acceptodds
Under review as a conference paper at ICLR 2027

BrainAgent-CGP: Constraint-Guided Hierarchical Planning for Reliable Autonomous Brain-Signal Analysis

Abstract

Electroencephalography (EEG) analysis often relies on expert-designed pipelines in which processing steps, tool order, and intermediate data are defined manually. Large language model (LLM)-based agents can automate parts of this process from natural-language requests, but their generated workflows may still be invalid when required preprocessing steps or intermediate artifacts are missing. We propose BrainAgent-CGP, a constraint-guided multi-agent framework that separates semantic goal interpretation from executable workflow construction. Each analytical tool declares its required and produced artifacts, supported goals, agent ownership, execution cost, and reliability. A uniform-cost planner uses this information to construct dependency-valid workflows, followed by deterministic agent routing, runtime validation, and state-preserving replanning. BrainAgent-CGP is evaluated on 30 natural-language tasks spanning low, medium, and high workflow complexity. It achieves a Planning Success rate, Plan Validity Rate, Required-Tool Recall, and routing accuracy of 1.00, with an Invalid Tool Rate of 0.00. Removing artifact constraints reduces Plan Validity Rate to 0.233 and increases Invalid Tool Rate to 0.273. A language-robustness study over 90 paraphrased and unseen requests achieves an overall goal exact-match rate of 0.989 with the hybrid semantic interpreter while maintaining a Plan Validity Rate of 1.00. Controlled failure experiments achieve a Recovery Rate of 1.00 when an alternative path is available and a Safe Deferral Rate of 1.00 when no valid alternative exists. Finally, BrainAgent-CGP successfully executes 48 tool operations across 12 ISRUC-Sleep and Sleep-EDF Expanded recordings totaling 177.41 hours of EEG/PSG data. These results show that explicit artifact-state planning can improve the reliability of autonomous brain-signal analysis.

Primary area:
applications to neuroscience & cognitive science
Keywords:
EEG, large language models, autonomous agents, constraint-guided planning, brain-signal analysis

Reviews

Among:
Shape:
1234this paper, Bottom 2%
Figure 1. Mean review rating of the reviewed papers at ICLR 2027. This paper averages 1.25 over 4 reviews, above 2% of the others.
Reviewer_YhMiOpenReview ↗
Rating
1
Confidence
2
Informativeness
1
Presentation
1
Soundness
1
Read review
Paper summary

LLM-based brain-signal agents may generate workflows that are “semantically relevant but still computationally invalid” when required preprocessing steps or intermediate artifacts are missing. BrainAgent-CGP separates semantic goal interpretation from executable workflow construction, where a Constraint-Guided Planner builds dependency-valid workflows from the required and produced artifacts declared by each tool. The method is evaluated on a 30-task benchmark against three LLM-based planners with ablations, together with language-robustness, failure-recovery, and real-data experiments on ISRUC-Sleep and Sleep-EDF Expanded.

Critical strengths
  1. This paper provides a clear separation with a deterministic planner.
  2. A reasonable failure handling process is provided.
Critical weaknesses
  1. The main results are largely guaranteed by construction. CGP only expands tools whose required artifacts are available, so PVR = 1.00 and ITR = 0.00 follow directly from the algorithm, on a 30-task benchmark built from the same registry. The ablation shows that the cost and reliability terms do not change any workflow, so Eq. 9 is not validated. The failure-recovery experiment relies on three experiment-only fallback tools, and the real-data study checks only that a single four-tool workflow runs without errors.

  2. The planner comparison is hard to interpret. Prompts are not provided, and it is unclear whether the LLM baselines receive the same artifact declarations as CGP. Only one backbone (gpt-5.6-luna) is used, and there is no comparison with EEG Agent or BrainAgent. Figure 3 is also inconsistent with Table 11.

  3. Multiple citation errors. Several cited works do not match how they are described in the text (Ref. N denotes the N-th entry in the paper’s reference list):

  • Jiang et al. (2025) [Ref. 6] studies how LLM interactions affect users’ cognition using EEG, not tool-using agents.
  • Liu et al. (2026) [Ref. 11] is a survey and did not propose Plan-over-Graph, which is Zhang et al. (2025b) [Ref. 17].
  • Ming et al. (2025) [Ref. 12] is a brain-controlled robotic-arm paper, not GraSP [1].
  • Wu et al. (2025) [Ref. 14] is a seizure-prediction review; the described dependency-aware parallel planning matches GAP [2].
  • The GraphPlan entry [Ref. 9] also contains placeholder text.
  1. Limited novelty and terminology disconnected from prior work. The paper introduces new terms for established concepts without relating them to prior work. Semantic goal interpretation is NL-to-goal parsing, required/produced artifacts are preconditions/effects, and CGP is standard forward state-space search. This makes the paper harder to follow and obscures the close overlap with STRIPS/PDDL-style planning[3] and LLM+P[4], neither of which is discussed.

[1] GraSP: Graph-Structured Skill Compositions for LLM Agents, Xia et al., 2026.

[2] GAP: Graph-based Agent Planning with Parallel Tool Use and Reinforcement Learning, Wu et al., NeurIPS 2025.

[3] STRIPS: A New Approach to the Application of Theorem Proving to Problem Solving, Fikes et al., 1971.

[4] LLM+P: Empowering Large Language Models with Optimal Planning Proficiency, Liu et al., 2023.

Questions for authors

Clarifications:

  1. Do the LLM baselines receive the same required/produced artifact declarations as CGP, and is any validation or repair allowed? Please provide the prompts and justify using a single backbone.
  2. Does the 0.038 s planning latency of BrainAgent-CGP include semantic goal interpretation? Which interpreter (controlled parser or hybrid semantic interpreter) is used in Table 1?
  3. How is “w/o Artifact Constraints” implemented? Why does routing accuracy drop to 0.767 when routing is deterministic?
  4. Why do Figure 3 and Table 11 report different tool counts and redundant selections?
  5. In the real-data study, is output correctness checked beyond the absence of execution errors? Which preprocessing settings produce the abrupt drop in the PSD curves of Figure 2?
Reviewer_2shHOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
2
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
1
Read review
Paper summary

The paper introduces BrainAgent-CGP, a multi-agent framework for constructing and executing EEG/PSG analysis workflows from natural-language requests. Semantic goal interpretation is separated from workflow construction: a controlled phrase parser or a hybrid LLM-based interpreter maps the request to a fixed goal vocabulary, while a Constraint-Guided Planner (CGP) runs uniform-cost search over artifact states, expanding only tools whose declared input artifacts and signal constraints are satisfied. Each tool, in a manually-specified registry, declares its produced artifacts, supported goals, owning agent, cost and reliability. Tools are routed deterministically to shared, sleep or emotion agents. Any failed tools are blacklisted to replan from the preserved artifact state.

On a 30-task benchmark, BrainAgent-CGP achieves 100% planning success, plan validity rate (PVR), required-tool recall and routing accuracy, with much lower mean planning latency against three compenting LLM-based planners.

Critical strengths
  • The framework runs real signal-processing operations on public recordings with different channel configurations and sampling rates. Furthermore, its state-preserving replanning avoids re-executing validated upstream steps after a failure.
  • Separating intent parsing from workflow construction, and enforcing artifact preconditions before execution, is a pragmatic design that targets a failure mode reported for prior LLM-based brain-signal agents.
Critical weaknesses
  • The real-data and failure evaluations are narrow. As far as I understand, all 12 recordings are run with the same four-tool request. No real-data results are reported for any SleepAgent or EmotionAgent tool. The 177.41 h figure therefore reflects recording length rather than workflow diversity, and the abstract does not mention that a single workflow is used.
    • Recovery is shown in Appendix only for three cases, using experiment-only fallback producers that are not part of the 21-tool registry.
  • The perfect planning scores largely follow by construction. The registry appears to have a single producer per artifact, so the valid workflow is essentially the dependency closure of the requested goals. Accordingly, removing the reliability penalty or replacing the objective with unit-cost search changes nothing (Table 2).
    • Plan validity is measured against the same artifact dependencies the planner enforces (Eq. 13), and routing is a registry lookup (Eq. 11), so a PVR and routing accuracy of 100% are expected rather than empirical findings.
    • The benchmark never requires choosing among alternative producers, which is what motivates uniform-cost search in the first place.
  • The comparison with LLM-based planners is under-specified and asymmetric. The baseline backbone (GPT-5.6 Luna) is named only in Appendix C (on lines 703-704). Prompts, decoding settings and whether the baselines saw each tool's required and produced artifacts are not reported.
    • Table 1 gives means over 10 runs per task without any measure of variance.
    • The hybrid interpreter is only used for the 90 language variants, so in Table 1, CGP presumably receives goals from the deterministic phrase parser, which fails on all 30 unseen formulations (Table 7), while the baselines must interpret the request themselves.
  • Limited positioning against classical planning. The paper discusses recent LLM-based precondition-effect planners , but not classical planning, where typed pre-conditions, effects and cost-optimal search are usually standard. Some Google searches led me to the Nipype work by Gorgolewski et al. (2011), for instance. This makes it hard to judge the contribution beyond applying established techniques to a manually curated EEG registry, which also limits generalisation to new tools.
Questions for authors
  • What prompts, temperature and tool descriptions were given to the LLM baselines, and did these include each tool's required and produced artifacts? Could you also report the variance across the 10 runs?
  • Which parser is used for Tables 1 and 2, and how was its phrase dictionary constructed? Which LLM does the hybrid interpreter use?
  • Why was BrainAgent-CGP not evaluated on the benchmark of Zhou et al. (2026) (lines 135-138)? Are the single-LLM and hierarchical-LLM baselines re-implementations of EEGAgent and BrainAgent?
  • Tables 3 and 10 are identical and Section 5.4 largely repeats Appendix G.1, while Section 4 (Experimental Setup) is three lines that defer to the appendices. I believe that moving key setup details into the main body of the paper would help.
  • Several citations do not match the reference list. For instance,
    • the entry cited for GraSP (on line 158) refers to an unrelated paper, and
    • Plan-over-Graph is attributed to Liu et al. (2026) in the text but to Zhang et al. (2025b) in the references.
Reviewer_JjomOpenReview ↗
Rating
1
Confidence
3
Informativeness
2
Presentation
1
Soundness
1
Read review
Paper summary

This study is about automating EEG analysis with agents. It proposes an agent planning framework that incorporates the dependency into the tool definition and then uses LLM for goal detection. During workflow generation, Uniform-Cost Search (UCS), a classic and learning-free search method, will be used to find cost-efficient flows that can achieve the user's goal. The study validates the framework on the subsets extracted from two datasets, comparing against 3 baselines and mainly focusing on the task completion.

Critical strengths

The study proposes a simple and learning-free approach to improve the agent framework's efficiency and reliability. According to Table 1 and 2, the study achieves better performance across multiple evaluation metrics compared to baselines such as Single-LLM, Hierarchical LLM, and ReAct-style.

Critical weaknesses

This study solely focuses on the task completion, according to Table 1 & 2, and does not discuss much about task performance. From the instructions in Section F.1, the workflow is typically data loading -> feature extraction -> visualization and report, but I don't think the setting is challenging enough to demonstrate advantages of agent automation.

The proposed framework relies heavily on manual configurations (e.g., a predefined goal vocabulary G, tool dependencies manually specified through input and output artifacts, execution costs and reliability estimates assigned in advance). They raise concerns about the generalizability and adaptability of the framework, for example, how the system would handle new analytical goals or more complex EEG analysis tasks. (The existing experiments of unseen natural language requests demonstrate the robustness to linguistic variations only.) I recommend expanding the experimental evaluation to include more diverse and challenging EEG analysis tasks, particularly those involving machine learning modeling goals and more complex processing pipelines.

The writing of the manuscript needs to be improved, for example, in terms of coherence. Another thing: the authors describe EEGNet as a "pretrained model" in Section 2. Unlike large-scale pretrained EEG models such as LaBraM, EEGNet is commonly trained from scratch on task-specific datasets, so "pretrained model" seems inaccurate.

Questions for authors

What are the advantages of the proposed planning framework over a conventional dependency-based workflow engine? Asking this since all tool dependencies are manually predefined and the current tool registry seems to contain only a single artifact, it appears that the workflow could be constructed using topological sorting. I don't think it would cost much or take long if I ran all the feature extraction codes and generate all the plots (as long as the dataset has this channels). In this case, why use agents?

How adaptable is the proposed framework to new and unseen EEG analysis tasks?

How are the execution costs and reliability estimates determined? Are these parameters empirically measured or heuristically assigned? Since the ablation results in Table 2 show that removing the cost and reliability terms does not affect the selected workflows, could the authors further clarify their practical contribution to the proposed planning method?

Reviewer_tMdvOpenReview ↗
Rating
1
Confidence
3
Informativeness
1
Presentation
1
Soundness
1
Read review
Paper summary

The paper proposes BrainAgent-CGP, an agentic LLM framework for EEG analysis. The framework separates goal interpretation from workflow construction and uses a uniform-cost planner over tool-declared artifact dependencies to build valid workflows, with runtime validation and replanning. The authors report that it outperforms standard LLM prompting baselines on a benchmark of 12 samples.

Critical strengths

None

Critical weaknesses
  • The scope of the claims is narrow. The evaluation covers only the validity of the agent’s plans and tool calls and omits task-level performance on EEG analysis. Valid plans and tool calls do not guarantee correct final results, so the paper does not show that its contribution improves the outcome that matters. I recommend that the authors report end-task performance for each method and relate it to plan and tool-call validity.
  • The experimental setting is unclear, and the paper offers little discussion to support the interpretation of its results. The construction of the benchmark is not described in enough detail. It is unclear who wrote the tasks, how they were selected, and whether they were designed together with the tool specifications, which could favor the proposed framework. The benchmark is also small (12 samples), so the reported differences are unlikely to be statistically meaningful.
  • The writing of the manuscript needs substantial improvement. EEGNet is mentioned without a citation. Several central terms, such as “artifact state” and “explicit artifact dependencies”, are used without a definition or a link to prior work. This makes the method difficult to follow.
Questions for authors

See Weakness

From OpenReview, CC BY 4.0. Authors as signed there; shown unedited.

Related papers

Loading the map…

Discussion (0)

Sign in to comment.