- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 1
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper presents MGA, which combines RL trajectory proposals, sampling-based MPC, and Jacobian-based residual correction for contact-rich motion and impedance control.
Critical strengths
- Combining learned policies with model-based optimization is a promising direction.
- The experiments cover several contact-rich tasks, including surface scanning, peg insertion, and humanoid pushing.
Critical weaknesses
- Benchmark. The paper mainly evaluates on custom tasks and success criteria, despite many existing works in this area. I would prefer to see comparisons on established, open-source benchmarks using the same evaluation protocols.
- Presentation. I found some parts of the paper difficult to follow, especially the motivation and overall method. I think the main idea can be explained more simply, with less terminology and a clearer connection between the different components. This would help readers better understand the contributions.
- RL prior. The ablation shows that the RL prior helps on some tasks. However, the RL prior introduces additional rollouts, so the computational budgets are not fully matched. Also, the real-world experiments only evaluate the model-based component without the RL prior.
Questions for authors
- Can the authors evaluate MGA on established benchmarks from previous works?
- Can the authors compare the methods under matched total computational budgets, including the additional RL proposal rollouts?
- Can the authors provide real-world experiments using the complete method, including the RL prior?
- The real-world experiments use position-based force correction rather than full impedance control. Also, only one insertion trial is reported.. Can the authors provide further validation of the proposed impedance control method?