acceptodds
Under review as a conference paper at ICLR 2027

Rank-Aware Speculative Sampling for Diffusion Draft Trees

Abstract

Speculative sampling accelerates diffusion generation by verifying inexpensive draft states in parallel while preserving the target law. Recent tree-based methods allocate the parallel compute budget more effectively than single-chain drafts, as demonstrated by Diffusion Greedy Rejection Sampling (D-GRS). D-GRS generates conditionally independent candidates per node, and sequentially tests them in their generation order. Yet the sampled candidates admit an informative ranking without additional target-model evaluations. To exploit this, we introduce Rank-Aware Speculative Sampling (RASS), a verification rule for speculative draft trees based on rank-aware list coupling. RASS orders draft candidates along the proposal–target mean displacement and samples a rank with weights optimized to minimize total variation between the selected-proposal and target laws. Finally, the selected candidate is maximally coupled with the target, with residual correction ensuring *exact* sampling for any choice of rank weights. We evaluate RASS on a Gaussian-mixture target, unconditional pixel-space generation on FFHQ, conditional generation on CIFAR-10, and latent diffusion with Stable Diffusion 3.5 using COCO2014 prompts. Measured by the ratio of standard to speculative sampling’s target-model evaluation counts, RASS improves on D-GRS across the evaluated settings, with gains reaching approximately 20% on CIFAR-10 at matched compute budgets.

Primary area:
probabilistic methods (Bayesian methods, variational inference, sampling, UQ, etc.)
Keywords:
speculative diffusion sampling, diffusion models, speculative draft trees

Reviews

Among:
Shape:
1234this paper, Top 15%
Figure 1. Mean review rating of the reviewed papers at ICLR 2027. This paper averages 3.00 over 3 reviews, above 85% of the others.
Reviewer_P4FUOpenReview ↗
Rating
3(+1)
Confidence
2
Informativeness
3
Presentation
2
Soundness
3
Read review
Paper summary

The paper introduces Rank-Aware Speculative Sampling (RASS), a verification rule for speculative diffusion draft trees based on rank-aware list coupling. Existing tree-based diffusion samplers, such as D-GRS, generate K conditionally independent candidate states per node and verify them sequentially in their drafting order. In contrast, RASS ranks the candidates and selects one according to an optimized distribution over ranks designed to maximize the acceptance probability. The selected candidate is accepted according to a maximal-coupling rule based on the target and selected-proposal densities; if rejected, a residual correction step ensures exact sampling from the target distribution. Additionally, the paper derives an upper bound on the acceptance probability achievable by any exact verifier using K independent Gaussian proposals.

Critical strengths

The paper presents a mathematically principled approach to improving speculative verification by exploiting the exchangeability of draft candidates. The formulation connects rank selection to total-variation minimization and provides an exactness guarantee for arbitrary feasible rank weights. The experiments demonstrate improvements in target-call efficiency over existing speculative sampling baselines across several evaluation settings.

Critical weaknesses

A> The evaluation is limited in scope, covering only one text-to-image task, two datasets, and a single model (SD3.5). The authors should evaluate the method on a broader range of modern diffusion architectures, such as PixelDiT[1] for pixel-space generation and FLUX[2] for latent-space generation, to establish its generalizability and practical relevance.

B> The paper should provide a more detailed breakdown of RASS's overhead, including ranking, projection, and residual correction, as current measurements exclude some of these costs. It should also discuss or compare against complementary acceleration methods, such as feature caching (like TeaCache[3]), which reuses intermediate neural-network features to reduce per-step computation. End-to-end latency and performance comparisons would better establish RASS's practical benefits.

C> The novelty of the proposed method appears largely limited to ranking draft candidates and optimizing the rank-selection distribution, building on D-GRS, which is cited as a recent arXiv preprint.

[1] Yu, Y., Xiong, W., Nie, W., Sheng, Y., Liu, S., & Luo, J. (2026). Pixeldit: Pixel diffusion transformers for image generation. In Proceedings of the IEEE/CVF Conference on Computer Vision and Pattern Recognition (pp. 14273-14282).

[2] https://huggingface.co/black-forest-labs/FLUX.2-klein-9b-kv

[3] Liu, F., Zhang, S., Wang, X., Wei, Y., Qiu, H., Zhao, Y., ... & Wan, F. (2025, June). Timestep embedding tells: It’s time to cache for video diffusion model. In 2025 IEEE/CVF Conference on Computer Vision and Pattern Recognition (CVPR) (pp. 7353-7363). IEEE.

Questions for authors

The paper is an interesting read. Please clarify how much additional computation RASS introduces through candidate ranking, high-dimensional projections, rank-weight optimization, and residual correction, individually. How does this overhead affect end-to-end generation latency?

1 comment
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

PixelDiT and FLUX.2 Results, Per-Component Overhead, and Novelty

We thank the reviewer for the review. Each revision is highlighted in color in the updated PDF.

A. Broader architectures. The original evaluation was designed to span the regimes of the normalized mean gap between proposal and target, which governs acceptance: a controlled Gaussian mixture, pixel-space generation on CIFAR-10 and FFHQ, and latent text-to-image generation with SD3.5. We agree that modern architectures strengthen the evidence of generality, and we therefore added both suggested models, each on 100 paired inputs (Sec. 5; red):

  • PixelDiT-XL, a pixel-space transformer for class-conditional ImageNet generation at 256×256256\times256. RASS attains the highest target-call speedup in every configuration, improves on D-GRS by up to 2.3%, and reaches the best speedup of D-GRS with 28% less parallel budget.
  • FLUX.2 [klein] 9B, a latent text-to-image transformer at 512×512512\times512. RASS improves on D-GRS by 1.7–2.8% and reaches the best speedup of D-GRS with half the parallel budget.

B. Overhead per component and end-to-end latency. In the original manuscript, we measured the scalar verification in isolation (App. D.3), since it is the only computation that differs between RASS and D-GRS. We agree that its effect within complete generation is equally relevant, and we therefore added two analyses:

  • We time every phase of complete sampling on CIFAR-10 and PixelDiT, including drafting, projection, ranking, acceptance test, residual correction and rank-weight optimization, with and without precomputed rank weights (App. D.4; purple).
  • We measure the end-to-end latency and peak memory of all samplers on all five models (App. E.4; blue).

We observe:

  • Ranking, that is, sorting the candidates and drawing a rank, takes less than 0.1% of the sampling time.
  • High-dimensional projection takes at most about 1% of a speculative round and is shared by all samplers.
  • Residual correction is the largest component specific to RASS, but it still takes only 0.2-0.7% of the sampling time.
  • Rank-weight optimization adds no cost during sampling. Since the weights depend only on the rounded gap and the number of candidates, they are computed once offline and cached in a table that serves every model, and retrieving them takes less than 0.02% of the sampling time.

Take-away: denoiser evaluations account for 89–97% of the sampling time, whereas all computations specific to RASS account for only 0.2–0.9%. Consequently, RASS generates images faster than D-GRS in six of seven measured configurations, by 1.2-6.0%; in the seventh, both methods require the same number of target calls and their times agree within one standard error. End to end, at the best budget of each method, RASS attains the highest wall-clock speedup among the speculative samplers on every model, up to 1.80×1.80\times on CIFAR-10 and 1.66×1.66\times on FFHQ, with the same peak memory as D-GRS (App. E.4; blue).

Feature caching. We agree that feature caching, such as TeaCache, is relevant, and we discuss it in the related work (App. A; purple). The two approaches are complementary. Feature caching replaces network outputs by reused features and therefore changes the sampling distribution, whereas speculative sampling uses reused quantities only to draft and removes their error exactly through verification. A feature-cached network can therefore serve as the proposal of RASS without affecting exactness.

C. Novelty. RASS is a verification rule within the draft-tree framework, for which D-GRS is the strongest available baseline. Moreover, the rank-aware coupling is not limited to speculative sampling: it applies to every coupling problem with the same structure, namely a Gaussian target and several independent Gaussian proposals that share its isotropic covariance. Its contribution goes beyond ranking:

  1. Ranking alone does not suffice. Always selecting the top-ranked candidate yields a lower target-call speedup than D-GRS in pixel space, whereas the optimized rank distribution gives RASS a higher speedup than D-GRS in every configuration (App. E.7; teal).
  2. Exactness for any rank weights (Thm. 2) requires the order-statistic mixture law of the selected candidate (Prop. 1) and the matching residual correction.
  3. A universal acceptance bound for any exact list coupling of independent Gaussian drafts (Prop. 3), which is strictly tighter than bounds that allow dependent proposals, together with the closed-form acceptance of RASS (Thm. 4). New round-level results connect per-node acceptance to the accepted path length (App. C.5; orange). These results apply to every verifier, including D-GRS.
  4. An efficient and validated implementation, with rank weights solved once offline by a linear program and exact residual sampling, whose verification costs below 1% of the sampling time (App. D.4; purple) and reproduces the target law to numerical precision (App. D.6; green).
Reviewer_Tg5cOpenReview ↗
Rating
3
Confidence
3
Informativeness
2
Presentation
3
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

This paper proposes Rank-Aware Speculative Sampling (RASS), a verification rule for diffusion draft trees. Instead of testing independent draft candidates in generation order, as in D-GRS, RASS ranks them along the proposal-target mean displacement direction and optimizes a distribution over ranks to maximize the overlap between the selected-proposal and target distributions. Maximal coupling and residual correction preserve the target transition law.

Under the assumption of conditionally independent Gaussian proposals sharing the target's isotropic covariance, the paper proves exactness of the ideal verifier and characterizes the optimal acceptance probability attainable by any list-coupling scheme. Experiments on Gaussian mixtures, CIFAR-10, FFHQ and SD3.5-Medium show improved target-call efficiency over D-GRS, with comparable sample-quality metrics. The reported speedups measure reductions in sequential target-model calls rather than end-to-end inference latency.

Critical strengths
  1. Principled verification that makes better use of existing drafts. The paper exploits the exchangeability of independent draft candidates to construct a rank-aware proposal, followed by maximal coupling and residual correction. The exactness guarantee holds for any feasible rank weights under the stated Gaussian assumptions. This provides a principled way to improve draft utilization without retraining the diffusion model or adding target evaluations at a fixed tree configuration.

  2. Useful theoretical benchmark and consistent empirical improvements. The characterization of the optimal acceptance probability for independent Gaussian drafts provides a sharp benchmark for list-based verification, even though RASS need not attain it. The experiments show higher mean target-call efficiency than D-GRS across the evaluated settings, with relative gains reaching 20.9% on CIFAR-10 and useful reductions in the parallel budget needed to reach a given efficiency. The comparable FID and CLIP results are consistent with the distribution-preservation guarantee.

Critical weaknesses

W1. End-to-end acceleration remains unverified. The reduction in sequential target calls is a useful algorithmic result, but its translation into wall-clock acceleration remains uncertain. RASS and D-GRS use the same trees and parallel budgets in the controlled comparisons, so the relevant incremental costs are rank-weight computation and verification. The cached-weight microbenchmarks are encouraging, but do not show how often weight-cache misses occur during actual sampling or how much they contribute to total sampling time. Representative end-to-end GPU latency and peak-memory measurements would help establish whether the call savings yield practical acceleration under realistic batch and cache conditions.

W2. The contribution of rank-weight optimization is not sufficiently isolated. Figure 3 supports the benefit of optimized weights at the single-node level, but their contribution to complete sampling trajectories is not sufficiently isolated. Comparisons with uniform and highest-rank selection, using the same tree, proposal and exact correction, would distinguish the benefit of rank selection from the additional benefit of optimizing its weights. This matters particularly on SD3.5, where the largest matched-tree improvement over D-GRS is 1.93%. The reported parallel-budget savings are valuable, but the per-method confidence intervals do not directly quantify uncertainty in the paired gains. Trajectory-level rank ablations and paired uncertainty estimates would therefore clarify both the source and robustness of the improvement.

Questions for authors

Q1. End-to-end efficiency. Could the authors report representative end-to-end GPU latency and peak-memory measurements for RASS, D-GRS and RMC under comparable parallel budgets, particularly on SD3.5? Please distinguish cold and warm rank-weight caches and report cache-hit rates, so that the contribution of weight optimization to actual sampling time can be assessed.

Q2. Paired uncertainty on SD3.5. Given the shared caption-noise inputs, could the authors report confidence intervals for the paired differences or relative improvements between RASS and D-GRS at fixed tree configurations? This would complement the per-method intervals in Figure 5. If the current estimates are inconclusive, additional paired inputs or seeds would help establish the reliability of the small gains.

Q3. Trajectory-level benefit of optimized rank weights. Figure 3 demonstrates the single-node acceptance benefit of optimized weights. How much does this translate into target-call or latency gains over uniform and highest-rank selection on CIFAR-10 and SD3.5? The alternatives should use the corresponding maximal coupling and residual correction to preserve the same target law.

Q4. Numerical validation of residual sampling. Which residual sampler was used for the main experiments? If inverse-CDF sampling was used, how was the accuracy and completeness of the residual-interval search checked? A comparison against the rejection sampler, or a grid/tolerance sensitivity study in the scalar setting, would help quantify implementation error independently of FID and CLIP.

Q5. Relationship to block verification. The related-work discussion cites Block Verification (Soen et al., 2026). Could the authors provide a representative comparison under comparable sampling and compute settings, or clarify the adaptation barriers and whether the two approaches are complementary? This would help position RASS beyond its direct comparison with D-GRS and RMC.

3 comments
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Latency, Paired SD3.5 Intervals, Rank-Weight Ablation, Residual Sampler and Block Verification

We thank the reviewer for the review. Each revision is highlighted in color in the updated PDF.

W1/Q1. End-to-end latency, peak memory and weight caches. In the manuscript, we report the target-call speedup, the standard hardware-independent metric in speculative sampling. We agree that latency is equally important and added two analyses:

  • We time every phase of complete sampling on CIFAR-10 and PixelDiT, with a precomputed weight table and with a cache emptied before every image (App. D.4; purple).
  • We measure the end-to-end latency and peak memory of all samplers on all five models with 100 paired inputs (App. E.4; blue).

We observe:

  • Weight caches. With a cache emptied before every image, RASS solves 7575–8888 RankWeights instances per image. With a table computed once offline, valid for every model, every lookup is a hit and retrieval takes below 0.02% of the sampling time.
  • Overhead. Denoiser evaluations account for 89-97% of the sampling time, whereas all computations specific to RASS account for only 0.2-0.9%. Consequently, RASS generates images faster than D-GRS in six of seven measured configurations, by 1.2–6.0%; in the seventh, both require the same number of target calls and their times agree within one standard error.
  • Latency and memory. At the best budget of each method, RASS attains the highest wall-clock speedup among the speculative samplers on every model, including SD3.5, and up to 1.80×1.80\times on CIFAR-10 and 1.66×1.66\times on FFHQ, with the same peak memory as D-GRS.

Q2. Paired uncertainty on SD3.5. We agree that paired intervals are needed. Using the 100 shared caption–noise inputs of the SD3.5 runs in Figure 6, we computed, for each tree with branching factor KK and depth LL, the paired 95% confidence interval of the relative improvement of RASS over D-GRS in target-call speedup. The improvement is positive in all ten trees (+0.2 to +1.4%), and its interval excludes zero for (K,L)∈{(5,2),(6,2),(4,3)}(K,L)\in\{(5,2),(6,2),(4,3)\}, e.g., +1.30±1.13+1.30\pm1.13% at K=6K=6, L=2L=2, confirmed by independent runs with 0.700.70 calls saved per image (95% interval [0.31,1.10][0.31,1.10]; App. E.6; orange). For the other trees, the intervals include zero. This is expected from App. E.6: on SD3.5, most nodes have large gaps, at which all verifiers rarely accept, so the attainable gain is small.

W2/Q3. Contribution of the optimized weights. At matched trees and budgets, with the same proposal and exact correction, we compare the optimized weights ω⋆\omega^\star with top-rank and uniform rank selection (App. E.7; teal). Take-away: RASS adapts to every regime because ω⋆\omega^\star solves Eq. (12), interpolating between uniform selection at small gaps and top-rank selection at large gaps. On CIFAR-10 and FFHQ, ω⋆\omega^\star improves on top-rank selection by 6.3–25.0% and on uniform selection by 5.2–15.5%, while top-rank selection alone is slower than D-GRS. On SD3.5, where most gaps are large, RASS reduces to top-rank selection and outperforms uniform selection by 1.2–4.5%.

Q4. Residual sampler. All target-call and sample-quality experiments use the inverse-CDF sampler (Sec. 5; red). We validate it against high-resolution references, including an independent residual CDF, through three tests (App. D.6; green):

  1. Interval detection and grid sensitivity. We compare the intervals and masses found by the 513-point crossing search with those of much finer searches and an independent quadrature. Missed intervals are rare and carry at most 7.3×10−97.3\times10^{-9} for K≤6K\le6, which equals the total-variation error of one verification; a grid of 8,193 points removes all misses up to K=15K=15.
  2. Quantile accuracy. An exact inverse-CDF sampler maps u∈(0,1)u\in(0,1) to the uu-quantile of the residual law. For about 20,000 values of uu, including extreme tails and interval boundaries, the reference CDF at the returned point matches uu to within 8.4×10−148.4\times10^{-14}.
  3. Output law. Kolmogorov–Smirnov tests on 10610^6 outputs of the complete verifier find no deviation from the target law and no difference between the inverse-CDF and rejection samplers.

Take-away: the implemented correction is exact to numerical precision.

Q5. Block verification. Block verification was developed concurrently with our work. By verifying a single drafted chain jointly, it is an alternative to draft trees and a natural baseline. Its adaptation requires care with the reuse of target evaluations: after a rejection, it draws the component orthogonal to the mean gap independently of the drafts. We therefore evaluate it under three prefetch policies, together with RMC and D-GRS under its most effective one (App. E.2; brown). Block verification improves on RMC, as reported by its authors, whereas D-GRS attains a higher target-call speedup at almost every budget.

Thank you for the substantial revision. The numerical validation of residual sampling, the paired SD3.5 analysis, and the rank-weight ablations address my main questions. The ablations clarify where optimizing the weights helps and why top-rank selection performs nearly identically on SD3.5.

I am maintaining my rating of 3 (Weak acceptance). The verification rule and the acceptance bound for independent Gaussian drafts are useful contributions, and the revision makes the scope of the empirical gains clearer.

Thank you for your constructive comments throughout the review process. We are pleased that the additional analyses have addressed your questions. We would be happy to provide further clarification if needed.

Reviewer_6jFbOpenReview ↗
Rating
3(+1)
Confidence
3
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

RASS improves verification of diffusion draft trees with independent equal-covariance Gaussian proposals. It projects candidates onto the target–proposal mean direction, samples a rank using weights determined by the normalized mean gap, derives the resulting order-statistic mixture density, and maximally couples that selected distribution to the target. Rejection uses a residual correction distribution. The paper also characterizes the optimal acceptance probability for an independent candidate list and evaluates target-call efficiency on synthetic, pixel-space, and text-to-image settings. The theoretical contribution is useful; practical runtime, numerical verification, and the connection between local acceptance and full-trajectory efficiency remain less fully established.

Critical strengths
  1. The method corrects for the distribution induced by selection. Proposition 1 derives the selected-child density from a mixture of beta order-statistic densities. Acceptance and residual correction then use that distribution rather than the original single-child proposal. This addresses the selection bias directly, and Theorem 2 preserves the target law for any feasible fixed rank weights, even when those weights are only approximately optimized.
  2. The acceptance bound provides a useful theoretical benchmark. Proposition 3 characterizes the best achievable acceptance from an independent Gaussian candidate list. Comparing the practical rank-mixture family with this limit separates shortcomings of a verifier from limitations of the available candidates. The projection construction also explains why the scalar verification problem can be independent of the ambient state dimension.
  3. The experiments control the candidate-tree comparison. RASS and D-GRS are tested with matched tree configurations and proposal construction across multiple churn levels, alongside a chain-based baseline. The paper reports a substantial relative gain in some CIFAR-10 configurations and smaller gains on FFHQ and SD3.5. Appendix E.2 additionally considers internal-node evaluation, showing that the leaf-evaluation policy affects the compute tradeoff.
Critical weaknesses
  1. Target-call savings do not yet establish a practical speed benefit. The paper correctly labels its main metric as target-call speedup. However, one call can evaluate a large draft-tree batch, and Appendix D.3 excludes model execution, projections, and uncached rank optimization from the cached-weight verification timings. An uncached solve costs roughly 5.8–8 ms. Without measured cache-hit rates and end-to-end batch costs, it is unclear when the method improves runtime, especially for SD3.5 where the reported best means are 1.152× for RASS and 1.142× for D-GRS.

  2. The numerical correction needs a more direct exactness check. Appendix D.2 uses a 513-point crossing search for inverse-CDF residual sampling and explicitly notes that a finite grid does not guarantee finding every residual interval. Its two-tail example shows why missing a small component matters. FID, CLIP, and visual examples do not test this issue directly. Appendix D.4 correctly distinguishes the ideal theorem from implementation error, but there is no targeted residual-mass or scalar-distribution diagnostic demonstrating that the implemented correction is sufficiently accurate.

  3. The acceptance objective is local while the claimed efficiency benefit is sequential. Equation (12) maximizes immediate overlap for one candidate list, and Proposition 3 bounds acceptance at that node. Neither establishes that this choice maximizes committed path length or minimizes target calls across rounds: the accepted state and retained evaluation affect subsequent proposal quality. Figure 3 shows that the advantage depends on the normalized mean gap, but the experiments do not connect encountered gap distributions and tree depths to the much smaller SD3.5 gains. This leaves the conditions under which the theoretical advantage translates into useful trajectory-level improvement insufficiently explained.

  4. The contribution of the optimized rank weights is not isolated. RASS adds two components over D-GRS: ranking the children, and selecting a rank with weights ω* from a linear program. The experiments evaluate only their combination. By Theorem 2, simpler weights, such as always selecting the top-ranked child, are equally exact and avoid the linear program and its cache-miss cost; ω affects only speedup. Figure 6 shows that ω* is near uniform as δ → 0 and nearly all on the top rank for δ ≳ 2 (K = 4). Without the encountered δ distribution or an end-to-end comparison, it is unclear whether the optimization matters in practice.

Questions for authors
  1. Please report end-to-end latency and peak memory for representative fixed tree budgets, including tree construction, projections, synchronization, residual correction, and cold versus warm rank-weight caches. What cache-hit rate occurs along actual SD3.5 trajectories, and where is the runtime break-even point against D-GRS?
  2. Which residual sampler produced the main experimental results? Can you validate the scalar output law across representative and adversarial mean gaps, including cases with multiple residual intervals, and compare the inverse-CDF implementation with the rejection-sampling alternative? Please quantify any missed mass or numerical discrepancy.
  3. Can you relate the encountered normalized mean gaps, accepted tree depths, and subsequent proposal quality to the measured target-call gains? In particular, what limits SD3.5, and how much of the gain remains under a common parent-only cache policy? This would separate immediate rank-selection gains from effects mediated by prefetching.
  4. At matched trees and budgets, how does the speedup of fixed top-rank weights compare with ω* on CIFAR-10 and SD3.5, and what fraction of verified nodes falls in the δ range where they differ?
3 comments
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Latency, Residual Exactness, Trajectory-Level Gains and Rank Weights

We thank the reviewer for the thorough review.

W1/Q1. Latency, memory, cache hits and break-even. In the main manuscript, we report the target-call speedup, the standard metric in speculative sampling, which measures sequential work independently of the hardware. We agree that wall-clock time is equally important in practice and added two analyses:

  • We time every phase of complete generation on CIFAR-10 and PixelDiT, including drafting, projection, ranking, acceptance test and residual correction, with warm and cold weight caches (App. D.4; purple).
  • We measure the wall-clock time and peak memory of all samplers on all five models (App. E.4; blue).

We observe:

  • At the best budget of each method, RASS attains the highest wall-clock speedup among the speculative samplers on every model, including SD3.5, with the same peak memory as D-GRS.
  • Target evaluation accounts for 89–97% of the sampling time, the dd-dimensional projection for at most about 1% of a round (shared by all methods), and RASS's scalar verification for only 0.2–0.9%. With an empty cache, solving RankWeights would increase the sampling time by 6–84%. With a precomputed table, valid for every model since the weights depend only on (δ~,K)(\tilde\delta,K), every lookup is a hit.
  • Break-even against D-GRS: both methods pay the same cost cˉ\bar c per round and differ only in the number NcN_{\mathrm{c}} of target calls and the verification time VV per image (App. D.4). RASS is therefore faster whenever (NcD-GRS−NcRASS),cˉ>VRASS−VD-GRS(N{\text{c}}^{\text{D-GRS}}-N{\text{c}}^{\text{RASS}}),\bar c > V^{\text{RASS}}-V^{\text{D-GRS}}. With the measured costs, saving 0.10.1–0.40.4 calls per image suffices, whereas RASS saves 1.11.1–2.22.2 in six of seven configurations and is then faster by 1.2-6.0%.

W2/Q2. Residual sampler. All target-call and sample-quality experiments use the inverse-CDF sampler (Sec. 5; red). We provide the requested diagnostics (App. D.6; green) against high-resolution references, including an independently implemented residual CDF, through three tests:

  1. Interval detection. We compare the residual intervals and masses of the crossing search with a much finer search and an independent quadrature, including adversarial gaps and residuals with up to four intervals. Missed intervals are rare and carry at most 7.3×10−97.3\times10^{-9} for K≤6K\le6. This equals the total-variation error of one verification and bounds the trajectory error below 10−610^{-6} (App. D.5).
  2. Quantile accuracy. An exact inverse-CDF sampler maps u∈(0,1)u\in(0,1) to the uu-quantile of the residual law. For about 20,000 values of uu, including extreme tails and interval boundaries, we evaluate the reference CDF at the returned point, which should equal uu. The largest error is 8.4×10−148.4\times10^{-14}.
  3. Output law. We run the complete verifier for 10610^6 trials and compare its outputs with the target law, and with those of the rejection sampler, using Kolmogorov–Smirnov tests. All distances are below 0.00140.0014, a value that an exact sampler exceeds with probability at most 5% (Dvoretzky–Kiefer–Wolfowitz inequality), and a two-sample test finds no difference between the samplers.

Take-away: the implemented correction is exact to numerical precision.

W3/Q3. From per-node acceptance to trajectories. Per-node objectives are standard in the literature, e.g., in RMC and D-GRS. However, we agree that Eq. (12) is local. Therefore, we prove that a per-node advantage yields a stochastically longer accepted path whenever the encountered gaps are not larger (Prop. 5, Cor. 6; App. C.5; orange), and we record δ\delta, depth and acceptance at every verification (App. E.6; orange):

  • Per node, the advantage over D-GRS is largest at δ∈[0.5,1)\delta\in[0.5,1) and vanishes for δ≥4\delta\ge4.
  • 77% of CIFAR-10 nodes have δ<2\delta<2, whereas 68% of SD3.5 nodes have δ≥4\delta\ge4. On SD3.5, the median gap is 5.045.04 at the root and 9.719.71 at depth one, so rounds rarely pass the root. At the median gap (5.835.83), Prop. 3 caps the acceptance of any exact verifier with K=6K=6 at 0.0080.008, which limits SD3.5.
  • Parent-only cache: on CIFAR-10, the RASS advantage persists (1.811.81 vs. 1.361.36 calls saved over D-GRS), an immediate effect of rank selection. On SD3.5, every method falls to 1.00×1.00\times, so its gain is mediated by prefetching, which lowers the median root gap from 13.3113.31 to 5.045.04.

W4/Q4. Top-rank vs. ω⋆\omega^\star. We define the range of gaps where the two weights differ as (0,δK♯)(0,\delta_K^\sharp), with δK♯=sup⁡{δ>0:αK(δ;ω⋆)−αK(δ;ωmax⁡)≥10−3}\delta_K^\sharp=\sup\{\delta>0:\alpha_K(\delta;\omega^\star)-\alpha_K(\delta;\omega^{\max})\ge10^{-3}\} (App. E.7; teal). On CIFAR-10, this range contains 28–65% of the nodes, and on SD3.5 only 0.1–8.8%. Accordingly, at matched trees and budgets, ω⋆\omega^\star outperforms top-rank selection by 6.3–25.0% in pixel space, where top-rank selection alone is slower than D-GRS, whereas on SD3.5 the two coincide.

Reviewer_6jFbOpenReview ↗

Response after rebuttal

Thank you for the clarifications and additional experiments. The residual-sampling diagnostics, rank-weight ablations, and timing analysis address my main concerns. While practical speedups remain limited on some models, the new evidence strengthens the paper’s contribution to exact draft-tree verification. I will therefore raise my rating from 2 to 3. Please retain the qualifications on practical speedups and conditional trajectory-level guarantees.

AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Thank You for Your Support and Willingness to Increase Your Score

Thank you very much for your time and acknowledging that our clarifications and additional experiments have addressed your concerns!

We appreciate your willingness to raise your score from 2 to 3. Your feedback has helped us substantially strengthen the paper, and we are grateful for your support and encouragement.

Thank you again for your time and reconsideration!

Comments on the paper

2 comments
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Summary of Revisions

We thank all reviewers for their constructive reviews.

As several questions were shared, we summarize the main revisions here. Each revision is highlighted in a distinct color in the updated PDF, and the individual responses refer to the same colors.

1. Broader evaluation. We added PixelDiT-XL (ImageNet 2562256^2, pixel space) and FLUX.2 [klein] 9B (text-to-image 5122512^2, latent space), each on 100 paired inputs (Sec. 5; red). RASS attains the highest target-call speedup in every configuration of both models. On PixelDiT, it improves on D-GRS by up to 2.3% and reaches the best speedup of D-GRS with 28% less parallel budget; on FLUX.2, it improves on D-GRS by 1.7–2.8% and matches its best speedup with half the budget. We also compare with block verification (App. E.2; brown), which improves on RMC but attains a lower speedup than D-GRS at almost every budget under a common prefetch policy.

2. Wall-clock time and peak memory (App. E.4; blue). We measure the end-to-end latency of all methods on all five models. Take-away: at the best budget of each method, RASS attains the highest wall-clock speedup among the speculative samplers on every model, and on CIFAR-10 and FFHQ it accelerates generation by up to 1.80×1.80\times and 1.66×1.66\times. Its peak memory is identical to that of D-GRS.

3. Overhead within complete generation (App. D.4; purple). We time every phase of sampling, including ranking, projection, rank-weight optimization and residual correction, with warm and cold weight caches. Take-away: the denoiser evaluations account for 89–97% of the sampling time, whereas all computations specific to RASS account for only 0.2–0.9%. The rank weights depend only on (δ~,K)(\tilde\delta, K), so a single offline table serves every model. As a result, RASS generates images faster than D-GRS in six of seven measured configurations, by 1.2–6.0%; in the seventh, both methods require the same number of target calls and their generation times agree within one standard error.

4. Numerical validation of the residual sampler (App. D.6; green). We validate the inverse-CDF sampler against high-resolution references, including an independently implemented residual CDF, through three tests: (i) interval detection over 5,202 configurations, including adversarial gaps and residuals with up to four intervals; (ii) the accuracy of about 20,000 quantiles, including extreme tails and interval boundaries; and (iii) Kolmogorov–Smirnov tests of the output law of the complete verifier over 10610^6 trials, against the target law and against the rejection sampler. Take-away: the implementation is exact to numerical precision. The total-variation error per verification is at most 7.3×10−97.3\times10^{-9} for K≤6K\le6, quantile errors are at most 8.4×10−148.4\times10^{-14}, and the tests detect no systematic deviation from the target law.

5. From per-node acceptance to trajectories (App. C.5 and E.6; orange). We prove round-level results showing that, at comparable gaps, a per-node advantage yields a stochastically longer accepted path (Prop. 5, Cor. 6). We then record the normalized gap δ\delta, accepted depth and acceptance at every verification on CIFAR-10 and SD3.5, under the nearest-node and parent-only cache policies. Take-away: the gain of speculation depends on the regime of δ\delta, since acceptance is high for small δ\delta and vanishes for large δ\delta. Prefetching moves the proposals towards the favorable regime, lowering the median root gap from 1.891.89 to 0.090.09 on CIFAR-10 and from 13.3113.31 to 5.045.04 on SD3.5, and within each regime RASS accepts most often. The smaller SD3.5 gains arise because 68% of its nodes remain at δ≥4\delta\ge4, whereas on CIFAR-10 the advantage of RASS persists under a common parent-only cache.

6. Contribution of the optimized rank weights (App. E.7; teal). At matched trees and budgets, we compare RASS with uniform and top-rank selection, with the same proposal and exact correction, and measure the fraction of verified nodes at which the weights differ. Take-away: RASS adapts to every regime because it uses the optimal solution of Eq. (12), which interpolates between uniform selection for small δ\delta and top-rank selection for large δ\delta. Its gain over these fixed choices therefore depends on δ\delta. In pixel space, where 28–65% of the nodes lie where the weights differ, RASS improves on top-rank selection by 6.3–25.0% and on uniform selection by 5.2–15.5%, while top-rank selection alone is slower than D-GRS. On SD3.5, RASS reduces to top-rank selection and outperforms uniform selection.

Overall, the new results confirm the conclusions of the submission. RASS improves target-call efficiency over D-GRS on all evaluated models, its verification overhead is below 1% of the sampling time, and its implementation reproduces the target law to numerical precision. We address the remaining points in the individual responses.

Dear Reviewers,

The authors have submitted their rebuttal. Please review it and share your comments. If anything is unclear or requires clarification, please let the authors know as soon as possible. The author–reviewer discussion period ends on 18 November.

Best regards,

AC

From OpenReview, CC BY 4.0. Authors as signed there; shown unedited.

Related papers

Loading the map…

Discussion (0)

Sign in to comment.