acceptodds
Withdrawn from ICLR 2027

RREDCoT: Segment-Level Reward Redistribution for Reasoning Models

Withdrawn from ICLR 2027, so left out of the paper lists and the map.

Abstract

Recent advancements in reasoning language models have been driven by Reinforcement Learning (RL) fine-tuning. Most often, these rely on the Group Relative Policy Optimization (GRPO) algorithm or modifications thereof to steer the models to produce Chain-of-Thought (CoT) traces. The final answer can only be verified, and the reward assigned, after the CoT trace is complete, making it a delayed reward problem. GRPO and its modifications correspond to Monte Carlo methods in standard RL, which are known to suffer from high variance. A possible solution to this problem is the redistribution of rewards through credit assignment, where segments of the CoT trace that are important for arriving at the desirable solution are emphasized by assigning a higher reward. While Monte Carlo sampling can be used to provide an unbiased estimate of intermediate state values, its computational overhead makes it unsuitable for train-time credit assignment in long contexts at high granularity. We introduce RREDCoT (Reward REDistribution for Chain of Thought), which utilizes the model itself to approximate the optimal reward redistribution without additional generation. We investigate the advantages of our method compared to MC sampling and several attribution methods.

Primary area:
reinforcement learning
Keywords:
LLM, post-training, reasoning, reward, MC, importance sampling, estimator

Reviews

Among:
Shape:
1234this paper, Bottom 10%
Figure 1. Mean review rating of the reviewed papers at ICLR 2027. This paper averages 1.67 over 3 reviews, above 10% of the others.
Reviewer_STeSOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
2
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

This paper introduces RREDCoT, a segment-level reward redistribution method for reasoning models. It addresses credit assignment under delayed final-answer rewards during reinforcement learning fine-tuning. The method uses the model itself to estimate each segment’s contribution and redistribute rewards along the chain-of-thought trace. The authors evaluate the method on mathematical reasoning tasks and examine its correlations with Monte Carlo estimates and attribution methods.

Critical strengths
  1. The paper addresses fine-grained credit assignment under final-answer rewards. Building on RUDDER, it provides segment-specific training signals while reusing the generating model to reduce estimation costs relative to Monte Carlo sampling.
  2. Fine-tuning experiments of RREDCOT show improvements over GRPO on four of five evaluated benchmarks, providing preliminary evidence of the method’s effectiveness. The paper also analyzes Monte Carlo sampling costs and truncation effects.
Critical weaknesses
  1. The paper lacks controlled ablations of reference solution paths, hybrid segmentation, and normalization of σ\sigma. In particular, the benefit over using only changes in reference-answer probability remains unclear.
  2. The distinction from SPO (NeurIPS 2025), SSVPO (ICLR 2026), and TIPS (ICLR 2026) remains unclear. These methods already explore segment/step-level credit assignment or answer-probability-based rewards.
  3. The paper lacks controlled ablations of reference solution paths, hybrid segmentation, and weight normalization. In particular, the benefit over using only changes in correct-answer probability remains unclear.
  4. The experiments mainly compare against GRPO and Open-RS. The limited coverage of existing RL methods for mathematical reasoning makes it difficult to assess the proposed method’s relative effectiveness.
  5. There are also minor presentation issues, including inconsistent figure captions and typographical errors.
Questions for authors
  1. What estimator is used in the implementation? How are the normalization factors in Eqs. (9) and (22) consistent with the value definition in Eq. (4)?
  2. What additional benefit does the reference solution term provide beyond using only changes in correct-answer probability? Can the authors provide a controlled ablation?
  3. Could the authors include additional RL baselines for mathematical reasoning, such as SPO and SSVPO, to better assess the proposed method’s effectiveness?
Reviewer_cznbOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
3
Informativeness
2
Presentation
1
Soundness
1
Read review
Paper summary

In reinforcement learning with verifiable rewards, typically the reward is only non-zero at the end of the trajectory, so all tokens get the same reinforcement, so no meaningful credit assignment. This paper attempts to do better credit assignment by segmenting a trajectory and then crediting segments given how likely they are in generating correct answers relative to what came before the segment.

the claim is this is cheaper than MC, but it still correlates with it. It is indeed cheaper because the estimates can be obtained by teacher forcing and also clever KV caching makes computation manageable. As to whether it generally is tracking MC, I have other opinions which I will share below.

Critical strengths
  • poor credit assignment is real, so the motivation is pretty clear
  • the idea is practical. can be implemented easily and its much faster than running MC.
  • the paper introduces conceptually useful quantities
Critical weaknesses

I traced the argument from the Bellman eq to the algorithm, and there are several steps where dots cant be connected easily

eq 2: correctness of the answer is defined on -- actual answers -- but then the function takes s_{t+1} as input. in other words there is a type mismatch between eq 1 and 2. then the next line secretly fixes this

eq 3: again, s_t is taken as input, which is a type mismatch. now here, the Q value in RL does not average over actions. the action is actually set as an input argument to the Q value, not something to take expectation over. minor: discount factor is missing

eq 4: the prefix s_t is actually vanished from the right hand side. written like this, for every state we have the same number. Y and U were defined as action subsets, but instead here they are used as whole answers and traces.

eq 5: this is fine as a optimality statement, but note that it applies to the true q function. the quantities computed are not related to q functions, and there is no bound measuring the error relative to the q function, so calling it approximate q function is also not warranted.

eq 9: the true value acreage over all continuations the model might produce, but this equation sums over one reference pair.

Algorithm 1: v_t is the likelihood of text, not an expected return. this is computing something myopic: if the segment would not immediately increase probability of the correct solution, despite the fact continued generation from it would have resulted in high reward, then the segment would get punished.

Questions for authors

Why use delta R and delta V? aren't we double counting here?

I am not convinced that the quantity computed resembles the standard definition of value function. We need theoretic error bounds and more clear experiments to support this

For example, can you pick a set of prefixes (mid-trace) and compute the true value V(s_t) by many MC rollouts from that prefix, with no truncation. Report, per position in the trace, the correlation and absolute error against the MC value, with confidence intervals.

If the estimator is a value function, it should track MC in both level and change. A low correlation early in the trace, or correct ranking but wrong scale, shows it’s a progress score.

A value function should be the expected final reward when the model continues decoding from the current prefix, but your quantity only measures how likely a fixed reference answer or solution is if generation stopped right now (Eq. 9, Alg. 1), which is a myopic score and not an expectation over the model’s own continuations. As a result, a step that temporarily lowers the reference likelihood but enables later success, or a valid solution path that differs from the reference, is credited incorrectly, so the claim of an “approximately optimal redistribution” (Eq. 5) is not supported as of yet.

Reviewer_jYrxOpenReview ↗
Rating
1
Confidence
3
Informativeness
2
Presentation
1
Soundness
1
Read review
Paper summary

RREDCoT adapts RUDDER-style reward redistribution to CoT. It segments traces and uses changes in the model's likelihood of the reference answer and solution across segment prefixes as segment weights σ in a GRPO-style objective. It analyzes the estimator's bias and its correlation with MC, LOO, and gradient attribution, and reports math results on Qwen3-4B and R1-Distill-1.5B.

Critical strengths

1.Credit assignment without extra generation, far cheaper than MC. 2.A useful analysis of truncated-MC bias and variance, and of attribution vs. credit assignment. 3.A candid limitations section.

Critical weaknesses

1.The estimator derivation is inconsistent. With q uniform on S, E_q[f/q] = Σ_S f, not (1/N)Σ_S f, and the estimator is really a deterministic truncated sum over a restricted support. Eq. 10 refers to Z without defining it, and Eqs. 4 and 22 define the value differently. 2.The return-equivalence argument does not match the objective. The theory requires Σσ = 1, but the experiments use L1 normalization with possibly negative σ. Eq. 11 is also not the redistributed-reward SDP that RUDDER's theorem covers. 3.The comparisons are confounded. The Open-RS checkpoints were trained on different data. The reported benchmarks are used as validation sets for checkpoint selection. The grader is inconsistent (LLM judges vs. math-verify). Compute is 1.5–2× that of GRPO with no matched comparison, and there is a single run. 4.The writing has editorial errors. The Fig. 2 caption swaps left and right, Algorithm 1 contains leftover text and duplicated comments, Appendix C is empty, and MC is called MCMC. Relevant baselines (VinePPO, PRIME, RLPR) are not discussed.

Questions for authors

1.Is σ allowed to be negative? What guarantee holds for the objective actually used? Please correct Eqs. 9, 10, and 22. 2.With the same data, references, and reward, at matched compute and over multiple seeds, how much does redistribution alone improve over GRPO? 3.How were checkpoints selected, and which grader produced each table?

From OpenReview, CC BY 4.0. Authors as signed there; shown unedited.

Related papers

Discussion (0)

Sign in to comment.