acceptodds
Under review as a conference paper at ICLR 2027

GraphSteer: Soft Edge Reweighting via Informative Leiden Subgraphs for Graph Out-of-Distribution Generalization

Abstract

Graph neural networks often exploit environment-specific correlations that do not remain stable under distribution shifts, leading to poor out-of-distribution (OOD) generalization. Existing graph OOD methods commonly rely on identifying invariant subgraphs or suppressing spurious structures, but such approaches may discard useful information when the distinction between relevant and irrelevant graph components is imperfect. We propose GraphSteer, a soft structural reweighting framework that partitions graphs into candidate subgraphs using Leiden community detection, which we extend to incorporate node-feature information. GraphSteer estimates subgraph informativeness from a subgraph classifier's predictive confidence and uses this information to reweight graph edges while preserving the full graph structure for downstream message passing. This soft structural intervention avoids irreversible structural deletion when subgraph identification is imperfect, while the resulting communities and informativeness scores provide an inspectable view of how GraphSteer emphasises different graph regions under covariate and concept shifts. Unlike many existing methods evaluated on specific graph domains or shift settings, GraphSteer is evaluated across image-derived, molecular, and synthetic graphs under both covariate and concept shifts, without requiring ground-truth environment labels. Experiments on GOOD-CMNIST, GOOD-HIV, and GOOD-Motif demonstrate competitive and robust OOD performance across these settings.

Primary area:
learning on graphs and other geometries & topologies
Keywords:
Graph neural networks, out-of-distribution generalization, graph representation learning, subgraph informativeness, edge reweighting, distribution shift

Reviews

Among:
Shape:
1234this paper, Bottom 9%
Figure 1. Mean review rating of the reviewed papers at ICLR 2027. This paper averages 1.50 over 4 reviews, above 9% of the others.
Reviewer_6RJvOpenReview ↗
Rating
1
Confidence
4
Informativeness
1
Presentation
2
Soundness
1
Read review
Paper summary

This paper proposes to select a Leiden community using classifier confidence for downstream graph classification. The paper reports competitive OOD performance across three datasets under covariate and concept shifts

Critical strengths

The method is straightforward

The paper shows that retaining the full graph reduces information loss

Experimental analysis is broad

Critical weaknesses

Contrary to Section 3.3, stable P(Y∣G)P(Y|G) does not imply stable subgraph-label relationships. Thus, a training-predictive community can be misleading at test time

The paper's own unweighted model scores 74.53 on HIV-covariate (GraphSteer: 74.52), and 92.62 on Motif-concept (GraphSteer: 92.77). Comparisons against much weaker ERM results do not isolate the contribution of reweighting

The pruning baseline removes both nodes and edges, while plain Leiden receives weights tuned for the proposed variant. These comparisons do not cleanly establish the benefits of soft weighting

The authors do not provide code for reproducing the reported results. More concerningly, the Reproducibility Statement (lines 503) states that "Code, configuration files, random seeds, and preprocessing details should be included in the supplementary material or an anonymous repository," which reads like an unedited placeholder

Questions for authors

Please see above

1 comment

Stability of subgraph-label relationships

We agree that stable P(Y∣G)P(Y|G) under covariate shift does not necessarily imply stable subgraph-label relationships. To evaluate this question, we assessed subgraph selection by measuring alignment with known task-relevant structures across splits:

Table 1. Selected-subgraph alignment (%).

DatasetShiftScoreTrainID-ValID-TestOOD-ValOOD-Test
CMNISTConceptEntropy88.889.388.689.690.0
Margin94.494.494.694.794.8
CovariateEntropy66.267.166.8100.0100.0
Margin33.233.534.2100.0100.0
MotifConceptEntropy61.761.559.963.664.2
Margin60.660.659.062.863.7
CovariateEntropy98.698.398.699.498.4
Margin98.598.398.5100.098.5

CMNIST: selected community contains foreground; Motif: selected community meets the causal-subgraph criterion.

For covariate shift, Motif alignment remains high across splits (98.3%–100%), while CMNIST reaches 100% on OOD splits despite lower ID alignment. Under concept shift, alignment is high on CMNIST (88.6%–94.8%) but lower on Motif (59%–64.2%). These results provide evidence that selection can transfer to unseen data.

We will revise Section 3.3 as follows:

Under covariate shift, the main challenge for subgraph selection is to generalize to regions of the distribution that are underrepresented in the training set. Our empirical results suggest that such generalization is feasible in the evaluated settings, although this does not guarantee that the selected subgraphs capture invariant information. Under concept shift, subgraphs that are informative in the training distribution may not remain informative at test time, potentially leading to the selection of less useful subgraphs. This motivates soft edge reweighting rather than fully pruning non-selected subgraphs, allowing potentially useful information to be retained.

Node-preserving pruning controls

We agree that deleting nodes confounded the previous pruning comparison. We added (1,0,0)(1,0,0) (intra-subgraph edges only) and (1,1,0)(1,1,0) (intra-subgraph plus boundary edges); both retain all nodes and node features, including isolated nodes. We also report unweighted (1,1,1)(1,1,1) and independently tuned Original Leiden.

Table 2. GOOD-CMNIST color/concept ablation (accuracy in %, mean ± SD).

SelectionVariantScoreWeightsID TestOOD Test
ID-ValSubgraph only——87.94±0.2725.29±2.25
Hard pruningMargin(1,0,0)87.24±0.2515.56±1.73
Outside pruningMargin(1,1,0)90.24±0.3639.43±4.01
UnweightedMargin(1,1,1)89.66±0.1940.56±1.11
Original LeidenMargin(1,0.9,0.9)89.95±0.2540.78±0.42
GraphSteerMargin(1,0.7,0.3)91.93±0.1151.34±0.85
OOD-ValSubgraph only——87.47±0.1929.12±0.55
Hard pruningMargin(1,0,0)84.26±1.3322.28±0.83
Outside pruningMargin(1,1,0)89.77±0.9741.89±1.04
UnweightedMargin(1,1,1)89.47±0.3142.68±0.62
Original LeidenEntropy(1,0.9,0.9)89.02±0.1243.00±0.70
GraphSteerMargin(1,0.9,0.3)91.33±0.2752.23±0.86

Subgraph only additionally removes external nodes. Original Leiden and GraphSteer select scores and weights independently under the same validation protocol.

GraphSteer exceeds node-preserving Outside-Edge Pruning by 11.91 pp (ID-Val selection) and 10.34 pp (OOD-Val selection), supporting soft weighting over binary removal.

Comparable unweighted results

We acknowledge that the unweighted configuration (1,1,1)(1,1,1) achieves comparable performance to GraphSteer on GOOD-HIV covariate (74.53% vs. 74.52%) and GOOD-Motif concept (92.6% vs. 92.77%).

While soft edge reweighting does not always provide substantial gains, it maintains competitive performance without meaningful degradation. As shown in Table 1, it also provides substantial improvements over binary edge pruning under challenging distribution shifts.

Original Leiden tuning

We independently tuned the confidence scores and edge weights for Original Leiden and Node-Feature-Aware Leiden using the same validation protocol. GraphSteer outperforms Original Leiden by 10.56 pp under ID-Val selection (51.34% vs. 40.78%) and 9.23 pp under OOD-Val selection (52.23% vs. 43.00%), demonstrating the benefit of feature-aware partitioning.

Reproducibility

We apologize for the incomplete reproducibility statement. We will revise it to clarify the preprocessing, backbone architectures, hyperparameters, random seeds, and model-selection procedures. If the paper is accepted, we will provide the complete source code, configuration files, and reproducibility details in the final version.

Reviewer_MuPpOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
3
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

GraphSteer addresses graph OOD generalization by partitioning graphs into Leiden communities, scoring candidate subgraphs using a trained classifier’s predictive confidence, and assigning different weights to edges inside, across, and outside the selected community. A downstream GIN/GINE is trained on the resulting weighted graphs. Experiments cover covariate and concept shifts on GOOD-CMNIST, GOOD-HIV, and GOOD-Motif.

Critical strengths

Retaining the original graph while allowing partial attenuation of messages is a simple and interpretable approach to mitigating information loss from imperfect subgraph selection.

The evaluation covers multiple graph domains and shift types. Appendix G includes a useful comparison with training only on the selected subgraph, and substantial improvements over unweighted controls are reported in some settings.

Critical weaknesses
  • The selection mechanism lacks sufficient justification. Predictive confidence in the training domain is not established as a reliable indicator of subgraph utility under distribution shift. In particular, the argument in Section 3.3 is incomplete: invariance of (P(Y\mid G)) under covariate shift does not generally imply invariance of (P(Y\mid G_m)) for a candidate subgraph. The suitability of Leiden communities and confidence scoring also lacks quantitative validation against known motifs or simpler selection rules.

  • The contribution of soft reweighting is not fully isolated. Appendix G removes external nodes and features as well as edges, so it does not distinguish the benefit of intermediate edge weights from retaining additional information. Moreover, the corresponding unweighted control achieves 74.53 versus GraphSteer’s 74.52 on HIV covariate shift (Table 10), and 92.59 versus 92.77 on Motif concept shift (Table 11). These results warrant a clearer comparison with unweighted baselines using the same implementation and training settings.

  • The reported model selection requires clarification. For CMNIST covariate shift, Table 2 selects a configuration with ID-validation performance of 77.51, whereas Table 8 reports 78.03 for the unweighted configuration within the same Entropy group. The 0.52-percentage-point gap exceeds the stated tolerance of 0.05 in Eq. (10). The HIV learning rate and Motif run count also differ across the experimental descriptions.

Questions for authors
  • Can you quantify how often confidence scoring selects the true motif versus the spurious base, and compare it with random or size-based community selection?

  • Can you add binary edge-mask controls that retain all nodes, and include the corresponding unweighted baselines in the main comparison?

  • How does the CMNIST configuration above satisfy the stated selection rule? Please also reconcile the HIV learning rate and Motif run count.

1 comment

Confidence-based selection and ground-truth structures

We agree that stable P(Y∣G)P(Y|G) does not imply stable subgraph-label relationships. We will weaken Section 3.3 accordingly: predictive confidence is a heuristic for identifying task-relevant communities, not a guarantee of invariance.

To empirically evaluate confidence-based selection, we examine whether selected communities align with known task-relevant structures across training, ID, and OOD splits. We additionally estimate a uniform-random selection baseline using the average number of Leiden communities per graph.

Table 1. Ground-truth subgraph alignment across dataset splits (%).

DatasetShiftSelectorTrainID-ValID-TestOOD-ValOOD-Test
CMNISTConceptRandom (est.)20.4920.5320.4920.4920.49
Entropy88.889.388.689.690.0
Margin94.494.494.694.794.8
CovariateRandom (est.)20.4920.4920.4920.5820.49
Entropy66.267.166.8100.0100.0
Margin33.233.534.2100.0100.0
MotifConceptRandom (est.)30.2129.7630.1230.0329.85
Entropy61.761.559.963.664.2
Margin60.660.659.062.863.7
CovariateRandom (est.)29.8529.9430.0349.5028.99
Entropy98.698.398.699.498.4
Margin98.598.398.5100.098.5

CMNIST alignment measures whether the selected community contains the foreground structure, while Motif alignment uses the relaxed ground-truth causal-subgraph criterion. Assuming one qualifying community per graph, random selection is approximated by 100/K‾100/\overline K, where K‾\overline K is the average number of communities. These are estimates rather than exact random-selection rates, which require averaging 100/Ki100/K_i over individual graphs.

The results show that confidence-based selection exceeds the estimated random reference across the evaluated settings. In particular, CMNIST under concept shift achieves 88.6%–94.8% foreground alignment, while Motif under covariate shift achieves 98.3%–100.0% causal-subgraph alignment, including OOD splits.

However, alignment is lower on Motif under concept shift (59.0%–64.2%), and CMNIST under covariate shift exhibits considerable variation across splits and confidence metrics.

These findings suggest that confidence-based selection can identify task-relevant structures in certain settings, although predictive confidence does not guarantee invariance. GraphSteer therefore uses confidence as a heuristic to guide soft edge reweighting while preserving the complete graph.

Node-preserving binary masks and unweighted controls

We agree that removing nodes in Appendix G confounded the comparison. We added (1,0,0)(1,0,0) (retain intra-community edges only) and (1,1,0)(1,1,0) (retain intra-community and boundary edges). Both preserve every original node and feature, including isolated nodes.

Table 2. GOOD-CMNIST color/concept OOD-test accuracy (%, mean ± SD).

SelectionVariantWeightsOOD Test
ID-ValHard pruning(1,0,0)15.56±1.73
Outside pruning(1,1,0)39.43±4.01
Unweighted(1,1,1)40.56±1.11
Original Leiden(1,0.9,0.9)40.78±0.42
GraphSteer(1,0.7,0.3)51.34±0.85
OOD-ValHard pruning(1,0,0)22.28±0.83
Outside pruning(1,1,0)41.89±1.04
Unweighted(1,1,1)42.68±0.62
Original Leiden(1,0.9,0.9)43.00±0.70
GraphSteer(1,0.9,0.3)52.23±0.86

Original Leiden and feature-aware Leiden independently select scores and edge weights under the same validation procedure.

GraphSteer exceeds outside-edge pruning by 11.91/10.34 pp and the unweighted control by 10.78/9.55 pp (ID-Val/OOD-Val selection). These comparisons support the contribution of soft weighting without node removal in this setting. We acknowledge nearly identical unweighted and reweighted results on HIV-covariate (74.53% vs. 74.52%) and Motif-concept (92.59% vs. 92.77%); gains are not universal. Comparisons with differently configured ERM runs alone do not isolate reweighting, so we will distinguish matched (1,1,1)(1,1,1) controls in the revised manuscript.

Model selection and experimental consistency

CMNIST (77.51 vs. 78.03). The discrepancy arises because the unweighted configuration (1,1,1)(1,1,1) is excluded from GraphSteer's model-selection candidates and evaluated separately as a baseline. Therefore, the best configuration is selected based on the highest validation score among eligible reweighted configurations, rather than including (1,1,1)(1,1,1). We will clarify this exclusion and the selection procedure in the revised manuscript.

Reviewer_GfjTOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
4
Informativeness
2
Presentation
3
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

The paper proposes GraphSteer for graph-level OOD generalization. Each graph is partitioned into communities using a feature-aware extension of Leiden. A separately trained subgraph classifier scores each community by its predictive confidence, and the most confident community is selected. Edges inside, across the boundary of, and outside this community then receive three different fixed weights, and the reweighted graph is fed to a GIN/GINE backbone. The method does not require environment labels and is evaluated on GOOD-CMNIST, GOOD-HIV, and GOOD-Motif under covariate and concept shifts.

The paper is clearly written and easy to follow. The overview figure and the visualizations of the Leiden partitions and the selected subgraphs make the method intuitive and show which graph regions it emphasizes.

Critical strengths
  1. Replacing hard subgraph selection with soft edge reweighting is an intuitive way to avoid irreversibly discarding useful structure when subgraph identification is imperfect.

  2. The method works without ground-truth environment labels and is evaluated under both covariate and concept shifts on image-derived, molecular, and synthetic graphs.

  3. The community partitions and selected subgraphs can be visualized directly, giving an inspectable view of which graph regions the model emphasizes.

Critical weaknesses
  • The training of the subgraph classifier is not well justified.

Each community inherits the label of its parent graph, so all communities from the same graph share one label and there is no negative or background class. The classifier therefore learns how frequently a community appears in graphs of each class, not whether it determines the label. Under concept shift, spurious communities that are strongly correlated with the label during training may thus receive the highest confidence. If I have misunderstood the training procedure, please feel free to correct me.

  • Baseline comparisons are not controlled, and the contribution may be overstated.

Baseline results appear to be copied from prior papers with different backbones and protocols, while GraphSteer is tuned with OOD validation over 44 configurations. The authors' own unweighted model in the appendix already matches GraphSteer on several settings (e.g., about 92.6 vs. 92.77 on GOOD-Motif concept shift, where ERM is reported as 81.44), so much of the reported gain likely comes from the training setup rather than the proposed reweighting.

Questions for authors
  1. GraphSteer requires running Leiden on every graph, training an additional subgraph classifier, scoring all communities of every graph, and training the downstream GNN for each of the 44 configurations. Could the authors provide a time-complexity analysis and comparisons against ERM and the main baselines?

  2. Could the authors select a few representative methods (e.g., ERM, GSAT, CIGA, and PrunE) and re-run them with the same backbone, hyperparameter budget, and model-selection rule on all six settings, including the unweighted configuration as a baseline in the main table?

  3. Could the learned classifier be replaced with a deterministic, training-free method, for example using a Weisfeiler–Lehman subtree graph kernel to measure the similarity between each community and the training graphs of each class? This would remove an extra training stage, no longer depend on whether the classifier's probabilities are reliable, and clarify whether the improvement comes from the learned confidence or from the community structure itself.

1 comment

Supervision of the auxiliary subgraph classifier

Each Leiden community inherits its parent graph's label, and the auxiliary GCN is explicitly trained to predict that label from the community's features and topology. It learns class-predictive feature/topology patterns, not a literal frequency count. Nevertheless, we agree that parent-label supervision can reinforce spurious correlations, especially under concept shift. We do not claim that high confidence proves causal relevance or invariance.

To examine this limitation, we measured alignment with known ground-truth structures. On GOOD-CMNIST (color/concept), foreground alignment is 88.6%–94.8% across splits and confidence metrics. On GOOD-Motif (basis/covariate), relaxed causal-subgraph alignment is 98.3%–100.0%. However, Motif/concept alignment is lower (59.0%–64.2%). These observations support confidence as a useful but imperfect heuristic. Crucially, GraphSteer reweights edges without discarding nonselected nodes or edges.

Training-free community scoring

We evaluated a training-free selector based on the Weisfeiler–Lehman (WL) subtree kernel on GOOD-Motif using the same Leiden communities. Normalized WL similarities were computed against up to 100 original training graphs per class using two refinement iterations. Each community was scored by its maximum class-wise similarity (WL-based MaxSimilarity).

On the OOD-test split, GraphSteer achieved 64.22% causal-subgraph alignment under concept shift, compared with 51.08% for WL. Under covariate shift, GraphSteer achieved 98.40%, compared with 65.10% for WL.

These results suggest that learned confidence better identifies causal-aligned communities than the evaluated WL-based selector, although downstream OOD classification performance was not assessed.

Baseline fairness and controlled reruns

For GOOD-CMNIST, all baseline comparisons were already conducted under consistent experimental settings. Since submission, we have additionally reproduced eight general baselines on both GOOD-Motif and GOOD-HIV under covariate and concept shifts, using the same GIN backbone and core training hyperparameters as GraphSteer.

On GOOD-Motif, the reproduced ERM achieves 92.70% accuracy under concept shift with OOD-validation selection, comparable to GraphSteer's 92.77%. Under covariate shift, the strongest reproduced baseline achieves only 55.69%, highlighting GraphSteer's substantial advantage in this setting.

On GOOD-HIV, the strongest reproduced baselines achieve 73.94% ROC-AUC under covariate shift (ERM) and 75.08% under concept shift (IRM). These additional results extend our controlled comparisons across all three datasets and both distribution shifts.

We will update the baseline table accordingly.

Contribution of edge reweighting

While soft edge reweighting does not always yield substantial improvements, it maintains comparable performance without meaningful degradation. Importantly, it provides substantial gains in certain settings, particularly under challenging distribution shifts, as demonstrated by our additional ablation experiments.

We additionally evaluated node-preserving binary masks on CMNIST/color/concept (OOD-test accuracy, mean ±\pm SD):

Selection(1,0,0)(1,0,0)(1,1,0)(1,1,0)(1,1,1)(1,1,1)GraphSteer
ID-Val15.56±1.7315.56\pm1.7339.43±4.0139.43\pm4.0140.56±1.1140.56\pm1.1151.34±0.8551.34\pm0.85
OOD-Val22.28±0.8322.28\pm0.8341.89±1.0441.89\pm1.0442.68±0.6242.68\pm0.6252.23±0.8652.23\pm0.86

All controls retain the original nodes and features. GraphSteer improves on unweighted by 10.78/9.55 pp (ID-/OOD-Val selection), supporting a specific benefit from soft weighting in this setting, without asserting that this holds universally.

Computational complexity and runtime

GraphSteer has a one-time partitioning, auxiliary-training, scoring, and weighting stage, followed by ordinary GNN training with scalar edge weights. For total nodes NN, edges MM, maximum communities per graph KK, auxiliary epochs EE, and hidden width hh, a conservative preprocessing estimate is

Tpre=O(TLeiden+K(N+M)+E(Nh2+Mh)).T_{\rm pre}=O(T_{\rm Leiden}+K(N+M)+E(Nh^2+Mh)).

For a fixed reweighted graph, downstream training has the same asymptotic order as the corresponding ERM backbone: Tweighted=Θ(TERM)T_{\rm weighted}=\Theta(T_{\rm ERM}). The full search cost must additionally include downstream training for each tested weight configuration.

Measured wall-clock time (seconds):

StageCMNIST-CpCMNIST-CvMotif-CpMotif-CvHIV-CpHIV-Cv
Preprocessing38344212346464670954
Final GNN9052104641747211135175451
Total12886146762092257541876405

Cp/Cv denote concept/covariate shifts. Preprocessing is reused across seeds; final-GNN time is averaged across seeds.

Reviewer_AMaFOpenReview ↗
Rating
1
Confidence
3
Informativeness
1
Presentation
2
Soundness
1
Read review
Paper summary

This paper presents GraphSteer, an algorithm that helps graph neural networks perform well on out-of-distribution data. GraphSteer uses feature-aware Leiden community detection to partition a graph into candidate subgraphs and estimates each subgraph's informativeness based on a classifier’s confidence. It then adjusts edge weights while preserving the full graph for message passing. In this graph OOD framework, the original topology remains intact, while message passing is softly reweighted according to the estimated subgraph informativeness, thereby modulating edge contributions during downstream GNN training. The paper presents some interesting ideas. However, it lacks detail in several areas, including analytical guarantees and incremental improvements in the results.

Critical strengths

The idea of visualizing the scored subgraphs to get insights into which graph structures under different OOD scenarios is very interesting.

Critical weaknesses
  1. The literature review is fair, but it does not adequately position the paper’s contribution in relation to existing work.
  2. It is unclear how the proposed subgraph-based approach reveals which aspects of the graph structure affect OOD scenarios.
  3. The paper provides no theoretical evidence for the approach or analytical guarantees.
  4. The results show a minor improvement compared to the baseline.
  5. The paper does not discuss the limitations.
Questions for authors
  1. Can the authors provide theoretical guarantees for the paper’s approach?
1 comment

Positioning relative to existing work

  • DIR discovers invariant rationales through interventions on non-causal graph components.
  • CIGA learns invariant subgraphs using causal invariance and contrastive learning.
  • PrunE learns an edge selector to prune potentially spurious connections.

Unlike these approaches, GraphSteer does not explicitly identify invariant or spurious subgraphs. Instead, Leiden detects candidate communities, predictive confidence selects the top-ranked community, and three-level edge weights regulate message passing within, across, and outside the selected community. Rather than relying on binary pruning, GraphSteer can attenuate non-selected structures while retaining potentially useful information.

Structural insights and performance improvements

GraphSteer is motivated by the hypothesis that graph regions differ in task relevance and sensitivity to distribution shifts. We evaluated selected-community alignment with known structures:

Dataset / ShiftAlignment
CMNIST / Concept88.688.6–94.8%94.8\%
CMNIST / Covariate33.233.2–100%100\%
Motif / Covariate98.398.3–100%100\%
Motif / Concept5959–64.2%64.2\%

CMNIST measures foreground inclusion; Motif uses a relaxed causal-subgraph criterion. High alignment suggests task-relevant selection, while lower Motif-concept alignment shows that confidence does not guarantee invariance.

On GOOD-CMNIST concept shift (OOD-validation selection), GraphSteer (1,0.9,0.3)(1,0.9,0.3) achieves 52.23% OOD accuracy versus hard pruning (1,0,0)(1,0,0): 22.28%; outside pruning (1,1,0)(1,1,0): 41.89%; unweighted (1,1,1)(1,1,1): 42.68%; and original Leiden: 43.00%. Pruning retains nodes/features but suppresses edge messages; original Leiden independently tunes its scorer and weights under the same protocol. GraphSteer gains 10.34 pp over outside pruning, 9.55 pp over unweighted, and 9.23 pp over original Leiden.

Gains vary across datasets: HIV-covariate achieves 74.52% vs. 74.53% unweighted (ROC-AUC), while Motif-concept achieves 92.77% vs. 92.59% (accuracy). These results indicate that GraphSteer maintains comparable performance even when improvements are marginal, without substantial degradation.

Limitations

We will clarify five limitations:

  • Community detection: Selected Leiden communities often capture task-relevant structures, but invariant-structure recovery is not guaranteed under shifts.
  • Confidence selection: Spurious shortcuts may yield high confidence, especially under concept shift.
  • Fixed reweighting: Three coarse edge categories and top-one selection can miss finer relationships; weights need dataset-specific tuning.
  • Validation dependence: ID- and OOD-validation can select different weights and produce different generalization results.
  • Computational overhead: Leiden and auxiliary GCN add preprocessing; although reusable, each weight candidate requires additional downstream GNN training.

Theoretical justification and guarantees

While we do not provide formal theoretical guarantees, our empirical evaluation across three diverse graph datasets (GOOD-CMNIST, GOOD-HIV, and GOOD-Motif), covering both covariate and concept distribution shifts, provides evidence supporting the effectiveness of GraphSteer in improving out-of-distribution generalization.

From OpenReview, CC BY 4.0. Authors as signed there; shown unedited.

Related papers

Loading the map…

Discussion (0)

Sign in to comment.