- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 1
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
Break up latent action prediction into two part training to handle stochastic execution: 1) training that focuses on next state predictors with the executed action probabilities and a frozen visual component, and then 2) training that focuses on movement probabilities for each command. Evaluated in two-room datasets and the pushT task.
Critical strengths
The work addresses a unique question related to properly identifying latent actions, and does so in a formalized manner.
Critical weaknesses
Much of the time, action execution noise is not Gaussian or unimodal, but it seems like the current execution model only handles this kind of stochasticity, and with a fixed value of variance. This seems like a strong oversight.
There is not much clarity on how the channel optimization is actually performed for phase 2; that is, is this optimized with a soft criterion, a convex solver, etc., at least in the main paper. Without having clarity on the actual optimization process, it is difficult to determine the weaknesses of such a method.
Sections 3.4-3.5 are not clearly justified, making it hard to parse what issue they are intended to solve. As it is, they do not seem to fit into the two-part training described cleanly. Furthermore, they are full of additional jargon which does not appear to be particularly useful. In general, the paper appears to overuse jargon and AI terminology, which makes it challenging to follow, both in Sections 3 and 4, where the experiments are challenging to parse. As such, the story is somewhat incoherent.
Neither of the experimental domains are particularly realistic, and the setting of a stochastic execution environment is also one which is not particularly realistic, combining to create a setup which does not appear to have very clear justification.
Questions for authors
See Weaknesses