- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
This paper deals with longitudinal person-level contrastive learning. They discuss the problem that over time, samples from the same person should not necessarily be treated as positive paris, as they may change significantly. They show empirical evidence in 2 in-home sensing datasets that information is lost because of these longitudinal changes. They propose to contrast other observations from the same person (i.e. controlling what is considered invariant).
Critical strengths
- The paper is mostly well presented with a logical flow.
- The central idea is clearly explained.
Critical weaknesses
- I understand the problem you are tackling, but I am unclear whether this is really a relevant/important/existing problem. Do other works really do longitudinal person-level contrastive learning over long time periods? And does this cause models to underperform? In any case, you should definitely expand on this in the introduction and further discuss related works.
- I am unclear about what the task you are really trying to do is. Why is it of interest to have as a primary metric the information shared between two samples? I feel like this should be coupled to downstream tasks to show actual impact of the phenomena you observe/method you propose.
- Experiments are lacking in breadth. Only two small datasets are studied.
[Not factored into score] 4. The appendix is very long and contains 50+ tables. Can you summarise what the appendix shows? Are all results/explanations in the appendix necessary to the paper? 5. The paper writing sounds (to me) extremely AI-generated. This may frustrate future readers.
Questions for authors
See weaknesses