- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 1
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
The paper studies final-model privacy for clipped, projected proximal-anchored DP-SGD.
Critical strengths
The presentation is ok and I beleive with AI assistance the technical proofs should be correct in general.
Critical weaknesses
It is very hard for me to follow the paper, even though I have been working in differential privacy and theory in general for years. I highly suspect the paper is heavily assisted by AI tools, as many steps and description are not standard.
There are many words the authors use are not clear to me. This makes the paper hard to understand. Please refer to the next "Questions For Authors" Section.
Questions for authors
I do not use AI-tools to review, so it is likely I miss some of the details and have grammar mistakes since I am not a native speaker. If so, please just indicate what I miss or where I am wrong. Thank you.
Things that i'd prefer to be clarified:
-
In abstrast, why this is a "hidden-state setting" and what is "proximal-anchored"? Also, for the first time use abbreviations like "PABI", the authors should state what does it mean, even if it is in the abstrast. What are exact Gaussian smoothing and causal shift allocation, are these new techniques by the authors (so that the authors should say they developed new techniques), or existing techniques (so that the authors should say they utilized xxx). The authors say it computes the certificate in O(T) time, what is T?
-
In page 2, what is a "horizon-independent bound"? What is a "diameter"? What is "average factor"? There are other similar unclears things in the first 3 pages, making me unable to follow the paper.
-
What is a "fixed-slot representation"? What is a "propagation factor"?
-
What is a "probe" and "finite probe"?
-
Is this shifted-Renyi divergence in (11) entirely novel? Why is it needed?
-
The authors should not make the fonts in Algorithm 1 substantially smaller than the usual font.
-
What is a "contiguous-interval"?
Overall, the authors used quite a lof of terms that are either undefined or lack of explanation. It is very difficult for me to read the paper.
Moreover, in Ethics Statement the authors say "The proposed watermarking method....." which is clearly not for this paper.