- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 1
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
The paper proposes ROI-ReFT, a neuroscience-guided framework for emotional image editing that aims to achieve target emotions while preserving the source image content. Motivated by an analysis showing that existing emotion editors exhibit stronger representational correspondence with visual brain regions than affect-related regions, the authors introduce two complementary neural guidance signals derived from the TRIBE v2 brain foundation model: source visual responses for content preservation and predicted affective response changes for emotion manipulation. These signals are integrated into a frozen diffusion editor through dual-branch, gated low-rank representation interventions. The framework is trained using neural response alignment objectives alongside conventional emotion and content preservation losses. Experiments on 400 selected editing requests demonstrate improvements over existing methods in target-emotion accuracy and visual content preservation, supported by ablation studies and representational analyses.
Critical strengths
-
Interesting neuroscience-inspired perspective. The paper introduces predicted neural responses as guidance for emotional image editing, combining visual and affect-related representations to balance emotional manipulation and content preservation. This provides an interesting perspective on incorporating brain foundation models into generative editing.
-
Strong experimental results and comprehensive ablations. The proposed method achieves substantial improvements in target-emotion accuracy and content preservation over its base editor and other baselines. The ablation studies further demonstrate the complementary contributions of visual and affective guidance, supporting the effectiveness of the proposed framework.
Critical weaknesses
-
Unclear motivation and insufficient neuroscientific justification. The paper's narrative is difficult to follow, particularly the connection between cognitive reappraisal, the Component Process Model, and the proposed ROI-based intervention. The observation that existing editors exhibit weaker correspondence with affect-related regions does not necessarily imply insufficient emotional understanding. Moreover, given the distributed nature of emotional representations, the justification for selecting specific affect-related ROIs remains insufficient.
-
Lack of human-centered evaluation. The paper relies primarily on automatic emotion classifiers and predicted neural responses, without conducting a human user study. This is particularly concerning given its emphasis on cognitive appraisal and context-dependent emotional interpretation. Without human evaluation, it remains unclear whether the reported improvements reflect genuine changes in perceived emotion and whether the edited images preserve their intended contextual meaning.
Questions for authors
-
Neuroscientific motivation and ROI selection. How are the affect-related ROIs selected, and what evidence supports their specific relevance to emotional responses? Given that emotion is represented across distributed brain networks, how do the authors justify the separation between visual and affective ROIs? Could the observed improvements arise from general visual or semantic information rather than emotion-specific neural representations?
-
Interpretation of the representation analysis. The paper argues that weaker correspondence between existing editors' hidden states and affect-related neural responses motivates explicit neural guidance. However, could this difference reflect variations in neural response predictability or encoding difficulty across brain regions, rather than insufficient emotional understanding? What evidence establishes a connection between this representational imbalance and emotional editing performance?
-
Human evaluation of emotional editing. Have the authors considered conducting a user study to evaluate whether the generated images actually convey the intended emotions to human observers? Given the emphasis on cognitive appraisal and context-dependent emotional interpretation, how can the authors establish that improvements in automatic emotion classification correspond to meaningful changes in human emotional perception?
-
Validation of cognitive reappraisal. The introduction uses cognitive reappraisal to motivate the framework, emphasizing that identical visual content can evoke different emotions depending on its interpretation. Does the proposed method actually capture or modify such contextual interpretations? Can the authors provide experiments involving emotionally ambiguous scenes to substantiate this central motivation?
-
Contribution of the dual-branch intervention. Although the ablation studies demonstrate improvements from interactive dual-branch guidance, what specific behaviors does this interaction enable beyond independent conditioning? Can the authors provide qualitative or spatial analyses illustrating how the visual and affective branches coordinate during editing?
-
*Comparison with modern image editing models. How does the proposed method compare with recent foundation model-based image editing systems, such as Qwen-Image-Edit, which demonstrate strong semantic understanding and instruction-following capabilities? Would the reported advantages in emotional editing and content preservation still hold against these stronger baselines?