- Rating
- 3(+1)
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
The paper proposes elliptic schedule, which is a stochastic interpolant schedule and corresponding discretization scheme derived for Gaussian target distributions. Theoretically, It proves minimax optimality when the target distribution is Gaussian. Furthermore they extends elliptic schedule to log-concave distributions and gives query complexity here. In experiments they show elliptic schedule can result in better performance.
Critical strengths
- The proposed Zoloflow connects optimal interpolation schedule and rational function approximation, this is a novel and interesting idea.
- For log-concave sampling they give theoretical analysis and query complexity, this is a solid result and the query complexity seems reliable.
Critical weaknesses
- Elliptic schedule is derived for a class of narrow well-behaved Gaussian target distributions. For general distributions such as log-concave distributions, this paper do not give theoretical guarantee that the elliptic sampling schedule performs better than other schedules.
- The experimental results are not comprehensive enough to demonstrate that elliptic sampling is indeed a better choice for practical generative tasks.
Questions for authors
- I do not fully understand the Gaussian experiments. It seems that the other schedules do not converge as the number of score evaluations increases, which is a suspicious result. Can you explain it?
- The 2D experiments seem to aim to show an improvement in NLL under the same score evaluation budget. However, the results are still poor for elliptic schedule, which raises the concern that the budget was deliberately chosen to be very small. Could you use a larger score evaluation budget and examine whether elliptic sampling can approach the ground truth while other schedules cannot?
- The improvements in evaluation metrics on practical generative tasks appear to come more from hyperparameter search than from the elliptic schedule itself. You should provide more convincing evidence that the elliptic schedule can offer practical benefits despite the lack of a theoretical guarantee.
2 comments
Official Comment by Reviewer wRcy
Thank you for your detailed response and the substantial improvements to the revised manuscript. The additional Stable Diffusion 3.5 experimental results are quite convincing and have addressed my main concern. I will raise my score accordingly.
Response to reviewer comments
Weaknesses
Questions