- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 1
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
The paper studies quadrotor trajectory tracking and proposes a probabilistic system identification framework. The method consists of two stages. First, the authors analytically lift standard nonlinear quadrotor dynamics into a pre-defined 63-dimensional Koopman representation, obtaining approximate bilinear dynamics by truncating higher-order terms. Instead of learning the representation or unrestricted dynamics operators, they estimate physical parameters (mass, inertia, drag, and damping) and Gaussian noise covariances from noisy flight trajectories using generalized expectation conditional maximization. Second, for trajectory tracking, the authors approximate the bilinear dynamics by fixing the state-dependent control matrices along a guide trajectory, which yields a convex quadratic program for MPC. A covariance-weighted disturbance observer further compensates for model mismatch.
Experiments in MuJoCo evaluate the proposed method on the Skydio X2 quadrotor using 90 seconds of noisy training data. The method achieves competitive open-loop prediction and closed-loop tracking performance compared with the evaluated baselines, while maintaining low control latency. The appendix provides qualitative tracking results on the Crazyflie platform.
Critical strengths
-
The overall method is technically sound. Its data efficiency is largely enabled by incorporating strong domain-specific knowledge into the model: the method identifies four groups of physical parameters (mass, inertia, drag, and damping), along with relatively low-dimensional Gaussian noise covariances, within a fixed, analytically defined Koopman representation. This physics-informed approach is well motivated, and the experimental results demonstrate its effectiveness with limited training data.
-
Although qualitative, the additional experiments on Crazyflie 2 demonstrate the applicability of the proposed framework to different quadrotor dynamics.
Critical weaknesses
-
The presentation is hard to follow and makes the core novelty difficult to identify. Several components have been explored in prior work, including EM-based bilinear Koopman identification [1], data-driven Koopman modeling with convex quadrotor MPC [2], and analytical Koopman lifting with truncation bounds and linear MPC [3]. These works should be discussed more thoroughly in related work and preliminaries (or appendix), so the method section can better emphasize its novel contributions: whether physics-constrained probabilistic identification improves control under model mismatch.
-
Appendix G.5 shows that the method remains relatively insensitive to modest increases in zero-mean observation noise. While encouraging, it is unclear whether this robustness comes from covariance learning or the relatively simple isotropic noise structure. Evaluating anisotropic or correlated observation noise would provide stronger evidence for the benefits of probabilistic modeling.
-
An ablation disabling the covariance-weighted wrench observer would help isolate its contribution to closed-loop performance.
-
The authors compare their convex MPC against nonlinear rigid-body MPC in Appendix G.6, but do not discuss prior work on accelerating nonlinear MPC through imitation learning [4].
-
-
The data-efficiency claim could be strengthened. Since the method restricts dynamics learning to four groups of physical parameters, its advantage should be evident with limited training data. A data-scaling experiment comparing prediction performance against learned Koopman representations would help demonstrate whether the proposed method saturates with less data more directly.
[1] Otto, Samuel, Sebastian Peitz, and Clarence Rowley. "Learning bilinear models of actuated Koopman generators from partially observed trajectories." SIAM Journal on Applied Dynamical Systems 23.1 (2024): 885-923.
[2] Narayanan, Sriram SKS, et al. "Se (3) koopman-mpc: Data-driven learning and control of quadrotor uavs." IFAC-PapersOnLine 56.3 (2023): 607-612.
[3] Rajkumar, Santosh Mohan, et al. "Real-time linear MPC for quadrotors on SE (3): An analytical koopman-based realization." IEEE Robotics and Automation Letters (2025).
[4] Mao, Katherine, et al. "Sequence Modeling for Time-Optimal Quadrotor Trajectory Optimization with Sampling-based Robustness Analysis." CoRL (2025).
Questions for authors
-
Is there a specific reason for considering only nine reference trajectory families? Since the method performs system identification, it should be able to handle a broader range of trajectories and control behaviors.
-
Could the authors discuss the suggested ablations in the weaknesses section and explain why they may be unnecessary or infeasible?