- Rating
- 3
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 3
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
The paper proposes a retrieval intent modeling method for CoVR task. The method achieves more precise modification and selective preservation through component-by-granularity CSP representation, explicit-intent-guided localized modification, and implicit-intent-guided granularity selection, raising R@1 from 25.84 to 35.06 on FineCVR-1M.
Critical strengths
- The paper is well-written and easy to understand.
- Implicit intent is indeed crucial for CoVR, and the method is well-motivated.
- Experimental results validate the effectiveness of the proposed method.
Critical weaknesses
- There is a lack of comparison with recent state-of-the-art methods, such as HUD (Chen et al., 2025), REFINE (Hu et al., 2026), and ReTrack (Li et al., 2026).
- Why does CSP utilize Qwen 3-VL, whereas EMS employs the clustering method from FDCA to decompose display intent? Would using Qwen 3-VL yield better results?
- The paper interprets the granularity attention produced by IGAM as implicit retrieval intent. However, since no explicit supervision or ground-truth annotation of implicit intent is provided, it remains unclear whether these attention weights genuinely capture user intent or merely reflect retrieval-optimized granularity weighting. Could the authors provide stronger quantitative or human-aligned evidence validating this interpretation?
Questions for authors
See the weaknesses above.
3 comments
Thank you for your rebuttal, all my concerns have been addressed. So I keep my score.
Thank You for the Constructive Review and Future Directions
Thank you for your careful review and constructive feedback. We are glad that our responses have addressed your concerns. Your suggestions strengthened our comparisons and intent validation, while the proposed Qwen3-VL alternative also highlighted a valuable direction for future intent parsing.
Response to Reviewer z56y: Additional Comparisons and Intent Validation
Thank you for your constructive review. Below, we add comparisons with REFINE and ReTrack, evaluate Qwen3-VL for component selection, and provide human-aligned and query-dependent evidence for IGAM. In the revised PDF, the changes discussed below are marked in blue.
w1:Comparisons with HUD, REFINE, and ReTrack.
HUD is already included in Table 1 of our submitted manuscript. We additionally evaluate REFINE and ReTrack using their official implementations, training on the FineCVR-1M training split and evaluating on the same test split as IC-CoVR.
We have added the REFINE and ReTrack results to Table 1 (p. 7, lines 331–332) and included their references.
w2:Why use FDCA-based parsing in EMS rather than Qwen3-VL?
In our framework, Qwen3-VL constructs query-independent CSP representations, whereas EMS makes query-specific modification decisions. While Qwen can also select the component to modify, EMS additionally needs to align the operation intent with that component and produce retrieval-relevant features, motivating an integrated framework optimized under retrieval supervision.
We directly compared the two choices by replacing BIP’s component selection with a component index predicted by Qwen3-VL, keeping the remaining pipeline unchanged. Results evaluated after EMS and before IPS are:
Qwen-based selection reduces R@1 by 2.51 percentage points. Thus, while Qwen offers a feasible alternative for component selection, BIP achieves higher top-1 retrieval accuracy in this comparison.
w3:Quantitative and human-aligned evidence that IGAM’s weights capture implicit retrieval intent.
IGAM’s granularity weights are optimized for retrieval without intent labels. We test whether this “retrieval-optimized granularity weighting” also reflects human judgments of what to preserve and changes with the query context.
Five annotators rated how much detail each CSP component needed to preserve for retrieval across 100 triplets, using a 1–3 scale in increments of 0.5, where higher scores indicate finer granularity. Of these, 80 triplets were rated by one annotator each, and 20 by all five, using the median per component as the human score. The model score is wc+2wm+3wf, rounded to the nearest 0.5, where wc, wm, and wf are the coarse, middle, and fine weights. Across all 300 component-level comparisons, agreement with human judgments reaches Spearman’s ρ=0.768 and quadratic-weighted Cohen’s κ=0.727. Inter-annotator Fleiss’ κ on the 20 jointly rated triplets is 0.652.
Additionally, with the reference video and CSP held fixed, changing the modification text yields a video-averaged variation between granularity-weight distributions of 0.1173, measured across 8,227 text pairs sharing 802 reference videos. This shows that IGAM adjusts its granularity preferences to the query context.
Together, these results support interpreting IGAM as modeling context-dependent, human-aligned preservation granularity, our operational definition of implicit intent. We have added both validations to Appendix D.2 (p. 23, lines 1211–1226).
We welcome any further questions and would be happy to discuss the method and additional results in more detail.