acceptodds
Withdrawn from ICLR 2027

Manifold Generative Annealing for Contact Constraint-aware Impedance Control with Reinforcement Learning Prior

Withdrawn from ICLR 2027, so left out of the paper lists and the map.

Abstract

Contact-rich robotic tasks require coordinated motion and impedance under uncertain interaction dynamics and physical constraints. While recent methods on learned policies provide useful interaction strategies, they may fail when contact conditions differ from those encountered during training. Model-based generative methods show promising receding-horizon trajectories optimization results, but often lack structured behavioral guidance and refinement that jointly accounts for constraint geometry and actual contact responses. To this end, we propose Manifold Generative Annealing (MGA), a joint model-free and model-based generative framework for motion–impedance optimization. MGA first organizes pretrained reinforcement learning policies into structured sequence proposals, retaining task-specific interaction strategies without committing to their execution. It then evaluates these proposals alongside exploratory samples through model-based rollouts for refinement or separate execution selection. Crucially, realization-aware manifold refinement aligns updates from the refinement bank with both task constraints and locally achievable physical responses, allowing learned experience to guide online adaptation under changing contact conditions. Experiments cover surface scanning, peg insertion, and humanoid pushing, with improved safety success rate of impedance control under nominal and sensing-shift conditions.

Primary area:
applications to robotics, autonomy, planning
Keywords:
Model-Free Model-Based Generative Inference, Reinforcement Learning Priors, Geometry-Aware Sampling, Constrained Optimization, Robot Learning

Reviews

Among:
Shape:
1234this paper, Bottom 49%
Figure 1. Mean review rating of the reviewed papers at ICLR 2027. This paper averages 2.25 over 4 reviews, above 49% of the others.
Reviewer_Af94OpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
2
Informativeness
2
Presentation
1
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

This paper presents MGA, which combines RL trajectory proposals, sampling-based MPC, and Jacobian-based residual correction for contact-rich motion and impedance control.

Critical strengths
  • Combining learned policies with model-based optimization is a promising direction.
  • The experiments cover several contact-rich tasks, including surface scanning, peg insertion, and humanoid pushing.
Critical weaknesses
  • Benchmark. The paper mainly evaluates on custom tasks and success criteria, despite many existing works in this area. I would prefer to see comparisons on established, open-source benchmarks using the same evaluation protocols.
  • Presentation. I found some parts of the paper difficult to follow, especially the motivation and overall method. I think the main idea can be explained more simply, with less terminology and a clearer connection between the different components. This would help readers better understand the contributions.
  • RL prior. The ablation shows that the RL prior helps on some tasks. However, the RL prior introduces additional rollouts, so the computational budgets are not fully matched. Also, the real-world experiments only evaluate the model-based component without the RL prior.
Questions for authors
  • Can the authors evaluate MGA on established benchmarks from previous works?
  • Can the authors compare the methods under matched total computational budgets, including the additional RL proposal rollouts?
  • Can the authors provide real-world experiments using the complete method, including the RL prior?
  • The real-world experiments use position-based force correction rather than full impedance control. Also, only one insertion trial is reported.. Can the authors provide further validation of the proposed impedance control method?
Reviewer_rcfrOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
3
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
3
Read review
Paper summary

This paper proposes Manifold Generative Annealing (MGA), a framework for joint motion and impedance optimization in contact-rich robotic tasks. The method incorporates pretrained reinforcement learning (RL) policies as trajectory priors and combines them with model-based generative annealing to evaluate and refine candidate trajectories online. Furthermore, the authors introduce Realization-Aware Manifold Refinement, which employs geometric shaping and Local Residual Correction (LRC) to reduce constraint violations during trajectory optimization. Experiments on surface scanning, peg insertion, and humanoid pushing demonstrate competitive safe-success rates under varying contact conditions and sensing perturbations. Additional real-world robotic arm experiments provide preliminary evidence of the method's practical applicability.

Critical strengths

S1. A well-motivated framework. The paper combines RL-based behavioral priors, model-based generative optimization, and manifold refinement, providing a promising framework for joint motion and impedance optimization in contact-rich tasks.

S2. Well-motivated constraint refinement mechanism. The proposed approach employs geometric shaping to suppress updates that may violate task constraints, followed by LRC to correct remaining residuals. The accompanying local theoretical analysis further supports the design and helps explain its effectiveness.

Critical weaknesses

W1. Incomplete validation of the full MGA framework on real robots. Although the paper includes real-world robotic experiments, these only evaluate the model-based refinement component without incorporating the RL prior or directly executing the full Cartesian impedance matrix. Moreover, the real-world insertion experiment consists of a single relatively large-clearance insertion trial, without comparisons against relevant baselines.

W2. Insufficient isolation of the actual contribution of the RL prior. In the peg insertion and humanoid pushing experiments, the RL prior is evaluated as an additional trajectory expert rather than being directly integrated into the generative refinement process. These experiments also involve additional rollout evaluations, making it difficult to determine whether the observed improvements arise from the proposed joint framework or simply from a larger candidate pool and additional computation.

W3. Limited evaluation of robustness and computational efficiency. The tested OOD perturbations are relatively limited, and MGA does not consistently outperform its ablated variants in some unseen surface conditions.

Questions for authors

Q1. Can the authors provide real-world experiments that evaluate the complete MGA framework? It would be valuable to integrate the RL prior, model-based refinement, and LRC in real contact-rich manipulation tasks and compare the complete framework against relevant baselines to demonstrate its practical benefits.

Q2. To what extent do the improvements attributed to the RL prior result from learned behavioral knowledge rather than additional sampling and computation? An equal-rollout-budget comparison would help clarify this issue. It would also be useful to compare additive expert selection with directly integrating RL proposals into the generative refinement bank.

Q3. How effectively does manifold refinement enforce physical constraints under complex contact conditions? The authors could further investigate the relationship between task residual reduction and actual violations of contact force, friction, and balance constraints. Additional ablations independently removing geometric shaping, LRC, and execution revalidation would help clarify the contributions of each component.

Reviewer_SyemOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
3
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

The paper presents MGA for motion and impedance planning in contact-rich tasks. The system generates candidate sequences using RL policies and Gaussian sampling, evaluates them through model rollouts, and updates the plan using geometric direction shaping and local residual correction (LRC). Experiments cover surface scanning, peg insertion, humanoid pushing, and physical-arm scanning and insertion.

Critical strengths

The paper addresses a practical problem. Motion commands, stiffness, and physical responses interact during contact, and using feedback to revise the plan is a useful direction. The LRC ablations show convincing gains in scanning coverage, insertion completion, and humanoid unjamming. Reporting path coverage, contact loads, and failures also helps explain which behaviors improve.

Critical weaknesses

In insertion and humanoid tasks, the RL horizons are evaluated after Gaussian refinement and compete with its output. Adding the prior therefore also adds rollout evaluations. MGA further introduces feasibility costs and execution revalidation. I would like to see how much of the gain remains when the no-prior variant receives the same total rollout budget, and when the other planners use the same feasibility costs and acceptance checks.

D-MPC [1] already learns multi-step action proposals and a multi-step dynamics model, then combines them in online MPC. It is relevant to MGA's use of learned behavior to focus model-based search. Diffusion-MPC [2] jointly generates future states and actions, incorporates reward guidance and constraint projection during reverse sampling, and improves the planner through interaction data. This is particularly relevant to MGA's combination of generative refinement and geometric correction. MGA instead uses frozen RL policies, explicit model rollouts, and feedback-conditioned task residuals. The paper should explain where these choices help and test them against a representative learning-based MPC approach. The current MPPI, DIAL, and PegasusFlow comparisons leave open whether the gains would persist against a planner that already combines learned trajectory structure with online objective and constraint guidance.

The experiments establish the value of LRC more clearly than that of direction shaping. The shaping operator uses directions constructed from the residual-energy gradient; the appendix notes that this encoding can vanish at zero residual even when the constraint Jacobian remains nonzero. How often does this occur, and does shaping still improve the final plan? Comparing LRC alone, LRC with the implemented shaping operator, and LRC with full-Jacobian shaping would help justify this part of the method.

Each planning call requires repeated rollouts, local response estimation, Jacobian computation, correction, and execution revalidation. The paper gives a 20-ms control interval but no measured planning latency. Please report the hardware, mean and tail solve times, and the behavior when a solve exceeds the control period. Matching nominal proposal counts provides little information about the cost of these additional operations.

The hardware setup omits the RL prior and uses lower-level force feedback, progress pauses, and contact recovery during scanning. The insertion result is one large-clearance trial with contact-force refinement disabled. I would find a comparison using the same lower-level controller, with and without MGA refinement, more informative than the current standalone demonstrations. It would show how much the planner contributes beyond the feedback and recovery logic.

References

[1] Zhou et al. Diffusion Model Predictive Control. https://arxiv.org/abs/2410.05364

[2] Huang et al. Flexible Locomotion Learning with Diffusion Model Predictive Control. https://arxiv.org/abs/2510.04234

Questions for authors
  1. Can the authors compare MGA with D-MPC [1], Diffusion-MPC [2], or a representative adaptation under matched online computational budgets? In particular, does feedback-conditioned refinement improve performance over learned proposals combined with ordinary reward and constraint guidance?

  2. Can the authors add an equal-total-rollout prior ablation and compare LRC alone, LRC with the implemented shaping operator, and LRC with full-Jacobian shaping?

  3. What are the measured planning latencies? On hardware, how does performance change when refinement is removed while the lower-level controller and recovery logic remain fixed?

References

[1] Zhou et al. Diffusion Model Predictive Control. https://arxiv.org/abs/2410.05364

[2] Huang et al. Flexible Locomotion Learning with Diffusion Model Predictive Control. https://arxiv.org/abs/2510.04234

Reviewer_5BfNOpenReview ↗
Rating
3
Confidence
2
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
3
Read review
Paper summary

In contact-rich tasks such as surface scanning and peg insertion, a robot must decide both where to move (motion) and the stiffness of that motion (impedance). A policy trained can fail when the actual surface is different from training. To address this problem, this work propose Manifold Generative Annealing (MGA), which uses pretrained RL policies to suggest motion and stiffness, and a dynamics model to evaluate candidate sequences. It progressively narrows the sampling range (anneling), uses task constraints and contact feedback to shape each update, and corrects residual errors before execution.

Experimental results show MGA improve the success rate of contact-rich tasks, e.g., peg insertions from 17 to 24 out of 30 (baselines) to 28/30 (MGA).

Critical strengths

Overall I think the method is round and well-designed, experiments seem solid in both simulation and real-world settings.

Critical weaknesses

I don't think there's any critical weakness of this work, but if the system can be simpler & more elegant, the method may lead to larger impact. I spent a long time understanding every component of the system.

Questions for authors

In mga_surface_hybrid_center_soft.gif, why does the sensor tip penetrate into the surface? (Or is that considered a failure case?)

From OpenReview, CC BY 4.0. Authors as signed there; shown unedited.

Related papers

Discussion (0)

Sign in to comment.