- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes Partial Policy Gradients (PPG), a framework for controlling the temporal scope of credit assignment in reinforcement learning for multi-turn LLM interactions. Instead of attributing the full trajectory reward to each action, PPG updates the policy using a selected subset of future rewards. The framework encompasses full policy gradients, greedy policy gradients, and K-step lookahead policy gradients. The authors provide a theoretical analysis of gradient concentration and empirically evaluate the approach on persona-consistent dialogue generation and agentic tool-calling tasks. The results suggest that intermediate lookahead horizons can improve performance over full policy gradients and greedy approaches, while reducing gradient estimation variance.
Critical strengths
- A unified framework for temporal credit assignment. The paper presents a coherent formulation that unifies full, greedy, and K-step policy gradients by varying the subset of future rewards assigned to each action. The theoretical concentration analysis provides a useful perspective on the trade-off between statistical efficiency and the scope of credit assignment.
- Promising empirical results supported by variance measurements. The experiments cover multiple conversational domains and two LLM architectures. The authors evaluate both rollout-level and step-level consistency and provide direct measurements of gradient variance across different lookahead horizons. The results demonstrate that intermediate horizons can substantially outperform full policy gradients in several settings.
Critical weaknesses
- Limited methodological novelty and insufficient comparison with closely related approaches. The central idea of restricting the temporal scope of reward attribution is closely related to existing work on multi-step returns and temporal credit assignment. In particular, Segment Policy Optimization (SPO) has already explored segment-level credit assignment for LLM reinforcement learning. Although PPG provides a more general formulation and introduces overlapping K-step reward windows, the empirical evaluation does not include a direct comparison with SPO or other closely related temporal credit assignment methods. This makes it difficult to determine whether the proposed formulation offers substantial advantages beyond existing approaches.
- Insufficient evidence for the proposed bias–variance trade-off and its generalizability. The paper attributes much of the performance improvement to reduced gradient variance, but the empirical variance analysis is conducted at a single training checkpoint. Since changing K also changes the optimization objective, improved downstream performance cannot be conclusively attributed to variance reduction alone. Furthermore, the main experiments focus on tasks with decomposable per-step consistency rewards and use only one random seed. The K-step trade-off is evaluated primarily in offline training, while PPO is trained online, limiting the fairness of that comparison. Additional evaluations on tasks involving delayed or sparse rewards would strengthen the claim that the proposed approach generalizes to broader long-horizon agent settings.
Questions for authors
- How does K-Step-PG compare with Segment Policy Optimization and other temporal credit assignment methods under matched models, datasets, and training budgets?
- Can the authors provide additional experiments isolating the effects of gradient variance reduction from the changes in the optimization objective introduced by varying K? For example, measurements across multiple training checkpoints would be informative.
- How does PPG perform when early actions strongly influence rewards appearing many steps later, particularly in tasks with delayed or sparse rewards? Would the optimal K differ substantially in these settings?
- Can the authors provide multi-seed evaluations and a more controlled comparison between online and offline policy optimization?
2 comments
3. Generalization to delayed and sparse rewards
We agree that environments with sparse or delayed rewards are an important setting for evaluating temporal credit assignment. Our current benchmarks provide dense, decomposable per-turn prompt-consistency rewards, and we do not claim that their results directly establish performance under arbitrary delayed terminal rewards. If an action has an important consequence that is observed only many turns later, a hard K-step window shorter than that delay may exclude the relevant future reward from the action's direct training signal. In such environments, longer-horizon policies or different attribution mechanisms may be preferable, despite the statistical-efficiency advantages associated with shorter reward windows. This is consistent with our empirical observation that the best tested horizon depends on the application.
In the original experiments, 3-Step-PG performs best on Therapy rollout consistency, whereas 5-Step-PG performs best on agentic tool-calling rollout consistency. Full PG is also preferable in some additional settings, including the Education domain in Table 7. These findings support task-dependent horizon selection. However, they are not substitutes for a controlled sparse-reward or delayed-outcome benchmark. We will clarify this boundary in Section 5.2 and the limitations section, and identify delayed-reward evaluation as an important extension.
4. Independent seeds and controlled online/offline comparisons
We agree that additional independent-seed experiments would strengthen reproducibility, particularly for small performance differences. Our original experiments use fixed seed 123. As documented in the paper, the complete training and evaluation pipeline was repeated three times with the same seed to characterize execution nondeterminism. A comprehensive independent-seed sweep spanning two 8B-parameter models, multiple domains, and all credit-assignment horizons was not feasible within the available resources.
We also agree that PPO is not a fully controlled comparator because the PPO baseline is trained online, while our PG-family experiments use offline training. However, our central controlled comparison is among GreedyPG, K-Step-PG, and Full PG, which share the same logged trajectories, reward labels, backbone, optimizer, training budget, and evaluation protocol. PPO is included as an external reference rather than a regime-matched baseline. We will clarify the distinction between controlled within-family comparisons and external PPO results in Sections 5.1–5.2.
We thank the reviewer for the constructive assessment and for recognizing the value of the unified temporal credit-assignment framework, the concentration analysis, and the empirical improvements across conversational domains and model architectures.
1. Comparison with Segment Policy Optimization and related methods
We agree that Segment Policy Optimization (SPO; Guo et al., 2025) is closely related to our work and warrants a precise comparison.
Our manuscript already discusses segment-based policy optimization in Section 6 and presents a segment-policy instantiation of the reward-subset framework in Appendix A.5. However, we agree that formal representability is not equivalent to a controlled empirical comparison. There is an important distinction in the structure of temporal credit assignment. In segment-based attribution, rewards are assigned to actions within a designated segment, with the partition boundaries determining which rewards contribute to each action. In contrast, K-Step-PG uses overlapping, sliding reward windows, where each action receives credit from up to K subsequent rewards, independently of a predefined segmentation. For example, adjacent actions can share several future rewards under K-Step-PG, whereas a fixed-segment policy changes its attribution pattern at segment boundaries.
Furthermore, the full SPO training procedure involves optimization and segmentation choices beyond selecting a reward-dependency set. Our conversational trajectories do not provide a canonical semantic partition. Consequently, a matched SPO comparison would require introducing and controlling an additional segmentation procedure, while also aligning the optimizer, training data, and experimental budget.
2. Separating gradient variance reduction from changes in the optimization objective
We agree that modifying K changes both the temporal scope of the optimization objective and the corresponding stochastic gradient estimator. Consequently, improved downstream performance cannot be attributed exclusively to variance reduction. Our framework studies precisely this trade-off: restricting future-reward dependencies may yield statistically easier-to-estimate gradients, while potentially sacrificing useful longer-range dependencies. Theorem 4 characterizes the associated worst-case concentration behavior under stated assumptions. It does not establish that every shorter-horizon policy is superior or that the measured performance gains are caused solely by lower variance.
To strengthen the empirical evidence, we extended the gradient-variance measurements to multiple checkpoints. Using Qwen3-8B on Therapy, we evaluated steps 100, 250, and 400 following the existing Appendix D.7 variance-estimation protocol.
At every checkpoint, the measured variance increases with the temporal attribution horizon. These results extend the original Table 6 finding beyond a single training checkpoint and demonstrate that the empirical variance–horizon relationship persists across the evaluated training stages. However, because the analysis uses checkpoints from the respective trained policies, it does not isolate the attribution horizon while holding model parameters fixed. We therefore view the new results as evidence of a persistent empirical association, rather than definitive causal identification of the source of downstream improvements. We will add this analysis to Appendix D.1, clarify the protocol in Appendix D.7, and revise Section 5.2 to distinguish the concentration mechanism from the effects of optimizing different reward objectives.