded jointly; 3D structure from ESMFold | structural motifs retrieved per term | No |
| Prompteina | free-text caption | all-atom structure, sequence | caption token embeddings | Yes |
[W3] Iterative binder design setup. We report the gain from iterative optimization over i.i.d. sampling for the same model, and compare this gain across models. The within-model gain removes each model's base performance from the comparison. The evaluation tests whether a model with a more expressive conditioning interface can gain more from iteration relative to i.i.d. sampling.
[W3] Comparison with Proteo-R1. As released, Proteo-R1 and Prompteina support different design tasks. Proteo-R1 redesigns masked CDR loops inside a supplied antibody-antigen complex, while Prompteina designs a binder from scratch against a target. Nevertheless, Proteo-R1's approach of reasoning over a design request and translating it natively into residue-level constraints is a promising avenue for language-based protein design. Extending Proteo-R1 to de novo binder design would require retraining it, which we leave to future work. We thank the reviewer for the pointer, and now cite and discuss Proteo-R1 in Related Work and in the conditioning survey in App. A.
We thank the reviewer again for their time and feedback, and welcome any further clarifications!
- Betker et al. Improving image generation with better captions. Technical report, OpenAI, 2023.
- Smart et al. HOLE: A program for the analysis of the pore dimensions of ion channel structural models. Journal of Molecular Graphics, 1996
- Dhar et al. Membrane Barrels Are Taller, Fatter, Inside-Out Soluble Barrels. J. Phys. Chem. B, 2021.
The reviewer appreciates the authors' detailed responses and the additional experimental results. The rebuttal has addressed most of the concerns. In light of these clarifications and improvements, the reviewer has raised the recommendation to Weak Accept.
Thank you once again for the constructive feedback and for raising your score!
We thank the reviewer for their review, and for pointing us to relevant related work which we now cite. We address each weakness below.
[W1] Does natural language beat label conditioning at a matched budget? Yes. We now include a new experiment suggested by the reviewer: a dedicated CATH-label conditioner with the same pooled and cross-attention pathways as text. We fix the architecture, data and compute budget at 47,275 steps, so the runs differ only in the conditioning signal. Under this matched setting, natural language outperforms label conditioning (92.0% vs. 66.7% on CATH class, 27.0% vs. 25.1% on architecture; Table Xha9.1). We report this new ablation in App. D, Table 9.
We only evaluate CATH for these ablations because the CATH-label conditioning runs are limited to CATH class and architecture, whereas the natural-language runs support many properties beyond CATH (last column of Table Xha9.1; Table 1, App. Table 11). Specifying constraints in natural language lets us scale the number of properties we condition on, while a label interface requires a predefined embedding table for each new property.
Table Xha9.1. CATH top-1 accuracy (%) by conditioning interface and pathway. The last column lists the properties each interface controls; the 18 text tasks are measured on the released model, not on these matched runs.
[W1] Is Prompteina sensitive to semantic changes? Yes. Our evaluations in Section 3.1 test semantic sensitivity: whether changing the property specified in the prompt changes the generated structure. We measure 18 structural properties, and Prompteina leads on 15 (Table 1; App. Table 11). For helix and strand count we prompt
This protein contains {X} helices.with lengths fixed across requested counts, against empty-prompt controls at the same 50 lengths. Changing onlyXcontrols the realized count, while the empty-prompt controls show no count control (App. Table 12). We also show a more qualitative example: on CATH architecture, Prompteina is sensitive to a single-word change between two architectures (100% on "Horseshoe", 96% on "Barrel"), while Proteina follows the Horseshoe request and not the Barrel one (84% and 58%, Table Xha9.2). Together, this suggests Prompteina is sensitive to semantic changes in the prompt.Table Xha9.2. GearNet top-1 architecture accuracy (%). Prompteina's prompts differ by one word in the CATH architecture name. The panel means over all 35 architectures are 51.1% for Prompteina and 27.5% for Proteina.
an Alpha-Beta Horseshoe foldan Alpha-Beta Barrel fold[W1] Is Prompteina robust to non-semantic changes? Yes. We currently demonstrate semantic invariance by testing Prompteina's robustness to paraphrasing (App. Table 13). To establish comparative robustness, we extend these CATH class and helix count evaluations to Chroma (text), BioMatrix, and Pinal. For each property, we specify the prompts in four ways, with lengths matched across the generations. Prompteina has the highest mean and the lowest standard deviation on both properties (Table Xha9.3). We report this new comparison in App. E.1, Table 14. We also show that Prompteina remains robust on a finer-grained steering task, binder interface residue count, which none of the other models support, at ρ 0.976 to 0.997 (App. Table 19).
Table Xha9.3. Mean and S.d. across four wordings of the same specification. CATH class accuracy is top-1 over three classes (33.3% chance). Helix count is the Spearman correlation between requested and realized counts.