- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper investigates the limitations of global spectral conditioning in diffusion-based molecular structure elucidation from NMR spectra. The authors identify that existing methods typically compress spectral information into a single global representation, which is uniformly applied to all atoms and bonds, potentially limiting the model's ability to capture local spectrum–structure relationships. To address this issue, they propose per-element spectral cross-attention, allowing individual atoms and candidate bonds to independently attend to relevant spectral tokens. The proposed conditioning mechanism is integrated into two existing diffusion architectures, NMR-DiGress and ChefNMR, and further enhanced with an auxiliary spectral reconstruction loss. Experiments on the simulated SpectraBase dataset demonstrate substantial improvements in top-1 exact structure recovery, increasing from 43.26% to 52.10% on NMR-DiGress and reaching 76.64% on ChefNMR. With additional spectral reconstruction supervision, performance further improves to 54.38% and 78.29%, respectively. The authors also provide theoretical analysis of the greater expressiveness of element-specific conditioning and evaluate transfer to experimental NMR spectra, where improvements in exact recovery are more limited. Overall, the paper highlights the importance of fine-grained spectral conditioning for molecular structure generation and demonstrates its effectiveness across different diffusion architectures.
Critical strengths
Clear motivation and meaningful problem formulation. The paper identifies a potential limitation of global spectral conditioning in diffusion-based NMR structure elucidation and investigates whether fine-grained conditioning can better capture local spectrum–structure relationships.
Critical weaknesses
Limited methodological novelty. The main contribution is replacing global FiLM/AdaLN conditioning with standard per-element cross-attention, a widely adopted mechanism in conditional generative modeling. The authors should better clarify the methodological novelty beyond adapting existing cross-attention techniques to NMR-based molecular structure elucidation.
Limited improvements on experimental NMR spectra. Although the proposed method achieves substantial gains on simulated SpectraBase data, its improvements on experimentally measured spectra are marginal. On SpecTeach, top-1 recovery improves only from 41.2% to 42.9%, while performance on NMRShiftDB2 remains approximately unchanged. This raises concerns about the practical generalization of the proposed approach.
Insufficient compute-matched comparisons. The cross-attention modules introduce additional parameters and computational overhead. More rigorous comparisons under matched parameter counts, training budgets, and inference costs would help isolate the benefits of the proposed conditioning mechanism.
Questions for authors
See Weaknesses.
Reply to Reviewer wsYh: pooled conditioning limits two models on simulated spectra, the SpecTeach numbers are corrected, and after the same training time our model is about 7 points above ChefNMR-S on simulated spectra
Thank you for your review.
We agree that cross-attention is a widely used mechanism. What we show is that pooled FiLM and adaLN conditioning limits these two models on simulated spectra, and we quantify the effect. The same change improves two models that generate molecules in very different ways, with NMR-DiGress improving from 43.3% to 52.1% and ChefNMR-S from 69.2% to 76.6%. On simulated spectra, the published ChefNMR-L reaches about 72% with three times the parameters of our ChefNMR model, CA-ChefNMR-S. On simulated spectra the improvement also holds for molecules whose ring scaffold never occurs in the training data, as described in point 2 of the summary comment. We will clarify this contribution in the revised paper, which we will upload before the discussion period ends.
You are right that we do not show an improvement on experimental spectra, and we have to correct the numbers you quote. We found a one-bin offset in the experimental 13C inputs, which we describe in point 3 of the summary comment. With the offset corrected, ChefNMR-S and our model solve about 55% of the SpecTeach molecules, and they are not distinguishable.
We also investigated why the accuracy on experimental spectra is so much lower.
As used here, NMRShiftDB2 only contains 13C shifts, so it only tests the 13C input, which has the same one-bin offset. In the revised paper we will report the result of the NMRShiftDB2 runs with the corrected input.
In the revised paper we will add a table with the parameters, optimiser steps and training FLOPs of CA-ChefNMR-S and the released ChefNMR-S. If this answers your concerns, we would be grateful if you reconsidered your score.