- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This manuscript newly introduced Reimagine Video Dynamics (RVD), which learns a compact dynamics token through video reconstruction conditioned on the first frame. The authors combined compressed V-JEPA 2 features with a Wan-based renderer and trains a language-guided dynamics editor using counterfactual video pairs. The same representation also supports appearance re-rendering and retiming without additional training.
Critical strengths
Separating dynamics editing from rendering provides a clear interface for multiple video manipulation tasks. Beyond the 900 edits, including 600 appearance edits and 300 dynamics edits, the paper includes an optical-flow-based motion-preservation evaluation and fixed-target-context comparisons, providing meaningful evidence of functional control.
Critical weaknesses
The contribution of the learned dynamics token is not sufficiently isolated. The functional controls in Tables are already useful, but Tab. 2 reports only reconstruction metrics and does not establish an advantage over equally compact V-JEPA features. A comparison measuring motion preservation and appearance leakage under the same renderer is needed, together with a clearer distinction from reconstruction-based motion representations. Furthermore, the Tab. 3 evaluates the two-stage training and loss design through token-space statistics, several of which are directly optimized by the proposed losses. Rendering these ablations, including a simple token-MSE baseline, under fixed target contexts would show whether they improve edit completion, motion timing, and appearance consistency.
Furthermore, the evaluation needs closer baselines and independent validation. The fourth table (Tab.4) omits the cited DynaEdit, which uses the same Wan I2V backbone model and supports target-frame/caption conditioning, so a comparison using RVD’s planned target context is needed. Edit-success scores should also be checked with blind human evaluation or an independent model, because the Qwen-based judge shares its model family with the RVD pipeline.
Questions for authors
Please carefully address all the concerns mentioned in weakness section.