- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
In this paper, the authors propose a game-theoretic search-and-distillation framework for mixed doubles curling, which they treat as a stochastic, continuous-action, physics-based game. Specifically, a graph transformer encodes stones, landmark points and game context as a graph with handcrafted geometric edge features. Human match records contain board positions but no release parameters, so the authors recover human actions with a Cross-Entropy Method inverse solver, and use the results to initialize the policy and value heads. Training then runs three PSRO-style rounds. Each round computes a meta-Nash mixture over the current policy population and searches for an approximate best response with KR-UCT against a JAX physics simulator under Student-t execution noise. Search proposals are accepted only when a paired gate confirms a gain, and the accepted decisions are distilled into the next policy.
Critical strengths
- S1: Curling combines alternating zero-sum play, continuous actions, stochastic execution and nontrivial collision physics.
- S2: Search runs on the explicit simulator rather than a learned model.
- S3: Execution noise is part of the model, where noise is used when ranking candidates and when executing the throw.
- S4: Blind, randomized paired judgments by U.S. Olympic curling staff are rare and valuable in game-AI papers, and the free-text feedback gives qualitative insight.
- S5: The free-guard-zone rule, power play, simulator constants, action bounds, noise scales, search hyper-parameters and compute are all documented, so the setup could be rebuilt.
Critical weaknesses
- W1: The game-theoretic evidence is thin. Only three response rounds were run. The first two restricted games were essentially pure, and per-round gains are small.
- W2: No relevant algorithmic baselines, such as plain KR-UCT with no learned policy/value, human-prior policy in the same simulator, and self-play/NFSP agent.
- W3: LLM agents could be a weak and confounded main baseline.
- W4: Ablations do not support all design requirements.
- W5: The inverse solver uses a different physics preset from the one used for play and evaluation, so the human priors are recovered in one physics and deployed in another.
- W6: The method combines known components with relatively limited novelty. The contribution is mostly system integration for one domain, and nothing shows the framework generalizes to other physical games.
Questions for authors
- Q1: Play and evaluation use different physics parameters from the inverse solver. How sensitive are the recovered human actions, and the downstream policy, to this mismatch?
- Q2: Can the ablations be measured in playing strength with uncertainty, rather than differences in the third or fourth decimal place of held-out NLL and MSE? If neither auxiliary objective changes play, why keep them as core design requirements?
- Q3: Can the policy be conditioned on end index, score and ends remaining so it can handle match-level strategy and power-play timing? Have you tried the framework on any other physical game to support the generality implied by the title?
Please Engage With Authors
Dear Reviewers,
We're halfway through the discussion stage. The authors have provided their responses to your reviews. If the responses have not addressed the concerns raised in your reviews, please raise and allow the authors to respond again. If yes, please still respond to the authors to reflect that.
Many thanks, AC