- Rating
- 3(+1)
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2(+1)
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 3
Read review
Paper summary
The paper studies predictive contraction in time-series forecasting, in which predictions show less variation than the observed targets. Its central question is whether this reduction reflects appropriate averaging over uncertain futures or excessive contraction introduced by the forecasting model, considering variation across samples with similar observed histories and variation within individual forecast trajectories. The authors define contrast operators and contraction ratios for these two perspectives. They then derive an observable criterion that combines predictive amplitude with target alignment to identify the optimal scalar rescaling of predicted contrasts. Under the stated assumptions, this coefficient is equivalent to the coefficient obtained using a Bayes-optimal conditional-mean reference, without requiring that reference to be estimated.
Experiments across eight models and six benchmark datasets show that contraction is widespread (Figure 3). However, accounting for alignment changes its interpretation: sample-wise contrasts generally favor further attenuation, whereas temporal contrasts exhibit both amplification and attenuation regimes (Figure 4). The paper also examines retrospective scaling preferences across individual windows (Section 4.3) and shows that global temporal rescaling produces limited forecasting improvements, even with test-oracle fitting (Table 4). Its conclusion is that reduced variation relative to observed targets alone is insufficient evidence of excessive smoothing.
Critical strengths
The paper distinguishes contraction caused by optimal averaging under uncertainty from excessive contraction. This is valuable because reduced predictive variation shouldn't simply be interpreted as a model deficiency without considering whether that variation is predictable.
The paper defines an observable criterion that combines amplitude and target alignment to identify optimal scalar rescaling without estimating the Bayes reference. Analysis across eight models and six datasets demonstrates that amplification is not universally beneficial (Figure 4), providing useful evidence for interpreting forecasting behavior.
Critical weaknesses
The contribution beyond prior work is insufficiently discussed and established. A dedicated discussion of existing theoretical and empirical studies on forecast rescaling, error decomposition, and uncertainty-induced contraction would help clarify which aspects are established and what new insights this work provides. This distinction is particularly important for assessing the novelty and significance of an analysis paper. Please compare the paper’s main findings directly with prior theoretical or even empirical work on rescaling, error decomposition, and uncertainty-induced contraction. Explain how your findings either confirm existing knowledge, challenge it, or provide new insights.
Model error is not really or clearly distinguished from irreducible uncertainty. A controlled validation of the diagnostic could answer this! In fact, the paper would benefit from synthetic experiments where the true conditional mean is known. Comparing this optimal predictor with predictions whose amplitude is intentionally reduced or whose shape is distorted would test whether the diagnostic correctly identifies excessive contraction. These experiments would also clarify which window-level patterns reflect model errors and which can arise from unpredictable noise, even for an optimal predictor.
Questions for authors
Please address the concerns raised in the weaknesses section.
4 comments
Thank you again for your thoughtful review and constructive suggestions. We would like to follow up and wonder if our responses have addressed your concerns. For ease of reference, we summarize below the corresponding revisions and newly added experiments. The revised passages are highlighted in blue in the updated manuscript.
W1: On the novelty and contributions
We have expanded the Introduction (Pages 2–3) to clarify the relationship between prior studies on over-smoothing and Bayes-optimal averaging under conditional uncertainty, and to better position our theoretical and empirical contributions.
The theoretical foundation and the proposed observable criterion are further clarified in Section 4.1 (Page 6), while Section 4.4 (Page 8) clarifies the contrast-error decomposition based on Theil (1966), explaining the limitations of uniform amplitude correction.
W2: On distinguishing model error from irreducible uncertainty
We have added controlled synthetic experiments in Appendix A.5 (Pages 16–19).
-
Section A.5.1 (Page 16): Constructs an AR(2) process with latent frequency uncertainty, for which the Bayes-optimal conditional mean is known.
-
Section A.5.2 (Pages 17–18): Validates the proposed diagnostic through controlled amplitude and energy-preserving shape interventions. Figure 12 summarizes their effects on predictive amplitude and target alignment.
-
Section A.5.3 (Pages 18–19): Decomposes window-level scaling coefficients into conditional-mean scaling preferences and residual fluctuations due to irreducible uncertainty. Table 6 quantifies their respective contributions, showing that the former accounts for 32.5%–61.6% of the combined variance in window-level scaling coefficients across the learned predictors.
We would appreciate any further feedback or guidance you may have, and would be willing to address any remaining questions or concerns.
Dear authors,
Thank you for your detailed responses to my questions and also to the points raised by the other reviewers. The discussion has clarified the paper’s contributions and addressed my main concerns. I now have a more positive assessment of the work and have raised my score.
We sincerely appreciate your positive reassessment and your decision to raise your rating. Thank you for the time and thoughtful consideration devoted to reviewing our work and engaging in this discussion. Your insightful feedback prompted us to conduct deeper analyses and clarify key aspects of our methodology, which helped us further strengthen our manuscript. We are pleased that our revisions have addressed your main concerns, and remain grateful for the valuable feedback for improving this work.
We appreciate the reviewer’s recognition of the importance of distinguishing excessive model contraction, as well as the value of an observable criterion that avoids explicitly estimating the Bayes-optimal predictor. The constructive suggestions have helped us further clarify the relationship between our contributions and prior work, and strengthen the validation and interpretation of our findings. We address the two concerns below.
W1: On the novelty and contributions relative to prior work
Regarding the theoretical contribution, our analysis is grounded in established statistical results, including least-squares forecast recalibration (Mincer and Zarnowitz, 1969), forecast error decomposition (Theil, 1966), and the orthogonality property of conditional expectation. We have made these works explicit in the revised manuscript. The central theoretical result of our work is an observable characterization of predictive contraction under conditional uncertainty. This characterization enables a purely post hoc assessment of Bayes-referenced contraction, requiring only model predictions and ground-truth targets, without estimating the Bayes-optimal predictor. We establish this characterization separately for sample-wise and temporal contrasts, providing a unified analytical framework for examining predictive contraction along these two dimensions.
Regarding the empirical contribution, prior studies on over-smoothing have identified the attenuation of predictive dynamics as a potential modeling limitation and proposed approaches to preserve meaningful future variation (Le Guen and Thome, 2019; Sun et al., 2025; Yu et al., 2026; Zhang et al., 2026). In contrast, Green et al. (2026) demonstrate that reduced predictive variation can also arise from Bayes-optimal averaging under conditional uncertainty.
Our empirical findings help reconcile these perspectives. We confirm that predictive contraction is widespread and positively associated with forecasting error, consistent with the concerns raised by over-smoothing studies. We find that, after accounting for target alignment, sample-wise predictions predominantly favor further attenuation, whereas temporal predictions exhibit both excessive- and insufficient-contraction regimes, challenging the widely adopted assumption that predictive contraction reflects a modeling deficiency and needs to be rectified.
Furthermore, while existing studies primarily characterize over-smoothing through aggregate benchmark performance, we further examine retrospective scaling preferences at the individual-window level. This finer-grained analysis reveals substantial heterogeneity within the same model–dataset pair: some windows favor attenuation, while others favor amplification, and larger deviations from unit scaling in either direction tend to accompany higher forecasting error. This heterogeneity also helps explain why a single global temporal rescaling yields only modest gains, even under test-oracle fitting.
W2: On distinguishing model error from irreducible uncertainty
We have added controlled synthetic experiments in the Appendix A.5, using an AR(2) process with latent frequency uncertainty, for which the Bayes-optimal conditional mean can be computed exactly. This enables direct validation of the proposed diagnostic and an examination of the respective contributions of model deviations and irreducible uncertainty.
First, we validate the diagnostic through controlled interventions. Scaling the Bayes-optimal predictions by a factor c yields the expected Bayes-referenced coefficient βˉ⋆=1/c, correctly distinguishing contraction from amplification. We further apply an energy-preserving shape transformation, which alters prediction alignment without changing amplitude. The resulting scaling coefficients deviate from one, confirming that the diagnostic captures both amplitude and alignment effects (Figure 12).
Second, we examine the sources of window-level heterogeneity. As raised by the reviewer, irreducible uncertainty can produce window-level heterogeneity even under the Bayes-optimal predictor. Nevertheless, in our controlled setting, learned predictors exhibit additional heterogeneity in their Bayes-referenced scaling preferences, accounting for 33%–62% of the variance. This demonstrates that model deviations can contribute substantially to the observed heterogeneity alongside irreducible uncertainty.