- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 1
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
The paper proposes a method for reusing a way of responding from a reference. The proposed method encodes a reference into a response representation and installs it at sites in a target scenes. It then rollouts local responses with a target-dependent updates, implemented as a heat simulation for materials with a learned light transport. The experiments show that proposed method results in 52 correct material edits (out of 68 total) against 6 for a baseline.
Critical strengths
Disentangling a reusable component of response from the scene-dependent component is an interesting framing, and such factorization could allow for a more controlled interventions.
Critical weaknesses
- The paper considers narrow, constructed tasks with a highly engineered method. The material benchmark is a synthetic family of four responses defined by hand-specified state equations. The proposed method uses those equations, and only predicts their coefficients. All four responses are seen in training, and the “held-out” set is configurations of a single world. The task therefore largely reduces to identifying one of four known responses and running the ground-truth simulator.
- The evaluation is limited and does not support the claims the paper makes. The material comparison is not like-for-like. The baseline gets an RGB clip and text, while the proposed method gets explicit state, geometry, stimulus, transition labels and a simulator. The baseline’s six “successes” are scenes where the correct output is no motion, and the extended baseline fails its own training controls.
Questions for authors
Please see Critical Weaknesses.
3 comments
Thank you for the rebuttal to me review! Unfortunately, it does not address my concerns.
Weakness 1. The rebuttal defends the use of a specified physical model and solver by analogy to prior work. That is not my issue. My issue is that all four responses are seen in training (App. C.3) and the update equations and solver are given to the method, which predicts only their coefficients (App. B.2). The response does not dispute either fact. The experiments it cites (Fig. 3, Table 15, Table 4) use the same four known responses and the same prescribed equations. They show that the simulator produces different outcomes under different layouts and states, not that a response outside the training set can be learned and reused.
Weakness 2. The response does not address the input mismatch in Table 1, the fact that the baseline's six successes are static controls (App. E.1), or the fact that the extended baseline fails its own training controls (Table 14). The Table 15 result (16/16 vs 0/16) is measured against that same baseline. Table 4 is judged on the numerical rollout, not on generated output, and shows that a heat-driven simulation depends on its state and geometry.
I am keeping my score.
Thank you for your review!
While we want to point out the important distinction between the "four response" in training and the full response the tests actually require to generate, we recognize our setting may not make it obvious enough. It is also related to your concern about testing actual generative output. To address your concern, we added another material experiment to demonstrate Vectile's own learned capability. We make a shell bend-unbend-bend under continuous heat, creating a non-monotonic transition in the middle of its response property. None of the training data demonstrates the non-non-monotonic transition, so this non-monotonic response is guaranteed to be never seen during training. This also makes nearest-neighbor impossible to recover the correct response. At test time, we show Vectile a reference of this bend-unbend-bend material. Vectile, not nearest-neighbor, successfully generated this non-monotonic behavior. We added this result to Appendix J in our new revision, page 34.
On your input mismatch concern, we want to make two points: first, all information that Vectile uses is also semantically given as input to VIPER-Style/Wan. For example, we gave VIPER-Style/Wan the initial heat state as text. The main difference is interface structure. Second, in established literature, it is a common practice to give information to the baseline in its own format. In ObjectMover, LightMover, and Ctrl&Shift, the geometric or spatial conditions are all adapted to each baseline's supported interface that may be less structured than the authors' methods.
The baseline performance may give you concern about the comparison. However, firstly, it does receive extra state and geometry information as our last note points out, and secondly, in our training setting and budget it does indeed perform very badly. VIPER-Style/Wan may perform differently if given a different budget or training setup, but that shouldn't invalidate the particular finding and report in our paper.
We also want to emphasize that our VIPER-style/Wan comparator is not an off-the-shelf, prompt-only video generator. It implements VIPER's dedicated reference-physics conditioning pathway, including 128 learnable physics queries through Qwen3-VL-4B, an MLLM-to-DiT connector, and LoRA adaptation of Wan2.1-VACE-1.3B, with all three alignment, transfer, and generator-adaptation stages completed (2,200 updates). The original VIPER is itself a competitive reference-conditioned physics-generation method, reporting a physical-similarity score of 3.42 compared with 2.14 for VACE in the authors' evaluation. Our comparator is a smaller, independently trained implementation rather than the original authors' checkpoint, and we explicitly document this distinction. It's not an unadapted or deliberately weakened baseline.
Thank you again for reviewing our paper. If our new information addressed your concern, would you kindly raise your score?
You have reduced our study of reference-conditioned transport to a four-way classification problem, then used that reduction to dismiss its scientific contribution. This is a ridiculous evaluation.
The history of our field makes your evaluation very difficult to justify. ControlNet (ICCV 2023) introduced spatial control through a pretrained generator; DragonDiffusion (ICLR 2024) constructed explicit editing energies; ObjectMover (CVPR 2025) and LightMover (CVPR 2026) established controllable interventions through specialized conditions and generated or rendered supervision. In learned physics, NCLaw (ICML 2023) retained governing PDEs while learning constitutive behavior, and PhysDreamer (ECCV 2024) inferred material properties within an established elastic model and solver.
These choices have a constructive necessity. Learning arbitrary physical laws, reconstructing geometry, modeling interactions, and achieving faithful visual synthesis simultaneously would make both experimental attribution and computational cost nearly unmanageable. Constructive research isolates the dependency worth understanding, builds a controlled way to manipulate it, and tests the resulting capability. This is how advances in the field have been made possible and verifiable.
If a specified physical model, an existing solver, and deliberately constructed interventions are sufficient to dismiss our contribution, what consistent scientific principle would qualify the contributions of PhysDreamer, LightMover, and the established control methods above?
Their value cannot be erased by reducing them to their inherited components. Neither can ours. The relevant question is what new operation those components have been organized to make possible, and what the experiments establish about it.
We selected two existing problems with complementary transport difficulties. And we went substantially further than demonstrating that this organization produces plausible edits.
We manually examined the LightMover authors' publicly released evaluation outputs, identified their lighting propagation failures, and showed that, in fact, we could do better. LightMover's own evaluation cases 183/185/187/200 exposed relay, branched reflections, directional response, and occluded cascades. These are failures from an established evaluation. We did not invent these tasks to favor us. In fact, this motivated us to distinguish local response, propagation, and visual expression.
Our submitted Fig. 4 already shows a direct visual win. The comparator changes one kitchen receiver but leaves the other almost white; Vectile restores the missing blue response. We also have six additional joint-movement edits recover emitter placement and visible response.
For the material problem, in Fig. 3, we independently install responses in an ordered pairing excluded from target training and validation. The same responses produce different downstream behavior under different layouts, correctly observed from two cameras. In Table 15, we impose a stricter intervention: replace only the front reference while keeping the rear response and target conditions fixed within each matched pair. The rear changes its motion. Across source and installation settings, the very same replacement produces different downstream consequences. All 16 generated views succeed in this additional development factorial.
We deliberately designed these experiments because reproducing a reference motion would prove far too little. The rear sheet has no new reference, and neither observation contains its counterfactual future. Our experiment tests whether a locally reusable response can participate in a new interaction whose consequences are determined by the target.
We then examined the computation itself. With the response model fixed, removing temperature, activation, and conduction reduces numerical world-response success from 12/12 to 4/12; freezing renewed exposure geometry changes 14/14 to 11/14 (Table 4). These interventions distinguish carried response history from target-mediated propagation. They provide empirical information about which dependencies our transport abstraction must preserve that we consider valuable to the field.
We chose established problems, identified a reusable transport operation they could expose, imposed strict additional interventions to distinguish genuine response reuse from reproducing an observed outcome, and demonstrated improvement on prior work's failure modes.
Your review gives almost none of this scientific work its proper place. The very constraints that make our experiments interpretable somehow become your grounds for dismissal, and it is unclear if our demonstrated work actually received your careful evaluation.