- Rating
- 3
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper investigates the prediction of absorption cross-sections, a property determined by molecular structure, temperature, and pressure. The authors also provide a systematic comparison of simulated data augmentation, label processing, representation methods, and network architectures. The results indicate that an appropriate amount of simulated data and the use of label masking can improve the prediction of experimental spectra, while more complex architectures do not demonstrate a consistent advantage.
Critical strengths
The task is of practical significance. The use of molecule-based cross-validation, combined with the exclusion of molecules that appear in both the simulated and experimental datasets, helps to mitigate data leakage. The experiments cover a range of design factors and report both effect sizes and negative results, providing a useful benchmark for future research.
Critical weaknesses
- The most distinctive aspect of the task, that is, whether the model has learned how temperature and pressure alter the spectra, has not yet been fully verified. If the overall error is primarily driven by the inherent differences in spectral shapes between distinct molecules, a model could potentially achieve a decent aggregate performance even if it only predicts typical spectra (e.g., near room temperature) and remains insensitive to variations in temperature and pressure.
- The benefits of synthetic data augmentation may be coupled with the training budget. Since the number of training epochs is held constant across configurations, adding synthetic data significantly increases the total training data; the authors should control the training budget to isolate the effects of increased computational resources.
Questions for authors
Please refer to the weakness part above.
3 comments
I thank the authors for providing additional results. I also appreciate the practice of acknowledging the issues in their previous version. As my concerns are mostly addressed, I keep my original score of weak acceptance.
Thank you for your constructive reviews.
Thank you for your constructive comments, for both questions, please refer to Official Comment by Authors.