acceptodds
Under review as a conference paper at ICLR 2027

AdvG: A Provably Convergent Actor–Critic Algorithm for Reinforcement Learning in Continuous Time and Space

Abstract

Reinforcement learning in continuous time and state-action space poses a core challenge for today's RL research. Deterministic actor–critic methods offer a model-free approach by estimating how action changes affect expected return, while avoiding action-space integration in the policy update. For controlled diffusions with unknown dynamics, however, estimating these effects becomes difficult as shorter observation intervals reduce the signal-to-noise ratio. We propose AdvG, a novel deterministic policy gradient (DPG) algorithm using multi-step temporal difference error for value estimation while learning the advantage rate's action derivative from individual exploratory perturbations. By analyzing critic stability, we establish the first finite-sample joint actor and critic convergence guarantee in model-free DPG learning for nonlinear controlled diffusions. With exact critic features, we establish an joint convergence rate, with the expected total duration of collected RL trajectories. Furthermore, our algorithm inspires the construction of an actor gradient estimator with mean-squared error of order , achieving the minimax optimality over a family of diffusion models allowing nonlinear action effects.

Primary area:
reinforcement learning
Keywords:
Continuous-time reinforcement learning, actor--critic methods, deterministic policy gradients, finite-time convergence, minimax estimation.

Reviews

Among:
Shape:
1234this paper, Top 15%
Figure 1. Mean review rating of the reviewed papers at ICLR 2027. This paper averages 3.00 over 3 reviews, above 85% of the others.
Reviewer_MAnvOpenReview ↗
Rating
3
Confidence
2
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
3
Read review
Paper summary

The authors propose a novel deterministic policy gradient (DPG) algorithm called AdvG using multi-step temporal difference error for value estimation while learning the advantage rate’s action derivative from individual exploratory perturbations. By analyzing critic stability, the authors establish the first finite-sample joint actor and critic convergence guarantee in model-free DPG learning for nonlinear controlled diffusions.

Critical strengths
  1. The authors propose a novel algorithm and establish a finite-sample joint actor–critic convergence guarantee for model-free deterministic policy gradient learning in nonlinear controlled diffusion systems.

  2. The authors compare the proposed algorithm against established reinforcement learning methods, including SAC, TD3, and DDPG. This comparision helps in understanding the relative performance of the algorithm.

Critical weaknesses
  1. The experiments are performed on LQ control and noisy pendulum tasks. These are relatively simple environments and hence the experimental results may not provide any information on the effectiveness in complex, high-dimensional real-world applications.
Questions for authors

Please refer to the weakness section.

3 comments
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Official Response to Reviewer MAnv

We thank you for the positive assessment of the algorithm and convergence analysis.

W1: The experiments on LQ control and noisy Pendulum provide limited evidence for complex, high-dimensional real-world applications.

A1: To address this concern, we added experiments on higher-dimensional tasks including HalfCheetah and Hopper from Gymnasium, comparing AdvG with CT-DDPG at different observation intervals. The revised manuscript presents the learning curves in Appendix E.1.3, Figures 10-11, and the numerical results in Table 3.

The reward curves show that AdvG learns faster than CT-DDPG, and AdvG achieves higher final mean returns at both observation intervals on each task. The final returns are:

TaskhhAdvGCT-DDPG
HalfCheetah0.054,907 ± 3063,019 ± 980
HalfCheetah0.016,033 ± 1,5045,460 ± 1,455
Hopper0.0082,694 ± 732,153 ± 412
Hopper0.0022,367 ± 982,131 ± 205

These results extend the evidence for AdvG beyond LQ and noisy Pendulum to more complex, higher-dimensional simulated control.

the authors have addressed my concerns. I maintain my score

I thank the authors for addressing my concerns. I have decided to retain my score.

Reviewer_UxC4OpenReview ↗
Rating
3
Confidence
3
Informativeness
3
Presentation
3
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

this paper derives a provably convergent deterministic actor critic algorithm for continuous-time stochastic control.

Critical strengths

the algorithm makes a clever distinction between using multistep info to estimate values and matching individual action perturbations with their corresponding residuals to estimate action derivatives.

Critical weaknesses

the experiments are rather limited and uses neural critics while the theory relies on fixed critics, which doesn't fully close the theory to implementation gap

Questions for authors

does the advantage over the baselines remain when comparing computational time rather than physical interaction time, particularly at smaller observation intervals?

are improvements present on more challenging nonlinear systems beyond the noisy pendulum?

1 comment
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Official Response to Reviewer UxC4

We thank you for your thoughtful comments and suggestions. We have added experiments addressing the fixed-feature assumption in our convergence theorem and the computational cost, and have explored more challenging control tasks.

W1: The experiments use neural critics, while the convergence theory assumes fixed critic features.

A1: As a complement to the original experiments with critics parameterized by neural networks, we added two complementary experiments on linear critics with fixed features:

  • Exact features on scalar LQR (Appendix E.2, Figures 12-13). We added this experiment to test the convergence predicted by Theorem 4.2 using fixed-feature critics. The features represent the value function and advantage derivative exactly, so the theorem's feature-approximation term vanishes.

    We measure the theorem's actor stationarity and critic tracking errors, averaged over training iterations. Across 30 runs per budget, the mean joint error has a fitted log-log slope of -0.418 against total physical interaction time TT, close to the predicted -0.4. These results provide empirical support for the O(T−2/5)O(T^{-2/5}) joint convergence bound in the fixed-feature setting.

  • Fixed-feature critics on stochastic LQ (Appendix E.5, Figure 16 and Table 5). In this experiment, we apply AdvG to LQ with both critic networks using fixed polynomial features. Only 45 value coefficients and 30 advantage coefficients are learned. AdvG proves to be effective in this setting, with final returns of -4.05 ± 0.45 at h=0.02h=0.02 and -3.75 ± 0.21 at h=0.005h=0.005, which are close to the returns when we used neural networks to parameterize critics. This experiment provides evidence that fixed-feature critics can support useful policy learning.

W2: Does AdvG retain its advantage when computational time is compared, particularly at smaller observation intervals?

A2: We compare the training cost of AdvG with that of other baselines on stochastic LQ. Experiments show that AdvG achieves higher final returns at comparable training cost (Appendix E.4, Figure 15 and Table 4). We measured total collection plus learning time; at the finest interval, h=0.001h=0.001, the results are:

MethodTraining time (minutes)Final return
AdvG14.67 ± 0.48-3.18 ± 0.10
CT-DDPG14.82 ± 0.25-4.64 ± 1.38
DDPG11.59 ± 0.73-170.50 ± 61.94
TD312.16 ± 0.13-146.85 ± 66.08
SAC15.97 ± 0.64-261.26 ± 69.30

Entries are means ± sample standard deviations across five training seeds. AdvG and CT-DDPG differ in training time by at most 1.1% across all four observation intervals. DDPG and TD3 finish sooner but have substantially lower final returns in this comparison. Thus, the return improvement comes at comparable computational cost.

W3: Do the improvements extend to more challenging nonlinear systems beyond noisy Pendulum?

A3: To extend the scope of our experiments, we compared AdvG with CT-DDPG on Gym tasks including HalfCheetah and Hopper. Both methods are shown to substantially improve their policies: CT-DDPG establishes a strong baseline, whereas AdvG achieves higher mean returns at both tested observation intervals on each task (Appendix E.1.3, Figures 10-11 and Table 3). These experiments demonstrate that AdvG can perform well in more complicated nonlinear control tasks.

Reviewer_sy3YOpenReview ↗
Rating
3(+1)
Confidence
2
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
3(+1)
Read review
Paper summary

This paper introduces AdvG, a continuous-time Actor-Critic algorithm designed for reinforcement learning under SDE dynamics as the observation interval h→0h \to 0. To address variance explosion in continuous-time limits, AdvG employs a Cell-Pairing mechanism that separates value estimation from advantage gradient learning: it accumulates TD residuals over a multi-step physical time window δ=Lh\delta = Lh for the critic, while pairing each exploration perturbation UiU_i strictly with its corresponding cell-wise TD residual DiD_i to estimate advantage gradients. The authors present a theoretical convergence analysis for single-timescale updates (O(T−2/5)O(T^{-2/5})), derive an information-theoretic minimax lower bound (Ω(T−2/3)\Omega(T^{-2/3})), and evaluate the algorithm on low-dimensional continuous control tasks (Linear-Quadratic control and Pendulum).

Critical strengths
  1. Novel Cell-Pairing Mechanism for Continuous-Time Limits: The proposed Cell-Pairing technique effectively decouples value estimation (accumulated over a physical time window δ=Lh\delta = Lh) from advantage gradient estimation (paired locally within each cell ii). This elegant design prevents cross-time noise interference and mitigates variance explosion as h→0h \to 0.

  2. Rigorous Single-Timescale Convergence Proof: The theoretical analysis demonstrates that the Expected ODE's Jacobian has a block lower-triangular structure (one-way coupling from value error to advantage gradient). This guarantees Critic stability and establishes a finite-sample convergence rate of O(T−2/5)O(T^{-2/5}) under simultaneous, single-timescale Actor-Critic updates without relying on restrictive two-timescale assumptions.

  3. Information-Theoretic Minimax Optimality: The paper establishes an information-theoretic minimax lower bound of Ω(T−2/3)\Omega(T^{-2/3}) for advantage gradient estimation in continuous-time SDEs and proves that a tuned variant of AdvG achieves this tight upper bound, confirming its theoretical optimality.

Critical weaknesses
  1. Exaggerated Claims Regarding Baseline Performance Degradation: The paper emphasizes that baseline methods (such as CT-DDPG) suffer severe performance degradation under small step sizes (h→0h \to 0). However, Figure 3 shows that while CT-DDPG experiences a transient performance drop during early training, it quickly recovers and reaches practically the same asymptotic return as AdvG under both h=0.02h = 0.02 and h=0.005h = 0.005.

  2. Missing Empirical Verification for Core Theoretical Claims: While the paper highlights the O(T−2/5)O(T^{-2/5}) theoretical convergence rate (Theorem 4.2) and the Cell-Pairing mechanism, it lacks direct empirical validation. Specifically, there are no log-log plots (log⁡(T)\log(T) vs. log⁡(Error)\log(\text{Error})) to verify the theoretical slope of −2/5-2/5, nor are there isolated ablation plots measuring gradient variance with and without Cell-Pairing.

  3. Inadequate Parameter Sweeps and Limited Task Scope: The empirical evaluation of time-discretization robustness (h→0h \to 0) is restricted to only two step sizes (h=0.02h = 0.02 and h=0.005h = 0.005), which is insufficient to demonstrate a continuous scaling trend. Furthermore, the experiments are confined to low-dimensional synthetic environments (LQ control and Pendulum), leaving the algorithm's scalability to high-dimensional control or Deep RL setups unverified.

Questions for authors
  1. Interpretation of CT-DDPG's Recovery in the LQ Control Task: In the LQ control task (Figures 3), CT-DDPG experiences a transient drop in performance during early training under both h=0.02h = 0.02 and h=0.005h = 0.005, but eventually recovers and achieves practically the same asymptotic return as AdvG. How do the authors reconcile this empirical recovery with the claim that baseline methods suffer severe degradation or failure as h→0h \to 0?

  2. Empirical Verification of O(T−2/5)O(T^{-2/5}) Convergence and Cell-Pairing Ablation: To directly support Theorem 4.2 and validate the Cell-Pairing mechanism, could the authors provide: (a) A log-log plot (log⁡(T)\log(T) vs. log⁡(Error)\log(\text{Error}) or log⁡(∥∇J∥2)\log(\Vert{}\nabla J\Vert{}^2)) showing that the empirical convergence slope aligns with O(T−2/5)O(T^{-2/5})? (b) An isolated ablation plot comparing the gradient variance of AdvG with and without Cell-Pairing under identical network/hyperparameter settings?

3.Broader Step-Size (hh) Sweeps and Practical Implementation: To demonstrate continuous robustness under time-discretization (h→0h \to 0), could the authors provide a broader sweep of hh across multiple orders of magnitude (e.g., h∈{0.1,0.01,0.001,0.0001}h \in \{0.1, 0.01, 0.001, 0.0001\})? Additionally, how sensitive are the hyperparameters (such as window size LL and weight χ\chi) when scaling AdvG to higher-dimensional tasks?

3 comments
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Official Response to Reviewer sy3Y [1/2]

We thank you for the careful review and constructive suggestions. We have clarified the comparison with CT-DDPG and expanded the experiments to address your questions about convergence, cell pairing, observation intervals, and task complexity.

W1: CT-DDPG recovers on LQ control, raising concerns about the claim of severe degradation at small observation intervals.

A1: We agree that CT-DDPG recovers and learns effective policies, as CT-DDPG is itself designed for continuous-time RL. The sharp deterioration we discussed concerns the discrete-time baselines DDPG, TD3, and SAC as the observation interval hh decreases.

Our comparison with CT-DDPG asks whether cell pairing improves advantage-derivative estimation and policy performance. The variance comparisons described in 2(b) show a reduction in variance, and the expanded LQ experiments show higher mean final returns for AdvG at all four tested values of hh under the same training budget (Appendix E.1.1, Table 1). This evidence supports the conclusion that cell-pairing contributes to effective learning of a good policy.

W2(a): The predicted T−2/5T^{-2/5} convergence rate in Theorem 4.2 lacks direct empirical validation.

A2(a): To examine the convergence rate in Theorem 4.2, we added log-log plots on scalar stochastic LQR, where fixed features represent the value function and advantage derivative exactly. As Proposition B.9 shows, all assumptions of Theorem 4.2 are satisfied in this setting.

We apply the parameter scaling prescribed by the analysis, and measure the average actor stationarity and critic tracking errors (Appendix E.2, Figures 12-13). Across 30 runs per budget, the fitted slope of their sum is -0.418, close to the predicted slope of -0.4. These results provide empirical support for the T−2/5T^{-2/5} error scaling rate in Theorem 4.2.

W2(b): The effect of cell pairing should be isolated by comparing update variance in ablation studies with identical networks and hyperparameters.

A2(b): Appendix C.4 of the submitted manuscript examines how cell pairing affects advantage-derivative estimation. With both critics fitted to the same trajectory data, AdvG reduces the variance of the fitted advantage-derivative coefficient by a factor of 37.1 at L=64L=64 relative to the full-window estimator.

For an isolated ablation under identical networks and hyperparameters, we added a comparison that freezes the actor and both neural critics and applies the two update rules to identical trajectory minibatches (Appendix E.3, Figure 14). This measures the variance of individual advantage-critic updates. Our results show that the full-window update has 17.3 times the variance of the cell-pairing update at h=0.02h=0.02, rising to 560 times at h=0.0025h=0.0025.

W3: The observation-interval sweep is relatively narrow, and evaluation is limited to low-dimensional tasks.

A3: To examine performance over a wider range of observation intervals, we expanded both the LQ and Pendulum comparisons to h=0.1,0.02,0.005,0.001h=0.1,0.02,0.005,0.001, spanning two orders of magnitude (Appendices E.1.1-E.1.2, Tables 1-2). The physical training budget is fixed across intervals within each task. Final discounted returns are:

hhLQ: AdvGLQ: CT-DDPGPendulum: AdvGPendulum: CT-DDPG
0.1-3.32 ± 0.06-3.39 ± 0.14-9.93 ± 1.34-12.62 ± 5.45
0.02-3.09 ± 0.07-3.39 ± 0.35-7.13 ± 0.14-14.21 ± 1.13
0.005-3.06 ± 0.12-3.94 ± 0.37-7.84 ± 0.53-14.85 ± 0.46
0.001-3.18 ± 0.10-4.64 ± 1.38-10.11 ± 4.33-14.83 ± 1.36

The appendix tables also report performances of DDPG, TD3, and SAC.

On LQ, AdvG maintains similar performance across the full range, with mean returns between -3.32 and -3.06. It achieves the highest mean return among all five methods at every tested interval, with a larger advantage over CT-DDPG at the finer intervals.

On Pendulum, AdvG achieves substantially higher mean returns than all four baselines at the three finer intervals. At h=0.1h=0.1, it remains close to the best-performing baseline, DDPG.

To extend the scope of our experiments, we compared AdvG with CT-DDPG on Gym tasks including HalfCheetah and Hopper (Appendix E.1.3, Figures 10-11 and Table 3). The learning curves show substantial policy improvement for both methods: AdvG learns effective policies and achieves higher final mean returns at both tested intervals on each task, while CT-DDPG provides a strong continuous-time baseline.

AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Official Response to Reviewer sy3Y [2/2]

W4: How sensitive is AdvG to the window size LL and weight χ\chi?

A4: We carried out separate experiments to test the sensitivity of AdvG to hyperparameters including LL and χ\chi (Appendix E.6, Tables 6-7 and Figure 17). On noisy Pendulum, we compared fixed L∈{2,10,50}L\in\{2,10,50\} with lengths sampled uniformly from 1 to each maximum. Fixing LL at 10 gave the highest mean return (-7.77 ± 0.86), while shorter windows gave lower returns, and fixing L=50L=50 performed poorly. Uniform sampling with maximum lengths of 10 and 50 gave similar mean returns, with more variation across seeds than fixed L=10L=10. These results support choosing a moderate physical window in this setting and show that effective learning does not require randomizing the number of cells in each window.

We also tested χ∈{0.125,0.25,0.5,1}\chi\in\{0.125,0.25,0.5,1\} on scalar LQR with fixed critic features. Mean final returns varied little across different values of χ\chi, which provides evidence that the performance of AdvG is not sensitive to the parameter χ\chi.

I’m grateful that the authors carried out additional experiments and analyses and answered my questions clearly and directly. The additional results and the authors’ responses are overall reasonable and satisfactory. Accordingly, I will raise the score from 2 to 3.

Comments on the paper

1 comment

As the discussion period is approaching its end, please take a moment to review the authors’ responses and share any remaining thoughts or updates to your assessment. Thanks for your thoughtful reviews and discussion!

From OpenReview, CC BY 4.0. Authors as signed there; shown unedited.

Related papers

Loading the map…

Discussion (0)

Sign in to comment.