acceptodds
Withdrawn from ICLR 2027

DivLAM: Latent Action Discovery in World Models through Demonstrator Diversity

Withdrawn from ICLR 2027, so left out of the paper lists and the map.

Abstract

Stochastic execution makes action discovery from video ambiguous: a demonstrator's chosen command need not match the movement executed. DivLAM separates these hidden choices in two stages. Stage A learns shared next-state predictors and demonstrator-specific executed-action probabilities in a frozen visual representation. Stage B factors these probabilities into command policies and an execution channel specifying movement probabilities given each command. Building on existing minimum-volume identification theory, we prove that policies covering every ordered pair with probabilities and satisfy the required sufficient-scattering condition for at least four commands. A matched family restricted to cyclic neighbors instead yields an absorbed channel that incorporates policy mixing. Exact-input tests recover the predicted targets, while sampled counts distinguish sampling error from persistent bias. Across five fresh TwoRoom replication datasets, all-run mean channel total-variation errors after relabeling are for ordered pairs and for cyclic, versus for ignoring execution noise. This visual gap reflects both different population targets and unequal success in learning the executed basis. Discovery uses no action labels, but the frozen encoders were pretrained with actions; recovery is sensitive to encoder choice and fails on the tested PushT task. The results connect demonstrator policy coverage to channel recovery and distinguish factorization bias from errors in learning the executed basis.

Primary area:
unsupervised, self-supervised, semi-supervised, and supervised representation learning
Keywords:
latent action models, world models, action-free video learning, demonstrator diversity, identifiability, minimum-volume factorization, stochastic action execution

Reviews

Among:
Shape:
1234this paper, Bottom 2%
Figure 1. Mean review rating of the reviewed papers at ICLR 2027. This paper averages 1.33 over 3 reviews, above 2% of the others.
Reviewer_XtjfOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
2
Informativeness
2
Presentation
1
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

Break up latent action prediction into two part training to handle stochastic execution: 1) training that focuses on next state predictors with the executed action probabilities and a frozen visual component, and then 2) training that focuses on movement probabilities for each command. Evaluated in two-room datasets and the pushT task.

Critical strengths

The work addresses a unique question related to properly identifying latent actions, and does so in a formalized manner.

Critical weaknesses

Much of the time, action execution noise is not Gaussian or unimodal, but it seems like the current execution model only handles this kind of stochasticity, and with a fixed value of variance. This seems like a strong oversight.

There is not much clarity on how the channel optimization is actually performed for phase 2; that is, is this optimized with a soft criterion, a convex solver, etc., at least in the main paper. Without having clarity on the actual optimization process, it is difficult to determine the weaknesses of such a method.

Sections 3.4-3.5 are not clearly justified, making it hard to parse what issue they are intended to solve. As it is, they do not seem to fit into the two-part training described cleanly. Furthermore, they are full of additional jargon which does not appear to be particularly useful. In general, the paper appears to overuse jargon and AI terminology, which makes it challenging to follow, both in Sections 3 and 4, where the experiments are challenging to parse. As such, the story is somewhat incoherent.

Neither of the experimental domains are particularly realistic, and the setting of a stochastic execution environment is also one which is not particularly realistic, combining to create a setup which does not appear to have very clear justification.

Questions for authors

See Weaknesses

Reviewer_r2egOpenReview ↗
Rating
1
Confidence
2
Informativeness
2
Presentation
1
Soundness
1
Read review
Paper summary

The paper studies the problem of identifying actions from observations of demonstrators in a stochastic environment. It proposes a method that separates command selection from actual execution and examines two families of demonstrator policies. For one family, the method can recover the correct execution mechanism under certain conditions; for the other, it systematically recovers an incorrect one. Experiments on TwoRoom agree with these predictions. However, recovery is sensitive to the choice of encoder and is unsuccessful in the reported PushT experiments.

Critical strengths
  1. The experiments help distinguish three sources of error: learning from images, limited data, and bias of the decomposition itself, and the observed bias closely matches the theoretical prediction.
  2. The authors report unsuccessful results and openly discuss the limitations.
Critical weaknesses
  1. The extent of the novelty over Schur (2026) is not entirely clear to me. The main theorem is inherited from that work, and the regularizers are also adapted from it. There are new results, but I would like a clearer explanation of how substantially they advance the previous work.
  2. I am not convinced by the practical motivation. It is unclear where data with the required properties would arise and how a user could determine whether the method has recovered the true execution mechanism. The authors acknowledge that they do not provide a general way to certify the required diversity of hidden policies in real data.

I found the paper hard to follow overall. The problem setup and how the experiments relate to the theoretical results are difficult to catch from the presentation. A clearer narrative would help explain why the problem matters and how each part of the paper contributes to addressing it.

Questions for authors
  1. What concrete practical task motivates the method, and how would recovering the execution mechanism help in that task?
  2. What do the authors consider the main new contribution relative to Schur (2026)?
  3. Why is there no systematic quantitative comparison with a one-stage method?
Reviewer_kS52OpenReview ↗
Rating
1
Confidence
3
Informativeness
1
Presentation
1
Soundness
1
Read review
Paper summary

In this work, the authors present DivLAM, a way to discover latent actions from observations under stochastic execution. Under the stochastic execution assumption, the authors claim that while it may be hard to separate the intent and execution with one demonstrator, you could potentially do it with multiple because their preferences would be different and therefore they will present different mixes of commanded/executed behavior, which may let us recover both models. The authors present a two-stage method where the first aims to figure out the state-distribution under each demonstrator and stage to that tries to factorize this into intent (which is distinct) and execution stochasticity (which is fixed) with different demonstrators. In experiments in TwoRoom (an environment not specified in the paper) and PushT, the authors show that their methods may sometimes work under an unspecified metric, channel noise, among other also poorly specified topics.

Critical strengths

There are none, even the problem selection can be interesting in a different setting.

Critical weaknesses

This work has a distinct flavor of being generated by AI, including the section titles, such as "WHEN DEMONSTRATOR DIVERSITY IDENTIFIES THE FACTORS" and "DEMONSTRATOR GEOMETRY CHANGES THE RECOVERED CHANNEL". Overlooking that, and making an assumption of good faith, here are the principal weaknesses of the paper:

  1. The work does a poor job of identifying the central problem that it is trying to solve. Latent action prediction is itself a hard and broad-spanning problem, latent action inference under stochastic execution is even more specific of a problem, but the paper does not justify under which conditions it becomes a relevant problem under which condition they study this. Overall, this makes the paper come off as a low-effort, ask-AI-to-write-a-paper rather than a well thought out work of research building up from years of study.
  2. The introduction of the paper focuses too much on the specific instance (TwoRoom, four commands, exact probabilities) rather than giving a broad overview of the problem they are trying to solve.
  3. Related work section does not talk about stochastic execution work.
  4. The method section starts with "Under the conditions of Appendix Lemma A.1," which is unreadable jargon without an informal statement, which makes the rest of it incredibly difficult to read. The paper gets more unreadable from there on.
  5. There is no description of input or output spaces usually.
  6. In experimental design the TwoRoom environment is not specified (or anywhere, really).
  7. "Channel error" is used as a metric without explaining it anywhere.
  8. The "author"'s own study says that the experiments failed (Section 4.6) yet they saw it fit to submit to the conference, which seems to me quite disrespectful of the AC and the reviewer's time.
Questions for authors

I have none except wanting to understand what they hope to gain from this exercise.

From OpenReview, CC BY 4.0. Authors as signed there; shown unedited.

Related papers

Discussion (0)

Sign in to comment.