- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 1
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
The paper aims to create 3D graphics scenes which contain both indoor and outdoor components, e.g. from inside of a building to outside. No existing system provides these. The method is to specify the location of entrances, rooms, and contacts between indoors and outdoors, then iteratively arrange the scene to agree with these using a "world generator".
Critical strengths
Creating 3D graphics scenes is useful for many tasks.
The system tackles indoor outdoor and urban scene generation, jointly, which is challenging and underserved
Critical weaknesses
The method has a \textit{world generator}, which iterates against a set of constraints, but doesnt say what the world generator is. The code requires an LLM api key but the method does not say it uses an LLM, or which LLM, or how the LLM is used. The method does not say how the values of the constraints are chosen per scene (user provided or randomly genreated) or how Z1 K1 PE are encoded. I would strongly recommend replacing all mathematical notation with plain description.
The buildings and outdoor assets are not procedural, but the method only says how it chooses procedural objects. No dataset is stated for them. This could render the system unusable if the assets are not freely licensed.
There are very few qualitative examples and they do not showcase the authors method. Most are only indoors or only outdoors, not bridging between. None have difficult indoor-outdoor interfaces like unusually shaped buildings or sloped ground. Many look very photorealistic, but they are dominated by large views of existing building assets or indoor scenes. I do not think the quantitative metrics can guarantee that the scenes are highquality besides having photorealistic components.
Questions for authors
How was Figure 1(c) generated? It is very different in style from other outputs.
What features of the method are showcased by the Fig 3/4 examples? If the authors could describe specific features in specific images that are challenging (e.g. particular pathways or asset placements) this would help to justify that the outputs are significant.
Could the authors visualize their arrangements as abstract trajectories or polygons without relying on existing assets? This would make the effects of the method section's components concrete and visible, without attempting to be photoreal.
What is the source for the 3D building and outdoor assets? Can they be used freely by others (no restrictive / comercial licenses)?
Are the qualitative images shown randomly selected or manually selected ?
5 comments
Response to Reviewer 34GQ (2/4): Asset sources, figures, and qualitative examples
Q6: Building and outdoor asset sources.
R6: There may be a misunderstanding here: all outdoor assets and buildings are procedurally generated. These assets do not come from external datasets. All our detailed procedural assets, including indoor objects, outdoor objects, and buildings, are reproducible, and we have open-sourced their generators and configurations.
Q7: Visual style of Figure 1.
R7: Panels (a), (b), and (c) are schematic illustrations of the problem setting and our motivation, not experimental outputs. Their consistent visual style makes the differences between separate generation, post-hoc assembly, and unified generation easier to compare. We will state this explicitly in the caption.
Q8: What the qualitative examples demonstrate.
R8: We believe you are referring to Figures 4 and 5 rather than Figure 3. These examples demonstrate two capabilities: coherent object placement in indoor and outdoor scenes, and continuous routes across building entrances.
Figure 4 shows spatial relationships between objects and the geometric detail of procedural assets. In the dining-room example, chairs are arranged around the table; in the bedroom example, the bed and surrounding furniture form a coordinated layout. These arrangements require accounting for object dimensions and functional relationships when determining relative positions. Local details, such as the tableware, demonstrate the fine geometry of the procedural assets.
Figure 5 shows a continuous route across the building entrance. In our Corner Kitchen example, the route extends from the outdoor seating area, through the entrance, and between the indoor tables. The challenge is to coordinate outdoor seating, the building opening, and indoor furniture so that the route remains unobstructed across the indoor–outdoor boundary. The “04 / SPATIAL CONTINUITY” videos on the submitted project page show continuous traversal along this route. In contrast, GPT-6 Astra reduces the number of objects in the scene to ensure connectivity, whereas GLM-5.3 may generate unexpected objects directly on the path, obstructing passage.
Q9: Abstract layout visualization.
R9: We sincerely thank the reviewer for this insightful suggestion. Abstract layout visualization makes the effects of constraint optimization much clearer. The figure illustrates the same complete indoor–outdoor scene with 23 object footprints and two entrances. Figure (a) : Without indoor contract optimization, indoor furniture is disordered and overlapping, with objects occupying entrance clearance regions. Figure (b) : Without outdoor contract optimization, outdoor objects overlap and obstruct access. Figure (c) : Without building-envelope contract optimization, the indoor and outdoor entrance clearance regions are misaligned, so the outdoor path meets the wall instead of connecting to the door. Figure (d) : With all contracts, objects are placed without overlap, and both entrances and the outdoor access routes remain clear. Shading marks the reserved clearance regions on both sides of each entrance; red hatching marks overlaps and clearance violations.
Q10: Qualitative example selection.
R10: We did not select examples based on visual quality. To compare generation quality and spatial arrangements across methods within their supported scene types, we manually select categories such as dining rooms and bedrooms; the specific scenes within each category are randomly generated. Additional generated examples are available on the submitted project page.
Response to Reviewer 34GQ (3/4): Revised manuscript text (1/2)
3 The WorldBridge Framework
WorldBridge procedurally generates spatially connected indoor–outdoor environments and extends them into dynamic 4D worlds. We first extend Infinigen's procedural modeling to build an asset hierarchy spanning indoor objects, outdoor facilities, and functional buildings. We then coordinate indoor and outdoor layouts through shared spatial contracts, instantiate scene structures, and place assets hierarchically. Finally, we introduce object motion and environmental effects through dynamic code generation and visual feedback.
3.1 Procedural Asset Generation
Building on Infinigen (Raistrick et al., 2024), we extend its procedural generators to cover indoor objects, outdoor facilities, and functional buildings. As shown in the asset hierarchy figure, object-level generators produce reusable assets, while building-level generators compose architectural components into structures with both exterior and interior geometry.
Object-Level Generation. For each object category, we implement a procedural generator parameterized by dimensions, component counts, shape, and material attributes. Parameters can be specified explicitly or sampled according to predefined rules. The generator constructs objects through geometric operations, component transformations, instancing, and procedural material assignment. Geometric bounds and support references guide subsequent placement, while the component hierarchy enables editing and dynamic behavior attachment to individual parts.
Parameterized Building Construction. For each building category, we define rules specifying the required architectural components and their assembly. Each building generator takes the footprint, room partitions, openings, and floor elevations determined by the coordination stage in Sec. 3.2, and constructs the exterior and interior structures, including walls, slabs, doors, and windows, within a shared coordinate frame. The resulting geometry retains room boundaries and support surfaces as spatial references for subsequent furniture and equipment placement.
Response to Reviewer 34GQ (1/4): World generator, LLM usage, and constraints
We thank the reviewer for the careful review and valuable suggestions. We also thank the reviewer for recognizing that “Creating 3D graphics scenes is useful for many tasks” and describing joint indoor, outdoor, and urban scene generation as “challenging and underserved”.
R1: The “world generator” is a scene-generation module comprising a layout constraint solver and procedural asset generators. The solver iteratively adjusts the layout to satisfy spatial constraints. Procedural generators create the assets needed for the scene, such as tables and trees, and assemble them into a 3D scene according to the optimized layout.
R2: Our method uses GPT-5.6 (xhigh) as its LLM, primarily in the following two stages:
R3: Dimensions, spacing, and opening parameters can be explicitly specified by the user or randomly sampled within predefined ranges. Required access relations are specified in the scene configuration.
R4: The meanings and encodings of these symbols are as follows:
All positions and elevations use a shared coordinate frame, with lengths measured in metres.
R5: Thank you for the suggestion. We have removed the mathematical notation. The full step-by-step description is provided in the final two replies, “Revised manuscript text (1/2)” and “Revised manuscript text (2/2)”.