- Rating
- 3(+1)
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 1
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper studies the problem of steering an LLM to enable better task execution. That is, whether to steer a trajectory, where (at which step), and with which mechanism. By steering, the authors refer to the targeted modification of the agent's original trajectory which may lead to the changes in the agent's subsequent execution. Previous methods majorly use uncertainty to guide the steering of LLMs, while the authors claim that uncertainty is an imperfect guide since no single uncertainty signal reliably locates the step at which steering helps or tells which mechanism to use. The authors then propose a new metric called value of steering (VoS) to estimates how much steering is expected to change the final task score calculated by counting stepwise counterfactual steering outcomes of about 82,000 counterfactual steering outcomes on 1,864 trajectories (the authors call this collection of results as stepwise outcome table (SOT)), which measures if the steering could actually help with final results. Given this value, the authors claim that if 1) the best value across all steps is larger than a given threshold 2) the best value across all steps is larger than a quantile of the largest values of all of the successful training trajectories. (the two conditions may be combined to one if the authors set the first threshold theta to be equal as the second quantile theta_alpha). The authors train a module f_m to fit SOT and output the inferred value of steering, where the input to f_m is the features x_t, and x_t describes full trajectory (full trajectory τ, under the offline setting) or prefix (τ≤t, under the online setting). And f_m is fitted according to different steering mechanisms. The different mechanisms included in this paper include reflection, critic feedback, stronger-model assistance, and memory-based guidance. For the evaluations, the authors find out that their results have better performance compared with other uncertainty-based methods which adopt step-wise confidence, entropy, or perplexity (the baselines only decide where to trigger rather than being fully reproduced). The authors test their main method and always steer under the setting of only steering every trajectory once, i.e., only changing one step of trajectories rather than changing at every step while it's not clear how many times other baselines trigger per trajectory.
Critical strengths
This paper studies one important problem of when and how to intervene during the LLM agent's generation process to guide it to reflect on its generation. Compared with the per-step or per-token uncertainty mechanism to decide the right timing to improve reflection, the authors use a value that directly reflect the final execution results that takes the inspirations from reinforcement learning's value functions, which is somewhat novel.
Critical weaknesses
The method proposed in this paper, in its current form, is challenging to generalize and can hardly be considered practical. The model f_m is trained based on all the ground truth counterfactual sequences that can be listed, and VoS inherently gains more information and a direct relation to the final results compared to baselines. It is hard to consider the presented results as fair evaluations. The benefit of the baselines using per-step uncertainties is that they naturally fit better into online settings and generalize across tasks and mechanisms, but for the method proposed in this paper, although the authors use a separate module f_m to enable online settings, theoretically speaking, the method will have a large performance drop under out-of-distribution settings where f_m cannot predict whether a steering mechanism can actually help with the final results. Also, as stated in Appendix D, the baselines are not fully reproduced, so it's doubtful if the comparisons are fair enough.
Questions for authors
- In the paper, the always steer baseline trigger "at a step chosen on the training half", so when your main method is triggered in a certain trajectory, is the step chose the same as always steer?
- For the baselines, if they are not implemented in the full setting, how can they decide at which step and with what mechanism the steer should proceed? Also in the main results of Table 1, are the baselines also restricted to steer only once per trajectory?
- Since the task score marks it as successful or failed, why is task score S(τ) continuous rather than discrete?
5 comments
Official Rebuttal
W2. Fairness: f_m is trained on all ground-truth counterfactual sequences, so VoS gains more information and a direct relation to the final results than the baselines
VoS and the baselines are the same kind of method: all are uncertainty-based, and all use training data. At test time, VoS reads only the per-step uncertainty signals and the step index, as the baselines do (Section 2.4), online as well as offline.
The baselines are not training-free either: every one is fitted or calibrated on the same training half, with ground truth. Their thresholds and budgets are set on the outcomes of the training trajectories (Section 4.1, Appendix D), Barbi et al. and DS-MCM use task success, and DIAL learns a label of whether steering helps. In training, VoS adds only its target, the measured outcome of steering at each step of these same trajectories: counterfactual runs, not information of another kind.
This counterfactual supervision is our contribution. Prior methods decide when to steer from coarser targets: whether the agent will fail, or whether steering helps at all. SOT measures the outcome of steering itself: the change in the final score caused by steering at each step with each mechanism, on failed and successful trajectories alike. VoS learns exactly the quantity that the steering decision needs, and Section 3 shows why coarser targets fall short: predicting that a trajectory will fail does not tell at which step steering would help.
Measured outcomes are a better training target than prior labels (Table 2). With the same features and learner, prior targets reach 69.3 / 72.5 (failure label), 70.8 / 72.1 (DIAL's label), and 71.4 / 72.1 (Monte Carlo rollout values), against 73.4 / 73.6 for VoS (AppWorld, Gemma; offline / online).
VoS does not need exhaustive counterfactuals. A small set of training tasks suffices: on AppWorld with Gemma, 22 tasks (about 230 steered runs) already beat every baseline in Table 1 (see W1, and "W1 / Q1. Amount of SOT data needed" in our reply to Reviewer 8MwY).
W3. The baselines are not fully reproduced
A controlled comparison by design. We decompose steering an agent into three separate decisions: whether to steer, where, and with which mechanism. To compare methods on these decisions, Table 1 evaluates their decision rules in one interface rather than as full systems, since the gain of a whole pipeline cannot be attributed to any one decision. VoS is bound by the same constraints as the baselines: one message at one step, the same four mechanisms, and the same threshold calibration.
Only components outside these decisions are omitted (Appendix D): AUQ's uncertainty-aware memory acts as a prompt rather than a trigger, DIAL's optimizer needs the environment's scoring function (on AppWorld, the hidden unit tests), and Barbi et al.'s reset applies to multi-agent communication.
The setup does not favor VoS. With the same mechanism for all methods, VoS is best in 11 of 12 settings (Table 5); our monitor trained on the baselines' targets is worse (Table 2); and with up to five steering events, VoS is best at every number of events (Figure 6).
VoS also leads the full systems. We nevertheless ran AUQ and DIAL as full systems on Gemma. They improve on our re-implementations in 11 of the 12 cases, by up to 3.8 points, but VoS remains the best in all six settings: it leads full DIAL by 1.3 to 3.3 points and full AUQ by 3.5 to 9.7 points. The full systems add the components that Appendix D omits, whereas VoS is still bound by the constraints of Table 1; we report them for reference, and Table 1 remains the main comparison.
Benchmark metric in % on Gemma (offline / online):
| Method | AppWorld | ALFWorld | WebShop |
|---|---|---|---|
| AUQ, as in Table 1 | 68.1 / 69.2 | 74.7 / 74.9 | 67.1 / 67.7 |
| AUQ, full system | 69.1 / 70.1 | 75.5 / 76.5 | 67.4 / 68.4 |
| DIAL, as in Table 1 | 68.9 / 70.0 | 80.1 / 82.0 | 68.3 / 69.0 |
| DIAL, full system | 71.7 / 71.7 | 83.9 / 80.9 | 69.0 / 71.0 |
| VoS | 73.4 / 73.6 | 85.2 / 82.6 | 72.3 / 72.6 |
Revision. We will state this at the start of Appendix D and in the caption of Table 1, and add the results of the full systems to the appendix.
Official Rebuttal
Q1. Is the step chosen by VoS the same as the step of always steer?
No. Always steer "steers every trajectory once, at a step chosen on the training half" (Section 4.2): one fixed step index, the one with the highest mean score on the training trajectories, applied to every test trajectory. VoS decides per trajectory whether and where to steer, from its value estimates (Section 4.1). On trajectories that both steer, they choose the same step in only 14% of cases (23% offline, 5% online).
Q2. How do the baselines choose the step and the mechanism, and are they also limited to one steering event per trajectory?
Step: each baseline uses its own trigger; Appendix D states that "we re-implement the triggering rule of each method on SOT." Mechanism: AUQ uses reflection and ReDAct a stronger model, as in the originals; DIAL and Barbi et al. use memory-based guidance, since their own interventions do not apply here. Table 5 gives all methods memory-based guidance. One event: yes. Section 2.4 defines that "a steering policy π steers each trajectory at most once," and this holds for every policy in Table 1, VoS included. We also compare up to five steering events per trajectory in real runs, and VoS remains the best at every number of events (Figure 6).
Q3. Why is S(τ) continuous when trajectories are labelled as success or failure?
S(τ) ∈ [0, 1] covers all three benchmarks with one notation: WebShop's score is continuous, while AppWorld and ALFWorld are binary (S ∈ {0, 1}). A trajectory is successful when S = 1. We will state this in Section 2.1.
Presentation
To present our method more clearly, we restate it here in brief.
VoS is a steering monitor. For each trajectory, it decides whether to steer and at which step, from the per-step uncertainty signals and the step index alone, the same kind of input as the baselines. For every step, its value function f_m estimates the value of steering there (hence the name), that is, how much steering at that step would change the final task score.
Offline, VoS sees the completed trajectory, but not its score: if the highest estimate reaches a threshold θ_α, it rolls back to that step and steers there; otherwise it leaves the trajectory alone. Online, it steers at the first step whose estimate reaches θ_α. θ_α is the only threshold, and it is set on training trajectories so that at most a fraction α of the successful ones would be steered.
f_m is learned on training trajectories only: there, for each step separately, we steer the trajectory at that step with memory-based guidance, the mechanism that VoS uses, let the agent run to the end, and record the change in the final score. These measured changes form the stepwise outcome table (SOT) and are the regression target of f_m. At test time, VoS needs no counterfactual runs.
In Table 1, every method, the baselines included, steers each trajectory at most once and is fitted or calibrated on the same training half; with up to five steering events per trajectory, VoS remains the best at every number of events (Figure 6).
Official Rebuttal
Thank you for your careful reading and detailed comments. We answer them in three parts: W1 below, W2 and W3 in Part 2, and Q1 to Q3, followed by a brief restatement of our method, in Part 3.
We ran the experiments below. In short:
A single unified model works. One VoS model trained on all six settings together matches the six separate models in five of them (mean +8.8 / +6.5 against +8.7 / +6.9), because it learns from each setting's own data how uncertainty relates to the value of steering there. A separate model per setting is a choice of our evaluation, not a requirement of the method.
Gain over unmodified execution in points (offline / online):
Fitting VoS to a new setting needs few tasks. We also measured how much training data VoS needs, and a few hundred steered runs are enough (a steered run steers a trajectory at one step and runs the agent to the end). On AppWorld with Gemma, 22 training tasks (about 230 steered runs) already beat every baseline; on WebShop with Gemma, 75 training goals (about 390 steered runs) give +5.1 / +5.5, close to +5.6 / +5.9 with all 250. The full learning curves are in "W1 / Q1. Amount of SOT data needed" in our reply to Reviewer 8MwY.
Limited transfer stems largely from one of the main findings of the paper. Current uncertainty estimators were designed to detect output errors, not to steer multi-step agents, and we find that what they indicate changes across settings: which signal carries the value of steering depends on the benchmark and the agent (Section 4.3), and P(True) even detects failures in opposite directions on the two agents (Section 3.2). If the signals behaved the same everywhere, a fixed rule on one signal would suffice; VoS learns a monitor precisely because they do not, and for the same reason a model fitted to one setting may not carry over to another.
This is not specific to VoS: DIAL, the closest prior work, learns its gate per environment and backbone because the relation between token entropy and the value of intervening reverses across them (Li et al., 2026). As our conclusion notes, this calls for uncertainty quantification designed for steering multi-step agents.
Transfer costs the baselines as well. To test this, we trained each method on one setting and tested it on another: (i) on the other agent of the same benchmark, (ii) on another benchmark with the same agent. The baselines are also fitted or calibrated on each setting (Appendix D), and they lose roughly a third to a half of their gain on average.
VoS loses the smallest share in (i) offline and a relatively large share in (ii), but from a much larger gain: after transfer it still gains +7.6 / +4.2 in (i) and +5.2 / +3.8 in (ii), and offline this is more than any baseline gains when trained on the target setting itself (about +3 on average, Table 5). The gains of VoS in each setting, which transfer well on ALFWorld but little on AppWorld, are in "W1 / Q1. Generality: cross-setting transfer" in our reply to Reviewer 8MwY.
Change in gain as a share of the gain when trained on the same setting (offline / online), averaged over the six settings; all methods use memory-based guidance:
Revision. We will add these experiments and state the limits of transfer.
References