- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 3
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes PRIME, a continual learning framework for face anti-spoofing that aims to prevent previously established attack routes from being lost as new sessions arrive. PRIME freezes each attack prototype set together with the bona fide reference used by its routing rule, providing a theoretical guarantee of conditional zero forgetting on attack routing (ZF-A). It also introduces Joint Token Attention (JTA), a learnable readout that aggregates patch and register tokens across all layers of a frozen DINOv3 backbone, pretrained on a newly constructed synthetic dataset, FFHQ-SynthFAS, containing identity-matched attack and bona fide image pairs. Experiments on two protocols show strong cross-domain performance, with a mean HTER of 1.45% on the OCIM leave-one-out benchmark and 2.21% on five unseen datasets in a chronological three-session setting. Comparisons with continual learning baselines also show that PRIME preserves established attack routes without observed reversals on the evaluated samples.
Critical strengths
-
A clearly defined and practically relevant objective. The paper addresses a security-critical issue in continual face anti-spoofing: adding new data should not invalidate previously established attack routes. The formal ZF-A guarantee gives the method a clear objective beyond improving average classification accuracy.
-
Broad empirical evaluation with useful controlled comparisons. The paper evaluates PRIME on two protocols and multiple unseen datasets. In particular, the comparison of routing rules on shared frozen features helps isolate the contribution of the proposed routing mechanism. The paired synthetic dataset also attempts to reduce confounding factors by matching attack and bona fide images in identity and capture conditions.
Critical weaknesses
-
The routing guarantee does not directly guarantee the retention of correct classification decisions. ZF-A ensures that an established expert route cannot be removed, but it does not guarantee that the final prediction remains correct. Indeed, the paper reports that some bona fide frames are routed to attack experts (4.9% in Protocol 1 and 3.3% in Protocol 2). Although the authors acknowledge this limitation, the practical trade-off between route permanence and persistent false attack routing is not sufficiently characterized. More analysis of its impact on final classification errors and deployment reliability would strengthen the central claim.
-
The contribution of the individual methodological components and the fairness of the main comparisons remain insufficiently established. Although Table 4 provides a controlled comparison of routing rules on shared features, several headline comparisons involve methods with different backbones or training data. For example, the Protocol 2 comparison includes published baselines trained on CelebA-Spoof alone, whereas PRIME uses three sequential training datasets. In addition, the analysis does not directly compare JTA with simpler alternatives, such as last-layer token pooling or averaging features across layers. Consequently, it remains difficult to determine how much of the improvement comes from the immutable routing mechanism, the learned projector, and the synthetic pretraining data, respectively.
Questions for authors
-
Can the authors quantify the impact of permanently retained attack routes on final classification errors, particularly for bona fide frames that continue to be routed to attack experts? How does this trade-off evolve as more sessions are added?
-
Can the authors provide controlled ablations of JTA against simpler readout strategies, such as last-layer pooling and cross-layer averaging, to better establish the contribution of the proposed projector?
-
How does PRIME scale to substantially longer continual learning sequences? Since the number of expert evaluations can grow linearly with the number of stored experts in the worst case, it would be useful to report inference cost, memory usage, and routing behavior under a larger number of sessions.
Dear Reviewer md7p, thanks for your timely reply. Dear Reviewers RFcu and UQvV, could you please indicate whether the authors' response well addressed all of your suggestions or concerns, and update your final score? Thank you!
Dear ALL,
Dear Reviewer md7p, thanks for your timely reply. Dear Reviewers RFcu and UQvV, could you please indicate whether the authors' response well addressed all of your suggestions or concerns, and update your final score? Thank you!