- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 3
Read review
Paper summary
This paper tackles the Single-Class-Per-Subject (SCPS) problem in EEG classification, where models learn subject-specific identity shortcuts rather than generalizable disease features. The authors propose SPICE, a data augmentation framework that uses a constrained CycleGAN to generate counterfactual EEG.
Critical strengths
he paper correctly identifies the SCPS shortcut as a critical bottleneck in EEG decoding. The idea of intervening at the data level by synthesizing opposite-class signals for the same subject is a conceptually sound strategy to break this shortcut.
Critical weaknesses
- The paper is essentially a standard CycleGAN with identity-class as adversarial loss, which widely explored in the GAN literature.
- The results are mixed: out of 23 settings, only 6 show a clear improvement. The conclusion that the framework is broadly effective across cohorts is therefore overstated.
- Lack of ablation study for the components in the training loess.
Questions for authors
- Could you elaborate on the specific technical novelty of your generative framework beyond applying this standard GAN recipe to the EEG domain?
- Could you justify the conclusion that the framework is broadly effective across cohorts?
- Can you provide an ablation study removing each component in you training loess (subject loss, subject adversarial loss, spectral matching, displacement penalty) to show that they all actually drive the performance gains?
Thank the revierwers for their comments
We thank the reviewers for their thoughtful feedback. We agree that the current results do not demonstrate consistent gains across datasets. We have therefore decided to withdraw the submission. The reviewers’ comments on the lack of ablation studies and the limited evidence that our method preserves subject information will guide our future work.