acceptodds
Under review as a conference paper at ICLR 2027

Finite-Reference Error Bounds for Recurrent Value Evaluators in Policy Improvement

Abstract

We bound value error for finite-depth recurrent evaluators in policy improvement without assuming recurrent convergence. We compare the endpoint , the value read at the deployed depth , with a deeper finite endpoint of the same evaluator. For a fixed policy, the standard Bellman-residual bound and triangle inequality give an error radius of plus the -step residual of divided by . It is tighter than the direct residual bound on exactly when the residual reduction exceeds ; depth alone does not suffice. When the latent is carried across environment steps, the state includes the latent and the remaining edit budget; fixing the deployed policy and the shared depth- recurrent map keeps both endpoints in one MDP, so changes only endpoint evaluation. Exactly centered advantages connect the radius to a conservative policy improvement lower bound with signed evaluation error. An exact three-state example gives a nonvacuous radius and certifies improvement over the base. On a fixed 128-state Sudoku census, finite-reference proxies are 0.9 to 1.9% smaller than direct proxies across eight training seeds sharing one base initialization. Both remain uninformative as radii at roughly 70 times the checker scale; this is neither a uniform certificate nor a task-performance result. We analyze one candidate mixed exactly, state by state, with a frozen base policy at a fixed parameter snapshot.

Primary area:
reinforcement learning
Keywords:
Reinforcement Learning, Policy Improvement, Approximate Dynamic Programming, Recurrent Neural Networks, Bellman Residuals, Conservative Policy Iteration

Reviews

Among:
Shape:
1234this paper, Bottom 27%
Figure 1. Mean review rating of the reviewed papers at ICLR 2027. This paper averages 2.00 over 3 reviews, above 27% of the others.
Reviewer_ZbAcOpenReview ↗
Rating
1
Confidence
3
Informativeness
1
Presentation
2
Soundness
1
Read review
Paper summary

This paper studies finite-depth recurrent value evaluators and bounds the value error of the deployed depth-n endpoint by the discrepancy to a deeper depth-m endpoint plus the depth-m Bellman residual. The signed-CPI composition and the exact three-state example are correct and clearly presented, and the negative diagnostic is honest. However, all results are population sup-norm statements that require exact transition expectations and exact sup-norms; there is no finite-sample or computable version, and the quantities are not available model-free. The empirical evidence is based on a toy experiment.

Critical strengths

None

Critical weaknesses
  • The theoretical core is a standard result restated.
  • The persistent-latent augmented MDP formulation is mathematically consistent, but its importance and scope are not sufficiently motivated. Augmenting the state with a recurrent latent is not itself unusual, and the paper mainly uses this construction to ensure that FnF_n and the comparison endpoint at depth mm are evaluated within the same deployed MDP. This is a legitimate technical issue, but the presentation is difficult to follow and the paper does not clearly explain which classes of recurrent RL or reasoning systems actually require this formulation, or what broadly reusable insight is obtained beyond careful bookkeeping for this particular setup.
  • The empirical evaluation is limited. The learned result is based on a fixed 128-state Sudoku census with deterministic transitions and enumerable actions, which makes exact residual computation unusually convenient. This does not demonstrate that the proposed certificate remains usable in stochastic environments, large action spaces, or logged-data settings.
  • The paper refers to verify_finite_mdp.py, but no script or linked in the submission.
Questions for authors

see weakness.

Reviewer_8AZYOpenReview ↗
Rating
3
Confidence
3
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
3
Read review
Paper summary

This paper studies value error for recurrent evaluators read after a fixed number nn of internal steps. The paper did not assume recurrent convergence. It proposes a finite reference bound for the value error, generally tighter than the direct bound. The paper further analyzes the self-bootstrap residual for value regression settings, as well as the conservative policy improvement.

Critical strengths

The paper has a strong and solid theoretical development. The statements in the paper appears to be no obvious mathematical errors. The formulation of the problem is clear. Overall, this paper appears to be complete and persuasive.

Critical weaknesses
  1. The presentation clarity needs to be improved. Please make sure every notation is defined clearly when they first appear. For example, line 35: define UnU_n when it first appears. Please fix other similar problems. Also, I suggest to use mathematical language rather than descriptive language, for example, line 16-17.

  2. The example in Section 9 appears to be a toy model. It seems that these are very small state space and a small action space. I would expect to see larger spaces for experiments.

Besides, I have additional concerns, which are listed in the next section.

Questions for authors
  1. Is there related references for theorem 5.1? The proof strategy seems a standard argument for MDP error estimation.

  2. Theorem 7.3 is unclear to me, could the author give more explanation and interpretation of that theorem?

  3. Assumption 7.1 is critical in the development of the theorem. Could the authors give a real-world application example in which the assumption 7.1 holds?

  4. In real-world application, the bound of ∥Un−Vπ∥\|U_n-V^{\pi}\| depends on UmU_m, as Theorem 5.1 proposed. However, one would expect UmU_m to be a better approximation of VπV^{\pi} than UnU_n when m>nm>n. In this case, it seems better for us to directly use UmU_m as an estimation. I wonder the necessity of developing such a bound. Let me know if I misunderstood the problem.

  5. In general εres,n\varepsilon_{res,n} need not to be monotonely decreasing as nn increase, did the author consider this when arguing Eq. (7)?

Reviewer_tPCKOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
2
Informativeness
2
Presentation
3
Soundness
3
Read review
Paper summary

The paper studies value estimation error for recurrent evaluators deployed at finite computational depth. It uses a deeper finite output as a reference, combining endpoint discrepancy with the reference’s Bellman residual to bound the deployed output’s error. The authors characterize when this improves upon the direct residual bound, formalize persistent latent states within a shared augmented MDP, and propagate evaluation error into a conservative policy improvement guarantee. Validation includes an exact three-state example and an eight-seed Sudoku diagnostic on 128 fixed states. The learned diagnostic shows small reductions in proxy bounds, without establishing a uniform certificate or improved task performance.

Critical strengths
  • The persistent-state construction addresses a meaningful modeling issue. Including the stored latent and remaining edit budget in the state, while holding the deployed recurrent map fixed, ensures that different readout depths correspond to the same policy-evaluation problem.

  • The finite-reference bound can provide guarantees unavailable from the direct residual bound. The exact example reduces the value-error radius from 0.75 to 0.5, with an actual error of 0.25. An additional calculation using the same toy MDP shows that, at mixture weight 0.1, the finite-reference bound yields a positive policy-improvement lower bound while the corresponding direct-residual bound remains negative.

Critical weaknesses

The learned experiments do not demonstrate helpful policy-improvement decisions. The Sudoku proxy bounds decrease by approximately 0.9–1.9% but remain roughly 70 times the checker scale. The eight training seeds share one base initialization and the same 128-state census. These results neither establish uniform error control nor demonstrate a learned update that the finite-reference analysis can certify when the direct residual analysis cannot. The authors clearly disclose these limitations, but, given the modest theoretical increment, the existing evidence does not sufficiently establish the method’s practical significance.

Questions for authors
  • Appendix C.4.1 acknowledges tighter residual bounds under a finite edit budget. For the existing sixteen-edit Sudoku experiments, how do the finite-reference and direct bounds compare under this refinement, and does either support a nonvacuous policy-improvement guarantee?
  • How were the shared base policy and recurrent map obtained? What procedures determined the 128 evaluation states, reference depth, and evaluated checkpoints?

From OpenReview, CC BY 4.0. Authors as signed there; shown unedited.

Related papers

Loading the map…

Discussion (0)

Sign in to comment.