- Rating
- 3
- Confidence
- 3(+1)
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 3
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes wallpaper-group-equivariant message passing to model graphs relative to a periodic two-dimensional background. It introduces we3nn, a library for finite-group-equivariant neural networks, and evaluates the framework on synthetic benchmarks covering all 17 wallpaper groups. The framework is further applied to interatomic potential modeling for molecules adsorbed on graphene, using adsorbate-only graphs without explicitly representing substrate atoms.
Critical strengths
Strong theoretical contribution: wallpaper-group equivariance, Wyckoff-anchor encoding, nonsymmorphic translation-suborbit handling. A well-motivated approach to incorporating substrate symmetry. Encoding the fixed substrate through symmetry-aware positional features addresses a meaningful limitation of molecular graphs that otherwise omit the substrate environment. The combination of anchor displacements and member labels provides a concrete mechanism for retaining substrate-relative information.
Critical weaknesses
Frankly speaking I am not so familiar with your research area. Only a little suggestion is that I think the presentation is not clear enough to follow. This paper may lack a single overview figure that let readers quickly follow the problem and motivation. Besides, the main experiments relies on Tables, with useful result visualization deferred to the Appendix. I think it is useful to visulize the results clearly in the main paper.
Questions for authors
See weakness
4 comments
Figure 1 updated
Dear Reviewer,
To improve the readability and accessibility of the paper, we have prepared a new overview figure (Figure 1) that visually summarizes the main building blocks of the WallpaperNet framework.
The figure illustrates:
- (a) How wallpaper-group symmetries act on a molecular graph on a periodic substrate, including the transformation of Wyckoff-anchor (WA) vectors.
- (b) Which geometric and node features are used for message construction.
- (c–d) The two approaches to symmetry-preserving message passing: equivariant and invariant GNNs. For the equivariant approach, we illustrate how regular-representation channels are permuted under symmetry operations. For the invariant approach, we visualize an angular invariant with a periodicity of 60 and how invariant coefficients are used to construct equivariant vector features.
- (e) How WA translation-suborbit labeling works for nonsymmorphic wallpaper groups, illustrated using glide reflections in pgg.
We would greatly appreciate your feedback on whether this new figure improves the accessibility of the paper and provides a more intuitive introduction to the concepts and building blocks presented in Section 3.
Additionally, we have added two illustrations related to our molecular adsorption experiments on graphene. Figure 4 (page 62) provides an atomistic visualization of the system depicted schematically in Figure 1(a), while Figure 5 (page 63) illustrates why the position of a molecular graph relative to the underlying graphene lattice is important for these simulations.
We have not yet revised the main text , but we are currently working on improving. Given the short rebuttal period, we wanted to share these new figures with you first and ask whether you think they are a step in the right direction.
Improving the presentation
Dear Reviewer,
Based on your feedback, we modified the main text of the paper to make it easier to follow, The text highlighted in blue contains revisions aimed at improving the clarity, readability, and straightforwardness of the presentation. We additionally revised the main figure.
We hope these revisions address your main concern. We still have a little bit of time, before the rebuttal period ends, so if there are any additional suggestions from your side, we have still time to add them.
Looking forward to any additional feedback!
Thanks for your rebuttal,I am satisfied with your effort and increase my confidence to 3.
Overview image request
Dear Reviewer,
Thank you for your feedback and for your openness about your specialization in a different area of representation learning. We see your expertise as an advantage for our paper. We have seen that researchers from different backgrounds are finding applications of geometric deep learning in their areas, such as combining it with LLMs or flow-matching models, or connecting it more closely to physics. So it is in our interest to make our paper as accessible as possible. We are already working on restructuring Section 3, and we think that introducing an overview figure is a great idea! If you don’t mind, we will run it by you before Sunday to make sure that it connects well with the theoretical part of the paper. We are planning to base it on one of the illustrations in Appendix C, showing two graphs: the original and a transformed version, with their corresponding Wyckoff anchors. We will show which elements go into which building blocks described in the paper (Wyckoff-anchor features, translation-suborbit member labels, and interatomic distances).
Is there something in particular that in your opinion would help make paper more straight-forward?