- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes Chain-of-Attention (COA), a structured way for VLMs to explain what is happening in a traffic scene. Instead of only giving an answer, the model identifies important frames, locates pedestrians and vehicles, and explains how the event develops over time. Authors show that their proposed framework greatly improves object localization and explanation quality.
Critical strengths
The reviewer likes the diagnostic focus of the paper, that instead of merely reporting accuracy scores, the authors actively test whether the model is really using the video. For example in Table 6, when they replace the actual scene images with images from a different scene, pedestrian/vehicle localization collapses, yet the temporal score stays almost unchanged (.887 → .888). That is a good experiment because it shows that a seemingly good temporal metric can be “cheated” using ordering cues rather than visual understanding. This also matches the reviewer's own experiences.
Critical weaknesses
The basic COA idea is not fundamentally new. [1] is particularly close: it explicitly grounds video reasoning using timestamps + objects + bounding boxes + reasoning, and trains with rewards for answer accuracy, temporal alignment, and spatial precision. That overlaps heavily with COA's “when + where + explanation” pitch. Prior works like [2-4] already use RL to jointly optimize temporal grounding, spatial grounding, and structured output format in videos. The differences are only on the traffic scene application. The reviewer doesn’t see the contribution of the paper to be of ICLR standards.
[1] Open-o3-Video: Grounded Video Reasoning with Explicit Spatio-Temporal Evidence. ICML 2026
[2] STVG-R1: Incentivizing Instance-Level Reasoning and Grounding in Videos via Reinforcement Learning, ICLR 2026
[3] Visual-RFT: Visual Reinforcement Fine-Tuning, ICCV 2025
[4] Grounded-VideoLLM: Sharpening Fine-grained Temporal Grounding in Video Large Language Models, EMNLP 2025
Questions for authors
Why is strict output validity so low, and how much of that is actually a modeling problem? Any analysis on this?