- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 3(+1)
Read review
Paper summary
This paper studies the theoretical convergence guarantee of PPO-Clip algorithm as a closed-loop AC system. The analyzed MDPs are finite-horizon episodic. The paper jointly controls policy stationarity and critic tracking error, showing an explicit coupling amplification factor to elucidate how stochastic noise, clipping bias, multi-epoch data, and KL budget impact the algorithm's finite-time convergence behavior. For structured tabular MDP, it also shows an O(T^{-2/5}) stationary and critic-tracking bounds.
Critical strengths
-
A unified finite-time convergence analysis of closed PPO AC dynamics. The paper provides a rigorous non-asymptotic analysis controlling policy stationarity and critic tracking error simultaneously, and shows explicitly how each algorithm part (clip, multi-epoch data reuse, KL budget) impact the convergence. This result gives a useful guide for designing appropriate parameters of PPO-clip algorithm.
-
Careful treatment of adaptive data reuse with structured statistical guarantees. I think a notable technical novelty of this paper is the explicit control of empirical-to-population discrepancies when actor and critic iterates adaptive to the same reused data batch. Furthermore, the structured tabular result establishes uniform concentration for the actual clipped-gradient class without enumerating complete trajectories.
Critical weaknesses
- There are some restrictive assumptions. The main theorem of this paper relies on strong critic regularity conditions, including local convexity, quadratic growth, value realizability, and a Lipschitz-continuous selected critic optimum, together with uniform policy coverage and population KL control. These assumptions significantly restrict the applicability of the results to practical neural PPO and RLHF implementations. It would be better if the authors could explain how these assumptions are natural, or if they are commonly used in previous works.
- The writing needs substantially improved. Although the manuscript is rigorously structured and technically precise, its presentation is overly long, making it difficult to follow at times. Several topics: (1) the actor–critic coupling, (2) the bias introduced by clipping, and (3) the limitations of theoretical guarantees are revisited repeatedly across the introduction, main results, and appendices without offering any substantive new insights. Furthermore, the main theoretical results are laden with an abundance of constants, auxiliary quantities, and technical conditions, which obscures the core theoretical insights and their significance. The frequent inclusion of qualifying remarks and caveats further disrupts the flow of the argument and diminishes the emphasis on the paper’s primary contributions. In short, the quality of the manuscript could be significantly enhanced by making the exposition more concise and focused, highlighting key technical innovations, providing intuitive understanding before presenting formal statements, and eliminating redundant explanations.
Questions for authors
Q1. How does the proposed framework capture the interaction between critic estimation errors and PPO clipping?
The main theorem controls critic-induced GAE bias through the critic tracking error, while clipping distortion is treated as a separate residual term. In particular, the coupling coefficient vanishes when lambda=1, even though critic errors may still affect clipping decisions through the signs of estimated advantages. Could the authors clarify to what extent the analysis captures this interaction and whether a tighter, tracking-dependent bound on clipping distortion can be established?
Q2. Can the authors further clarify the technical novelty over existing PPO and actor–critic convergence analyses?
Prior works, such as Jin et al. (2024), Wu et al. (2020), and Doering et al. (2026), have already established convergence guarantees for PPO-Clip, learned actor–critic dynamics, and finite-batch reuse under different settings. Could the authors identify which specific technical challenges in the proposed analysis cannot be addressed by directly combining existing results? In particular, it would be helpful to distinguish genuinely new theoretical insights from the integration and refinement of established analytical techniques.
6 comments
Rebuttal (2/3)
Q2. Can the authors further clarify the technical novelty over existing PPO and actor–critic convergence analyses?
Response
We appreciate the opportunity to clarify our contribution. Our goal is a joint finite-time guarantee for actor stationarity and critic tracking under the PPO protocol studied here. Our contribution includes both additional discrepancy bounds and the adaptation and integration of established analytical tools.
1. Why this integration requires additional analysis. Both the actor and critic adapt to the same reused buffer. Critic error changes advantages and clipping decisions, while actor movement changes the critic’s population target. Given the training history, the expected minibatch gradients equal the empirical buffer gradients, and single-action importance weighting leaves a behavior-policy continuation error. Controlling these effects jointly requires compatible error bounds under a common sampling history that account for the feedback between the two updates.
The cited works provide important foundations. For our protocol, the remaining requirements are:
- Jin et al. retain an advantage/sampling discrepancy in their clipped-update guarantee. Our setting requires explicit bounds on the discrepancies arising when both parameters adapt to a reused buffer.
- Wu et al. analyze online Markovian updates with a linear TD(0) critic. A tracking analysis for our setting must account for stored-return critic fitting and the shared adaptive buffer history.
- Doering et al. control finite-buffer reuse under reshuffling using a symmetric ratio-truncation proxy and an advantage-bias bound. Our protocol additionally requires control of the actual sign-dependent clipped-gradient class with recomputed GAE.
2. The additional results we establish.
- Lemma C.5 bounds the actor and critic conditional gradient discrepancies under a common sampling history and isolates the behavior-policy continuation error.
- Lemma C.6, for bounded tabular critics, controls the actual sign-dependent clipped-gradient class uniformly over the adapted actor and critic. It uses positive and negative parts of the labels within time–state–action cells, avoiding continuity assumptions across clipping boundaries and enumeration of complete trajectories.
These bounds remain valid when the actor and critic share minibatch indices. Integrating them with the actor-progress and critic-tracking arguments allows us to close the coupled recursions and obtain the joint finite-time guarantee, with an explicit sufficient coupling condition and a common amplification factor for residual errors.
3. Changes to the manuscript. We have revised Related Work section to clarify the distinctions from prior analyses and the challenges posed by shared adaptive buffer reuse. The revision identifies the roles of Lemmas C.5–C.6 and distinguishes these additional bounds from the adaptation and integration of established analytical tools. The changes are highlighted in red.
Rebuttal (3/3)
W1: restrictness of assumption
Response
Thank you for raising this concern. Our goal is a joint finite-time guarantee for actor stationarity and critic tracking, accounting for clipping and buffer reuse. The assumptions control critic stability, target movement, and distribution mismatch. Related analyses use analogous controls, and several of our conditions are local or admit explicit relaxations.
1. Motivation and theoretical precedents.
-
Critic stability and target regularity. Under the stated smoothness and stepsize conditions, local convexity and quadratic growth support critic contraction, while a Lipschitz selected optimum controls target movement. The geometry is required on regions containing the critic iterates, selected optima, and connecting segments. [1, 2] impose uniform negative definiteness for TD stability; [1] also establishes Lipschitz dependence of the critic fixed point on actor parameters. Our regression conditions serve analogous stability and tracking purposes.
-
Realizability and value accuracy. Realizability identifies the population critic optimum with the true value function, and value Lipschitzness converts parameter-tracking error into a GAE error bound. This isolates tracking effects from representation error while allowing the learned critic to remain imperfect throughout training. Appendix N.3 permits bounded approximation error, retaining the learned-critic dynamics and other premises with an explicit approximation-error floor and a revised coupling condition.
-
Population KL control. Each buffer refresh begins with the current and behavior policies equal, so their KL divergence is initially zero. Under Appendix F's score bounds along parameter segments and gradient bounds, choosing the stepsize and reuse count appropriately guarantees the required population KL budget. Refreshing the reference policy each epoch permits continued policy change across training.
2. Joint consistency and alternative tracking measures.
Appendix J verifies that all premises hold jointly along the actual updates of a growing-horizon construction, establishing their consistency for the specified protocol. Appendix N.2 discusses loss-gap tracking as an alternative to parameter-distance tracking, subject to additional value-error calibration and objective-drift control.
We have added a brief explanation (highlighted in red) immediately after each of the six assumptions in Section 2.4 to clarify its role in the analysis.
[1] A Finite-Time Analysis of Two Time-Scale Actor-Critic Methods
[2] Finite-Time Analysis of Single-Timescale Actor-Critic
W2: writing and presentation
Response
Thank you for these helpful suggestions on presentation. We have made two targeted revisions around Theorem 3.1, with the revised and relocated passages highlighted in red.
1. Present the intuition before the theorem. The revised introduction explains how critic error affects the actor's advantage estimates and how actor movement shifts the critic's population target. It then describes how compatible error bounds yield a joint guarantee under the sufficient condition , with the common amplification factor .
2. Place the interpretation directly after the result. We moved the existing “Reading the guarantee: decomposition and amplification” paragraph immediately after Theorem 3.1. Readers can now interpret the error terms and coupling factor before proceeding to the two corollaries.
These changes clarify the progression from intuition to the formal guarantee and its interpretation, while preserving the mathematical statements and assumptions. We will further streamline repeated explanations and improve the flow of the exposition in the next revision.
In the end, thank you again for your thoughtful feedback. We hope our responses address your concerns, and we would be happy to clarify any remaining points or discuss further questions.
Rebuttal (1/3)
Thank you for your careful reading and constructive feedback. Below, we address your questions on critic-dependent clipping and technical novelty, clarify the motivation and scope of our assumptions, and summarize the revisions made to improve the paper’s presentation.
Response
Thank you for this insightful question. We agree that critic errors can change clipping decisions even at λ=1. The submitted theorem controls this interaction through a uniform clipping residual that does not track critic accuracy. Thus a=0 at λ=1 is compatible with critic-dependent clipped updates.
1. Why the coupling coefficient vanishes and how the residual covers the interaction. The coefficient a bounds the contribution of critic tracking error to the squared population actor bias before clipping. At λ=1, the TD residuals in GAE telescope. With matched terminal values Vw(sH)=Vπ(sH) and the prescribed terminal value included in Gh,
Ah(w)=Gh−Vw(sh).
Relative to using Vπ, the critic error therefore enters only through the state baseline b(s)=Vπ(s)−Vw(s). This error is independent of the action at a fixed state. At a fixed checkpoint, exact action importance weighting gives
=b(s)\sum_a\nabla\pi_\theta(a\mid s)=0.$$ This is the cancellation used in Corollary C.2: critic error contributes zero to the unclipped on-policy population direction. Accordingly, $a=4G_\pi^2L_V^2\widetilde C_{\lambda,H}^2$ vanishes at $\lambda=1$, since $\widetilde C_{\lambda,H}=\gamma(1-\lambda)\sum_{j=0}^{H-2}(\gamma\lambda)^j$, and hence $\rho=10ad=0$. The remaining critic-dependent clipping effect is covered by the clipping component of $F$ in Theorem 3.1: $$F_{\rm clip}:=8G_\pi^2A_{\max}^2\kappa(1+1/\delta)^2.$$ Even when $a=\rho=0$, this term contributes to the actor stationarity bound and to the critic tracking bound. It bounds total clipping distortion with learned-critic advantages uniformly over admissible critics, including effects of critic errors on advantage signs. Thus the interaction remains covered by the result, although its dependence on the current tracking error $\Delta_t$ is not explicit. Finite-batch and policy-drift errors are also retained separately in $F$. The refinement below isolates the critic-dependent part of clipping distortion. **2. A refined tracking-dependent checkpoint bound.** Fix the current actor and behavior policy, and define $D(w)=g_{\rm clip}(w)-g_{\rm unclip}(w)$. Both population directions average over behavior trajectories and a uniform time $h$, with weight $\gamma^h$, action ratio $r$, and the unclipped derivative at ties. The removed labels above the upper and below the lower clipping boundaries are $\max(\widehat A,0)$ and $\min(\widehat A,0)$, respectively; both maps are 1-Lipschitz. With matched terminal values, Eq. (C.43) gives $|\widehat A_h(w)-\widehat A_h(w^\star)|\le C_{\lambda,H}L_V\sqrt{\Delta_t}$, where $C_{\lambda,H}=1+\widetilde C_{\lambda,H}$ and $w^\star=w^\star(\theta_t)$. Under this averaging law, Corollary C.1 bounds $\mathbb E[r\,\mathbf 1_{\{|r-1|\ge\delta\}}]$ by $\sqrt{2\kappa}(1+1/\delta)$. Combining this with the score and label bounds gives $$\|D(w)-D(w^\star)\|\le L_D\sqrt{\Delta_t}, \qquad L_D=G_\pi C_{\lambda,H}L_V\sqrt{2\kappa}(1+1/\delta).$$ Consequently, $$\|D(w)\|^2\le 2\|D(w^\star)\|^2+2L_D^2\Delta_t.$$ This separates exact-value clipping distortion from the additional critic-dependent distortion. Since $C_{1,H}=1$, critic-dependent distortion can persist at $\lambda=1$; exact-value distortion can persist at perfect tracking. **3. Changes to the manuscript.** We have added **Proposition C.8 in Appendix C.6**, including both inequalities, a full proof, and an explanation of the remaining critic dependence at $\lambda=1$. We also added cross-references beside the existing clipping bound and in the coupling discussion. All additions are highlighted in red.