acceptodds
Under review as a conference paper at ICLR 2027

DRL Plus: A Replay-Free and Non-Bellman Policy-Learning Framework

Abstract

Reinforcement Learning (RL) has become a widely used framework for sequential decision-making, particularly in robotics, autonomous systems, and complex control tasks. Recent advances in Deep Reinforcement Learning (DRL) have enabled learning in high-dimensional environments; however, many conventional approaches rely on Bellman-based value estimation, carefully designed reward functions, and, particularly in off-policy methods, experience replay buffers. These dependencies can contribute to challenges such as high sample complexity, sensitivity to reward design, training instability, memory overhead, and safety concerns associated with trial-and-error learning in real-world applications. In this paper, we propose DRL Plus, a framework formulated within the Markov Decision Process (MDP) setting that eliminates Bellman-based value function estimation, handcrafted reward functions, and experience replay. Safety and performance are critical in robotics and autonomous systems; therefore, autonomous driving is selected as the target domain due to its complexity and stringent safety requirements. Through formal analysis and a set of carefully designed challenging driving scenarios, we demonstrate that DRL Plus achieves improved performance and safety compared with state-of-the-art deep reinforcement learning and safe reinforcement learning approaches.

Primary area:
reinforcement learning
Keywords:
Deep Reinforcement Learning, Autonomous Vehicles, Markov Decision Processes, Safety

Reviews

Among:
Shape:
1234this paper, Bottom 10%
Figure 1. Mean review rating of the reviewed papers at ICLR 2027. This paper averages 1.67 over 3 reviews, above 10% of the others.
Reviewer_nrJZOpenReview ↗
Rating
1
Confidence
2
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
1
Read review
Paper summary

experience replay, and complex reward design. The authors propose DRL Plus, in which a shared policy network outputs steering, throttle, and braking commands. A calculator predicts the vehicle’s next position from these actions, constructs a dynamic target rectangle, and computes a geometric loss. A verification module checks the candidate action and continues optimizing the policy if the result is not accepted. A finite-state machine identifies the current driving phase so that the shared network can be trained with the corresponding phase-specific loss. The paper’s main contribution is the integration of geometric learning signals and online action verification into a control pipeline that does not train a critic, perform Bellman backups, or maintain an experience replay buffer. For validation, the authors derive a zero failure probability under assumptions including invariance of the safe-state set; compare DRL Plus with DDPG, SAC, CPO, and PPO-Lagrangian in CARLA using phase completion rates, overall success rates, and control metrics, reporting a 100% overall success rate across 1,500 episodes; and use PRISM to check success, collision, and violation properties in an abstract overtaking model.

Critical strengths

A concrete alternative to value-based policy learning. DRL Plus combines predicted next-state geometry, a task-specific loss, and online action verification without a critic, Bellman backups, or experience replay. This is consequential because it offers a testable design for structured, safety-critical control tasks that goes beyond modifying a conventional reward function.

Critical weaknesses
  1. The training objectives are not clearly connected. The paper does not explain how the objective in Eq. (12) on page 5, the geometric loss returned by Algorithm 1 on page 7, the (J(θ)) update in Algorithm 2, and the stage-specific losses on page 16 form a single executable optimization procedure. The verification rule and its reliability are unclear. The acceptance criterion used by Verify is not sufficiently specified, and the paper does not analyze how errors in the predicted next position affect its decisions. Thepremise of the safety guarantee is not established. Equations (8)–(11) assume that the selected actions remain safe under the true transition dynamics, but the paper does not show that actions accepted by the verifier satisfy this condition.

  2. The contribution of the integration is not clearly established. The rectangular regions, finite-state machine, and stage-specific losses involve substantial task-specific design. The paper should clarify what this particular combination adds beyond existing prediction and safety-filtering methods. Targeted comparisons are missing. The current baselines do not isolate whether the reported improvement comes from the learning rule, geometric regions, stage decomposition, or online action filtering. Controlled comparisons with appropriate alternatives are needed. The current experiments do not adequately support the paper’s broader claims. The reported results from 1,500 episodes in one CARLA overtaking scenario do not establish safety across scenarios, a general solution to long-horizon credit assignment, or computational efficiency at decision time.

3.On page 7, the item labeled “Figure 4” is a numerical table. The text also refers to this success-rate table as “Table 4,” although Table 4 on page 8 reports the statistical test results. Please correct the table label and numbering, and update the corresponding in-text references.

Questions for authors

Please specify the training objective and parameter-update rule actually used. How do the safety-probability estimate and loss in Eq. (12) on page 5 relate to the geometric loss in Algorithm 1 on page 7, the (J(θ)) update in Algorithm 2, and the three stage-specific losses on page 16? Do gradients propagate through the next-position predictor? What is the exact acceptance criterion used by Verify? Given prediction errors and the motion of other vehicles, why must an accepted action satisfy the true-transition safety condition required by Eq. (8)? How does the PRISM abstraction correspond to the policy executed in CARLA? Were the 1,500 episodes used to calculate the success rates in Figure 4 run independently after training with the policy frozen? How do they relate to the 1,500 training episodes listed in Table 2? What are the success rates for each of the 25 random seeds, and what was the unit of analysis in the statistical tests? What controlled results distinguish the effects of the learning rule, dynamic regions, finite-state machine, and online verification on the success rate? Compared with predictive-control or safety-filtering methods given comparable task-specific information and decision-time computational budgets, what incremental benefit does the proposed integration provide?

1 comment
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Objective clarification, expanded experiments, and corrected presentation

We thank the reviewer for the detailed comments on mathematical consistency, evaluation, and presentation. The revision clarifies the methodology text, expands the experiments, and corrects the success-table labeling.

  1. Critical Weakness 1 and questions on the objective and gradients. Section 3.1 now defines the geometric loss between the predicted next position and the zone reference point in equation (6). Equation (7) combines it with the implemented regularization terms. The text states that the policy update uses ∇θLt\nabla_\theta\mathcal L_t through the differentiable calculator, with gradient clipping. Appendix A.2 distinguishes this local objective from the terminal performance measure JH(Π)J_H(\Pi). The earlier description of three phase-specific losses has been removed: maneuver phases determine the zone and reference point. Locations: Section 3.1, equations (6)–(7), lines 250–258, p. 5, and lines 270–274, p. 6; Appendix A.2, lines 754–755, p. 14.

  2. Critical Weakness 1 and questions on verification. Figure 2 now shows the predicted-position zone check, retention of feasible candidates, stopping decisions, and fallback selection when no feasible candidate is cached. The analytical discussion separately specifies uncertainty-set containment for the conditional safety argument. It explains why checking only the nominal predicted position is insufficient near a zone boundary and why position containment alone does not establish collision avoidance. Locations: Figure 2 and lines 180–193, p. 4; Section 3, lines 213–246, pp. 4–5; Section 3.1, lines 266–269, p. 5.

  3. Critical Weakness 2: Formulation and broader evaluation. The revised discussion distinguishes refinement of policy-network parameters from direct optimization of control variables. We also added MPC to overtaking and introduced a U-turn scenario with all six algorithms. DRL Plus and MPC both achieve 100% overall overtaking success. In U-turns, DRL Plus achieves 100% observed success compared with 6.80% for the evaluated MPC configuration. The revised conclusion summarizes the complete framework's performance across these two maneuvers. Locations: Section 3.1, lines 259–274, pp. 5–6; Section 4.1, lines 282–295, p. 6; Tables 2–3, p. 8; Section 6, lines 497–509, p. 10.

  4. Critical Weakness 3: Table labeling and references. The overtaking success-rate display is now Table 2, with its in-text reference corrected. Statistical significance results are presented separately in Table 6. Figure 4 now identifies the driving-scene illustration at simulation step 73. Locations: Figure 4 and lines 366–368, p. 7; Table 2, lines 378–389, p. 8; statistical-table reference, lines 421–424, p. 8; Table 6, p. 9.

  5. Questions on seed aggregation and statistical notation. The revised experimental text clarifies that Tables 2–3 aggregate results across 25 random seeds. Appendix A.3 defines the stage-performance value for run/seed ii and identifies NN as the number of runs. The run/seed is therefore the stated unit in the statistical formulation. Locations: Section 4.1, lines 362–364, p. 7; Appendix A.3, lines 783–809, p. 15; randomization settings in Table 9, p. 16.

  6. Question on PRISM correspondence. The new Appendix A.7 explains how controller action selection affects model interpretation and distinguishes abstract-model probabilities from deployed-controller performance. It identifies the abstraction map, event definitions, transition construction, and independent trajectory comparisons required to validate correspondence with CARLA. Locations: Appendix A.7, lines 949–959, p. 18, and lines 983–1025, p. 19.

Reviewer_hK5SOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
3
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary
  1. This paper proposes DRL Plus, a policy-learning framework that avoids Bellman-based value estimation and experience replay. A calculator predicts the next vehicle position, evaluates its compatibility with a predefined safety zone, and provides geometric losses for policy updates.
  2. A verification module accepts actions or triggers further optimization. A finite-state machine selects losses for following, overtaking, and returning to the original lane.
  3. The authors report 100% success across 1,500 CARLA episodes and present PRISM model-checking results, comparing against DDPG, SAC, CPO, and PPO-Lagrangian.
Critical strengths
  1. Explicit incorporation of safety checks. The architecture makes action validation a distinct component and uses spatial regions to express acceptable motion. This structure is interpretable and could be useful when reliable dynamics and geometric constraints are available.
  2. Encouraging task-specific results. The reported completion rates suggest that the integrated system can handle the evaluated following–overtaking–return sequence. The inclusion of constrained RL baselines, randomized speeds and distances, and formal property specifications provides useful starting material for further validation.
  3. Departure from standard RL paradigms. The framework completely eliminates the reliance on Bellman-based value updates and experience replay buffers. By doing so, it offers a novel perspective on avoiding the inherent instability and sample inefficiency often associated with conventional off-policy DRL methods.
Critical weaknesses
  1. The central learning contribution is insufficiently established. Although the paper claims to eliminate handcrafted rewards, Appendix A.6 introduces manually specified stage-dependent geometric losses and a finite-state machine. The task objective is therefore still substantially encoded by design. More importantly, the paper does not derive how these local updates optimize the terminal objective in Equation 7. Without comparisons against direct constrained optimization or controllers using the same calculator and verification mechanism, the contribution of policy learning remains unclear.
  2. The claimed safety guarantees are conditional on unverified assumptions. Equations 8–10 establish safety only after assuming that selected actions preserve the safe set with probability one. The paper does not prove this property for its approximate next-position calculator, establish continued action feasibility, or address prediction error and optimization deadlines. Likewise, Table 5 lacks sufficient detail about the PRISM abstractions and their correspondence to CARLA. The formal results therefore do not establish the claimed safety guarantees for the implemented system.
Questions for authors
  1. Please provide the complete stage-specific losses, zone-generation rules, and verification conditions. What establishes that minimizing these losses improves the terminal success objective rather than only satisfying local geometric targets?
  2. Under what dynamics-error bounds does the calculator guarantee safe-set invariance? What happens when no verified action is found within the control deadline? Please also explain how the PRISM transitions are constructed and validated against CARLA.
  3. Can the authors compare against direct constrained optimization and RL baselines equipped with the same calculator and verifier? Please report component ablations, per-seed held-out performance, and per-action optimization latency to distinguish learning benefits from supplied task structure and additional computation.
1 comment
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Shared geometric objective, safety assumptions, and PRISM interpretation

We thank the reviewer for identifying ambiguities in the learning objective and safety interpretation. We have revised the objective description and clarified the scope of the analytical and model-checking arguments.

  1. Critical Weakness 1 and Question 1: Correction of the phase-specific loss description.

The original description of separate FOLLOW, OVERTAKE, and RETURN losses was inaccurate and has been removed. Section 3.1 now defines a shared geometric loss measuring the distance between the predicted next position and the zone reference point. The local optimization objective combines this geometric loss with the implemented regularization terms. Maneuver phases determine the admissible zone and reference point rather than separate loss functions. Gradients propagate through the differentiable calculator to the policy parameters, with gradient clipping.

Locations: Section 3.1, equations (6)-(7), lines 250-258, p. 5, and lines 270-274, p. 6; Appendix A.2, lines 754-755, p. 14.

  1. Critical Weakness 1 and Question 1: Local objective versus terminal performance. Equation (2) defines the complete controller's probability of successful completion within the episode horizon, while equation (7) defines the local optimization objective. The revision explicitly states that minimizing the local objective does not, by itself, establish increased terminal success probability. The evaluation consequently reports intermediate-stage completion, overall success, and safety outcomes for the complete controller. This separates the optimization signal from the performance measure. Locations: Section 3, equation (2), lines 204–212, p. 4; Section 3.1, lines 270–274, p. 6; Table 1 and equation (9), p. 7; Tables 2–3, p. 8.

  2. Critical Weakness 2 and Question 2: Safety assumptions and fallback behavior. The revised analysis explicitly states the uncertainty coverage and safe-set containment conditions underlying the conditional invariance argument and discusses bounded position error. Figure 2 and Section 3.1 clarify that the counter and candidate cache are reset at each control step, only verified candidates are retained, and the lowest-loss feasible candidate is selected. If none is available when refinement ends, the architecture selects a scenario-dependent fallback. The text distinguishes an iteration budget from a wall-clock deadline. Locations: Section 3, equations (3)–(5) and lines 213–246, pp. 4–5; Figure 2, p. 4; Section 3.1, lines 266–269, p. 5; Section 4.1, lines 306–312, p. 6.

  3. Critical Weakness 2 and Question 2: PRISM interpretation. Appendix A.7 now distinguishes abstract-model properties from deployed-controller behavior. It explains why controller decisions must be resolved in the abstraction and distinguishes DTMC probability queries from minimum/maximum queries over unresolved MDP strategies. It documents the supplied CPO abstraction's collision and unsafe-distance conditions and identifies the additional state information needed for overtaking-success and lane-violation properties. It also specifies the abstraction mapping and independent trajectory comparisons required for interpreting correspondence with CARLA. These additions clarify the interpretation and validation requirements of the PRISM comparison. Locations: Appendix A.7, lines 938–988, pp. 18–19, and lines 990–1025, p. 19.

Reviewer_H13hOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
2
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
1
Read review
Paper summary

This paper proposes DRL Plus, a replay-free and non-Bellman policy-learning framework that replaces conventional reward-based learning with geometric safety zones and online optimization. The method predicts the consequences of candidate actions and optimizes the policy until predefined safety conditions are satisfied. Experiments in CARLA report a 100% success rate in a driving scenario involving following, overtaking, and returning, outperforming several DRL and safe RL baselines. The paper also presents a theoretical analysis and PRISM-based verification.

Critical strengths
  1. Representing task objectives through geometric safety zones offers an interpretable alternative to complex reward engineering, particularly for autonomous driving.

  2. The paper compares the proposed method with several DRL and safe RL baselines and additionally attempts formal verification using PRISM.

Critical weaknesses
  1. The proposed framework relies on a predefined dynamics model, manually designed safety zones, and online optimization. This resembles existing model-based planning and constrained optimization approaches. The distinction from MPC and safety-filtering methods is insufficiently established. Furthermore, replacing reward functions with task-specific losses and geometric constraints does not necessarily eliminate manual objective design.

  2. The safety guarantee depends on an invariance assumption that is not demonstrated for the actual system. The experimental evaluation is limited to a single driving scenario, and comparisons with model-free RL baselines may not adequately isolate the benefits of the proposed method. The absence of MPC or planning-based baselines, together with limited computational cost analysis, makes it difficult to assess the significance of the reported performance improvements.

Questions for authors
  1. How does DRL Plus fundamentally differ from existing model-based planning or constrained optimization methods? Is the policy optimized at every step during deployment?
  2. How is the safety invariance assumption guaranteed when the prediction model is imperfect?
  3. How are the safety zones constructed, and do the baselines have access to equivalent information?
  4. What is the computational cost per decision, and how does the method compare with MPC or conventional planning approaches?
1 comment
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Clarified formulation, conditional safety, and expanded evaluation

We thank the reviewer for the constructive comments. The revision clarifies the optimization mechanism and safety assumptions and expands the experimental comparison.

  1. Critical Weakness 1 and Question 1: Optimization mechanism and deployment. Section 3.1 clarifies that DRL Plus optimizes policy-network parameters, changing the mapping from observations to candidate controls. Direct action optimization instead adjusts the controls themselves. Both formulations can use predictive dynamics and geometric constraints. Figure 2 now shows online candidate refinement before action execution, including verification, feasible-candidate retention, and fallback selection. The shared geometric objective is maintained across maneuver phases; the phases determine the zone and reference point. This makes the supplied scenario structure explicit. Locations: Section 3, Figure 2 and lines 180–193, p. 4; Section 3.1, lines 250–274, pp. 5–6.

  2. Critical Weakness 2: Additional scenario and MPC baseline. We added MPC to the overtaking comparison and introduced a U-turn scenario with DRL Plus, DDPG, SAC, CPO, PPO-Lagrangian, and MPC. Tables 2–3 report 1,500 episodes per algorithm in each scenario, aggregated across 25 random seeds. DRL Plus and MPC both achieve 100% overall overtaking success. For U-turns, DRL Plus achieves 100% observed success, compared with 6.80% for the evaluated MPC configuration. The U-turn table additionally reports collision, stalled-episode, and off-road rates. Locations: Section 4.1, lines 282–295 and 313–322, p. 6; lines 362–375, p. 7; Tables 2–3, p. 8; U-turn configurations in Table 12, p. 18.

  3. Critical Weakness 2 and Question 2: Conditional safety formulation. The revised analysis introduces a successor-state uncertainty set with a coverage condition and defines certified actions through containment within the designated safe set. An induction argument establishes finite-horizon invariance under the stated coverage, feasibility, and action-selection conditions. The position-error discussion explains why nominal point containment is insufficient near a zone boundary and distinguishes position containment from collision avoidance, which also depends on vehicle footprint, traffic, and intervening motion. Locations: Section 3, equations (3)–(5), lines 213–246, pp. 4–5.

  4. Question 3: Zone construction and controller inputs. Equation (1) defines zone generation using the current observation and relevant road, traffic, and maneuver information. The controller regenerates the zone after each action using the newly observed state. Table 11 documents the overtaking inputs: 13 common features for the learning-based controllers, with two additional waypoint coordinates supplied to CPO and PPO-Lagrangian. Locations: Section 3, equation (1), lines 186–202, p. 4; Section 3.1, lines 270–274, p. 6; Table 11 and lines 880–884, p. 17.

From OpenReview, CC BY 4.0. Authors as signed there; shown unedited.

Related papers

Loading the map…

Discussion (0)

Sign in to comment.