- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 1
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
The paper discussed an approach to mitigate the foundational problem of long-term neural decoder representation drift in time in settings of limited labeled data. The authors proposed using the decoders' predictions as pseudo-labels.
Theoretically, they show that in the case of ridge decoders, the update is a data-dependent spectral shrinkage operator, which explains why lower-variance modes decay faster. In general, they claim that self-generated targets (pseudo-labels) cannot introduce new information about the underlying intent beyond what is already contained in the current neural activity and decoder.
Empirically, they validated their method on simulated drift and on 44 chronic sessions from four subjects. Their results showed that self-training can improve the benchmark variance-weighted R^2 by 0.087 compared to a frozen decoder.
Critical strengths
- The empirical evaluation seems extensive, with several baselines and controls. In addition, I find the non linear encoders part nesecery as an ablation.
Critical weaknesses
-
The theoretical part is weak. The propositions are extremely simple or common known equations; Proposition 1 is literally the normal equations, Propositions 2-3 are the spectral decomposition of the ridge operator, and Proposition 4 basically says that if you do not add any new information about the target, you cannot magically get new information about the target, which is trivial.
-
The method itself seems like an obvious thing to do when you don't have labels in sequence prediction over time; using your current predictions as pseudo-labels is probably one of the first baselines someone would try. which is not a contribution.
-
The paper is written poorly. It assumes prior knowledge from the reader about neural decoding/BCI and does not give enough introduction to the domain before jumping into the specific setup and notation. Because of that, I found the paper harder to follow than it should be.
Questions for authors
See weaknesses.
4 comments
Thank you for the rebuttal, yet my concerns remain valid, so I will keep my score.
Thank you for replying. For clarity in the discussion record, we note that a central point of the initial review rested on a factual misunderstanding of what the paper proposes, and that the remaining two concerns were addressed directly in the revision:
-
Factual premise (Summary and Weakness 2): The review states that we "proposed using the decoders' predictions as pseudo-labels" and objects that this baseline is "not a contribution". We do not propose self-training. We analyse and critique it because the iBCI literature actively recommends it for chronic decoding (Sec. 1: Li et al., 2011; Wilson et al., 2025; Wei et al., 2026).
-
Drift theory and BCI background (Weaknesses 1 and 3): Beyond condensing the static recursion into Proposition 1, the revision adds Theorem 2 (Sec. 3.2) for target-mapping drift (predicting session ΔR² on FALCON at r = 0.996, 44/44 signs) and Proposition 3 (Sec. 3.3) for general model classes, alongside a new Setting section (Sec. 2, Fig. 1) introducing iBCI decoding before any notation.
Could you let us know which specific technical concern remains after these changes?
Although the revision addresses some of my concerns, I remain unconvinced that the theoretical and empirical contributions together are sufficiently substantial for ICLR. Therefore, I will maintain my original score.
Response to Reviewer EzyG
We thank the reviewer for finding the empirical evaluation extensive and the nonlinear decoders a necessary ablation.
What the paper studies. The paper analyses self-training rather than proposing it. It studies this procedure because the iBCI literature uses and recommends it for long-term decoders, and because it is the standard label-free baseline in machine learning.
The revised introduction documents this in its second paragraph (Sec. 1). Li et al. (2011, Neural Computation) introduced Bayesian regression self-training, which "uses the decoder's output to periodically update its neuronal tuning model", and reported closed-loop control over 29 days. Wilson et al. (2025, Nature Biomedical Engineering) conclude that "self-training strategies demonstrate strong potential for long-term BCI stability". Wei et al. (2026) fine-tune iBCI decoders on their own pseudo-labels, including on FALCON. The FALCON documentation (App. A.2) states that "models that demonstrate gains in the FALCON metrics will certainly show improved predictions".
Against this background the paper makes three points. These gains can come entirely from attenuation: the frozen decoder turned down to self-training's gain scores higher R² with no loss of correlation, in all four subjects (permutation p < 10⁻⁴; Sec. 5.2, Table 2). The mechanism is exact (Theorem 2). The regularisation that pseudo-labels provide is better written as an explicit prior. On matched label budgets the prior improves labels-only recalibration at every budget from 1% to 100% in every subject, and with 2.5% of each session labelled it reaches an R² that labels-only fitting needs 2.8–8.9× as many labels to match (Sec. 5.5, Fig. 4).
Theory. The theory section is now organised around two results for the drift setting. The ridge spectral recursion is stated once as Proposition 1 and credited as the linear case of the self-distillation analysis of Mobahi, Farajtabar & Bartlett (2020) (Sec. 3.1).
Theorem 2 (new, Sec. 3.2) gives the exact change in squared error and in behavioural correlation after any number of self-training steps when the neural-to-behaviour mapping drifts, mode by mode. A mode gains from self-training if and only if the fraction of its calibrated weight that is still correct falls below (1+A)/2, where A is the filter's retention. Correlation falls when the filter removes modes that carry more behavioural covariance per unit output power than the rest. In expectation under a drift model, the condition combines drift persistence, calibration reliability and ridge shrinkage. The theorem is confirmed in simulation (r = 0.999 between closed form and simulation over 1440 (condition, session) pairs) and on every FALCON session (r = 0.996, correct sign in 44/44 sessions; Sec. 5.1, 5.3).
Proposition 3 (Sec. 3.3) holds for any label-free update and any model class. The expected change in risk equals ∥fk+1−mˉk∥2−∥fk−mˉk∥2, where mˉk is the posterior-mean regression function given the unlabelled data. The identity gives the exact condition under which label-free updates help: the unlabelled data must carry information about the change of mapping, as in gradual domain adaptation (Kumar et al., 2020) or input alignment. When they carry none, the update costs exactly the output energy it removes.
Accessibility for ML readers. A new Setting section (Sec. 2) explains what an intracortical decoder maps (binned spike counts to intended movement), calibration and chronic sessions, and what drift means here (both p(x) and p(z|x) change). It also explains open-loop evaluation and why R² and the scale-invariant correlation ρ can disagree. Figure 1 shows the three sources of information a recalibration can use. The protocol section states the scoring timeline and label budget explicitly (Sec. 4), and every symbol is defined before use.
We hope the revision makes clear that the paper contributes an exact theory, for the drift setting, of a baseline the field relies on, together with direct evidence on human and monkey recordings and a matched-budget demonstration of the explicit prior.