acceptodds
Withdrawn from ICLR 2027

What We Talk About When We Talk About Emotion Editing

Withdrawn from ICLR 2027, so left out of the paper lists and the map.

Abstract

Emotional image editing aims to change the emotion a scene conveys while preserving its essential content. Because the same scene can support different emotional interpretations, achieving an emotional goal requires visual changes grounded in the source context. Motivated by the Component Process Model, which links emotional responses to event appraisal, we investigate neural representations as a reference for these editing decisions. Using TRIBE v2, an fMRI encoding model, we analyze 400 source–target pairs across eight emotion categories. Hidden states from EmoEdit, EmoEditor, and AffectDelta correspond more strongly to predicted target-image responses in visual regions than in affect-related regions. This imbalance motivates ROI-ReFT, which combines source visual responses as a content reference with a predicted affective response change as an editing direction. Two interacting branches use both conditions to guide a frozen editor throughout generation. Predicted responses of the generated image supervise affective change and constrain visual drift. On a post hoc selected subset of 400 editing requests, ROI-ReFT achieves 91.75% target-emotion accuracy and 83.25% joint success, with the same output both matching the target emotion and reaching source–output DINO-I of at least 0.80. Our code and dataset will be publicly released.

Primary area:
applications to computer vision, audio, language, and other modalities
Keywords:
Emotional image editing, Brain-guided generation, fMRI-derived representations, Visual-affective guidance, Component Process Model

Reviews

Among:
Shape:
1234this paper, Bottom 27%
Figure 1. Mean review rating of the reviewed papers at ICLR 2027. This paper averages 2.00 over 3 reviews, above 27% of the others.
Reviewer_nHKROpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
4
Informativeness
2
Presentation
1
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

The paper proposes ROI-ReFT, a neuroscience-guided framework for emotional image editing that aims to achieve target emotions while preserving the source image content. Motivated by an analysis showing that existing emotion editors exhibit stronger representational correspondence with visual brain regions than affect-related regions, the authors introduce two complementary neural guidance signals derived from the TRIBE v2 brain foundation model: source visual responses for content preservation and predicted affective response changes for emotion manipulation. These signals are integrated into a frozen diffusion editor through dual-branch, gated low-rank representation interventions. The framework is trained using neural response alignment objectives alongside conventional emotion and content preservation losses. Experiments on 400 selected editing requests demonstrate improvements over existing methods in target-emotion accuracy and visual content preservation, supported by ablation studies and representational analyses.

Critical strengths
  1. Interesting neuroscience-inspired perspective. The paper introduces predicted neural responses as guidance for emotional image editing, combining visual and affect-related representations to balance emotional manipulation and content preservation. This provides an interesting perspective on incorporating brain foundation models into generative editing.

  2. Strong experimental results and comprehensive ablations. The proposed method achieves substantial improvements in target-emotion accuracy and content preservation over its base editor and other baselines. The ablation studies further demonstrate the complementary contributions of visual and affective guidance, supporting the effectiveness of the proposed framework.

Critical weaknesses
  1. Unclear motivation and insufficient neuroscientific justification. The paper's narrative is difficult to follow, particularly the connection between cognitive reappraisal, the Component Process Model, and the proposed ROI-based intervention. The observation that existing editors exhibit weaker correspondence with affect-related regions does not necessarily imply insufficient emotional understanding. Moreover, given the distributed nature of emotional representations, the justification for selecting specific affect-related ROIs remains insufficient.

  2. Lack of human-centered evaluation. The paper relies primarily on automatic emotion classifiers and predicted neural responses, without conducting a human user study. This is particularly concerning given its emphasis on cognitive appraisal and context-dependent emotional interpretation. Without human evaluation, it remains unclear whether the reported improvements reflect genuine changes in perceived emotion and whether the edited images preserve their intended contextual meaning.

Questions for authors
  1. Neuroscientific motivation and ROI selection. How are the affect-related ROIs selected, and what evidence supports their specific relevance to emotional responses? Given that emotion is represented across distributed brain networks, how do the authors justify the separation between visual and affective ROIs? Could the observed improvements arise from general visual or semantic information rather than emotion-specific neural representations?

  2. Interpretation of the representation analysis. The paper argues that weaker correspondence between existing editors' hidden states and affect-related neural responses motivates explicit neural guidance. However, could this difference reflect variations in neural response predictability or encoding difficulty across brain regions, rather than insufficient emotional understanding? What evidence establishes a connection between this representational imbalance and emotional editing performance?

  3. Human evaluation of emotional editing. Have the authors considered conducting a user study to evaluate whether the generated images actually convey the intended emotions to human observers? Given the emphasis on cognitive appraisal and context-dependent emotional interpretation, how can the authors establish that improvements in automatic emotion classification correspond to meaningful changes in human emotional perception?

  4. Validation of cognitive reappraisal. The introduction uses cognitive reappraisal to motivate the framework, emphasizing that identical visual content can evoke different emotions depending on its interpretation. Does the proposed method actually capture or modify such contextual interpretations? Can the authors provide experiments involving emotionally ambiguous scenes to substantiate this central motivation?

  5. Contribution of the dual-branch intervention. Although the ablation studies demonstrate improvements from interactive dual-branch guidance, what specific behaviors does this interaction enable beyond independent conditioning? Can the authors provide qualitative or spatial analyses illustrating how the visual and affective branches coordinate during editing?

  6. *Comparison with modern image editing models. How does the proposed method compare with recent foundation model-based image editing systems, such as Qwen-Image-Edit, which demonstrate strong semantic understanding and instruction-following capabilities? Would the reported advantages in emotional editing and content preservation still hold against these stronger baselines?

Reviewer_cJS8OpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
4
Informativeness
2
Presentation
3
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

This paper proposes ROI-ReFT for affective image editing, using predicted neural responses as intermediate control signals. It employs visual ROIs for content preservation and affect-related ROIs for emotion guidance, with dual-branch representation interventions applied to a frozen diffusion model.

Critical strengths
  1. The analysis of neural correspondence in existing affective editing models provides an interesting motivation for introducing brain-inspired guidance.

  2. The proposed method combines visual and affect-related brain responses to improve emotion editing while preserving the original image content.

  3. The experiments include comparisons with multiple baseline methods and ablation studies, providing evidence for the effectiveness of the proposed approach.

Critical weaknesses
  1. The proposed framework primarily combines a pretrained neural response prediction model with low-rank feature interventions on an existing diffusion backbone. Although the dual-ROI design is interesting, comparisons with CLIP, DINO, or affective features under matched adapter capacity and supervision are needed to establish whether the improvements specifically arise from brain-derived representations rather than additional feature guidance.

  2. All neural supervision relies on responses predicted by TRIBE v2 rather than directly measured fMRI, leaving unclear how reliably these predictions reflect actual human affective responses. Moreover, different individuals may interpret the same image differently, raising concerns about whether population-level predicted responses adequately capture subjective emotional perception. The reported improvements therefore demonstrate the utility of predicted neural representations for editing, but do not establish corresponding changes in actual human brain responses.

  3. The visual preservation loss uses the source-to-output distance of the frozen AffectDelta editor as a reference budget. If the baseline makes insufficient changes to achieve the target emotion, this budget may overly constrain necessary edits, whereas substantial baseline drift may permit excessive modifications. The robustness of this supervision to the quality of baseline outputs remains unclear.

  4. The reported emotion accuracy relies on a frozen ResNet-18 classifier without validation through human emotional judgments. In Figure 4, the first-row result for "Amusement" primarily changes lighting and atmosphere without introducing clear semantic cues associated with amusement, which also appears inconsistent with the paper's emphasis on scene interpretation and contextual meaning. Human evaluation is needed to determine whether the generated images genuinely convey the intended emotions.

  5. The evaluation uses a post hoc selected subset of only 400 editing requests from AffectPair-249K, but the selection criteria and timing are not sufficiently explained. The authors should clarify how the subset was constructed, whether training and evaluation samples overlap, and whether the selection procedure could introduce bias or limit the generalizability of the reported results.

  6. The paper draws motivation from the Component Process Model and cognitive reappraisal, emphasizing the importance of event interpretation and appraisal in emotional responses. However, the proposed method operates on predicted affect-related neural response differences without directly evaluating appraisal processes, leaving the connection between the theoretical motivation and neural guidance largely conceptual.

Questions for authors
  1. How do the authors validate that the affect-related ROI responses predicted by TRIBE v2 reliably reflect human emotional perception, particularly given that different individuals may interpret the same image differently? Is there evidence that the predicted response changes correspond to actual human neural or emotional responses?

  2. To what extent do the improvements specifically depend on brain-derived representations? Have the authors considered comparisons with CLIP, DINO, or affective features under matched adapter capacity and supervision to distinguish the contribution of neural guidance from general feature-based intervention?

  3. How sensitive is the visual preservation loss to the quality of the frozen AffectDelta outputs? In particular, could insufficient baseline editing overly constrain necessary changes, while substantial baseline visual drift permits excessive modifications?

  4. How were the 400 post hoc selected evaluation requests chosen, and was the subset fixed before model development and evaluation? Were training and evaluation samples checked for overlap, and could the selection procedure introduce bias into the reported results?

Reviewer_8nkfOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
3
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

This paper investigates emotional image editing using predicted cortical responses as guidance. Motivated by the Component Process Model, the authors analyze existing emotion editors and observe stronger correspondence between their hidden representations and TRIBE v2-predicted responses in visual regions than in affect-related regions. To address this imbalance, they propose ROI-ReFT, a dual-ROI representation intervention framework built on a frozen AffectDelta editor. The method combines source-image visual responses with predicted affective response changes through interacting gated low-rank interventions. Training further supervises the generated image's predicted affective responses while constraining visual drift. Experiments on a post hoc selected subset of 400 editing requests report improvements in target-emotion accuracy and visual preservation, supported by component ablations and representation-level analyses.

Critical strengths
  1. An interesting perspective on neural guidance for emotional image editing.

The paper introduces predicted cortical responses as an additional representation space for guiding emotional image editing. Its formulation distinguishes source visual responses, which provide a content reference, from predicted affective response changes, which guide the intended emotional transition. This is a conceptually interesting direction because emotional editing requires coordinating scene preservation with context-dependent visual modifications. The analysis of visual and affect-related representation correspondence also provides a reasonable motivation for investigating such guidance.

  1. A modular intervention framework with encouraging experimental improvements.

ROI-ReFT introduces gated low-rank interventions into a frozen diffusion editor while retaining its original source-image and emotion conditioning. The two branches interact throughout generation without requiring backbone fine-tuning. The reported results show substantial improvements over the base editor in target-emotion accuracy and visual preservation. Component ablations further demonstrate the complementary contributions of visual guidance, affective guidance, and their interaction. These findings provide encouraging evidence for the proposed architecture.

Critical weaknesses
  1. The proposed affective supervision does not sufficiently establish that the learned representation isolates emotional change.

The affective condition is derived from the difference between TRIBE-predicted source and target responses. However, this difference may encode variations in scene content, appearance, and other visual characteristics rather than emotion alone. The paper does not sufficiently demonstrate how these factors are separated in the selected affect-related ROI representations.

More importantly, because the affective encoder is linear, the source response cancels algebraically in Eq. (4), making the affective supervision equivalent to matching the generated and target ROI codes. Although source-relative conditioning is retained elsewhere in the framework, this particular loss does not independently enforce a source-relative emotional transition. Consequently, it remains unclear whether the improvements arise from learning meaningful affective changes or from matching additional target-image characteristics. Since TRIBE v2 is also used for representation-level evaluation, improved correspondence with the same teacher does not independently validate the emotional interpretation of the learned representations.

This concern directly affects the central scientific claim that the proposed neural guidance captures meaningful affective changes.

  1. The evaluation protocol provides insufficient evidence of generalization and human-perceived emotional editing quality.

The main results are reported on a post hoc selected subset of 400 editing requests from AffectPair-249K. Although the subset is balanced across emotion categories, the paper does not sufficiently explain the selection procedure or establish its independence from predictor pretraining, ROI projection fitting, intervention training, and hyperparameter selection. In particular, request-level separation may not guarantee evaluation on unseen source images. Without a clearly defined held-out protocol, the generalizability of the reported improvements remains uncertain.

Furthermore, emotional editing performance is primarily assessed through automated emotion predictions and visual similarity metrics. The paper does not clearly establish whether the emotion predictor used for training is independent of the evaluator used for reporting emotional accuracy. If the same model is used, the reported improvement may partly reflect optimization toward the evaluation classifier rather than better human-perceived emotional content.

The lack of independent human evaluation further limits the conclusions, since target-category predictions and image similarity scores cannot fully determine whether viewers perceive the intended emotion or consider the edited visual cues plausible. These limitations are particularly consequential given the paper's emphasis on emotionally meaningful image transformations.

Questions for authors

Q1. Affective representation and supervision: Given the linearity of the affective encoder, Eq. (4) appears equivalent to matching the generated and target affect-related ROI representations after cancellation of the source response. Could the authors clarify what additional source-relative constraint this objective provides? How do they establish that the selected ROI differences primarily capture affective changes rather than unrelated target-image variations?

Q2. Evaluation subset and data independence: What criteria were used to select the 400 evaluation requests? Were the selection criteria defined independently of model outputs and evaluation scores? Can the authors clarify whether source images in the evaluation subset were excluded from intervention training, affective predictor pretraining, ROI projection fitting, and hyperparameter selection? An independently defined held-out evaluation would materially strengthen the generalization claim.

Q3. Independence of emotion evaluation: Do the training emotion predictor P and evaluation predictor P_eval share the same architecture and weights? If so, how do the authors rule out improvements caused by optimization toward the evaluation classifier? Results from an independently trained emotion evaluator, ideally complemented by blinded human judgments, would help establish whether the edits produce meaningful perceived emotional changes.

Q4. Robustness of the reported improvements: Can the authors provide repeated-run results with uncertainty estimates and performance breakdowns across source-to-target emotion transitions? This would help determine whether the improvements are stable across different editing scenarios rather than being driven by particular subsets of the selected requests.

From OpenReview, CC BY 4.0. Authors as signed there; shown unedited.

Related papers

Discussion (0)

Sign in to comment.