- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 1
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
see weaknesses.
Critical strengths
N/A
Critical weaknesses
Weaknesses
- This paper is very clearly fully AI generated and not in a good way. The authors didn't even go through the process of re-writing paragraphs to be easily readable (its just a wall of text) or fix the plots e.g. Figure 2 (d) / Figure 3 to not have legends overlap half of the plots. Research is a means to communicate findings in an easy and understandable way and unfortunately the authors didn't prioritize this goal. The appendix and the main portion read like a research log rather than an actual paper and even some figures are missing even though they are referenced in the text (Figure 5, fig. A-E2). Clearly the authors aren't even sure what their contributions are "Our contributions are three" is followed 13 numbered items (l. 89–120). The paper has 12 matches for "an earlier draft" which shouldn't really appear in any camera ready paper and the text even mentions run IDs (
i0_d1,emltree_wd0.1_cpu,parity403_i1), script names (rung3_transplant.py,scratch_crossrun_t90.py) and log paths (runs/transplant.log,runs/registration_timestamps.txt).
Questions for authors
N/A