acceptodds
Under review as a conference paper at ICLR 2027

Identifying Reward Factors for Sparse Preference Elicitation

Abstract

Personalized reward models represent each user's reward as a weighted combination of shared factors. Predictive accuracy alone does not give these factors a stable meaning: an invertible recombination of the factors, offset by a corresponding change in the weights, preserves every prediction while changing the meaning of each weight. We study which factors a population's comparison data identify and how many comparisons are needed to recover a new user's sparse composition once the dictionary is fixed. When each reward is a positive scale times a simplex composition, a population with a specialist for every factor generates a reward cone whose extreme rays are exactly the factors. The dictionary and user compositions are then identifiable up to permutation within the anchored model class. Without anchors, the extreme rays correspond to extreme population mixtures and may exclude sparser newcomers. For a fixed dictionary, the simplex constraint makes the sign of a realizable group contrast test the user's total weight on that group. The decision is independent of the user's scale, although its reliability depends on that scale. CS-Elicit recovers an -sparse support by testing tree nodes, using noisy comparisons at answer bias . This count matches a counting lower bound up to logarithmic factors, and the weight estimation rate is independent of . Across language and control tasks, extraction improves dictionary stability across independent data draws. On PersonalLLM, extracting factors from LoRe utilities raises the cross-draw dictionary correlation from to . In the E4 scaling experiment, CS-Elicit reaches held-out accuracy for -sparse users with an extracted dictionary in questions, compared with for mutual information selection.

Primary area:
alignment, fairness, safety, privacy, and societal considerations
Keywords:
Personalized Reward Modeling, Preference Elicitation

Reviews

Among:
Shape:
1234this paper, Bottom 27%
Figure 1. Mean review rating of the reviewed papers at ICLR 2027. This paper averages 2.00 over 3 reviews, above 27% of the others.
Reviewer_47YvOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
2
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

This paper studies sparse preference elicitation for personalized reward models. It first extracts a shared reward-factor dictionary from population preference data, then proposes CS-Elicit, a group-testing method that identifies a new user’s active factors and estimates their weights using few pairwise comparisons. The method achieves efficient elicitation when user preferences are sparse and informative probes are available, but its applicability to realistic settings with dense, nonlinear, and context-dependent user preferences remains unclear.

Critical strengths
  1. The paper provides a clear theoretical analysis of reward-factor identifiability under anchor-user assumptions and derives an O(slog⁡K)O(s\log K) query complexity for sparse support recovery.

  2. The experiments cover both language and control tasks and compare CS-Elicit with several active elicitation baselines, showing promising gains for highly sparse users.

Critical weaknesses
  1. The method relies critically on the assumption that users have sparse compositions over a fixed shared dictionary. In realistic recommendation or personalization settings, user preferences are often dense, nonlinear, and context-dependent, in which case the proposed group-testing advantage may disappear.

  2. The practical reward-factor extraction pipeline is less rigorously supported than the fixed-dictionary elicitation theory. The finite-sample error of dictionary extraction is not theoretically bounded, and the extracted factors may not correspond to the true underlying preferences, especially when anchor users are absent or impure.

Questions for authors
  1. How does CS-Elicit perform when user compositions are dense or only approximately sparse? In particular, how does the query complexity and prediction accuracy change as the support size ss approaches the dictionary size KK?
  2. Can the authors evaluate the complete pipeline under more realistic user preferences with nonlinear interactions, context-dependent weights, and no pure anchor users?
Reviewer_Jp5KOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
2
Informativeness
2
Presentation
1
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

There is a line of research which decomposes personalized reward models into weighted combinations of shared factors. For instance, judging reviews could be decomposed into a combination of brevity, factuality etc. The authors argue that decomposing user-level aggregated rewards into shared latent factors and using them to elicit responses can be helpful for new users who value only a few of these factors.

The paper provides analysis on why specialists can serve as anchors to reconstruct population level reward. Building on this, the authors propose CS-Elicit, which provides pairwise tests to discover active factors. Theoretical analysis provides a bound of O (s log K) group tests to recover s-sparse support. Empirical studies show gains in dictionary reproducibility (factors reconstruction) and fewer questions for highly sparse users while the overall pipeline seems to have mixed results.

Critical strengths
  1. The paper identifies the conceptual limitations of accurate personalized reward predictions on why it does not uniquely identify the underlying latent factors. The authors argue that having specialists help cover the range of population level rewards and show why dictionaries extracted without specialists can fail to represent extreme new comers.
  2. The authors propose an principled elicitation method that leverages pairwise comparisons with explicit recovery guarantees. The experiments show savings for highly sparse users when information probes are available.
Critical weaknesses
  1. There is room for improvement regarding the readability of the paper. I found the information in Introduction, Sections 3 and 4 to be highly compressed with the introduction of several concepts in quick succession. Providing a simple example and visual representations might also improve the readability of this paper.
  2. Assumption 3 seems to be particularly strong and it is not clear how practical it is. It seems that CS-Elicit needs comparisons for every factor group and sufficient contrasts in preferences.
  3. The empirical studies have limited evaluations using natural human preferences. Constructing shared latent factors is a key component of the proposed methodology. Several results are based on predefined factors and synthetic users to construct the preference pairs which imposes the shared-factor structure into the reward model. The experiments assess the method under specific conditions but it is not clear if this would generalize to real-life applications.
  4. The empirical results also seem to be mixed under synthetic conditions. Specifically when the learned dictionary and estimators are fixed, CS-Elicit does not consistently outperform the baselines.
Questions for authors
  1. Could you help clarify why Assumption 3 holds in practice? Is it realistic that the response pools contain sufficiently informative probes for every required group?
  2. Would it be possible to run evaluations without the assumed preference structure comprising of predefined actors?
Reviewer_E2E8OpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
2
Informativeness
3
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

The paper studies how to learn stable, shared reward factors and use them to personalize a reward model with few user comparisons. It shows that factors can be identified, up to permutation, when the population contains a specialist for each factor. It then proposes CS-Elicit, which uses tree-based group comparisons to identify the small subset of factors relevant to a new user before estimating their weights. The authors provide conditional identification and sample-complexity guarantees and evaluate dictionary stability and elicitation efficiency on language and control tasks.

Critical strengths

The assumptions may be difficult to satisfy in practice. The method needs specialist-like users, sparse preferences, and response pairs that distinguish groups of factors. It is unclear how often these conditions hold for real users.

Most experiments use simulated preferences. These experiments help test the theory, but provide limited evidence that the same gains would hold with real people whose preferences may be less sparse or consistent.

The theory does not yet cover the full practical pipeline. The extraction guarantees assume exact user rewards, while these must be estimated from limited data in practice. How those estimation errors affect the final personalization remains unresolved.

The gains do not consistently come from the proposed query strategy. When the dictionary and estimator are held fixed in the end-to-end settings, mutual-information selection sometimes matches or beats CS-Elicit. This makes the added value of the elicitation strategy less clear outside the highly sparse settings.

Critical weaknesses
  • The assumptions may be difficult to satisfy in practice. The method needs specialist-like users, sparse preferences, and response pairs that distinguish groups of factors. It is unclear how often these conditions hold for real users.

  • Most experiments use simulated preferences. These experiments help test the theory, but provide limited evidence that the same gains would hold with real people whose preferences may be less sparse or consistent!!

  • The theory does not yet cover the full practical pipeline. The extraction guarantees assume exact user rewards, while these must be estimated from limited data in practice. How those estimation errors affect the final personalization remains unresolved.

Questions for authors

Could you provide evidence that the extracted reward factors capture meaningful, broadly shared dimensions of real human preferences, beyond their stability and usefulness for synthetic users constructed as mixtures of predefined factors?

Comments on the paper

2 comments

Dear Reviewers,

The authors have provided detailed responses to your comments and revised the manuscript accordingly.

As the discussion period ends on November 18, I would appreciate it if you could review the authors' responses and indicate whether your concerns have been adequately addressed or if any issues remain.

Thank you for your time and effort.

We thank all the reviewers and AC. Personalized reward models fit shared factors and per-user weights, but predictive accuracy does not determine the factors: an invertible recombination of the factors gives the same predictions with different weights. Our paper states determine the factors stably up to permutation, and turns that structure into a provably efficient way to question new users.

Contributions

  1. When population data identify reward factors. If the population contains a specialist for each factor, comparison data determine the factors and every user's weights up to permutation (Theorem 1). Without specialists, Proposition 1 shows exactly which new users the extracted factors miss. On PersonalLLM, extraction raises the cross-draw dictionary correlation from 0.42 to 0.63.
  2. Questioning cost that scales with sparsity. Because user weights lie on a simplex, the sign of one comparison tests a user's total weight on a group of factors, whatever the user's scale. CS-Elicit uses this to find s active factors out of K with O(s log K) group tests. Its comparison count matches a lower bound up to log factors, and its weight-estimation rate does not depend on K (Theorem 2). On PersonalLLM it reaches 93% accuracy in 10.1 questions, against 26.1 for mutual information (MI).
  3. A bridge between the two stages. Theorem 3 gives a condition under which CS-Elicit still recovers a new user's active factors when the specialists used for extraction are impure, assuming their rewards are known exactly.

What the rebuttal adds to the paper

  • Tighter theory. At 5% impurity, Theorem 3 now requires active weights above 0.186, down from 1.07, which no user could meet. A new estimation bound separates representation bias from sampling error; on PersonalLLM, sampling costs 0.3 points and the text features cost 18.6.
  • Where elicitation helps. CS-Elicit gains up to 10.8 points over random and 5.6 over MI for 1-sparse users, keeps its lead over MI at a tail mass of 0.1, and falls back toward random as users become dense.
  • User-specific weights. On UF-P-4, a user's own elicited weights reach 63.5% accuracy, against 58.2% for shared weights and 54.6% for another user's elicited weights.

Discussion

To our knowledge, few public human datasets provide enough labels per persistent annotator to measure individual preference signal reliably. PRISM (Kirk et al., 2024) has about 15 labels per user and Community Alignment (Zhang et al., 2026) about 40, and in our analysis the per-user gain on Community Alignment is only 0.011 nats. Most personalized-alignment benchmarks therefore use synthetic users or labels: UF-P-2/4 (Poddar et al., 2024), P-SOUPS (Jang et al., 2023), PersonalLLM (Zollo et al., 2025) and MaxMin-RLHF (Chakraborty et al., 2024). We follow this practice and add TL;DR (Stiennon et al., 2020), the one dataset in our study with recorded choices from persistent annotators. There, a dictionary learned from 19 annotators transfers to 20 unseen ones at 69.9% accuracy, against 65.4% for pooled BT and within 0.7 points of the strongest baseline. With zero answers it already reaches 70.0%, so on this dataset most of the gain comes from the dictionary.

On these benchmarks, building the reward dictionary is the main bottleneck. On PersonalLLM, the text features cost 18.6 accuracy points and finite labels 0.3, and with a fixed dictionary the choice of questions moves accuracy by only a few points. Kang (2026, arXiv:2605.09119) shows that decision-relevant diversity among users makes a personalized reward learnable, and an anchored population provides it by construction. CS-Elicit targets users whose weights concentrate on a few factors, a pattern supported by decision research (Tversky, 1972) and by LLM preference data, where WIMHF (Movva et al., 2026) recovers 84% of the predictable signal with about four active features per comparison.

From OpenReview, CC BY 4.0. Authors as signed there; shown unedited.

Related papers

Loading the map…

Discussion (0)

Sign in to comment.