- Rating
- 3
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
LatticeSpike runs alongside a frozen language model and detects hallucinations token by token as the response is being generated. It first maps hidden states and prediction signals into box embeddings, where the box volume represents the spread of the model’s semantic state. A volume-modulated recurrent spiking network then predicts its next state, and the prediction error is used as the token-level hallucination score. The authors also introduce the THRIVE-Llama and THRIVE-Gemma datasets and compare the method with 12 baselines on four corpora under a strictly causal protocol. The method achieves strong average precision and AUROC results overall.
Critical strengths
It supports real-time, token-level hallucination detection without using future tokens or modifying the generator.
The paper releases two relatively large datasets and validates them through multiple-model judging, human annotation, and statistical testing.
Critical weaknesses
LatticeSpike does not outperform all alternatives at every low-false-positive operating point. For some fixed FPR settings, Transformer-based replacement models perform better.
The THRIVE datasets mainly use a small number of open-source generators, greedy decoding, and a fixed response length. It is still unclear whether the method will generalize to larger models, stochastic decoding, multilingual generation, or interactive systems.
Questions for authors
LatticeSpike does not outperform all alternatives at every low-false-positive operating point. For some fixed FPR settings, Transformer-based replacement models perform better.
The THRIVE datasets mainly use a small number of open-source generators, greedy decoding, and a fixed response length. It is still unclear whether the method will generalize to larger models, stochastic decoding, multilingual generation, or interactive systems.
4 comments
Response 1
Reviewer wj6k - Response 1
Reviewer Point
"LatticeSpike does not outperform all alternatives at every low-false-positive operating point. For some fixed FPR settings, Transformer-based replacement models perform better."
Author Response
We agree that LatticeSpike does not uniformly dominate the parameter-matched Transformer replacement at every low-FPR operating point. However, it is important to note that this result comes from the controlled architectural ablation, where only the SNN dynamics layer is replaced for an attention mechanism, while the box encoder, six input channels, training objective, data split, checkpoint selection, and evaluation protocol are held fixed. Thus, the transformer variant similarly leverages several of our novel architectural contributions — particularly the box encoder and the concretization channel (our largest signal driver), alongside the rest of the six-channel input, the reconstruction-anomaly scoring, and the training objective — a likely explanation as to what drove its performance beyond attention alone.
Nevertheless, we believe future work could explore a hybrid architecture, as noted in the future work section of the paper. Such a framework would ideally leverage and combine the relative strengths from each design, such as the SNN supplying ranking quality (AP and AUROC) with the transformer supplying detection quality at tighter FPR budgets.
Reviewer Point
"The THRIVE datasets mainly use a small number of open-source generators, greedy decoding, and a fixed response length."
Author Response
Generators. Rather than focusing on breadth of generators, with THRIVE we instead wanted to focus on depth, while still expanding our reach to two distinct generator families and models (Llama-3.2-1B-Instruct and Gemma-2-2b-it); thus, we opted to release only two datasets but of of high quality, each having been validated by humans and statistically tested for quality control purposes.
Moreover, the dataset construction pipeline and code exists such that future work can easily build on these two datasets by expanding THRIVE's reach to other generator families.
As for LatticeSpike, our detection framework as tested extends well past the two generator mark. Beyond THRIVE, the paper evaluates LatticeSpike on RAGTruth (Llama-2-7b-chat) and TriviaQA (Qwen3-8B), and in this rebuttal we add three additional generators, one of which is a larger model (Qwen3-32b, shown below) and the other two which are very recent generators (Gemma 4 E4B and Qwen3.5-9B, shown in our response to Reviewer Cukc). LatticeSpike successfully generalizes across all 7 generators despite these varying in size, family, and recency — demonstrating its robustness and versatility.
Decoding. THRIVE uses greedy decoding by design, so that hallucinations reflect the generator's most likely output rather than sampling noise. Stochastic decoding is nonetheless already covered by our evaluation: every RAGTruth response (all 2,965) was sampled at temperatures between 0.7 and 1.0, so all RAGTruth results in the paper, and those included in the comparison with CHARM (Reviewer Cukc rebuttal), are on stochastically decoded text.
Response length. The 512-token limit is a generation cap, not a fixed length; actual responses vary widely and the vast majority of them fall within this limit. On THRIVE-L, responses have a median of 29 tokens (10th–90th percentile: 14–278); on THRIVE-G, a median of 9 tokens (10th–90th percentile: 4–49). Only 1.8% of THRIVE-L responses and 0.02% of THRIVE-G responses ever reach the cap. The cap, therefore, has a negligible effect on either dataset.
Response 2
Reviewer wj6k - Response 2
Reviewer Point
"It is still unclear whether the method will generalize to larger models, stochastic decoding, multilingual generation, or interactive systems."
Author Response
Larger models. To answer the question of whether LatticeSpike generalizes to larger models, we evaluated LatticeSpike on Qwen3-32B, the 4× larger sibling of the paper's TriviaQA generator (Qwen3-8B), using the identical data pipeline and model architecture as the one reported in the paper. Only one training hyperparameter was modified, concretization channel scaling (1 → 12), which we found allowed our model to converge quicker — resulting in a more energy efficient model — while maintaining or even improving performance.
Table 1 reports Qwen3-32B and Qwen3-8B TriviaQA test results for LatticeSpike. Values are mean ± sd over five seeds (42-46). Each generator produces its own answers and therefore its own labelled dataset, so the share of hallucinated tokens differs across rows. Importantly, AP, precision and F1 depend on that share, so they are not directly comparable across generators, AUROC and recall at a fixed false-positive rate are. The Qwen3-8B row represents the paper's reported numbers for LatticeSpike on TriviaQA. The Qwen3-32B run was carried out on a larger GPU (NVIDIA H200) compared to the Qwen3-8B run (NVIDIA RTX 5090) due to the increased GPU capacity requirements of the 32B model.
| Generator | Hallucinated tokens | AP | AP / random | AUROC | R@1% FPR | P@1% FPR | P / random | F1@1% FPR | F1 / random |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Qwen3-8B (paper) | 4.7% | 0.399 ± 0.008 | 8.5× | 0.888 ± 0.005 | 0.250 ± 0.002 | 0.577 ± 0.002 | 12.3× | 0.349 ± 0.003 | 21.2× |
| Qwen3-32B | 3.6% | 0.301 ± 0.014 | 8.4× | 0.866 ± 0.006 | 0.226 ± 0.018 | 0.456 ± 0.020 | 12.8× | 0.302 ± 0.021 | 19.3× |
Table 1: LatticeSpike results on a 4x larger model, as evaluated on TriviaQA. The table shows hallucinated token percentage, AP, AUROC, and recall, precision, and F1 at FPR ≤ 1% across generators; where applicable, "metric / random" columns divide each metric by a random detector's value.
As shown in the results, LatticeSpike successfully transfers to larger generators without architectural changes. Concretely, our model's improvement over a random detector is nearly identical across both generators on AP, precision, and F1: AP 8.4× (32B) vs. 8.5× (8B), precision at 1% FPR 12.8× (32B) vs. 12.3× (8B), F1 at 1% FPR 19.3× (32B) vs. 21.2× (8B). Moreover, on AUROC and recall LatticeSpike performs similarly on both language models — reaffirming its generalizability across generators of varying sizes.
Stochastic decoding. As mentioned in response 1, stochastic decoding is already covered by our evaluation: every RAGTruth response (all 2,965) was sampled at temperatures between 0.7 and 1.0. All RAGTruth results in the paper and in this rebuttal for Reviewer Cukc's response, including the comparison with CHARM, are therefore on stochastically decoded text.
Interactive systems. LatticeSpike is designed for interactive use. It scores each token causally while the response is being generated, using only the generator's internal state up to that step; each score is computed before the token is emitted, so a deployed system can stop, flag, or regenerate as soon as a hallucination is anticipated, rather than after the full response is shown. Our deployment benchmark noted in the paper measures this setting (Section 5.2), additionally we run a subsequent deployment benchmark as part of Reviewer Cukc's rebuttal response (Table 2), where we show the detector running token by token alongside the generator (23.3 ms per token including generation).
Furthermore, because historical user-to-language-model conversation enters the generator as context, which LatticeSpike reads through the generator's internal states, we expect the method to carry over to multi-turn settings; in fact, RAGTruth already hints at this with long conditioning contexts of up to ~2,600 tokens. However, a dedicated multi-turn evaluation, where hallucinations may depend on earlier turns, remains future work.
Multilingual generation. We agree that this remains untested, as it was out-of-scope for the current iteration of this project. All of our benchmarks are in English, and token-level hallucination labels in other languages would require a multilingual annotation pipeline, along with a multilingual training protocol for LatticeSpike. We note this explicitly as a limitation and a direction for future work.
Dear Reviewer wj6k,
Thank you again for your positive review. With the discussion period ending on November 18, 2026, we wanted to check whether our responses have addressed your two points. In brief:
- Low-FPR operating points. We agree the Transformer variant leads at some tight FPR budgets. That variant is our own ablation: it keeps LatticeSpike's box encoder, input channels, scoring, and loss. None of the thresholded differences between the two is statistically significant in either direction, while the spiking layer's AUROC advantage is significant against all four replacements.
- Generalization. We added three generators using the paper's TriviaQA pipeline unchanged. Two are recent models (Gemma 4 E4B and Qwen3.5-9B) and one is larger (Qwen3-32B, 4× the paper's Qwen3-8B). AUROC stays between 0.86 and 0.91, and the gain over a random detector is comparable to the paper's results.
- Stochastic decoding. All RAGTruth responses were sampled at temperatures of 0.7–1.0, so every RAGTruth result, including the new CHARM comparison, is on stochastically decoded text.
- Response length. THRIVE's 512-token limit is a cap, not a fixed length: only 1.8% (THRIVE-L) and 0.02% (THRIVE-G) of responses reach it.
- Interactive and multilingual use. LatticeSpike scores each token causally during generation. Multi-turn and multilingual evaluation remain future work, and we will state both explicitly as limitations.
If anything remains unclear, we would be happy to clarify. If our responses have resolved your concerns, we would appreciate your consideration in your final assessment.
Best regards, The Authors
Initial Comment
We thank reviewer wj6k for their time and review of our paper. Below we provide experimental results, answers, and clarifications regarding their review points.